Universal Human Rights Theory and the Practice of Rights Claiming

1. Conceptual Foundations of Rights
  • Definition: Human rights are rights individuals possess simply by virtue of being human.

  • Dual Senses of "Right":

    • Rectitude: Moral righteousness or "the right thing to do." Focuses on an objective standard of conduct and duty-bearer obligations.

    • Entitlement: Specific title to enjoy a right ("subjective right"). Focuses on the right-holder rather than an objective standard.

2. Relational Mechanics of Rights
  • Core Concept: Possessing a right to xx means being entitled to xx, authorizing claims that trump utility or social policy.

  • Triadic Relation: A has a right to x with respect to B\text{A has a right to } x \text{ with respect to B}

    • AA: Right-holder (actively controls the relationship).

    • xx: Object of the right.

    • BB: Duty-bearer (holds correlative obligations).

  • Key Features:

    • Violation by BB directly infringes AA's rights, triggering special remedial claims.

    • Right-holder AA has full discretion to assert, enforce, or excuse obligations.

3. Operational Modes and Dimensions
  • Four Dimensions: Exercise, respect, enjoyment, enforcement.

  • Three Operational Forms:

    • Assertive exercise: Right is explicitly claimed, activating duties and potential enforcement.

    • Active respect: Duty-bearer accounts for the right without explicit claims.

    • Objective enjoyment: Right operates implicitly as a societal norm without active thought or enforcement.

  • The Possession Paradox: A right is most valuable precisely when its object is not actively enjoyed or respected.

  • Environmental Variability:

    • World of Saints: Rights are respected automatically and rarely enforced.

    • Hobbesian State of Nature: Rights are ignored except through self-help enforcement or aligned self-interests.

4. Core Characteristics and Scope
  • Three Pillars:

    • Equal: Held identically by every human being.

    • Inalienable: Cannot be lost regardless of behavior or treatment.

    • Universal: Applies to all contemporary members of Homo sapiens.

  • Scope and Distinction:

    • Applies to specific selected values, not all good things (e.g., no human right to love or supportive parents).

    • Entitlement to a human right fundamentally differs from state-granted contingent legal protections.

5. Legal Hierarchies and Practical Claims
  • Legal Hierarchy: Right-holders seek remedies at the lowest legal level first (e.g., employment agreements, local laws, national statutes) before appealing to international instruments.

  • Functional Motivations: Used globally to curb oppression, demand responses to health or natural disasters, and enforce state accountability.

6. Rights and Democracy
  • Distinct Lineages: Democracy originates in ancient Greece, whereas rights emerge through modern revolutions and global declarations.

  • Theoretical Critiques: Critics (communitarians, feminists, critical race theorists) argue rights can foster atomistic individualism and obscure systemic power dynamics.

  • Democratic Practice: Advocates emphasize that making rights claims serves as an active democratic process to contest identity, social norms, and community boundaries.