Geographical Investigation and Fieldwork Methods

Stages of Geographical Fieldwork

Five stages of geographical fieldwork
  • Five Fieldwork Stages:

    • Stage 1: Craft research question or hypothesis

    • Stage 2: Collection of data

    • Stage 3: Analysis of data

    • Stage 4: Presentation of findings

    • Stage 5: Conclusion and evaluation

Research Questions and Hypotheses

  • Research Question:

    • Inquisitive question outlining a specific scope for investigation.

    • Used when limited research exists or variable relationships are uncertain.

    • Non-measurable; leads to multiple possible conclusions.

  • Hypothesis:

    • Predictive, measurable statement containing two or more variables (independent and dependent).

    • Used when significant background research exists.

    • Tested and accepted or rejected to form a definite conclusion.

Data Classification and Collection Sequencing

  • Primary vs. Secondary Data:

    • Primary Data: First-hand data collected by researchers (e.g., field sketches, photos, closed-ended survey responses).

    • Secondary Data: Data collected by third parties (e.g., books, articles, official maps).

  • Quantitative vs. Qualitative Data:

    • Quantitative Data: Quantifiable and measurable data (e.g., closed-ended survey answers, weather tracker readings, pedestrian counts).

    • Qualitative Data: Subjective, non-numerical data capturing opinions and emotions (e.g., open-ended survey answers, semi-structured interview transcripts).

  • Data Collection Sequences:

    • Quantitative then Qualitative: Quantitative data identifies overall patterns/trends first, followed by qualitative data to examine or explain them.

    • Qualitative then Quantitative: Qualitative data provides initial observations first, followed by quantitative data to verify them.

Fieldwork Limitations and Risk Management

  • Fieldwork Limitations:

    • Sample Size: A minimum sample size of 3030 is statistically required for reasonable analysis.

    • Practical Constraints: Constraints include timeframe, study area boundaries, equipment availability, access permissions, and available manpower.

  • Risk Mitigation:

    • Identification of environmental and safety risks prior to data collection (e.g., avoiding disturbance to resident otters or pollution at Bay East Garden near the barrage).

    • Implementation of measures to prevent harm to people and nature.

Sampling Methods

Sampling methods classification tree
  • Probability Sampling:

    • Random selection (e.g., random number generator or die) eliminating researcher selection bias.

    • Produces a representative sample of the target population.

    • Simple Random Sampling: Every member of the population has an equal chance of selection.

    • Stratified Random Sampling: Population divided into distinct sub-groups (e.g., age or sex ratio such as 60%60\% male and 40%40\% female); samples selected randomly within each subgroup in equal proportions.

  • Non-Probability Sampling:

    • Non-random, subjective selection by the researcher (e.g., selecting family or close friends).

    • Unlikely to be representative; higher risk of selection bias.

    • Convenience Sampling: Samples selected based on ease of accessibility.

    • Quota Sampling: Non-random selection to satisfy specified group quotas.

    • Used when rapid sampling is needed, or for exploratory research, conducting interviews, and questionnaire pre-testing.

Primary Data Collection Tools

  • Closed-Ended Questionnaire Surveys:

    • Collect quantitative data using predefined options for straightforward categorization and analysis.

    • Likert Scale: Measures levels of agreement or quality between opposing extreme positions.

    • Frequency Scale: Measures occurrence counts or time intervals.

    • Ranking Scale: Compares and orders preferences (recommended for fewer than 1010 items to maintain reliability).

  • Mental Maps:

    • Hand-drawn maps capturing personal spatial perceptions, familiarity, and feelings about an area.

    • Created on blank paper or pre-drawn base maps.

    • Combined with semi-structured interviews using open-ended questions to explore drawn features.

Data Processing and Analysis Methods

  • Quantitative Data Analysis:

    • Measures of Frequency: Counts and percentages calculated as:

Percentage=DataTotal data×100%\text{Percentage} = \frac{\text{Data}}{\text{Total data}} \times 100\%

  • Measures of Central Tendency:

    • Mean: Sum of all dataset values divided by the total number of values; includes all data but is sensitive to outlier skewing.

    • Median: Middle value of an ordered dataset; resilient to outliers but less sensitive to the overall dataset range.

    • Mode: Most frequent value; ideal for categorical data (e.g., primary transport mode) but unsuitable for continuous data.

    • Qualitative Mental Map Analysis:

  • Evaluated using centering/borders, feature scales, labeling, colors/legends, perspectives (aerial vs. street view), and added spatial components (paths, nodes, intersections).

  • Distortions, mislocations, and omissions reveal perceptual biases and spatial familiarity.

    • Pattern and Relationship Identification:

  • Scatter Plots & Best-Fit Lines: Show positive correlation, negative correlation, zero correlation, or isolated outliers/anomalies.

  • Spatial Patterns: Analyzed via geometric shapes, clusters (concentrated groups), and repetitions.

Data Presentation Methods

  • Maps:

    • Display spatial data using point symbols (dots), linear features (lines), and boundary regions (polygons).

    • Essential map elements: Title, Date, Orientation (North arrow), Scale, Legend, Author, and Data Source.

  • Graphs:

    • Bar Graphs & Pie Charts: Present categorical frequency distributions and proportion percentages.

    • Line Graphs: Display continuous variable trends over time or relationships between variables.

  • Photographs and Visual Media:

    • Satellite & Aerial Photographs: Illustrate spatial distribution and broad ecosystem/land patterns (e.g., Singapore terrestrial ecosystems map).

    • Ground-Level Photographs: Provide detailed views of specific local sites (e.g., Marina One).

  • Textual Data:

    • Colour-Coded Quotations: Group narrative qualitative findings into thematic categories.

    • Word Clouds: Visually display keyword frequency, where larger font size indicates higher occurrence and significance.