Methods of Embryo Selection (improved)
Rationale Behind Embryo Selection Methods
Employing specific methods for embryo selection based on scientific rationale in reproductive medicine.
Lecture Overview
Overview of key topics discussed in the lecture:
Development of a zygote to the blastocyst stage
Visual cues to assess embryo 'quality'
Clinical decisions made for embryo transfer on a specific day of development
Temporal development of embryos using time-lapse imaging
Pre-implantation Genetic Testing (PGT) and Embryo biopsy
Morphology Assessment
Embryo Development & Morphology
Embryo Morphology Scoring:
Commonly used method for assessing which embryos are chosen for transfer or freezing.
Advantages:
Quick
Easy
Non-invasive assessments
Disadvantages:
Not always reliable but considered good indicators, especially for freezing purposes.
National External Quality Assessment Scheme - NEQAS
Module Breakdown
Parameters for assessment:
Sperm Motility: Match (Grade )
Sperm Morphology: Match (Grade )
Embryos from Patients:
Patient : Match (Grade )
Patient : Match (Grade )
Patient : Match (Grade )
Patient : Match (Grade )
Grade Ranges:
: Very good
: Good
: Satisfactory
Match \% Explanation:
The Match parameter describes the correlation of your results with reference values, assessing the quality of outcomes.
Development Timeline of Embryos
Temporal Development of an Embryo
Day : Zygote forms within hours
Day : Transitions to -cell stage (h)
Day : Reaches -cell stage (h)
Day : Becomes -cell stage (h)
Day : Morula stage (h)
Day :
Early Blastocyst (h)
Expanding Blastocyst (h)
Fully Expanded Blastocyst (h)
Statistical Prediction:
Prediction of producing a full-term birth: based on development stage.
Pronuclear Morphology & Abnormality Causes
PN Zygote: Represents proper fertilisation with two pronuclei.
Abnormalities can arise from:
Chemical or physical stress causing parthenogenesis or non-synchronous appearance of pronuclei.
Retention of polar bodies in IVF and ICSI cases and polyspermy phenomena.
Pronuclear Nucleoli: A Predictor of Embryo Quality?
Nucleoli patterning has been proposed to determine quality, suggesting development occurs within a narrow window of time (James et al. ).
Embryo Morphology Scoring
Day & Day Scoring
Day Assessment: Embryos should ideally have cells;
Day Assessment: Should contain cells.
Blastomere Characteristics
Size and Fragmentation Assessment
Regularity and Size: Regularity in blastomere size significantly correlates with increased pregnancy outcomes (Hardarson et al., ; Holte et al., ).
Fragmentation:
Up to of in vitro embryos show fragmentation, impacting implantation.
Over fragmentation can impair development; of live birth embryos exhibit less than fragmentation (Alikani, ).
Influencing Factors: Apoptosis, culture conditions, maternal age, and hereditary factors may contribute.
Clinical Considerations for Embryo Quality and Transfer
Factors Influencing Decisions:
Quality of embryos vs. developmental rate
Previous IVF outcomes influencing future decisions
Number of embryos available for transfer
Endometrial synchrony may influence timing of transfer (Day vs. Day ).
Genetic screening needs and patient preferences.
Blastocyst Development and Scoring
Scoring on Day
Expansion Status: Ranges ( to ):
: Early Blastocyst (blastocoel < half volume)
: Blastocyst (blastocoel > half volume)
: Full Blastocyst (blastocoel fills embryo)
: Expanded Blastocyst (blastocoel > volume of embryo)
: Hatching Blastocyst (trophectoderm herniates through zona pellucida)
: Hatched Blastocyst (evacuated zona pellucida).
Temporal Development: Time-Lapse Imaging (TLI)
Systems Used: Various time-lapse imaging systems (Embryoscope, EEVA, etc.) capture images every minutes.
Detailed evaluations of developmental timings contribute to understanding embryo viability and potential.
TLI Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
Improved predictions of blastocyst potential and embryo vitality through continuous monitoring.
Disadvantages:
Possibility of surrendering viable embryos as culture selects against those with lower developmental potential.
Studies suggested differing implantation success between Day transfers and Day selection (Yang et al., ).
AI for Morphokinetic Scoring
Implementation:
Automation and improved selection of embryos from TLI data with AI. Potentially offering better predictive capabilities compared to traditional methods (Diakiw ; Sawada et al. ).
Pre-Implantation Genetic Testing (PGT)
Types of tests:
PGT-A: Aneuploidy Screening
PGT-M/SR: Mendelian Disorders Diagnosis
Evolution of PGT: Methods
Biopsy Techniques:
Polar Body Biopsy
Cleavage Stage Biopsy (PN, -cell stages)
Blastocyst Biopsy ( cells).
PGT Applications and Implications
Advantages:
Reduces chances of aneuploidy-related implantation failures.
Facilitated single embryo transfers, improving outcomes for patients with multiple clinical complexities.
Disadvantages:
Cost, risk of damaging embryos during biopsy, and complications from mosaicism remain challenges.
PGT Evidence
Need for further research; insufficient high-quality evidence for an increase in successful live births when employing PGT. Potential risks associated with mosaicism within embryos need clarification according to more recent studies (Cornelisse et al., ).