Sovereign Power vs. Disciplinary Power
Sovereign Power
- Historical Context: Sovereign power was the predominant form of rule during ancient times, medieval times, and eras defined by kings, monarchs, rulers, and emperors.
- Mechanism of Action:
- When an individual stepped out of line or broke established rules, authority was maintained by making a public example of that individual.
- Punishments were explicitly designed to be gruesome and were performed publicly in front of the general population.
- Dual Purpose of Sovereign Punishment:
- Punish the Person: To directly inflict punishment on the individual who committed the infraction.
- Public Deterrence: To visibly demonstrate to society the consequences of steping out of line, enforcing compliance through the threat that the exact same fate would happen to anyone else.
- Examples of Sovereign Power and Punishments:
- Public executions.
- Restraints in the public square, such as the stocks, where a person who broke rules was placed in public town-center restraints while people would chuck blue at them.
- Getting burned at the stake.
- Getting hung.
- Getting hooked in the stocks.
- Getting tarred and feathered.
Disciplinary Power
- Societal Shift: As governance evolved away from single-monarch systems into democracies, republics, and political structures not governed by a single ruler, sovereign power transitioned into disciplinary power.
- Mechanism of Action:
- Replaces single-ruler authority (e.g., a sovereign monarch declaring "off with their head") with institutional regulation.
- Discipline and punishment are distributed across institutional frameworks rather than handled by a single sovereign ruler or displayed publicly to the general public.
- Key Institutions:
- Institutions such as schools and prisons take on the role of enforcing discipline, managing populations, and keeping people in line.
- Systemic and Societal Considerations:
- Disciplinary power within institutional framework impacts access to essential services and care.
- Institutional access creates disparities, such as differing levels of healthcare access for individuals struggling with mental health issues or people experiencing homelessness compared to other members of society.
Questions and Audience Interaction
- Historical Knowledge and Media Inquiries:
- Direct prompts regarding public restraints: Queries asking if individuals have heard of the stocks or seen depictions in history textbooks or media showing rule-breakers restrained in public town squares while people chuck blue at them.
- Concept Verification:
- Direct clarification checks regarding the understanding of sovereign power: "Any questions about it? Is that for you?"