Hegel and Marx

Hegel’s Philosophical History

  • Hegel aimed to guide readers to "the concrete comprehension of absolute Truth," a non-formal self-consciousness.
  • This understanding encompasses the world and the meaning of human life in a way that aligns with Religion, with God as its central subject.
  • Hegel believed his work completed Luther’s "Spiritual Freedom and Reconciliation" and the Enlightenment demand for inward demonstration of truth.
  • Philosophy should lead to the insight that "the real world is as it ought to be".
  • This involves reconciling oneself to the death of God and recognizing universal divine reason as a vital principle.
  • God governs the world, and history is the execution of His plan.
  • The religiously informed life, even of a simple shepherd or peasant, embodies this reconciled consciousness, though its basis remains obscure to them.
  • Many contrast the world as it is with their ideal, leading to discontent or revolt, especially concerning "Reason, Justice, Liberty".
  • The activity arising from subjective will is integrated into the development of a State, which embodies the unfolding of the Divine Idea on Earth.
  • This progresses towards realizing complete self-consciousness of freedom in a rational State governed by laws of freedom.
  • Hegel critiques Kantian political liberalism for falling short of true freedom, viewing the State as more than a means of achieving universal limitation.
  • Hegel envisions a State embodying real laws of Freedom, unifying the objectively rational and subjectively rational will.
  • Progress towards this has been most evident in Germanic states, which have been less affected by Kantian liberal modernity.
  • Attainment causes reconciliation with the world and leads to an ideally immutable state: Reason pervades all of life.

Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit

  • Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit aims for complete self-understanding, reaching Absolute Knowledge or Spirit knowing itself as Spirit.
  • The goal is achieved through recollecting spiritual forms and their organization of their spiritual kingdom.
  • History and Science combine to form the recollection and Golgotha of Absolute Spirit, providing reality, truth, and certainty.
  • Hegel borrows from Schiller's poem "Friendship," altering the final lines.
  • In Man's grief-reconciled attaining to himself, God is given to himself.

Hegel vs. Schiller

  • Schiller emphasizes transcendence, with Man reaching towards God.
  • God creates souls in his image, yet finds no equal.
  • Schiller includes a dash to mark a separation, leaving God as "the transcendens."
  • Hegel seeks a reconciling negation of separation between Man and God, with each finding themselves in the other.
  • Hegel's view is more mystical, involving an experience of Oneness or Unity with the Whole, entailing loss of individual identification.
  • The fate of the individual in Hegel’s concept of State is a concern.
  • Hegel places emphasis on the community within the church, with love mediating between individual subjectivity and the church.
  • Kierkegaard critiques Hegel, asserting that the individual is the decisive Christian category, not the church.
  • The individual vs. community debate is central to political philosophy since Kant and Hegel, impacting Hegel's critique of Kant.
  • Hegel seeks to convince readers that limitation of self-will is essential for emancipation.

Marx’s Critique of Hegel

  • Marx engages with Hegel's Philosophy of Right, particularly the section on the State.
  • Marx shares Hegel's antipathy towards Kantianism and believes political liberalism falls short of allowing for full self-realization of Man.
  • Marx seeks a shift to the "real universality" of actual democracy, opposing the "mystical universality" of the Hegelian State.
  • The development of philosophical history pivots on religion and the concept of being "merely formal".

Marx’s Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right

  • Marx's Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right is a commentary on a specific section of Hegel's text, covering