Feminism Applied: Notes on the Gender Pay Gap 14

The Politics of Diversity: Feminism Applied (The Gender Pay Gap)

Key Objectives

  • Understanding the Gender Pay Gap
  • Exploring Evidence & Debate around the gender pay gap
  • Analyzing Sex Discrimination Protections

Understanding the Gender Pay Gap

  • Definition: The gender pay gap refers to the average income difference between women and men.
  • Historical Context:
  • In the 1950s: Women earned about 60% of what men earned.
  • By 2016: This figure rose to 77%.
  • Interpretations: Such disparities are often viewed as symptoms of sexism and sexual discrimination.

Evidence of the Gender Pay Gap

  • Wage Disparity over Time: The ratio of median earnings for full-time, year-round workers has shown a slow closing of the gender wage gap since the 1960s.
  • Key Years:
    • 1950: Women earned 60% compared to men.
    • 1973: Gender pay gap reached a peak of 56.6%.
    • 2020: Women earned 81% of what men earned.
  • 2018 Median Income Data:
  • Women: $45,097
  • Men: $55,291
  • The gap represents a $10,000+ difference.

The Gender Pay Gap Explained

  • Controlled vs. Uncontrolled Pay Gap:
  • Controlled Pay Gap: Compares individuals with the same job and qualifications, showing women earn 98 cents for every $1 earned by men.
  • Uncontrolled Pay Gap: Compares median salaries across all jobs, where women earn 81 cents for every $1 earned by men.
  • Factors Influencing the Gap:
  • Career Choices: Women often choose lower-paying occupations (e.g., education, healthcare) while men dominate higher-paying fields (e.g., technology, engineering).
  • Sex-Based Discrimination: Example includes disparities in pay and opportunities within similar occupations.
  • Intersectionality: The gap is larger for women of color, with Black women earning 75% of what White men earn on average, but 98% when accounting for same qualifications.

Implications of Pay Inequality

  • Significance: Despite progress, women still face barriers like financial resources and political influence, particularly in communities of color.
  • Historical Legacies: Past discrimination impacts current income levels due to unequal starting points.
  • Social Norms: Harder for women to advance in certain fields due to entrenched biases.

Landmark Case: Ledbetter v. Goodyear (2007)

  • Background: Lilly Ledbetter filed a lawsuit for gender discrimination after discovering she earned less than her male counterparts over 19 years.
  • Supreme Court Decision: Initially ruled against Ledbetter due to a technicality regarding the timeframe of filing discrimination claims.

Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act (2009)

  • Purpose: Amended the Civil Rights Act to close loopholes that limited women's ability to challenge unequal pay.
  • Key Provisions:
  • Defined unlawful employment practices that allow ongoing pay inequities to be challenged.
  • Enhanced protections against employment discrimination for women.

Conclusion and Recap

  • On average, women earn less than men.
  • The pay gap has been narrowing, with a remaining disparity of 2-3% in similar occupations.
  • Structural inequalities perpetuate these gaps, but recent legislation aims to rectify this injustice.

Reflection Questions

  • Is the income inequality between men and women a significant issue in today's society? What insights can be drawn from the trends and legislation discussed?