Society and Morality

Morality and Economic Activity

Definition of Morality

  • Morality is acting in accordance with principles or standards of right conduct.

The Role of Government in Maintaining Peace

  • Government's function includes maintaining peace, but intervention in trade and production should be occasional and a last resort.

  • Courts settle disputes when peaceful settlements fail.

  • Police cannot be everywhere at all times.

  • Government serves as the ultimate resort in maintaining peace.

The Necessity of Morality for Order

  • Morality and order require sources beyond constant police presence (totalitarian degree).

  • People must respect property, be productive, honest, just, upright, and faithful.

  • Varying degrees of trust are essential to extensive commerce.

  • Markets exist even under unfavorable conditions, but untrustworthiness increases security costs.

  • Increased security costs can raise prices, making goods unaffordable.

Morality without Authority

  • The theory suggests that markets, free from government intervention, develop their own order and morality.

  • Benefits of exchanging goods incentivize people to observe morality essential for production and distribution.

  • Morality based on calculation and utility is reinforced by successful production, trade, and commerce.

  • People are honest, truthful, and faithful due to the advantages of trade; no authority is needed to enforce morality.

Disadvantages of the "Morality without Authority" Theory

  • The theory hasn't been tested; no extensive society exists without some government.

  • No extensive society exists without morality based on authority beyond personal or social advantage.

  • Self-interest is a powerful motive, but it doesn't automatically lead to the general welfare.

  • Stealing, lying, and cheating can benefit individuals while harming others.

  • The general well-being depends on a highly developed moral/ethical sense.

Imparting Morality

  • Inculcating morality is not easy, even with religious convictions, parental teaching, social approval, and legal punishments.

  • Immorality and lawlessness can become widespread, threatening society's existence.

  • Morality needs extraordinary sanctions.

  • Multiple supports for morality are desirable.

  • Children learn morality and social behavior at home, along with customs and traditions.

  • Teaching morality occurs within parental authority, initially as "dos and don'ts."

  • Children want to know why they should do or not do certain things.

  • Parents may invoke authority ("Because I say so") or customs ("Because it isn't done").

  • Reason is an uncertain authority due to logical limitations.

Influences on Morality

  • Other sources of authority include siblings, peers, school, TV, movies, the Internet, and celebrities.

  • Church or Bible may become supplemental or ultimate authorities.

  • Appeals to conscience and legality also play a role.

Impact of Society and Morality on Economy

  • Morality supports economy; children learn honesty, trustworthiness, respect for property and rights, and faithfulness.

  • Virtues important to economy include hard work, thrift, punctuality, and doing a job well.

  • Desirability of independence, self-support, and providing for dependents is learned.

  • Kindliness, consideration for others, cooperation, and obedience to authority can affect economic affairs.

  • Learning morals and virtues isn't primarily for economic reasons, but they have an impact.

  • Respecting life, liberty, and property positively impacts economic lives.

  • Lack of a moral framework for these virtues results in tremendous economic costs.

Morality Outranks Economy

  • Economy can be placed in a subordinate role in life.

  • Some goods (e.g., cocaine, heroin) are harmful to produce and distribute, despite market effectiveness.

  • Attempts to prohibit goods in high demand (e.g., alcohol) may be ineffective and lead to lawlessness.

Claims About Morality

  • Claims about injustice, wealth distribution, extraordinary profits, and exploitation of workers may be uneconomic.

  • Attempts to redistribute wealth can harshly impact the economy.

  • Envy and covetousness may be licensed, leading to the taking of property from some to give to others.

Political Economy

  • Economics was shaped by classical economists, arguing against government regulation in the economy.

  • Market descriptions showed it works effectively without government interference.

  • Economics principles were useful knowledge.

  • Economics was initially called political economy and developed as a guide to political conduct.

  • Ideas emerged that the market worked well for some but not others.

  • Some economists championed government interventions.

  • Political economy was replaced by economics as economists increasingly supported interventions.

  • Many 20th-century economists advised governments on intervening in the economy.

  • Some economists still support the free market but have been a minority.

Morality in Government Policy

  • Morality questions exist in government action.

  • Unjust taxes are immoral.

  • Government redistributing wealth is considered immoral for individuals.

  • Taking property from some to give to others is wrong.

  • Electing representatives to do what individuals deem wrong is questioned.

  • These questions are answered in terms of morality, religion, and philosophy.

Society and Morality Form the Framework of Economy

  • Morality, sanctioned by society and religion, is important in economic activities.

  • Society, with customs, traditions, taboos, prescriptions, and institutions, is part of the economic background.

  • Economy is an aspect of society, prevailing morality, and beliefs.

Religion and Morality

  • Morality must be supported by rewards for doing right and penalties for doing wrong.

  • Sanctions accompany prohibitions and promise rewards.

  • Removing the sense of awe and mystery before God may remove the protection humans have from one another.

  • Murder may become widespread when people no longer believe in a transcendent God.