Comm Final
Definition of rhetoric: faculty of discovering, in the particular case, what are the available means of persuasion
Ethos: speakers character perceived by audience aka credibility, way you shape your own persona for an audience, portraying yourself, are you trustworthy, perceived ethics
Pathos: The speaker evoking of appropriate emotion from audience, example: make audience angry, using passion, can overdo it
Logos: The substance and structure of a speech’s ideas, reasoning, statistics and facts, cant have too much, that's like saying “Youre too right, too many facts, be more wrong”, natural advantage
Canons of Rhetoric (appropriate story vs fanfic): Marcus Tolio Scicero?
Invention: Selection of content, topics, and main ideas of speech (less creativity or originality than selection or imitation), decide what is going in speech and what's not going in speech
Arrangement: Organization of topics, ordering, disposition (3 part organization, keep simple)
Style: Written compoostion, figures of speech, rhetorical devices
Delivery: Vocal quality, bodily movement
Memory: Mode of prep, manuscript, extemporaneous, mesmorized
Types of support/quality of sourcing: testimony, example, facts/statistics, analogies, definitions
Problem / Solution: basic argument structure - describe the problem, explain solution
Monroe’s Motivated Sequence: Organized in terms of steps in audiences motivation rather than pure problem/solution
Steps include:
Attention step: grab people’s attention, hook (intro)
Need step: establish a problem that exists, “something needs to change” (body)
Satisfaction step: provide satisfaction by giving a specific solution to the problem (body)
Visualization step: make the audience visualize it, seeing the positive impact (body)
Action step: tell the audience to take action (conclusion)
Classical argument theory
Syllogism: Deductive, formal reasoning
3 parts of Syllogism:
Major premise (ex. All men are mortal)
Minor premise (ex. Socrates was a Man)
Conclusion (ex. Socrates is Mortal)
Enthymeme:
A rhetorical syllogism (broken/flawed)
1 or more parts are missing
Leaves it up to the audience to fill in blanks of reasoning
Fallacies:
Non sequitur: The warrant is missing: no reasoned connection is drawn between the premises and the conclusion.
Ex. Lou has money; therefore, they must be royalty.
False cause: Assuming that because one event occurs after another, that the first event caused the later one.
Ex. The economy rebounded after the president was elected; therefore, the president caused the economic rebound.
Red herring: Avoiding an uncomfortable issue by changing the topic to distract the auditor.
Ex. Reporter: Governor, did you take bribes? Governor: No, I cut taxes for regular people.
Fallacy of composition: Assuming that what is true for the part is equally true for the whole.
Ex. I have rubber tires; therefore, I have a rubber car.
Slippery slope: Assuming that one event will necessarily result in a series of events.
Ex. If I fail this test, then I will fail my other tests, flunk out of school, and end up on the street.
Appeal to probability: Confuses probability with certainty.
Ex. “The weather report said there was a chance of rain today. Why isn’t it raining right now?”
Either / Or: Poses a false dilemma between two options, when other options exist.
Ex. “America: Love it or leave it.”
Circular argument: The premises of the argument presume the conclusion.
Ex. “These referees have got it out for us because they always hate UGA!”
Ad hominem: Attacks the character of the opponent rather than the quality of the argument.
Ex. That candidate is so annoying when they talk!
Ad populum (bandwagoning): Appeals to the popularity of an idea rather than its validity.
Ex. Buy our product, everyone is doing it.
Equivocation: Using unclear language to exploit multiple meanings.
Ex. The government will not increase taxes, but instead generate revenue.
Inappropriate emotional response: Displaying too much/little of an emotion for the expectations of the situation.
Ex. A close family member responds cheerfully at the news of a relative’s death.
Modern argument theory
Toulmin Model:
Practical reasoning: What parts of an argument when it is working correctly?
Claim (stmt of argument)
Data (evidence, testimony, facts)
Warrant (reasoning, glues data to claim, relates to major premise)
Backing (defense of either data or warrant)
Qualifier (expands or contracts the breadth of the argument)
Rebuttal (an exception to the argument)
Narrative Paradigm (narrative probability / fidelity) - Language use & style (see textbook
chapter)
Rational paradigm:
Humans = rational beings
Argument - the basic form of decision making
Matter of knowledge, skill, and ability in argument
Narrative paradigm:
Homo Narrans: humans = storytellers
Narrative probability: whether a story coheres or hangs together (free of contradiction)
Narrative fidelity: whether the story rings true to audience experience
Trope and figure:
Four Master Tropes:
Metaphor: a word applying to one domain of things is transferred to another domain, very stark and certain
Ex. Life is a box of chocolates
VS. Simile: Life is like a box of chocolates (not a box of chocolates, just similar)
Metonymy: substitution of one word for an adjacent one within the same domain (tiny leaps, nicknaming)
EX. Washington scored a touchdown!
When you nickname someone, that's metonymy - takes something that's associated with something (Hey number 33, hey glasses, hey blue shirt)
Synecdoche: part of the whole or whole for the part
EX. all hands on deck (means get up here and help, not asking for you to put just your hand on the deck)
Lend me your ears (i want whole attention, not just your ears)
Eyes on me (Your whole attention, not just eyes)
Irony: Irony - using the opposite of the literal meaning
Ex. “Gentlemen, you can't fight in here! This is the War Room”
Figures: (figures of speech that change image evoked by word choice and arrangement + Metaphor and Synecdoche)
Periphrasis—substitution of a descriptive word or phrase for a proper name or of a proper name for a quality associated with the name. “She was being so Beyoncé at dinner.” “Mr. Straight As over here is too good to hang out with us.”
Litotes—understatement. The opposite of hyperbole. “No, go ahead and borrow my shirt without asking. It’s not like it’s my favorite shirt or anything.” “She wasn’t that big a deal, only the greatest teacher I had ever had.”
Prosopopoeia—giving voice to absent or deceased people. “Listen to their souls, men: ‘I killed my brother with malice in my heart. Hatred destroyed my family.’ You listen. And you take a lesson from the dead” (monologue from "Remember the Titans").
Paradox—statement that is self-contradictory on the surface yet seems to evoke a truth, nonetheless. “Whomsoever loses their life, shall find it.”
Ceremonial / epideictic speaking
Types of ceremonial speeches / occasion:
Eulogy: A eulogy is a speech given at a funeral or in the case of a deceased memory that is usually in praise of the values that the deceased represents for those who mourn their loss.
Toast or Roast: A toast (praise) or roast (blame) encapsulates general kinds of speeches of appreciation such as wedding speeches, after-dinner speeches, tribute speeches, awards speeches, nomination speeches, and so forth. Encomium: A speech that praises a subject that has fallen into disrepute. Introduction: Speeches of self-introduction are unique in that you are writing about yourself and therefore you need a good combination of praise and blame or else you appear too superficial.
Epidictic: A speech that shapes its audience’s beliefs by praising and/or blaming a subject for a value that the subject does or does not represent.
Subject + Value x (Praise or Blame) x Occasion = Epideictic
Rhetorical schemes:
Antithesis (plural antitheses)—contrary ideas expressed in a balanced sentence. It can be a contrast of opposites: “Evil men fear authority; good men cherish it.” Or it can be a contrast of degree: “One small step for man, one giant leap for all mankind.”
Chiasmus (from Greek, “cross” or “x”)—involves a specific inversion of word order. It involves taking parallelism and deliberately turning it inside out, creating a “crisscross” pattern. The sequence is typically a b b a. Examples: “I lead the life I love; I love the life I lead.” “Naked I rose from the earth; to the grave I fall clothed.”
Asyndeton—using no conjunctions to create an effect of speed or simplicity: Veni. Vidi. Vici. “I came. I saw. I conquered.” (As opposed to “I came, and then I saw, and then I conquered.”) Been there. Done that. Bought the T-shirt.
Polysyndeton—using many conjunctions to achieve an overwhelming effect: “This term, I am taking biology and English and history and math and music and physics and sociology.”
Climax (also called Auxesis and “Crescendo”)—arrangement in order of increasing importance: “Let a man acknowledge his obligations to himself, his family, his country, and his God.”
Bathos—the opposite of climax. Bathos is usually used humorously. Here, the least important item appears anticlimactically in a place where the reader expects something grand or dramatic. For instance, “I am making a stand in this workplace for human decency, professional integrity, and free doughnuts at lunchbreak.”
Tsmesis—intentionally breaking a word into two parts for emphasis. Film producer Samuel Goldwyn once wrote, “I have but two words to say to your request: Im Possible.”
Anaphora—repetition of beginning clauses. For instance, Churchill declared, “We shall not flag or fail. We shall go on to the end. We shall fight in France; we shall fight on the seas and oceans. We shall fight with growing confidence and growing strength in the air. We shall defend our island, whatever the cost shall be.”