Sectional Division, Nullification, and the Tariff Debates
Sectional Division and the Webster-Hayne Debate
John C. Calhoun's primary interest regarding his state of Carolina is the preservation of slavery.
The central conflict of the Webster Hayne debate presents a fundamental choice: either throw out the Constitution or support the ideals expressed in the Declaration of Independence.
Divergent regional priorities divide the nation's political landscape:
Northerners prioritize federal power.
Southerners prioritize states' rights.
Economic figures tied to these sectional disagreements include values such as per month.
This foundational argument continues for more years until Lincoln is elected in .
The Thomas Jefferson Dinner and the Jackson-Calhoun Rift
In , President Jackson and Vice President Calhoun engage in a direct political confrontation.
The confrontation takes place at a dinner organized to honor Thomas Jefferson.
The dinner contains inherent political irony, as Jefferson authored the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions, which served as the original historical basis for nullification.
During the event's toasts, Jackson and Calhoun publicly express opposing views on government authority:
Jackson gives a toast emphasizing that federal power is the most important principle.
Calhoun asserts that while federal power is significant, states' rights, state liberty, and freedom are principles that must be held most dear.
The public exchange highlights an irreconcilable divide between the President and Vice President.
Resignation of Calhoun and Escalation of Sectional Threats
Realizing that his political relationship with Jackson cannot be repaired (noted in reference to Payla), Calhoun resigns as Vice President.
Upon quitting the vice presidency, Calhoun returns to South Carolina, takes a seat as a Senator, and acts as an ardent supporter of states' rights.
The escalating fallout over nullification brings the nation close to civil war nearly years before it officially takes place.
Jackson reacts to nullification threats with aggressive presidential rhetoric:
Jackson vows to hang individuals who commit treason on the threshold.
Jackson explicitly threatens to go to South Carolina personally and kill those committing treason.
Protective Legislation: Tariff of and Tariff of
The Tariff of Abominations was enacted in .
Congress subsequently passes a brand new tariff, the Tariff of .
Southern states vehemently oppose the new tariff for two main reasons:
Fear of unchecked Northern power within the federal government.
Deeper concerns connected to regional security and the preservation of slavery.
Slave Revolts, Preservation of Slavery, and Political Transitions
Southern fears regarding federal authority are compounded by recent slave revolts in the South, specifically naming:
Denmark Messi
Gabe Gabriel Prozert
Nat Turner
Southerners worry that Northerners in the federal government will act against slavery, prompting Southern leaders to tighten state controls to ensure its protection.
Calhoun completes his political transition by quitting the vice presidency to become an explicit pro-slavery advocate for South Carolina alongside Ellicott.