The Mirrors of Las Meninas: Cochineal, Silver, and Clay

JSTOR is a non-profit service that supports scholars, researchers, and students by offering digital archives of a wide variety of content.
User acceptance of JSTOR's Terms & Conditions is required for access.

The thesis posits a singular world referred to as the Old World and the New World, stressing that these terms stem from the historical perspective rather than a true bifurcation (as highlighted by Garcilaso de la Vega).
Geoffrey Waite notes that the "meninas" (ladies-in-waiting) portrayed in history are often overlooked.

The cover of Carlos Fuentes's The Buried Mirror pairs imagery representing Spain and the New World, implicitly linking them through details.
Comparison shows that Las Meninas is a more profound representation of the transatlantic relationship than initially understood.

Objects produced by indigenous peoples are often hard to decipher within historical colonial contexts, with some artifacts highlighting their Amerindian craftsmanship, like feather mosaics.
Carolyn Dean and Dana Leibsohn emphasize that many colonial products are invisibly indigenous, constructed with methods rooted in pre-Hispanic traditions, impacting the interpretation of colonial Spanish America.
Visibility and invisibility of indigenous labor depend on our current perspectives, raising questions about how we analyze artifacts and what signs of indigenous labor we acknowledge.

Las Meninas serves as a lens through which the interconnections between Amerindian labor and Spanish elite culture become visible.
Three key painted details are identified as crucial:
- A red ceramic vessel reached for by Infanta Margarita
- A silver tray beneath this vessel
- A red curtain reflected in a mirror located in the background
Each of these objects symbolizes the products of New World labor.

Historical interpretations have largely focused on aesthetic movements leading back to the mid-seventeenth century, engaging with Michel Foucault's discourse on visibility and representation.
Foucault’s analysis highlights significant philosophical perspectives on visibility and invisibility within the painting, discussing how the subjects within the canvas interact with the reflections of power, represented by the king and queen.

J. H. Elliott's work links Velázquez’s later works to Spain’s economic decline, suggesting that Las Meninas reflects a sense of imperial desperation and the collapse of splendors.
This perspective is echoed in interpretations of royal portraiture, where artisanship and the value of art intersect, showing shifts in social contexts and the economy.

A significant analysis combines the visual representation of objects with references to historical documents, including travelogues and probate inventories.
The examination of cups, trays, and curtains invokes discussions of the global and local in material culture, emphasizing the importance of geographical origins of luxury items in affluent households.

Gemelli Careri's travel writings highlight the significance of New World commodities such as ceramics and silver, which circulated through extensive trade routes connecting various parts of the empire, including Asia.
The inventories from affluent households reinforce the depiction of a social landscape defined by the presence of goods from multiple geographical origins.

The significance of the b?caro (cup) in Las Meninas reflects a ceramic tradition from Guadalajara characterized by fine craftsmanship.
A definition within the text specifies that a b?caro is a vessel of fine clay, enjoyable for drinking, and esteemed across regions, including the Indies and Portugal, highlighting the transatlantic commodity exchanges.

Cochineal, derived from a New World insect, is reflected in the deep red hues of the curtain in Las Meninas, which indicates the colonial exploitation of resources.
The demand for red dyes shifted dramatically as cochineal became dominant by exceeding imports of traditional European dyes, demonstrating its economic significance in artistic and material culture.

Various social relations tying consumers to producers, especially focusing on labor dynamics in the New World, are elaborated. These relationships showed the socioeconomic ties underpinning consumption patterns within Spanish court life.

The depiction of various figures in the painting—including Amerindian laborers—suggests the broader complex identity of subjects, encompassing both the elite and indigenous populations.
Exploration of social dynamics between different ranks and roles within the painting serves to illuminate the nature of royal portraiture.

The cup, tray, and curtain within Las Meninas not only serve to enrich the painting's aesthetic but also point towards a deeper reflection on the economic and cultural exchanges between Spain and its colonies.
By examining these artifacts and their interrelations, Hamann advocates for a nuanced understanding of the colonial undercurrents that permeate Velázquez's work, presenting a microcosm of the broader socio-economic framework of the time.

The mirrors of Las Meninas: the explicit and implicit correlations between art, labor, and colonial economics become vital in giving context to the relationships reflected in Velázquez’s composition, highlighting a broader narrative of colonial studies.

Garcilaso de la Vega, Comentarios reales de los Incas (1609).
Geoffrey Waite, “Lenin in Las Meninas: An Essay in Historical-Materialist Vision” (1986).
Carolyn Dean and Dana Leibsohn, “Hybridity and Its Discontents: Considering Visual Culture in Colonial Spanish America.”
J. H. Elliott, Imperial Spain 1469-1716 (1963).
Additional references and citations from academic discourse on Las Meninas throughout the paper to establish scholarly context.