Boston University: Low Back Pain (LBP) with Movement Coordination Impairments

Overview

  • Instructor: Diane Dalton, PT, DPT, OCS

  • Main Focus: Movement Control and impairments related to chronic low back pain (CLBP).

Frameworks and Approaches

  • Hodges’ Hybrid Approach: Integrates the Treatment-Based Classification (TBC) and O'Sullivan’s frameworks into examinations and treatments relevant for pain classification.

    • Examined layer PIPT (Pain Inhibition and Proprioceptive Training) to inform treatment and assessment strategies.

Evidence-based Interventions

Recommendations from Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPG)
  • Physical therapists (PTs) should implement specific trunk muscle activation and movement control exercises for patients with CLBP and movement control impairment (Grade A evidence).

  • Exercise training, focusing on specific trunk muscle activation, is acceptable for patients with acute low back pain (Grade C evidence).

  • Approaches like TBC, cognitive functional therapy, or addressing movement system impairment can help reduce pain and disability in CLBP patients (Grade C evidence).

  • The TBC model is effective in reducing pain and disability for individuals experiencing acute low back pain (Grade B evidence).

Motor Control Definitions

  • Motor Control: Defined as "the way in which the nervous system controls posture and movement to perform a given motor task," including various motor, sensory, and integrative processes (van Dieën et al. 2019).

Theoretical Aspects of Motor Control

  • Systems Theory / Dynamical Systems Theory: Explores how stability relates to balance and motion, emphasizing that different motor solutions are necessary for different situations.

  • Variability in motor performance is necessary; excessive or insufficient variability can lead to complications.

Key Components of Motor Control

  • Optimal Muscle Activation: Ensures appropriate muscle engagement during tasks.

  • Accurate Sensory Information: Vital for effective motor responses.

  • Dynamic Control of Movement: Coordination of movement in real-time.

  • Maintenance of Static Position: Importance of holding positions while minimizing muscle fatigue.

Motor Control Differences in Low Back Pain

  • Motor control may demonstrate deviations in individuals experiencing low back pain (LBP). Questions raised include:

    • Is trunk muscle activity altered in those with LBP?

    • Can these changes in muscle activation reflect the commands from the motor system?

    • How do these changes manifest during steady-state postures or movement?

Changes in Muscle Activity in LBP

  • Inhibition of Deep Muscles: Leads to morphological changes in muscle structure over time.

    • Increased superficial muscle activity observed during tasks.

    • Altered timing of muscle firing noted with delayed contractions of deep muscles and increased activation of superficial muscles in reactive situations.

    • Persistent abnormal muscle activation can contribute to recurrent symptoms even after initial complaints subside (multiple studies cited).

Muscle Morphological Changes

  • Atrophy of Deep Muscles: Decreased cross-sectional area (CSA) in deep muscles, particularly in ipsilateral lumbar multifidus (LM) and transversus abdominis (TrA).

  • Alterations in muscle fiber types leading to changes in muscle composition over time, including fatty infiltration and fibrosis.

Proprioceptive and Postural Control Impairments

Proprioceptive Impairments
  • Observations include slower speeds and longer transition phases in movements such as the Sit to Stand Test (STSTS).

  • Changes in sensory cortex associated with altered proprioceptive strategies; reliance shift from lumbar muscles to ankle muscles alters sway responses.

Postural Control and Movement Dynamics
  • Observed variability in postural stiffness: some exhibit a loss of stiffness while others have excessive stiffness.

  • The implications of loading and muscle patterns influenced by varying postural conditions during tasks.

Alterations in Pain Processing

  • Smudging in Sensory and Motor Cortex: This leads to poorer precision in response to pain and motor tasks.

Summary of Adaptations in Motor Control for LBP Patients

  • Studies show variability and redistribution of muscle activation patterns across individuals.

  • These changes can modify mechanical behavior and lead to adaptations aimed at protecting from perceived threats of injury.

  • Behavioral responses such as reduced movement and increased splinting can be short-term solutions but may carry long-term negative implications.

Triage and Classification in Treatment Approaches

Treatment-Based Classification (TBC) Updates (2016)
  • Medical Management: Assessment strategy to recognize clinical findings and implement appropriate management based on red flags, medical comorbidities, and neurological evaluations.

  • Rehabilitation Management: Classification based on psychosocial risk and the presence of predominant leg pain.

  • Self-Care Management: Strategies directed at low psychosocial risk statuses and primarily axial low back concerns.

Management Phases
  1. Symptom Modulation: Focused treatments for high disability and volatile symptom status, including manipulation, mobilization, traction, and active rest.

  2. Movement Control: Interventions involving sensorimotor exercises, stabilization routines, and flexibility drills for moderate disability issues.

  3. Functional Optimization: Targets low disability with emphasis on strength, conditioning, sport-specific tasks and general fitness.

Movement Impairments vs. Control Impairments

  • Movement Impairments: Characterized by fear of movement, hyper-vigilance, muscle guarding, and aberrant movement patterns.

  • Control Impairments: Marked by anxiety, decreased proprioceptive awareness, loss of functional control, and inability to effectively dissociate lumbar from extremity movement.

Evidence Supporting Motor Control Exercises

  • Cochrane Review 2016 found benefits from Motor Control Exercises (MCE) for chronic LBP, comparable to other exercise types.

  • Limited effectiveness found in acute cases with insufficient participant grouping.

Neural Mobilization for Low Back Pain

  • Neurodynamic Techniques: Aim to restore stability in and surrounding the nervous system; demonstrated reductions in intraneural edema, improved fluid dispersion, and reversed immune response after nerve injury.

Motor Learning Principles

  • Focus on skill acquisition through enhancing context such as task-based practice, varied repetition, and appropriate feedback mechanisms.

  • OPTIMAL Theory of Motor Learning: Enhances motor learning through intrinsic motivation and attention, focusing on expected performance success, learner autonomy, and external focus on movement outcomes for improved automaticity.

Enhancing Expectancies and Learner Autonomy

  • Strategies to boost self-efficacy through positive feedback, social-comparative techniques, and autonomy-supportive instructional language, avoiding overly directive commands.

  • External focus on outcomes advances motor efficiency and forms a better coupling between intention and execution.