Engineering Principles and Assessment One Preparations in Design and Technology

Assessment One Requirements and Submission Guidelines

  • Assessment Number One is scheduled for Friday August 14, October '59. It is governed by a forty-eight hour rule.

  • The latest possible submission time is Wednesday, Sunday on or before 23:59.

  • If issues occur with the upload on Sunday, an email must be sent to the unit coordinator immediately on that day for a response.

  • The assessment is divided into two primary tasks:

    • Task One: An activity plan utilizing a specific template. This is a sequence of teaching activities aligning with Australian Curriculum knowledge and skills, focusing solely on Design and Technology. This section must contain no references as it is a practical sequence of steps.

    • Task Two: A critical reflection (approximately 750 words) on how technology activities are implemented in the classroom and connected to educational theories. This section requires academic referencing.

Educational Theories and Key Learning Areas

  • Three specific learning theories underpin the implementation of Design and Technology activities:

    • Behaviorism: Relates to the direct instruction and structured readings.

    • Constructivism: Demonstrated through group work and collaborative tasks. If an activity plan identifies constructivism as a foundation, the teaching sequence must include group tasks rather than just individual work.

    • Cognitivism: Involves the "stronger other" concept and spreading baseline knowledge and understanding through social or academic group settings.

  • Key concepts that underpin the Design and Technologies strand include:

    • Design thinking: The primary basis for the learning area.

    • Systems thinking: Explored through topics such as "food from farm to plate."

    • Engineering principles: Focuses on physical forces and material properties.

    • Project management: A component of design thinking used to develop student skills individually and collaboratively.

Assessment One Rubric and Quality Criteria

  • Criteria 1 (Activity Plan): Requires excellent overview, curriculum links, teacher preparation, and materials.

  • Criteria 2 (Teaching Strategies): Must align with technology processes and metadata, such as engineering principles (lift, drag, weight, thrust).

  • Criteria 3 (Process and Production Skills): Must align with the Processes and Production Skills (PPS). For Year 3 and up, the "investigating and defining" content descriptor must be included in the template. Foundation Year requires only one process and production skill.

  • Criteria 4 (Resources): Sample resources must be of excellent quality. If a PowerPoint is used, the details of its content must be described in the plan, even if the slides are not in the appendix. Web links must be functional and directed to specific pages.

  • Criteria 5 (Workshop Reflections): High Distinction (HD) requires evidence from all four workshop activities, including four images. A Distinction requires four photos but potentially less comprehensive literature integration.

Referencing and Academic Integrity

  • A strong submission for the 750-word reflection should ideally include between 6 and 10 references.

  • Mandatory references include the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) specifically for Design and Technologies and the appropriate Year Level.

  • Literature from week one, two, and three, as well as age-appropriate pedagogy and project-based learning links, should be utilized.

  • Generative AI (e.g., Co-Pilot) is permitted for sculpting or shaping teaching ideas, but a disclaimer must be placed on the cover sheet to protect the student. High AI detector flags may lead to meetings with the Academic Integrity Officer.

  • Images taken from the design journal must be formatted in APA 7 style within the written reflection.

Technical Document Formatting

  • The assessment document must be structured with specific page breaks:

    • Page 1: Cover Page (containing information copied from the task sheet).

    • Page 2: Activity Plan Template (including the investigation and defining content descriptor for Year 3+).

    • Page 3: Task Two Reflection (starting on a new page, set in portrait orientation).

    • Page 4: References (starting on a new page in APA 7 format).

    • Page 5: Appendix (starting on its own page).

  • Teaching sequences should not be written in paragraph format. They must be structured as active steps or bullet points representing the delivery of a lesson.

Engineering Principles: Content Descriptors and Forces

  • The curriculum focus for Year 3 and 4 in Engineering Principles relates to the content descriptor K02: "Describe how forces and the properties of materials affect function in a product or system."

  • In practice, if only a product is being made (e.g., a paper plane) without a system, the word "system" should be struck through in the documentation to show it was not taught.

  • The four fundamental forces of flight to be taught as meta-language are:

    • Weight: The force of gravity acting on the object.

    • Lift: The upward force that opposes weight.

    • Thrust: The forward force that moves the object through the air.

    • Drag: The aerodynamic force that opposes the motion of the object.

  • Balance between these forces is required for flight; for instance, too much weight causes the object to drop, while too much drag slows it down.

Case Study: Rosie Revere, Engineer

  • The book Rosie Revere, Engineer by Andrea Beatty and illustrated by David Roberts serves as a pedagogical tool for engineering.

  • Plot Summary:

    • Rosie is a young student in Leila Greer's classroom at Blue River Creek who secretly builds gadgets from trash (e.g., hot dog dispensers, helium pants).

    • After her "cheese hat" (made to protect her Uncle Fred from pythons) is laughed at, she hides her dreams until her Great Great Aunt Rose visits.

    • Aunt Rose, a former airplane builder, inspires Rosie to build the "cheesecopter."

    • The invention floats briefly and then crashes, which Rosie views as a failure, but Aunt Rose identifies as a "brilliant first flop" and a success.

  • Key Themes: Failure is a necessary step in the design process; resilience is critical; and the promotion of female participation in STEM/engineering fields. The story is loosely based on American female pioneers.

Practical Activity: The Paper Plane Design Challenge

  • Design Objective: Create a paper plane that flies over one meter, stays in the air as long as possible, flies as far as possible, and lands accurately.

  • Design Criteria:

    • Stay in air (duration).

    • Maximum distance.

    • Landing accuracy (tested at specific stations with markers/circles).

  • Design and Production Process:

    • Step 1: KWL Table (What I Know, What I Want to know, What I Learned). Students record prior knowledge of planes.

    • Step 2: Research and Brainstorming. 15 minutes to find the best design and plan production steps.

    • Step 3: Justification. Swapping group members to describe and sell the design idea using cognitive verbs (Explain/Identify/Describe).

    • Step 4: Prototyping. Generating at least two different design ideas (e.g., changing wingspan or nose shape).

    • Step 5: Testing and Evaluation. Four recorded throws/tests. Data points include distance and accuracy.

  • Modifications and Results:

    • Adjusting wingspan to increase lift or reduce weight.

    • Using a "snub nose" or folded nose to increase lift and prevent damage upon landing, though this can sometimes decrease accuracy.

    • Tilting wings upward to steady the plane and increase loft.

    • Using staples or glue to prevent the plane from coming apart, which affects weight distribution.

Structuring a Professional Teaching Sequence

  • A lesson plan should follow a consistent pedagogical structure:

    1. Introduce the Topic/Design Challenge: Use a hook like the Rosie Revere video or a KWL chart.

    2. Establish Key Terms: Provide definitions for core concepts like weight, lift, thrust, and drag.

    3. Active Student Investigation: Research, sketching designs, and defining parameters.

    4. Production and Testing: Building the product and conducting trials.

    5. Evaluation and Presentation: Groups use an A3 poster or PowerPoint to share results, using meta-language to justify modifications.

    6. Closure: Completing the "What I Learned" section of the KWL chart and handing in work.

  • Plans should be written in future tense (e.g., "Students will…") as they are working documents for future use.

Assessment Two Preliminary Planning

  • Assessment Two is a group project requiring clusters of 3 to 5 people.

  • Students must self-assign into groups via the "People" and "Project Groups" tabs on the Canvas site.

  • Groups should be locked in early, although shuffling is possible through week 9 and 10.

  • Asynchronous or remote students should join designated groups to prevent the coordinator from having to force group assignments.

Questions & Discussion

  • Question regarding formative assessment: Within the lesson sequence, should a checklist for formative assessment be included as an appendix or a student resource?

  • Response: Since formative assessment hasn't been formally taught in the first four weeks, it shouldn't be labeled as such. Instead, use it as "design criteria" and include the checklist within the teaching activity plan.

  • Question regarding project variety: Can current workshop activities (like the land yacht) be modified for Assessment One?

  • Response: Yes, students can tweak existing workshop ideas or use project-based videos (like the sugar-weighted boat) to ensure the submission isn't a direct rewrite of the workshop material.

  • Question regarding evidence of activity: What should be submitted as evidence for the final activity each week?

  • Response: Either the final product or a fully annotated design template. This is particularly important for asynchronous students who may lack physical materials.

  • Question regarding workshop photos: If I was told to upload photos to a design journal, do I still put them in the template?

  • Response: Yes, they must be moved from the design journal into the formal written reflection and formatted according to APA 7 guidelines.