Bartolomé de Las Casas Describes the Exploitation of Indigenous Peoples, 1542
Context
- Bartolomé de Las Casas, a Spanish Dominican priest, wrote to the King of Spain urging new laws to prevent the brutal exploitation of Native Americans.
- The Destruction of the Indies (1542) circulated in Europe and was used as humanitarian justification for other European nations to challenge Spain’s colonial empire.
Natives: Nature and Civility
- Natives are portrayed as innocently simple, devoid of craft, deceit, and malice, yet obedient to their own sovereigns and generally peaceful toward Spaniards.
- They are capable of morality and goodness and are amenable to Civilization and Catholic faith; they are not opposed to civility and good manners.
- Spaniards themselves acknowledge that the natives have the potential for eternal grace if they understood the Deity.
Spanish Brutality and Demography
- The narrative highlights a contrast between native innocence and Spanish brutality, describing early assaults as excessively cruel.
- Demographic catastrophe is central: dramatic depopulation across the Americas due to massacre, violence, and enslavement.
Geographic Extent and Depopulation
- Hispaniola population originally about 3,000,000; today the remnant is around 300.
- Lucayan Islands (the north side near Hispaniola) consist of about 60 islands; many others were deserted or destroyed.
- Isles of St. John and Jamaica are described as unpeopled and desolate; thirty islands in the region are largely depopulated across a vast area roughly over 1,000 miles in extent.
- The land area depopulated across greater regions is described as more extensive than any single country, with land left lifeless and unused.
Motive and Methods of Extirpation
- The ultimate end and scope of the Spaniards’ actions is claimed to be Gold; wealth drives the conquest and suppression of indigenous populations.
- Over the Forty years of tyranny, more than 12,000,000 men, women, and children perished; the total death toll over time is suggested as high as 50,000,000.
- Ten kingdoms are depopulated, and vast tracts of land are described as ruined and desolate.
- Two principal methods were used to extirpate the people: (1) unjust, bloody, cruel war; (2) killing those who sought liberty or posed a challenge to captivity, including those captured in war and deprived of the country’s air and life.
The Two Courses to Extirpation
- The first course: unjust, bloody, cruel war intended to destroy the native populations.
- The second course: slaughter or forced death of those who sought freedom or resisted captivity; many were killed or enslaved rather than allowed to live in liberty.
Purpose, Rhetoric, and Impact
- Las Casas argues from a Christian humanitarian perspective: natives are innocent and capable of salvation; Europeans should treat them with justice and protect their humanity.
- The work functions as evidence intended to persuade European audiences and policymakers to restrain Spain’s empire and to inspire other nations to pursue reform or rival expansion.
- The text emphasizes moral judgment of European conduct and uses dramatic demographic data to underline the catastrophic consequences of colonial violence.
Source and Significance
- Destruction of the Indies (Bartolomé de Las Casas) is cited from Project Gutenberg (2007) and reflects early modern debates over colonization, race, and humanity.
- The account is frequently referenced as a foundational humanitarian critique of indigenous exploitation in the Atlantic world.