Module 4 and 5 Study Notes: Supply, Demand, and Elasticity

Markets and Competition

  • Market: Defined as a group of buyers and sellers of a particular good or service.

  • Competitive Market: A market environment containing many buyers and sellers such that each individual has a negligible (or no) impact on the prevailing market price.

  • Quantity Demanded (QdQ_d): The specific amount of a good that buyers are both willing (desire the product) and able (possess the budget) to purchase at a given price.

  • Law of Demand: The claim that, with other things being equal, the quantity demanded of a good falls as the price of that good rises.

  • Demand Schedule: A structured table displaying the relationship between the price (PP) and the quantity demanded (QdQ_d).

  • Demand Curve: A graphical representation showing the relationship between the price (PP) and quantity demanded (QdQ_d).

  • Market Demand (Aggregate Demand): The sum of all individual demands for a specific good or service.

The Mechanics of Demand

  • Negative Relationship: Price and quantity demanded are negatively related. As P↑P \uparrow, Qd↓Q_d \downarrow.

  • Example Demand Schedule (Individual):     * P=10  ⟹  Qd=0P = 10 \implies Q_d = 0     * P=9  ⟹  Qd=0.5P = 9 \implies Q_d = 0.5     * P=8  ⟹  Qd=1P = 8 \implies Q_d = 1     * P=7  ⟹  Qd=1.5P = 7 \implies Q_d = 1.5     * P=6  ⟹  Qd=2P = 6 \implies Q_d = 2     * P=5  ⟹  Qd=2.5P = 5 \implies Q_d = 2.5     * P=4  ⟹  Qd=3P = 4 \implies Q_d = 3     * P=3  ⟹  Qd=3.5P = 3 \implies Q_d = 3.5     * P=2  ⟹  Qd=4P = 2 \implies Q_d = 4     * P=1  ⟹  Qd=4.5P = 1 \implies Q_d = 4.5     * P=0  ⟹  Qd=5P = 0 \implies Q_d = 5

  • Aggregating Market Demand:     * Market demand is calculated by summing individual consumer quantities at every price level.     * Data Example:         * At P=9P = 9: Consumer 1 (0.50.5) + Consumer 2 (1.01.0) = Market (1.51.5).         * At P=8P = 8: Consumer 1 (1.01.0) + Consumer 2 (2.02.0) = Market (3.03.0).         * At P=5P = 5: Consumer 1 (2.52.5) + Consumer 2 (5.05.0) = Market (7.57.5).         * At P=0P = 0: Consumer 1 (5.05.0) + Consumer 2 (10.010.0) = Market (15.015.0).

  • Shifters of the Demand Curve:     * Direction of Shift: An increase in demand shifts the curve to the right (higher quantity at any price). A decrease in demand shifts the curve to the left (lower quantity at any price).     * Determinants of Demand:         1. Income:             * Normal Good: Demand increases (D↑D \uparrow) when income increases (I↑I \uparrow). Change in income and demand move in the same direction.             * Inferior Good: Demand decreases (D↓D \downarrow) when income increases (I↑I \uparrow). Change in income and demand move in opposite directions.         2. Prices of Related Goods:             * Substitutes: If the price of MilkDuds falls, the demand for cupcakes falls (consumers switch to the cheaper substitute). If the price of MilkDuds rises, the demand for cupcakes rises.             * Complements: If the price of coffee falls, demand for cupcakes increases (consumed together). If the price of coffee rises, demand for cupcakes decreases.         3. Tastes/Preferences:             * Positive health news about a product increases demand.             * Negative health impact reports decrease demand.         4. Expectations about the Future Income:             * If an individual expects an increase in future income, they may increase demand for normal goods today, acting as if they already possess the funds.         5. Number of Buyers: An increase in population or the number of participants in the market increases overall demand.

The Mechanics of Supply

  • Quantity Supplied (QsQ_s): The amount of a good or service that sellers are willing and able to supply at a given price.

  • Law of Supply: The claim that, other things being equal, the quantity supplied of a good rises when the price of the good rises (P↑  ⟹  Qs↑P \uparrow \implies Q_s \uparrow).

  • Aggregating Market Supply:     * Market supply is the sum of quantities offered by all firms at each price point.     * Data Example:         * At P=5P = 5: Firm 1 (55) + Firm 2 (1010) = Market Supply (1515).         * At P=15P = 15: Firm 1 (1515) + Firm 2 (3030) = Market Supply (4545).         * At P=30P = 30: Firm 1 (3030) + Firm 2 (6060) = Market Supply (9090).

  • Shifters of the Supply Curve:     1. Input Prices: If the price of an input (e.g., cupcake liners) increases, supply decreases (S↓S \downarrow). If input prices decrease, supply increases (S↑S \uparrow).     2. Technology: Advances in technology (e.g., a faster oven) increase supply (S↑S \uparrow). Government restrictions on technology can decrease supply.     3. Expectations: If sellers expect the price of cupcakes to rise in the near future, they may hold back products today to sell them later for higher profit, thereby decreasing supply (S↓S \downarrow) today.     4. Number of Sellers: An increase in the number of sellers in the market increases supply (S↑S \uparrow), while a decrease in sellers decreases supply (S↓S \downarrow).

Market Equilibrium and Disequilibrium

  • Equilibrium: A state where the price reaches a level where quantity supplied equals quantity demanded (Qs=QdQ_s = Q_d).

  • Market Dynamics Table:     * P=10  ⟹  Qd=0,Qs=5  ⟹  extSurplusof5P = 10 \implies Q_d = 0, Q_s = 5 \implies ext{Surplus of } 5     * P=8  ⟹  Qd=1,Qs=4  ⟹  extSurplusof3P = 8 \implies Q_d = 1, Q_s = 4 \implies ext{Surplus of } 3     * P=6  ⟹  Qd=2,Qs=3  ⟹  extSurplusof1P = 6 \implies Q_d = 2, Q_s = 3 \implies ext{Surplus of } 1     * Equilibrium (P=5P=5): Qd=2.5,Qs=2.5Q_d = 2.5, Q_s = 2.5.     * P=2  ⟹  Qd=4,Qs=1  ⟹  extShortageof3P = 2 \implies Q_d = 4, Q_s = 1 \implies ext{Shortage of } 3     * P=0  ⟹  Qd=5,Qs=0  ⟹  extShortageof5P = 0 \implies Q_d = 5, Q_s = 0 \implies ext{Shortage of } 5

  • Surplus: A situation where Qs>QdQ_s > Q_d. Markets tend to lower prices to reach equilibrium.

  • Shortage: A situation where Qd>QsQ_d > Q_s. Markets tend to raise prices to reach equilibrium.

  • Comparative Statics (Single Curve Shifts):     * Decrease in Demand (D↓D \downarrow) oP↓,Q↓o P \downarrow, Q \downarrow     * Increase in Demand (D↑D \uparrow) oP↑,Q↑o P \uparrow, Q \uparrow     * Decrease in Supply (S↓S \downarrow) oP↑,Q↓o P \uparrow, Q \downarrow     * Increase in Supply (S↑S \uparrow) oP↓,Q↑o P \downarrow, Q \uparrow

  • Ambiguous Outcomes (Simultaneous Shifts):     * If both Demand and Supply change and the magnitude of the shifts is unknown, either the price or the quantity will have an ambiguous effect.

Elasticity and Its Applications

  • Elasticity: A general measure of responsiveness.

  • Price Elasticity of Demand (ϵd\epsilon_d): A measure of how much the quantity demanded of a good responds to a change in the price of that good.     * Formula: ϵd=racpercentage change in Qdpercentage change in P\epsilon_d = rac{\text{percentage change in } Q_d}{\text{percentage change in } P}.     * Absolute Values: Because demand curves are downward-sloping, elasticities are negative, but are reported as absolute values (∣ϵd∣|\epsilon_d|).

  • Determinants of Demand Elasticity:     1. Availability of Close Substitutes: More substitutes lead to higher elasticity.     2. Necessities vs. Luxuries: Necessities (e.g., insulin, water) are inelastic; luxuries (e.g., boats) are elastic.     3. Market Definition: Narrowly defined markets (e.g., blue felt pens) are more elastic than broad markets (e.g., toilet paper) due to easier substitution.     4. Time Horizon: Goods tend to be more elastic over longer time horizons as consumers have time to adjust.

  • Calculation Methods:     * Midpoint Method (Average): ϵd=ΔQdQavg÷ΔPPavg=Q2−Q1(Q1+Q22)÷P2−P1(P1+P22)\epsilon_d = \frac{\Delta Q_d}{Q_{avg}} \div \frac{\Delta P}{P_{avg}} = \frac{Q_2 - Q_1}{(\frac{Q_1 + Q_2}{2})} \div \frac{P_2 - P_1}{(\frac{P_1 + P_2}{2})}.

  • Classification of Elasticity:     * Elastic: ∣ϵd∣>1|\epsilon_d| > 1 (QdQ_d is very responsive).     * Inelastic: ∣ϵd∣<1|\epsilon_d| < 1 (QdQ_d is not very responsive).     * Unit Elastic: ∣ϵd∣=1|\epsilon_d| = 1.     * Perfectly Inelastic: Vertical demand curve.     * Perfectly Elastic: Horizontal demand curve.

  • Total Revenue (TR) and Elasticity:     * TR=P×QTR = P \times Q.     * Elastic Demand: Price and Total Revenue move in opposite directions (P↑,TR↓P \uparrow, TR \downarrow; P↓,TR↑P \downarrow, TR \uparrow). The quantity effect dominates.     * Inelastic Demand: Price and Total Revenue move in the same direction (P↑,TR↑P \uparrow, TR \uparrow; P↓,TR↓P \downarrow, TR \downarrow). The price effect dominates.     * Unit Elastic: Total revenue remains unchanged when price changes.

  • Example Calculation (UNI Tuition):     * Tuition increases by 18.5%18.5\%, enrollment drops by 1%1\%.     * ϵd=−1%18.5%=−0.05\epsilon_d = \frac{-1\%}{18.5\%} = -0.05. This is price inelastic (∣ϵd∣<1|\epsilon_d| < 1).

  • Elasticity vs. Slope: Slope is constant for a linear demand curve, but elasticity is not. A single demand curve can have elastic, unit elastic, and inelastic regions.

  • Other Elasticities:     * Income Elasticity (ϵi\epsilon_i): %ΔQd%ΔIncome\frac{\% \Delta Q_d}{\% \Delta \text{Income}}.         * Normal good: ϵi>0\epsilon_i > 0.         * Inferior good: ϵi<0\epsilon_i < 0.     * Cross-Price Elasticity (ϵab\epsilon_{ab}): %ΔQd(good A)%ΔP(good B)\frac{\% \Delta Q_d(\text{good A})}{\% \Delta P(\text{good B})}.         * Substitutes: ϵab>0\epsilon_{ab} > 0.         * Complements: ϵab<0\epsilon_{ab} < 0.

  • Price Elasticity of Supply (ϵs\epsilon_s): %ΔQs%ΔP\frac{\% \Delta Q_s}{\% \Delta P}.     * Steeper supply curves are more inelastic; flatter ones are more elastic.

Government Policies: Price Controls and Taxes

  • Price Ceiling: A legal maximum on the price at which a good or service can be sold.

  • Price Floor: A legal minimum on the price at which a good or service can be sold (e.g., Minimum Wage).

  • Tax Incidence: The study of how the burden of a tax is shared among market participants.

  • Tax on Buyers:     1. Decreases Willingness to Pay (WTP).     2. Demand curve shifts down/left by the size of the tax.

  • Tax on Sellers:     1. Increases cost to sellers.     2. Supply curve shifts up/left by the size of the tax.

  • Mathematical Example (D:P=30−QD: P = 30 - Q, S:P=2QS: P = 2Q):     * Initial Equilibrium: 30−Q=2Q  ⟹  Q∗=10,P∗=2030 - Q = 2Q \implies Q^* = 10, P^* = 20.     * With a 33 tax (either side):         * New Quantity (QtQ_t) = 99.         * Price buyers pay (PbP_b) = 2121.         * Price sellers receive (PsP_s) = 1818.         * Buyers' Burden: P_b - P^* = 21 - 20 = $1.         * Sellers' Burden: P^* - P_s = 20 - 18 = $2.

  • General Tax Conclusions:     * Taxes discourage market activity (quantity traded decreases).     * Both buyers and sellers share the burden, regardless of which party the tax is levied upon.     * Elasticity and Tax Burden: The less flexible (more inelastic) party bears the greater burden of the tax.

Market Efficiency

  • Consumer Surplus (CS): A buyer's willingness to pay minus the amount the buyer actually pays. Graphically, the area under the demand curve and above the market price.

  • Producer Surplus (PS): The amount a seller is paid minus the seller's cost. Graphically, the area above the supply curve and below the market price.

  • Total Surplus (TS): Also called Total Welfare. TS=CS+PSTS = CS + PS.

  • Efficiency: An allocation of resources that maximizes the Total Surplus received by all members of society.

  • Equity: The fairness of the distribution of well-being among society members.

  • Free Market Insights:     * Supply is allocated to buyers who value the goods most (highest WTP).     * Demand is allocated to sellers who produce at the lowest cost.     * Markets produce the quantity that maximizes surplus (Efficiency).

Costs of Taxation: Deadweight Loss

  • Deadweight Loss (DWL): The fall in total surplus that results from a market distortion, such as a tax. It represents the loss to buyers and sellers that exceeds the revenue raised by the government.

  • Welfare Analysis of Tax:     * CSCS changes by −(B+C)-(B + C).     * PSPS changes by −(D+E)-(D + E).     * Tax Revenue\text{Tax Revenue} = (Pb−Ps)×Qt(P_b - P_s) \times Q_t (Areas B+DB + D).     * DWL=C+EDWL = C + E.

  • Determinants of DWL:     * Tax size: As tax size increases, DWL increases at an increasing rate.     * Elasticity: DWL increases as the price elasticity of supply or demand increases. More elastic markets result in larger DWL.

  • Tax Revenue Dynamics:     * As tax size increases, tax revenue first increases, then decreases (Laffer Curve concept).     * The "Ideal" tax maximizes revenue while minimizing DWL, which involves a difficult trade-off found through economic modeling and trial-and-error.

  • Numerical Problem Case Study:     * Given D:P=80−4QD: P = 80 - 4Q and S:P=QS: P = Q.     * Pre-tax: Q∗=16,P∗=16Q^* = 16, P^* = 16. CS=512,PS=128,TS=640CS = 512, PS = 128, TS = 640.     * With 1010 tax on suppliers: Qt=14,Pb=24,Ps=14Q_t = 14, P_b = 24, P_s = 14.     * Post-tax outcomes: CS=392,PS=98,Tax Revenue=140,TS (with revenue)=630CS = 392, PS = 98, \text{Tax Revenue} = 140, TS \text{ (with revenue)} = 630.     * DWL=640−630=10DWL = 640 - 630 = 10. (Calculated as 12×(16−14)×10=10\frac{1}{2} \times (16 - 14) \times 10 = 10).