1.5: Positive approach
WJEC advanced information
Therapy: Explain main components and evaluate effectiveness and ethical considerations.
Classical evidence: Explain methodology, procedures, findings, conclusions and evaluate these, and additional ethical considerations.
Approach: Evaluate the approaches strengths and weaknesses, and compare to the four other approaches.
Positive approach assumptions
Acknowledgement of free will
The positive approach believes all humans are in charge of their own emotions, and can choose to direct them.
They believe that humans are self-directing and adaptive, and by using out strengths and virtues we can enhance our lives. Additionally, it is important to minimise negativity.
Diener and Seligman researched the relationships students had with friends and family, and the amount of time invested in these relationships.
They found those with the strongest ties were happiest, and those happiest were less likely to experience depression.
This shows that we can choose to engage in activities that make us happy, such as spending time with family, and these activities can alleviate low moods.
Authenticity of goodness and excellence
This assumption states that as much attention given to bad moods, such as anger and sadness, should also be given to happiness.
It believes that happiness is as natural as anxiety and stress, and a major obstacle in psychological research is the lack of authenticity given to positive feelings.
Seligman believes people are born with inherent traits, such as kindness, generosity and humour, which must be nurtured in order to improve our lives.
The positive approach focuses on elevating positive emotions, believing this will alleviate the bad ones.
Focus on the ‘good life‘
Seligman lists three different good lives:
The pleasant life - happiness is achieved by pursuing positive emotions from the past, present and future.
The good life - happiness comes from pursuing absorbing and engaging activities.
The meaningful life - happiness comes from living for a greater purpose.
Seligman believes we build up from the pleasant life to the good life, via the formation of healthy relationships and careers. He encourages that all people should seek a meaningful life.
The good life is attained through developing strengths and virtues, and three other key elements:
Positive connections to others - our ability to love, trust and develop relationships with others.
Positive individual traits - personal qualities such as morality, bravery and creative.
Life regulatory qualities - these control our behaviour to allow us to reach our goals, such as indepence and a sense of autonomy.
Therapy: Quality of Life Therapy
Applications of assumptions
Promotes authenticity as focuses on boosting happiness by decreasing worries and stress.
It also supports free will, as the methods involve a person choosing to follow the advice given.
It also encourages people to improve their strengths and weaknesses.
Main components
Quality of Life Inventory
This is an assessment of the client’s life using 16 metrics in order to identify problem areas, plan interventions and measure their effects.
These help identify areas that are personally important, and upon improving these contentment and overall well-being can also improve.
These areas are health, self-esteem, goals and values, economical standards of living, work satisfaction, play + recreation and leisure, learning, creativity, help and civic action, romantic love, friendship, relationships with children, relationships with relatives, home, relationships with neighbours and community.
CASIO model
This a five-fold model of life satisfaction.
Circumstances of the area of life.
Attitude towards the area of life.
Standards of how a person reaches evaluation or fulfillment in the area of life.
Importance placed on the area of life.
Overall satisfaction with other areas of life that are not of concern.
This is a way of reviewing areas of life that cause dissatisfaction, as well as areas they may have been overlooking.
Three pillars of Quality of Life
There are three pillars a therapist uses at the same time the CASIO model is started on individual life areas:
The first pillar is feelings of strength or inner abundance, which aims to help the client feel content and able to strive towards a better life.
The second is meaning in life, which helps the client identify a future goal.
The third is quality time, where a client is encouraged to spend time resting and reflecting.
Effectiveness evaluation
Toghyani et al investigated it’s effects on Iranian adolescent boys who had low scores on a well-being questionnaire.
They found those who had Quality of Life therapy had a significant improve in well-being after eight session
Grant et al looked into its effects on depression, by studying 16 participants with an interest in bibliography to read a manual of quality of life, with weekly meetings to discuss.
They found that all participants had a significant increase in quality of life and belief in their own competence.
Aghayousefi and Yasin Seifi examined the impact of Quality of Life therapy of those suffering with multiple sclerosis.
Those who received Quality of Life therapy had a significant decrease in depression and anxiety.
However, there is no evidence that Quality of Life therapy is more effective than applying basic positive psychology principles. Journaling was also found to be effective in producing positive states by Emmons and McCullough.
Ethical evaluation
This focuses on the positives of life, instead of dragging up the past and blaming the client for their thought patterns.
It also empowers the client, as there is a focus on free will.
However, it can be argued positive psychology is too new a movement, and that these strategies don’t have enough research or evidence.
Additionally, pessimists have been found to have their performances damaged if they have optimism forced upon them.
Classical evidence
Introduction
Done by Myers and Diener, who wanted to explore what caused happiness.
They did this by focusing on other research instead of creating their own, in order to give a more widespread overview of different aspects.
Due to this, they decided to do a meta-analysis
Methodology
They used many different types of research:
Interviews - Asking people about their SWB (subjective well-being) using a closed question, e.g asking a person if they are satisfied with life with three answers, very, not very, not at all.
Questionnaires - Asking people using a multi-scale item (a ranking from 1-10).
Observation - Ask people what they are thinking or doing at specific times in order to sample behaviour.
Correlations - Asking people other questions along with their SWB and plotting them on a graph. For example, positive view of life and happiness.
Review - They looked into reviews of multiple studies, and meta-analysis.
Findings
Myths of happiness
Happiness and age:
A survey of 160,000 people of different ages in 16 different countries found no differences - Inglehart.
Different factors contribute to happiness at different ages, such as health and social relations - Herzog et al.
Mid-life crisis are not the only crisis people can experience, and these can be at any age - McCrea and Costa.
Happiness and gender:
A survey of 160,000 people in 16 different countries found that 80% of women and men report being ‘fairly satisfied with life‘ - Inglehart.
A person’s gender accounted for 1% of global well-being - Haring et al.
Women are twice as vulnerable to depression as men - Robins and Regier.
Happiness and race or culture:
African-Americans report being twice as happy as European-Americans - Diener et al.
In Portugal, 10% of people reported being happy compared to 40% of people in the Netherlands - Inglehart.
People in individualist cultures report higher amounts of happiness than collectivist cultures. This is likely due to collectivists caring more about others, while individualists focus on themselves.
Happiness and money
In 1993, 75% of American college students selected being ‘well-off financially‘ as an essential life goal compared to 39% in 1987 - Astin et al.
There is a modest correlation of +1.2 between happiness and income - Diener et al.
Those on the Forbes rich list are 37% less happy than the average American - Diener et al.
People who win the lottery report only a small increase in happiness - Argyle.
Traits of happy people
Key traits:
High self-esteem - Happy people believe themselves to have good ideas and be fun to be around.
Sense of personal control - People who feel empowered perform better in school and cope better with stress.
Optimism - People who are happy expect to succeed when they try something new.
Extraversion - People who are outgoing are happier with others and alone, however newer research shows introverts are happier as they cope better with loneliness.
Relationships:
People who can name several close friends are healthier and happier than those who can’t - Burt.
Married people are 39% happy while unmarried are 24% happy, a 15% difference - Lee et al.
However, a meta-analysis of 93 studies found that men and women report equal levels of happiness for marriage and non-marriage.
Work satisfaction and ‘flow‘:
People in work are happier than those out of, as it gives a sense of identity and personal income.
The concept of flow, that when we get caught up in an activity other things matter less. Using beepers to track people throughout their day, it was found people were happiest when experiencing flow - Csikszentmihalyi.
Faith:
Religious people in North America and Europe report higher levels of happiness - Poloma and Pendleton.
People with a high spiritual commitment were twice as likely to say they were ‘very happy‘ - Gallup.
Happiness is linked to strength of religious affiliation and frequency of worship attendance - Witter et al.
Conclusions
Importance of adaptation:
Positive and negative events fade over time, such as winning the lottery. This adaptation to life’s circumstances allows humans to move on from psychological trauma.
Cultural worldview:
Cultural attitudes predispose interpretations of life events, such as some cultures seeing the world as benevolent and emphasising negative emotions such as anxiety, anger and stress.
Values and goals:
People with high SWB have goals and ambitions. Other factors are only important if they relate to a person’s goals.
As happiness is not predictable from race, financial status, gender or age, psychologists can focus on aspects that due matter in order to enhance human subjective well-being.
Experimental evaluation
Self-report
All subjective well being reports are inherently subjective as they are self-reported.
People may lie, or conform to social desirability bias.
However, it has been found that friend’s often rate people the same happiness level, increasing the validity.
A psychodynamic view is that people are actually repressing their true unhappiness, which is unlikely.
This means there is reason to believe self-reports of happiness.
Correlations
Many findings are correlational, meaning causal statements cannot be made. There are many extraneous or confounding variables that may cause a difference, such as married people being happier due to having more money.
We can also not tell the direction of correlational relationships. For example, happy people are more appealing marriage partners (Mastekaasa) meaning that it may be happy people are more likely to get married, not that marriage makes people happy.
The samples
The samples may be biased, as they focus more on Western samples and therefore more individualist cultures.
Collectivist cultures may be equally as happy but don’t express it as much, and more report higher levels when those around them succeed rather than themselves.
Additionally, any biased samples and any other validity issues would affect the whole analysis.
Ethical evaluation
Psychological harm
There is low risk of harm to the participants as behaviour is not manipulated.
However, people may find their sadness exacerbated once asked to reflect on their emotions, so a debrief in necessary.
If a patient reveals anything worrying during a debrief, it is a psychologist’s duty to refer them to a source of professional help.
This is because the BPS says that a psychologist should only practice within the boundaries of their confidence, meaning they should only do what they are specialised in.
Socially sensitive research
Socially sensitive research is research that may cause bias to be formed against certain groups.
For example, the study says only 10% of Portuguese people are happy, which may cause mistreatment.
This is faulty thinking as there is no way of knowing if the sample is generalisable.
Evaluation
Determinist < free will
People can choose their emotions, and these are not dictated by their struggles.
This helps people feel as if they can move on from their past and choose happiness.
Idiographic > nomothetic
While these are almost balanced, the focus on individual strengths makes it more personal.
This is a positive, as people can alter the approaches and therapies to fit their needs.
However, this approach has been criticized for ignoring cultural differences, as it focuses on individualism while collectivism is a key belief in 70% of the world’s population.
Nature < nurture
Slight lean towards nurture as interactions with others are deemed to be important.
Undermines free will angle.
Other approaches comparison
Cognitive
Both focus on free will to change thinking via therapies.
Positive is less scientific.
Cognitive is more reductionist and nomothetic.
Biological
Biological is more scientific, nature, determinist, nomothetic and reductionist.
Psychodynamic
Both non-scientific.
Positive is more free will, nurture and holistic.
Behaviourist
Both nurture leaning.
Positive is more free will.
Both have successful therapies.
Scientific < non-scientific
Happiness is not measurable by an objective means and relies entirely on self-report techniques, which are extremely susceptible to lying and biases such as social desirability.
Applications
Mindfulness therapy is practiced in many places, such as schools and workplaces. It is also used in the military to reduce stress and suicide rates.
Unique
The focus on happiness, which was an unexplored area of psychology. This approach shifted psychology’s focus from negativity, to positivity.
However, positive psychology is criticised for copying the humanistic approach, an example is Maslow’s hierarchy of needs.
Reductionist < holism
Focuses on all of a person’s strengths and what they specifically need to improve.