Annotated Bibliography: Should Everyone Go to College?
Document Details and Context
Academic Overview:
Student Name: Kareem Talaat
Instructor: Mr. Van Velzer
Course Title: Beginning Composition Block
Date: September
Project Title: Annotated Bibliography: Should Everyone Go to College?
Source 1: "Should Everyone Go To College?" (NPR / All Things Considered)
Citation Details:
Title: "Should Everyone Go To College?"
Program / Publication: All Things Considered
Broadcast Date: July
Database: Gale In Context: High School
Document Link / URL: link.gale.com/apps/doc/A203640212/GPS?u=fol36665&sid=bookmark-GPS&xid=4d63a 4b9
Access Date: Sept.
Program Host: Robert Siegel
Reporting Journalist: Claudio Sanchez (retired, award-winning reporter)
Core Content and Arguments:
Explores the proposition that traditional four-year college education is not suitable for every student.
Positions community college as a strong alternative pathway.
Highlights former President Barack Obama's endorsement of community colleges over traditional four-year universities.
Emphasizes that many upcoming jobs will require an associate's degree rather than a bachelor's degree.
Reliability, Peer Review, and Bias Evaluation:
Publisher Background: All Things Considered is published by National Public Radio (NPR), a semi-reliable nonprofit news organization focused on truthful reporting.
Fact-Checking Structure: NPR does not employ dedicated fact-checkers; instead, a group of employed editors assesses accuracy and peer-reviews content.
Public Trust Data: According to Pew Research, of American adults trust NPR. This figure includes the of surveyed adults who have never heard of NPR.
Evidence and Sources: Utilizes statements from well-known figures, including President Barack Obama, alongside multiple supporting references.
Lateral Reading Findings:
Sources such as RadioInk and Education One confirm that NPR is a credible news resource.
AllSides rates NPR as leaning left, indicating potential political bias.
Application and Practical Utility:
Documents the growing shift toward associate's degrees becoming the standard entry point for career fields.
Validates community college as a beneficial primary path rather than a fallback option.
Useful in research essays to provide alternative routes for students avoiding four-year colleges, while keeping in mind potential political bias.
Source 2: "Not Everyone Should Go to College. And That’s OK." (Education Week)
Citation Details:
Authors: Michael B. Horn and Bob Moesta
Title: "Not Everyone Should Go to College. And That’s OK."
Periodical: Education Week
Publication Date: March
Access Date: August
Article URL: https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/opinion-not-every-student-should-go-to-colleg e-and-thats-ok/2020/03
Author Qualifications:
Michael B. Horn: Holds a Bachelor of Arts (BA) from Yale University and a Master of Business Administration (MBA) from Harvard University; currently serves as a lecturer at the Harvard Graduate School of Education.
Bob Moesta: Holds multiple academic degrees from Michigan State University, Harvard Business School, and Stanford University.
Core Content and Demographic Data:
Examines the issue of students attending college due to societal expectations or personal hardships rather than alignment with personal ambitions.
Key Student Statistics:
of college students are the first generation in their family to pursue a bachelor's degree.
of college students have at least one child.
of college students come from households situated in the bottom three socio-economic quintiles.
Demonstrates that students from disadvantaged backgrounds often enroll primarily to escape difficult life circumstances.
Explains that societal pressure framing college as mandatory leads students to attend regardless of their individual goals.
Reliability, Peer Review, and Bias Evaluation:
Organization Profile: Published by Editorial Projects in Education, a nonprofit organization founded in
Reputation: Education Week is an award-winning publication recognized for education news, data, and analysis.
Fact-Checking Structure: Employs internal editors and staff reporters for information verification rather than maintaining dedicated fact-checkers.
Bias Rating: Lateral reading through AllSides rates Education Week as centered, indicating limited political bias.
Application and Practical Utility:
Explains non-academic motives driving college attendance.
Answers research questions on college necessity by revealing that many enrolled students would be better served by non-traditional alternatives.
Supports arguments against universal college attendance by highlighting mismatch between student goals and institutional models.
Source 3: "College Is the Holy Grail, But Should Everyone Go?" (Brookings Institute)
Citation Details:
Author: Isabel V. Sawhill
Title: "College Is the Holy Grail, But Should Everyone Go?"
Publisher: Brookings Institute
Publication Date: May
Access Date: August
Article URL: https://www.brookings.edu/articles/should-everyone-go-to-college/
Author Qualifications:
Isabel V. Sawhill: Renowned researcher and winner of the Moynihan prize.
Core Content and Return on Investment (ROI) Analytics:
Evaluates the benefits and drawbacks of pursuing higher education.
Notes that while a quality bachelor's degree can offer a high return, financial returns vary significantly based on the specific institution and student major.
Institutional ROI Statistics: A Brookings brief indicates that out of higher education institutions evaluated, produce a negative ROI.
Concludes that four-year colleges are not designed to serve all individuals, making vocational trade schools or alternate pathways superior options for many.
Reliability, Peer Review, and Bias Evaluation:
Organization Profile: The Brookings Institute is a public policy think tank established in
Fact-Checking Structure: Uses internal editors and peer reviewers to ensure accurate reporting.
Industry Accolades: Named "Think Tank of the Year" in the first edition published by the University of Pennsylvania; recognized as the most cited think tank globally as of
Bias Rating: A UCLA study categorized the Brookings Institute as centrist, noting it is cited by both conservative and liberal politicians.
Application and Practical Utility:
Highlights financial and structural shortcomings of universal higher education.
Demonstrates that non-college career paths can offer stronger outcomes depending on individual goals.
Delivers empirical data and analytical evidence supporting arguments that four-year higher education is not necessary for every student.