Eighteenth Century North America: Colonies, Conflicts, and Transformations
Administrative Reminders and Communication Protocols:- Students are reminded about upcoming assignments: the first article assignment (due Monday, September ), lecture activity (due Friday), and SmartBook number four (due Sunday).- When emailing the instructor, students must include their class ID and clearly state their class.- Students should first reach out to their TAs; if TAs don't respond or instruct them to, then contact the instructor. The instructor aims to respond within to hours, typically in the mornings, which is the best time for emergency responses.
The Middle Colonies: New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania
Dutch Settlement of New Netherlands (Present-day New York and New Jersey):
Primarily settled by the Dutch starting in the .
Named the area "New Netherlands."
Established New Amsterdam (now Manhattan Island), building a city and a fort there.
A physical wall was built to separate inhabitants from indigenous people residing further up the island and into areas like the modern-day Bronx, giving rise to the name Wall Street.
Controlled for approximately years before being captured by the British, who renamed them New York and New Jersey.
Challenges and Lasting Impacts:
Colonies struggled with disease, difficulty in attracting settlers, and British aggression (e.g., pirates from Chesapeake/New England).
Despite being largely unsuccessful, Dutch influence remained significant: wealthy elites in the and centuries (e.g., Schuyler, Van Rensselaer families) were of Dutch origin.
The Dutch were the first to introduce enslaved people to New York and New Jersey, making slavery a major aspect of these colonies well into the century.
Pennsylvania and the Quakers:
Primarily settled by Quakers, officially known as the Religious Society of Friends.
Core Quaker Beliefs:
Practiced a personal connection with God, believing everyone could have direct access without priests or preachers.
Held a radical, egalitarian view of religion for the time, asserting equal spiritual connection for men, women, Black, white, and indigenous people, contrasting with the hierarchical structures of the Catholic and most Protestant churches.
Famous painting depicts a Quaker meeting house where anyone could speak and preach, lacking organized structure of traditional churches.
Despite egalitarian ideals, inequalities persisted (e.g., women often disadvantaged, primarily white attendance).
Strong pacifist stance; they avoided war and dressed in a distinct manner.
The name "Quakers" arose from the stereotype that non-Quakers observed them "quaking" or shaking with religious fervor.
Establishment of Pennsylvania:
William Penn, an English Quaker, received a charter from the King of England (King Charles II, ) and established Pennsylvania in his honor (Penn's Woods).
Quakers actively spread their faith throughout the British Empire (e.g., Barbados, South Carolina, Canada).
Pennsylvania became the main hub for Quakers coming from England.
Relations with Indigenous People:
Known for pacifism and peaceful coexistence, avoiding conflict.
Bought land from indigenous people rather than conquering it.
Growth and Influence:
Pennsylvania became very rich, with Philadelphia growing into the largest and wealthiest city in the colonies, a major trade hub.
As the colony grew, more non-Quakers settled, some not sharing pacifist beliefs.
Quakers became leaders in the abolitionist movement; while some were enslavers early on, the vast majority renounced slavery by the century.
The first call for abolition in North America was the Germantown Protest by Quakers, condemning slavery's immorality.
Quakers were a backbone of activism for women's rights, enslaved people's rights, and indigenous rights due to their egalitarian principles.
The Transatlantic Slave Trade and Human Cost
Century Surge in Slave Trade:
The saw a significant increase in the Transatlantic Slave Trade, fuelling large plantations in Brazil, the Caribbean (Haiti, Cuba, Jamaica), and the Carolinas.
Atlantic World Economy:
The "Atlantic World" refers to colonies and countries connected by the Atlantic Ocean and involved in the slave trade from Africa.
Sugar was the main export crop of the Atlantic World, highly profitable for rum production and a status symbol in Europe.
Statistics and Dehumanization:
Historians often cite figures like people sent to Brazil and an estimated 12,000,000} people overall forced into the Transatlantic Slave Trade from the century until .
While numbers show scope, focusing solely on them can dehumanize the experience. The lecture emphasized empathy and understanding the individual human experience.
The Brutality of the Middle Passage:
Capture: People were enslaved during inter-tribal wars in Africa and sold to European traders (primarily Portuguese, Dutch) on the coast.
Rumors and Fear: Enslaved individuals had heard rumors about Europeans (e.g., eating people, permanent disappearance).
Ship Conditions: Forced onto ships, separated from known people, crammed "foot to head" in multiple levels below deck. An image depicted to people in minimal space.
Duration and Filth: Travel lasted two to three months from West Africa to the Americas (Brazil, South Carolina). Individuals were confined, unable to move, relieve themselves (leading to living in their own and others' waste), and disease was rampant.
Abuse: Sailors often sexually assaulted enslaved women.
Suicide Attempts: Many attempted suicide by jumping overboard, preferring death to enslavement, leading to insurance companies forming in England to cover losses of "human cargo."
Arrival in the Americas: Sold to white families, facing language barriers, sustained physical and sexual violence, and -hour workdays in unfamiliar lands.
Distinction from African Slavery:
Slavery existed in Africa prior to European involvement, often based on capture with opportunities for servitude, advancement, and eventual freedom.
The chattel slavery in the Americas was unique: based purely on race, where people were forcibly captured, sold as property, and entirely debased as human beings, a form of dehumanization not seen before.
Resistance and Adaptation:
Despite the brutality, people resisted: revolting on ships, burning ships, choosing mass suicide.
Upon arrival, enslaved people created their own communities, maintained religious practices, and adapted languages, demonstrating profound human resilience and resistance.
The painting "The Old Plantation" (circa ) depicts enslaved people in South Carolina celebrating with West African instruments and dance, illustrating cultural preservation and community formation amidst enslavement. This is a crucial early primary source.
The Thirteen Colonies During the Century
Georgia: From Buffer to Slave Society:
Created as a buffer against Spanish Florida.
Initially outlawed slavery but quickly reversed course due to the success of slave-based economies in neighboring South Carolina.
Enslaved population grew from in to by , rapidly becoming a major slave society.
Regional Grouping of the Colonies:
Lower South: Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina.
Chesapeake Colonies/Upper South: Virginia, Maryland, Delaware.
Middle Colonies: Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York.
New England: Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts (including Maine), New Hampshire.
Distinct Societies and Governance:
Colonies developed distinct societies, personalities, languages, and accents (-).
Nearly all colonies had some form of representative government with elected bodies passing laws and managing colonial administration.
Each colony had a royal governor appointed by the British government.
This system allowed British administration to manage daily operations without needing constant direct London oversight.
Population Growth and Economic Stability:
Significant population increase due to immigration from England and more stable conditions (Virginia, for example, becoming less of a "hellhole").
Money was made from tobacco, rice, and trade.
Philadelphia became the largest and wealthiest city, a major trade hub.
New York City, with its deep harbor, became the second largest city and facilitated extensive trade.
Indigenous populations were largely subdued or forced out, leading to a period of relative stability, with conflicts being short-lived.
Loyalty to the British Crown:
The colonies were highly loyal to the king, considering themselves Englishmen and valuing their connection through loyalty to the British Crown, rather than strong inter-colonial identity.
The colonies were integral to the broader British Atlantic Empire, on par with other colonies like Barbados, Jamaica, Nova Scotia, and Bermuda.
The Great Awakening ( and onward)
Pre-Awakening Religious Landscape:
New England:
Puritans evolved into Congregationalists, who were less strict but still rigid.
Congregationalist churches were town-focused, with internal hierarchies where full membership was a long and difficult process, often favoring wealthy families.
Many "half members" (baptized but not full members) existed, leading to stagnation; the Puritan movement faltered, and New England was seen as religiously isolated.
As cities like Boston grew with trade, diverse religious groups felt excluded from these rigid congregations.
The South (Chesapeake, Lower South):
Primarily Anglican (Church of England), a hierarchical structure similar to Catholicism.
Severe shortage of pastors: Virginia had over people but only pastors in . This meant many people couldn't attend church or had to travel long, dangerous distances.
High illiteracy rates and Bibles in Latin further hindered personal religious engagement.
Wealthy southerners often received preferential treatment from pastors, who relied on their donations.
Middle Colonies (Pennsylvania, New York, New Jersey):
High religious diversity: Quakers, Presbyterians, Lutherans, German Reform, Dutch Reform, Catholics, and small Jewish communities.
Lacked a connective religious community; often looked down upon by Anglicans and Congregationalists.
Emergence of the Great Awakening:
Haphazardly began with traveling ministers who went to the people, rather than people coming to churches.
George Whitefield (Most Famous Preacher):
Known for his baby face, cross-eyed appearance, perceived handsomeness, and powerful speaking voice.
Traveled extensively throughout the colonies, holding large outdoor revivals (camp encampments) in woods or towns.
Broke down class divides, promoting an egalitarian message that anyone, regardless of wealth or status, could be baptized and experience a personal relationship with God without paying dues or following rigid steps.
New Denominations: Spawned new Protestant denominations like Methodists, Baptists, and Episcopalians, emphasizing personal religious experience.
Evangelicalism: Ministers were dynamic performers, preaching "eternal damnation" and the urgency of salvation to avoid hell, drawing huge crowds (e.g., "Joel Osteen before Joel Osteen").
Impact on Enslaved and Indigenous People:
Ministers actively preached to enslaved people, free blacks, and indigenous people, leading to mass conversions and breaking down existing social constructs in religion.
Contributed to the formation of African American culture, blending West African religious ideas with Christianity and English.
Colonial Unity:
Fostered a sense of unity among Protestants across the colonies, emphasizing their shared identity as colonists connected by faith, transcending previous denominational rivalries.
Challenged established authority within churches and, by extension, the state, laying groundwork for future revolutionary movements.
Simmering Tensions in the Colonies Leading to Revolution
Mercantilism:
British imperial policy forcing colonies to trade exclusively with the mother country, providing raw materials and buying finished goods.
Not foolproof; colonies still needed goods from other countries (e.g., sugar from Portuguese Brazil, French Haiti).
Led to tariffs and taxes on non-British goods, creating economic strain.
Debt and Limited Influence:
Colonists, especially southern planters (e.g., Washington, Jefferson), incurred significant debt to English banks and merchants due to high costs of establishing plantations and buying enslaved people.
High interest rates and restricted trade limited the wealth and influence of colonial elites compared to British nobility.
Thomas Jefferson's lifelong debt fueled his hatred for England.
The Enlightenment:
European intellectual movement (started in century) exploring ideas of religion, government, and society, promoting individualism and the benefit of the people over monarchy.
Questioned the divine right of kings and hereditary rule.
Ideas spread through coffee shops and the printing press (invented in the century), with influential thinkers like John Locke and Francis Bacon.
Directly influenced the American, French, and Haitian Revolutions, with concepts like "all men are created equal" being central.
Deism: A form of religion among the wealthy elite, contrasting with the Great Awakening.
Deists viewed God as a "clockmaker" who created the universe, set it in motion, and then stepped away, explaining creation without direct divine intervention or religious fallacies.
Many Founding Fathers, like Thomas Jefferson, were deists, differing from modern evangelical Christianity.
Challenging Authority: Both the Great Awakening (religious authority) and the Enlightenment (political authority) were revolutionary movements, challenging existing power structures.
Land Hunger and Economic Discontent:
Thousands of immigrants sought land and wealth (tobacco, rice farming, merchant activities).
Tobacco farming rapidly depleted soil, requiring continuous expansion for new land.
British government began curtailing westward expansion, partly due to French control of lands west of the colonies.
For poor whites, especially in Virginia, upward mobility was difficult; owning enslaved people for tobacco was expensive, leading to insurmountable debt.
These grievances, while not immediately revolutionary, created simmering discontent that would be ignited by subsequent events like the Seven Years' War.
New France (West of the Colonies)
Settlement and Expansion:
French presence in the Saint Lawrence River area since the century (e.g., Quebec founded in ).
Laid claim to vast territories, including the Mississippi area (Louisiana, named after King Louis), establishing towns like New Orleans, Baton Rouge, and Biloxi.
Population Struggles:
French government struggled to attract settlers due to harsh climate (especially in Canada, making lucrative crops impossible) and rumored dangers.
Settlers were often soldiers, poor young men, or orphaned women (whose dowries were paid by the Crown to encourage marriage).
By , New France had roughly 15,000} people, primarily in Montreal and Quebec, significantly outpaced by the colonies (over ).
Economy and Indigenous Relations:
Primarily focused on the fur trade (e.g., beaver pelts for hats), which was less profitable than tobacco or sugar and required paying gifts to indigenous groups.
Due to low population, the French could not conquer indigenous lands like the British. Instead, they had to cooperate and mediate with various powerful indigenous groups.
The French were formidable allies with groups like the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois Confederation) in the Great Lakes region, a well-organized and populous confederacy.
Militaristic and Draconian Governance:
France under Louis XIV was an absolute monarchy (the "Sun King" famously stated, "I am the state"), with centralized power and no representative bodies.
Colonial governance was highly militaristic, with single French leaders overseeing each colony (e.g., Montreal, Quebec, New Orleans).
This draconian style was necessitated by low population, the need to manage indigenous relations, and challenging environmental conditions.
"Middle Ground" Concept:
Historians describe the relationship between French and indigenous people as a "middle ground" involving give-and-take, not complete exploitation.
The French referred to their king as the "father" and indigenous people as "his children," a paternalistic view.
However, many indigenous groups (e.g., matrilineal societies) did not share this paternalistic outlook, interpreting the "father" title differently, showing a cultural disconnect.
French claims on maps were often aspirational, not fully settled territories.
Spanish Borderlands
Decline of Spanish Power ( Century):
Spain lost significant European wars and key sugar-producing colonies (e.g., France took western Hispaniola, creating Haiti; British captured Jamaica).
By , Haiti and Jamaica produced approximately of the world's sugar, highlighting Spain's economic and military setbacks.
By the century, Spain was clearly no longer the top European power, suffering from outdated military and colonial structures.
Bourbon Reforms and Reassertion:
The Bourbon family took over the Spanish crown, instituting reforms (Bourbon Reforms) to modernize the empire's organization.
Concerned about French and English expansion in North America, Spain sought to protect its claims.
New towns and forts were established, especially in California (e.g., San Diego, Monterey in the late century) and Florida (e.g., St. Augustine, the oldest European city in North America).
Population and Indigenous Relations Challenges:
Similar to the French, Spain struggled to attract large populations to its borderlands (e.g., plains).
Travel from Spain to these northern territories was arduous.
These areas had high concentrations of diverse indigenous populations.
Indigenous Power: The Comanche Empire:
Plains indigenous groups like the Comanche acquired and bartered for horses, transforming their culture into nomadic horse groups (Lakota, Kiowa).
The Comanche became highly mobile and effective warriors, commanding armies of up to men, and historians refer to their territory as the "Comanche Empire."
Spain was not strong enough to defeat the Comanche and had to work with them, often playing different indigenous groups against each other.
Impact of Horses on the Environment:
Large numbers of horses (hundreds of thousands) grazing on unaccustomed land led to environmental changes, including drought and soil erosion.
Conflict with Apache and Reservations:
The Comanche pushed the Apache westward (indigenous to Texas) into conflict with Pueblo people and Spanish towns.
Spain allied with the Comanche to decimate Apache groups, eventually forcing Apache onto reservations—one of the earliest instances of Europeans forcing indigenous people onto reservations.
Conclusion of Spanish Influence:
Through reforms, alliances, and new forts, Spain managed to retain parts of its empire (e.g., Cuba, Texas, Florida).
However, Spain remained heavily dependent on powerful indigenous groups like the Comanche for its existence in the region and was no longer the dominant player it once was.