Comprehensive Guide to Logical Fallacies
Fundamentals of Logical Fallacies
- Definition of a Fallacy:
- A fallacy is an attractive but unreliable piece of reasoning.
- While writers typically aim to avoid making obvious fallacies in their reasoning, fallacies frequently occur unintentionally.
- In other cases, fallacies are employed deliberately when a writer believes they can successfully deceive an audience with faulty logic.
Fallacies of Relevance, Origin, and Personal Attack
Ad Hominem:
- Etymology and Translation: Latin for "against the man."
- Definition: The act of personally attacking opponents rather than addressing and engaging with their arguments.
- Mechanism: An ad hominem functions as an argument that appeals directly to emotion rather than reason, and to personal feeling rather than intellect.
Genetic Fallacy:
- Definition: Judging something as either inherently good or bad entirely on the basis of where it comes from, or from whom it originated.
- Mechanism: The fallacy sidesteps the actual substance of an argument by shifting the audience's focus onto the origins of the person or idea.
- Relationship to Other Fallacies: It is structurally similar to an ad hominem fallacy because it leverages existing negative perceptions to discredit someone's argument without presenting any objective justification or case for why the argument itself lacks merit.
Straw Man:
- Definition: Misrepresenting, distorting, or oversimplifying an opponent's argument to make it significantly easier to refute.
Fallacies of Emotional and Social Appeal
Appeal to Authority:
- Definition: Asserting that because somebody famous or prominent supports an idea, the idea must automatically be correct.
- Application: Widely utilized in commercial advertising to endorse products or viewpoints.
Appeal to the Bandwagon:
- Definition: Offering as evidence for an idea the claim that many people currently believe it, used to believe it, or actively practice it.
- Historical Example: In the 18001s, there was a widespread belief that bloodletting cured sickness. All of the people who held this view were not just wrong, but horribly wrong, as bloodletting actually made patients sicker.
- Core Principle: The widespread popularity or historical acceptance of an idea is no guarantee of its correctness.
Appeal to Emotion:
- Definition: An attempt to substitute a sound, logical argument with an appeal directed straight at the audience's emotional sensibilities.
- Common Varieties: Typical emotional appeals include an appeal to sympathy, an appeal to revenge, and an appeal to patriotism.
- Scope: Basically any human emotion can be leveraged as an emotional appeal in place of valid reasoning.
Fallacies of Analogy, Conventional Wisdom, and Categorical Shifting
Bad Analogy:
- Definition: Claiming that two situations, objects, or concepts are highly similar when they are not fundamentally comparable.
- Verbatim Example: "We have pure food and drug laws regulating what we put in our bodies; why can't we have laws to keep musicians from giving us filth for the mind?"
Cliche Thinking:
- Definition: Utilizing a well-known proverb, idiom, or saying as conclusive evidence, treating the cliché as though it were proven fact or possessed no exceptions.
- Verbatim Example: "I say: 'America: love it or leave it.' Anyone who disagrees with anything our country does must hate America. So maybe they should just move somewhere else."
No True Scottsman:
- Alternative Designations: Also known as appeal to purity [form of], or no true Christian.
- Definition: When a universal claim (employing absolute terms such as "all" or "every") is challenged and refuted, the speaker—rather than conceding the point or meaningfully revising the claim—alters the assertion from universal to specific without establishing objective criteria for the newly introduced specificity.
- Logical Form:
- Expression of the universal rule:
- Refutation step:
- Ad hoc alteration:
Causal, Deductive, and Inductive Fallacies
False Cause:
- Definition: Assuming that because two events occurred in succession, the first event must have caused the second event.
- Governing Principle: Sequence is not causation.
- Verbatim Example: "Before women got the vote, there were no nuclear weapons. Therefore women's suffrage must have led to nuclear weapons."
Hasty Generalization:
- Definition: Formulating a broad generalization based on insufficient, unrepresentative, or anecdotal data.
- Verbatim Example: "My uncle didn't go to college, and he makes a lot of money. So, people who don't go to college do just as well as those who do."
Non Sequitur:
- Definition: A conclusion that does not logically follow from its premises, rendering the argument formally invalid.
- Illustrative Example: "You've probably heard an example of a non sequitur before, therefore bunny rabbits are way cuter than chipmunks."
- Cultural Application: Non sequiturs are frequently utilized for comedic effect across movies, novels, and television shows.
Slippery Slope:
- Definition: The unfounded assumption that once a specific action or situation begins, it will inevitably continue down an uncontrollable path to its most extreme possible outcome.
- Verbatim Example: "If you drink a glass of wine, then you'll soon be drinking all the time, and then you'll become a homeless alcoholic."
Fallacies of Limited Choice
False Dilemma:
- Alternative Designations: Also known as the Either/or fallacy.
- Definition: Occurs when only two alternative choices are presented when in fact more exist, or when a broad spectrum of viable choices exists between two extremes.
- Linguistic Markers: Typically characterized by "either this or that" phrasing, though it can also occur through the deliberate omission of valid alternative choices.
False Trilemma:
- Definition: A specific structural variety of the limited-choice fallacy in which exactly three options or choices are presented when additional possibilities exist.