Individual Variation Essay
Analyse and compare how speakers/writers in both texts use language to covey personal and social identity.
Regional Variation
Text A GAP:
G - Man from Southern Yorkshire, possibly in a conversation. He’s talking about personal things/things to do with himself.
A - Isn’t specified in the data, his speech is informal and everyday like
P - He seems to be narrating things about his life/honestly still not sure on this.
Text C GAP:
G - Woman from South Yorkshire Rotherham, talking about her dream and how it coincided with a real life experience.
A - Maybe, a conversation with someone.
P - Informing/communicating to the other person about her experience of the dream?
In both texts, Speakers from the South Of Yorkshire are introduced. While the male is from Barnsley the female is from Rotherham. In the data the names/ages or any other additional context isn’t specified but it seems that In Text A the man seems to be talking about things concerning him, this is similar to Text C where the woman also talks about a dream which is centred on her own experiences. Both texts use the first person singular pronoun “I”, as shown in the quotes “I mean tha’s got thi mate” (Text A) and “I had this dream” (Text C), therefore using self orientated phatic tokens. In the first text it seems the man correctly uses the voiced dental fricative as shown in “/ðaz"/” however he omits the glottal stop and uses the “z” phoneme instead of the s. It could also be mentioned that the man uses specific British dialect such as “mate” and “lass” which could maybe show his social cultural background. This is contrast to Text C where the woman uses more of a standard approach, when narrating her dream. She uses simple past tense such as “had” and “was”, which could be a contrast to the colloquial and non standard approach the Yorkshire man uses. Alternatively the woman still uses some non standard speech (but not as much as the man does) as seen “ we were on us way to Chestefield”, the woman seems to use the possesive pronoun “us” instead of our which could also be a dialect feature much like the man’s.
In Text A, it seems like the man is constantly moving on from different topics without any coherence, as seen when he says “ tha comes down gym” and then talks about “ seeing your mates and lass”. However in text C, the woman seems to have some form of chronology to her speech, as seen “ We were driving up a hill and there were traffic lights on either side of the hill, and on the left hand corner there was a roundabout.” However it could be noted that there isn’t any previous context on what questions have been asked to these people, and who is asking them, also it may just come down to different communication styles which each speaker has. In Text A, idioms are also used as seen “ life’s too short kid” and “tha’s gotta let thi hair down”, which could show
It could also be mentioned that speakers in both texts, have very different attitudes on what they are talking about. In Text A, the Yorkshire man mentions “your lass” which may be hinting at his girlfriend/partner, however he then goes onto mention “it doesn’t matter if tha pulls a bird or not”. The speaker refers to females as ‘bird’ which is a typical slang term refferring to women, which could probably be seen as objectifying as he reduces a women to a thing.