Paper2

Light Weighting Opportunities in Commercial Vehicle Frame Structures

Introduction

  • Focus on estimating light weighting opportunities for commercial road vehicle frame structures.

  • Estimation based on simplified static load cases relevant for frame dimensioning.

  • Comparison of various materials shows that light metals do not provide a weight reduction advantage over steel.

  • Material-independent topology optimization offers greater weight reduction potential than mere material substitution.

  • Ladder frame structure is established as the current optimal design for balancing complexity, cost, and weight.

Design Requirements for Frame Structures

  • Frame structure serves as the central interface for attaching various vehicle components.

  • Typically produced in high volumes, allowing for variations in superstructure by smaller companies.

  • Must be adaptable to various superstructure configurations and capable of handling different load spectra.

  • Key load case: vertical bending, modeled as a 2D beam supported at both ends with a single load.

  • Dynamic forces from road conditions factored into static models with an experience-based impact factor ranging from 1.3 to 3.

  • Flexibility is vital, especially in construction or mining applications, where a deformation angle of up to 20° is common.

  • Ladder frame structure consists of open U-shaped longitudinal beams connected by cross members, offering flexibility and cost-effectiveness.

Comparison of Lightweight Potential of Various Materials

  • Material choice impacts lightweight potential, factoring design requirements and load spectra.

  • Cost estimations should encompass production, assembly, tooling, and maintenance costs—not solely material costs.

  • Comparative study highlights:

    • Aluminum's higher overall weight reduction potential compared to high strength steel (HSS) but varies by component load case.

  • Maximum thickness of frame profile section derived from stress calculations based on yield strength, material properties, and design space constraints.

Geometry-Driven Lightweight Construction

  • Adjusting section dimensions can yield proportional weight changes without changing material.

  • The goal is to maximize load capacity while minimizing material use.

  • Using a U-shaped profile can reduce weight significantly by maintaining the same section modulus.

  • Advanced manufacturing techniques (e.g., roll forming) help achieve complex shapes without compromising structural integrity.

Node Design Considerations

  • Proper node design is crucial to minimizing structural failures in frames with different profiles.

  • Design rules for node types include:

    • Allowing free warping of flanges to prevent stress peaks during load.

    • Using only webs for joining longitudinal beams and cross members to avoid stress concentration.

    • Attach loads close to the shear center for less torsion.

  • Case studies demonstrate successful upgrades from mild to high strength steel, achieving significant weight reduction in operational capacities.

Achievements by Chinese Truck Manufacturers

  • Dongfeng Motor Co. reports weight reductions through design changes and material upgrades; examples include:

    • Weight reductions of 84 kg and 96 kg from frame and angle sheet changes, respectively.

    • Upgrading longitudinal beams to high strength steel resulted in 150 kg weight savings.

  • Use of varying high strength steel grades leads to substantial weight reductions, supporting increased loading capacity without major cost increases.

Conclusions and Outlook

  • High strength steel offers optimal weight saving and cost benefits for commercial vehicles.

  • Design and topology must prioritize maintaining performance in joint and connecting areas to mitigate risk.

  • Collaborative efforts between vehicle manufacturers and steel producers crucial for developing and applying newer materials and technologies for frame structures.

  • Demonstration of lightweight design benefits essential in changing perception among vehicle operators.