Sectional Division, Nullification, and the Tariff Debates

Sectional Division and the Webster-Hayne Debate

  • John C. Calhoun's primary interest regarding his state of Carolina is the preservation of slavery.

  • The central conflict of the Webster Hayne debate presents a fundamental choice: either throw out the Constitution or support the ideals expressed in the Declaration of Independence.

  • Divergent regional priorities divide the nation's political landscape:

    • Northerners prioritize federal power.

    • Southerners prioritize states' rights.

  • Economic figures tied to these sectional disagreements include values such as $24\$24 per month.

  • This foundational argument continues for 3030 more years until Lincoln is elected in 18601860.

The 18301830 Thomas Jefferson Dinner and the Jackson-Calhoun Rift

  • In 18301830, President Jackson and Vice President Calhoun engage in a direct political confrontation.

  • The confrontation takes place at a dinner organized to honor Thomas Jefferson.

  • The dinner contains inherent political irony, as Jefferson authored the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions, which served as the original historical basis for nullification.

  • During the event's toasts, Jackson and Calhoun publicly express opposing views on government authority:

    • Jackson gives a toast emphasizing that federal power is the most important principle.

    • Calhoun asserts that while federal power is significant, states' rights, state liberty, and freedom are principles that must be held most dear.

  • The public exchange highlights an irreconcilable divide between the President and Vice President.

Resignation of Calhoun and Escalation of Sectional Threats

  • Realizing that his political relationship with Jackson cannot be repaired (noted in reference to Payla), Calhoun resigns as Vice President.

  • Upon quitting the vice presidency, Calhoun returns to South Carolina, takes a seat as a Senator, and acts as an ardent supporter of states' rights.

  • The escalating fallout over nullification brings the nation close to civil war nearly 3030 years before it officially takes place.

  • Jackson reacts to nullification threats with aggressive presidential rhetoric:

    • Jackson vows to hang individuals who commit treason on the threshold.

    • Jackson explicitly threatens to go to South Carolina personally and kill those committing treason.

Protective Legislation: Tariff of 18281828 and Tariff of 18321832

  • The Tariff of Abominations was enacted in 18281828.

  • Congress subsequently passes a brand new tariff, the Tariff of 18321832.

  • Southern states vehemently oppose the new tariff for two main reasons:

    • Fear of unchecked Northern power within the federal government.

    • Deeper concerns connected to regional security and the preservation of slavery.

Slave Revolts, Preservation of Slavery, and Political Transitions

  • Southern fears regarding federal authority are compounded by recent slave revolts in the South, specifically naming:

    • Denmark Messi

    • Gabe Gabriel Prozert

    • Nat Turner

  • Southerners worry that Northerners in the federal government will act against slavery, prompting Southern leaders to tighten state controls to ensure its protection.

  • Calhoun completes his political transition by quitting the vice presidency to become an explicit pro-slavery advocate for South Carolina alongside Ellicott.