Henretta Ch. 10/11

The Rise of Popular Politics, 1810–1828

Expansion of the Franchise

  • The Democratic Revolution symbolized by the expansion of the franchise (the right to vote).

  • By the 1830s, most states allowed nearly all white men to vote, unlike England where the Reform Bill of 1832 extended the vote to only 600,000 out of 6 million men (10% of the male population).

  • Political parties provided mechanisms for voters to express their preferences.

Decline of Notables and Rise of Parties

  • The American Revolution weakened elite-run society but did not abolish it entirely.

  • Only Pennsylvania and Vermont gave the vote to all male taxpayers; many low-status families continued to defer to the wealthy.

  • Wealthy notables (landlords, slave-owning planters, merchants) dominated America’s political system post-Revolution.

  • John Jay, the first Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, argued that property owners were most suitable to govern.

  • Notables influenced local elections through patronage—lending money to farmers, giving business to storekeepers, and using refreshments as incentives.

The Rise of Democracy

  • Maryland reformers challenged property qualifications for voting in the 1810s, labeling them as “tyranny.”

  • As a reaction, broader suffrage was grudgingly accepted in seaboard states to curb westward migration.

  • New voters preferred candidates who embraced simplicity over aristocratic attire, leading to the election of modest men to office.

  • New state constitutions (Indiana, Illinois, Alabama) typically mandated broad male suffrage.

  • Public officials from humble backgrounds influenced changes like reducing debt imprisonment and promoting land claim simplification.

  • By the mid-1820s, most states had enfranchised all white men or those paying taxes, with few exceptions.

Political Developments in the Early 1820s

  • Between 1818 and 1821, more democratic constitutions were established in Connecticut, Massachusetts, and New York, focusing on population-based legislative representation and popular election of judges.

  • Political contests became contentious amidst the burgeoning democracy, often corrupted by party-driven patronage.

  • Parties appeared to provide structure to political debates, turning early freedoms into structured political engagement.

The Shift to Party Politics

  • Martin Van Buren sought to create a political structure based on party rather than familial ties in New York.

  • He advocated that political factions were necessary checks on governmental power.

  • Van Buren formed the first statewide political machine in New York, using media to promote policies and increase voter turnout through a strong patronage system.

Political Leadership and the Election of 1824

The Election of 1824

  • The decline of the notable-led Federalist Party and the fragmentation of the Republican Party led to the 1824 election with five key candidates: John Quincy Adams, John C. Calhoun, William H. Crawford, Henry Clay, and Andrew Jackson.

  • The popular election system became widespread; states elected electoral delegates rather than relying on legislative votes.

  • Although Jackson received the most electoral votes, no candidate achieved a majority, leading to a decision in the House of Representatives where Clay's influence played a pivotal role, resulting in Adams's victory via a “corrupt bargain.”

  • Adams proposed ambitious national projects and supported tariffs under the American System but faced significant opposition, especially from southern states.

The Policies of Adams and Jackson's Opposition

The Adams Presidency

  • Adams advocated for a strong national government focused on economic improvements and scientific advances, aligning with Clay’s American System.

  • His proposals largely met with resistance, especially among southern planters who feared protective tariffs and federal control.

  • The Tariff of 1824 provided protection for northern industries, exacerbating sectional tensions.

  • Adams's political approach was often labeled out-of-date, opposing the rising focus on popular opinion.

The Election of 1828 and Jackson's Campaign

  • Martin Van Buren revitalized Jackson’s political coalition focusing on popular equality among the electorate.

  • Jacksonians orchestrated a major campaign that celebrated democratic values and gained widespread support among various social groups.

  • The election showed a significant increase in voter turnout compared to the previously low participation in 1824.

Jackson's Transformative Presidency, 1829–1837

Jackson's Political Vision

  • Jackson's presidency transformed the national government through the expansion of presidential powers and a move toward a limited government.

  • He adopted a rotation system for officeholders and led a decisive rejection of the American System in favor of state authority.

  • His agenda included the elimination of national infrastructure projects and advocacy for local governance.

The Tariff and Nullification Crisis

  • High tariffs, particularly the Tariff of 1828, incited southern states' backlash, leading to the Nullification Crisis spearheaded by South Carolina against federal tariffs.

  • Increased tensions defined Jackson’s response to sectionalism and states’ rights arguments, with Jackson advocating federal authority.

The Bank War

  • Jackson opposed the Second Bank, citing constitutional grounds and class disparities, describing it as a harmful monopoly.

  • His veto against rechartering the Bank signified a dramatic increase in presidential power over Congress.

  • Upon winning the 1832 election, he hastened the removal of federal funds from the bank, leading to its ultimate dissolution.

Indian Removal Policies

  • Jackson’s administration pushed through the Indian Removal Act, leading to forced relocations of many Native American tribes, culminating in events such as the Trail of Tears.

  • Indigenous resistance often met with military force underscored the federal government’s commitment to land expansion.

Legacy and Impact

  • Jackson's presidency is marked by a complex legacy of expanding executive power while simultaneously advocating for a limited government approach.

  • The Taney Court continued this legacy by reversing many nationalist principles established previously, promoting a differing interpretation of the Constitution.

  • His period saw significant shifts in political philosophy, leading to the formation of the second party system, featuring Democrats and Whigs.