16

Personality Disorders

Overview of Personality and the Big Five Traits

  • Personality: Relatively enduring and consistent patterns of thinking, feeling, and acting that define individual uniqueness.
  • Key Traits: The Big Five personality traits include:
    • Openness to Experience: Curiosity about a wide array of subjects.
    • Conscientiousness: Organization and reliability, contrasted with carelessness.
    • Extraversion: Sociability and outgoingness.
    • Agreeableness: Helpfulness and altruism towards others.
    • Negative Affectivity (Neuroticism): Proneness to worry and emotional instability.

Evolutionary Perspective on the Big Five

  • Nettle (2006) posits there is no single optimal level for the Big Five traits from an evolutionary perspective, suggesting diversity in traits benefits group survival (Wallrich et al., 2024).

Can Personality Traits Be Maladaptive?

  • Maladaptive Traits: Traits can be problematic if they:
    • Exist at extremes (e.g., very high neuroticism leading to emotional lability).
    • Are inflexible, severely impacting adaptability to environmental changes.
    • Mismatch with environmental needs/goals.
    • Correlate with psychological diagnoses (e.g., high neuroticism with internalizing disorders).
  • Additional Influences: Individual motives, goals, and strategies might contribute to clinical problems.

Introduction to Personality Disorders in the DSM

Understanding Personality Symptoms

Examples of Maladaptive Behavior:
  • A salesperson engages in deceitful practices without guilt.
  • Upset over minor disruptions in plans, reflecting rigid behavior.
  • Excessive concern for security, leading to compulsive locking of doors.
  • Limited social interactions beyond work-related communication.

DSM-5 Definition of Personality Disorder

  • Criterion A: Enduring pattern of inner experience/behavior, deviating from cultural expectations across two or more areas (cognition, emotion, relationships, impulse control).
  • Criterion B: The pattern is inflexible and pervasive across various personal/social contexts.
  • Criterion C: The pattern results in clinically significant distress or impairment.
  • Criterion D: The pattern is stable and long-lasting, tracing back to early adulthood.
  • Note: DSM-5 removed the “axis” system present in DSM-IV for personality disorders.

Characteristics of Personality Disorders (Table 1)

  • Personality Disorder Types:
    • Paranoid: Distrust and suspiciousness; perceives others as malevolent.
    • Schizoid: Detachment from social relationships and restricted emotional expression.
    • Schizotypal: Discomfort in close relationships with cognitive distortions.
    • Antisocial: Disregard for others' rights; deceitfulness and impulsivity.
    • Borderline: Instability in relationships, self-image, and affects; impulsivity.
    • Histrionic: Excessive emotionality and attention-seeking.
    • Narcissistic: Grandiosity, need for admiration, lack of empathy.
    • Avoidant: Social inhibition, feelings of inadequacy, hypersensitivity to evaluation.
    • Dependent: Excessive need for care, leading to submissive behavior.
    • Obsessive-Compulsive: Preoccupation with orderliness and perfectionism.

Diagnostic Criteria for Selected Personality Disorders

Example 1: Paranoid Personality Disorder

  • Criteria:
    • A pattern of distrust such that others' motives are seen as malicious, beginning in early adulthood, evidenced by four or more of the following:
    1. Unjustified suspicion of exploitation or harm.
    2. Doubts about loyalty or trustworthiness of friends.
    3. Reluctance to confide in others due to fears of malicious use of information.
    4. Misinterpretation of benign comments as threatening.
    5. Unforgiveness of slights.
    6. Misperception of attacks on reputation.
    7. Unjustified suspicion regarding fidelity.
  • Exclusion: Criteria do not overlap with schizophrenia or mood disorders.

Example 2: Schizoid Personality Disorder

  • Criteria:
    • Pattern of detachment from social relationships, beginning in early adulthood, with four of the following:
    1. Lack of desire for close relationships.
    2. Preference for solitary activities.
    3. Limited interest in sexual experiences.
    4. Little pleasure in activities.
    5. Lack of close friends except first-degree relatives.
    6. Indifference to praise or criticism.
    7. Emotional coldness or detachment.
  • Exclusion: Not during episodes of schizophrenia or autism spectrum disorders.

Prevalence and Comorbidity of Personality Disorders

  • Approximately 10-12% of US adults have met criteria for at least one personality disorder over the past 2-5 years.
  • Personality disorders show very high rates of comorbidity with other DSM disorders.

Prevalence Rates (Community vs. Treatment Settings)

  • Treatment Settings: Higher rates of personality disorders compared to community findings, indicating prevalence variation based on setting.

Etiology of Personality Disorders

Nature vs. Nurture

  • Personality disorders have moderate to high heritability.
  • Shared genetic risk exists across various personality disorders and non-PD conditions.
  • Common environmental factors such as family trauma also play a significant role.
  • Complexity in causative relationships between genetic, environmental factors, and personality traits.

Example: Antisocial Personality Disorder

  • Diagnostic Criteria:
    • A pervasive pattern of disregard for others' rights, evidenced since age 15, with at least three of the following:
    1. Failure to adhere to social norms leading to arrests.
    2. Deceitfulness through lying or conning.
    3. Impulsivity or planning failures.
    4. Aggressiveness leading to fights.
    5. Reckless endangerment.
    6. Irresponsibility in work and financial matters.
    7. Lack of remorse for actions.
    • The individual must be at least age 18.
  • Conduct Disorder evidence required before age 15.

Risk Factors and Developmental Perspectives in ASPD

Risk Factors

  • Genetic Factors: Traits associated with psychopathy are moderately heritable.
  • Environmental Factors: Family backgrounds characterized by low warmth and high negativity increase risk.
  • Developmental Trajectories: Early antisocial behaviors predict adult ASPD with severity increasing with onset age.
  • Gene-Environment Interactions: Emphasizes the impact of inherited traits combined with adverse environmental contexts.

Diagnostic Challenges in Personality Disorders

Misdiagnosis

  • High rates of misdiagnoses due to imprecise criteria.
  • Structured interviews improve reliability but are often underused.

Diagnostic Overlap and Heterogeneity

  • Comorbidities are prevalent, with over 50% of individuals meeting criteria for more than one PD, creating complex research challenges.

Coverage and Stability

  • DSM often lacks adequate diagnostic overlap and stability, with fluctuating symptomatology over time. It highlights challenges in retaining long-term diagnostic categories.

Alternative Models for Diagnosing Personality Disorders

Dimensional Approaches

  • DSM-5 proposed a dimensional model to shift focus from categorical to dimensional assessments of personality traits.
  • AMPD (Alternative Model of Personality Disorders) suggested more refined and clinically relevant trait measures.
  • Emphasizes personality functioning and stability as central diagnostic criteria.

Treatment for Personality Disorders

Treatment Approaches

  • Historical skepticism on the treatability of PDs; however, recent evidence shows many individuals benefit from therapy.
  • Interpersonal and cognitive-behavioral therapies are applied for various PDs, with some notable methodologies being:
    • Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT): Combines CBT with mindfulness, effective for BPD.
    • Specific treatments like RO-DBT and exposure-based CBT for disorders like OCPD and ASPD.

General Findings

  • Early intervention enhances treatment effectiveness; however, managing personality disorders often presents unique challenges regarding client retention and willingness to engage.

Common Misconceptions and Stigma

  • Personality disorders carry unique stigma, prevalent among professionals and might affect treatment approaches.

Conclusion

  • The understanding and treatment of personality disorders require ongoing adaptation to align with evolving psychological research and clinical practice while addressing the complexities associated with personality traits and their implications in treating mental health issues.