chapter 1 fraud
Chapter 1: Core Foundation Related to Forensic Accounting and Fraud Examination
Course Code: BU5510
Course Title: Forensics & Fraud Examination
Instructor: Dr. Patrick O'Brien
Module 1: What is Fraud?
Definition of Forensic Accounting: The intersection of accounting and the law.
Consideration extends to employment damages from events like work injuries or fatal incidents.
Complexity requires more than just basic accounting data.
Definition of Fraud: An intentional deception, either by omission or commission, that results in economic loss to victims or gains to perpetrators.
Example: “Theft by deception”.
Economic Impact: The cost of fraud may reach up to $4.7 trillion annually, with an upward trend.
Legal Elements of Fraud
Four Essential Elements:
A material false statement.
Knowledge of the statement's falsity when made.
Reliance on the false statement by the victim.
Damages resulting from reliance on the false statement.
Methods of Money Relief:
Illegal money relief can occur by force, trickery, or larceny.
Fraud primarily employs trickery.
Legal Definition: Same in criminal and civil cases; however, criminal cases have a higher burden of proof.
Legal Elements of Fraud (Continued)
Definition of Larceny:
Felonious stealing involving taking, carrying, or driving away someone’s property without consent, with intent to deprive the owner of it.
Proving Larceny: Requires four elements:
Taking or carrying away.
Property belonging to another.
Without owner’s consent.
Intent to deprive owner of its use or possession.
Definition of Embezzlement:
The willful conversion of another's property lawfully possessed (e.g., via employment).
Distinction: Possession does not equal ownership.
Major Categories of Fraud
Asset Misappropriation:
Theft or misuse of organizational assets (e.g., skimming cash/checks, stealing inventory, payroll fraud).
Corruption:
Wrongful use of influence in transactions for personal gain, which contradicts duties to employers (e.g., kickbacks, conflicts of interest).
Financial Statement Fraud:
Intentional misrepresentation of financial or non-financial information (e.g., overstating revenues, understating liabilities).
Occurs less frequently (10% cases) but median loss is significant ($1 million), higher than asset misappropriation.
Major Categories of Fraud (Continued)
Fraud Scheme Categories and Statistics:
Asset Misappropriation:
Percentage: 86%
Median Loss: $100,000
Corruption:
Percentage: 50%
Median Loss: $150,000
Financial Reporting Fraud:
Percentage: 9%
Median Loss: $593,000
Types of Fraud
Types of Asset Misappropriation:
Cash theft, skimming, billing and payroll schemes.
Types of Corruption:
Bribery, illegal gratuities, conflicts of interest, invoice kickbacks, purchasing schemes, sales schemes, and bid rigging.
Difference Between Fraud and Abuse
Misconduct Not Constituting Fraud:
Includes abusive practices causing losses without rising to fraud (e.g., using company equipment inappropriately or personal business during work hours).
Module 2: What is Forensic Accounting?
Definition: Application of financial principles to facts/hypotheses within legal disputes consisting of:
Litigation Advisory Services: Role as an expert or consultant.
Investigative Services: Utilizing forensic skills, may or may not involve courtroom testimony.
Engagements: May include cases involving economic damages, workplace disputes, asset valuations.
Communication Skills: Essential for interaction with attorneys; engagements can have an adversarial nature.
Module 3: Professional Skill Set
Three Major Skill Types:
Technical Competence: Accounting, auditing, finance, quantitative methods.
Investigative Skills: Collection, analysis, evaluation of evidence; critical thinking.
Communication Skills: Effectively conveying findings is crucial for success.
Module 4: Role of Auditing, Fraud Examination, and Forensic Accounting
Purpose of Financial Statement Auditing: Ensuring financial statements are free from material misstatement—note that immaterial misstatements do not require detection efforts.
Role of Fraud Examiners: Usually called post-suspicion to assist in fraud detection/prevention.
Forensic Accounting Functions: Include calculating economic damages, providing litigation support, deriving asset/business valuations.
The Role of Auditing, Fraud Examination, and Forensic Accounting (Continued)
Auditing Process:
Risk assessments, internal controls, planning, financial statement fraud detection, and evidence gathering.
Fraud Examination Process: Involves litigation support, economic damage calculations, and audits of businesses.
ACFE Report to the Nations
Median Loss in Fraud Cases:
Recorded losses show varying median amounts based on scheme type (e.g., billing, noncash, fraud against cash on hand).
Distribution of fraud cases and their respective median losses across different categories and regions indicates widespread impacts.
Fraud Detection and Detection Methods
Top Concealment Methods Used by Fraudsters:
Created fraudulent physical documents (39%)
Altered physical documents (32%)
Created fraudulent electronic documents/files (28%)
Altered electronic documents/files (25%)
Destroyed/withheld physical documents (23%)
Internal Controls Effectiveness
Analyzing primary internal control weaknesses to understand potential fraud areas.
Areas such as job rotation, surprise audits, proactive monitoring, and formalized fraud policies play a critical role.
Behavioral Red Flags Displayed by Perpetrators
Identifying common behavioral traits typical in individuals committing occupational fraud helps in early detection.
Indicators: Financial difficulties, control issues, excessive pressure, and occupational insulation or secrecy.
Fraud Examination Methodology
Process: A structured approach for resolving fraud allegations, running from initiation to conclusion.
Includes gathering evidence, interviewing, report writing, and potentially testifying.
Predication: Required basis for a fraud examination, founded on reasonable suspicion backed by circumstantial evidence.
Fraud Prevention: Emphasizes creating environments with minimal fraud risks, involving effective internal controls and an ethical workplace.
Conclusion
Criminal and civil remediation involves the recovery of losses through various means, alongside modification of internal operational processes to mitigate future fraud incidents.
Evidence-based decision-making is essential in investigations and requires thorough, substantiated conclusions from the gathered data.