Integrated Pest Management – Quarantine Control II
Historical Impact of Introduced Pests & Pathogens
- Middle of 19th century introductions from America devastated European viticulture
- Powdery mildew (Uncinula necator)
- Grape phylloxera
- Downy mildew (Plasmopara viticola)
- Chestnut blight (Endothia parasitica) arrived in the USA on Oriental nursery stock in 1906
- Virtually eliminated the American chestnut as a forest tree
- Caused extensive economic and ecological losses
- Coffee leaf rust (Hemileia vastatrix) in Sri Lanka led to replacement of coffee with tea as a plantation crop
- Coconut leaf miner (Promecotheca cumingi) destroyed about 20000 ha of coconut plantations in the late 1960\text{s}
Complementary Role of Plant Quarantine in Germplasm Exchange
- Plant introductions include:
- New crops or varieties for diversification
- Germplasm of primitive landraces, wild/weedy relatives
- Traits sought from centres of origin/diversity
- Resistance to pests/pathogens, high yield, early maturity, tolerance to cold/drought/salinity, improved oil/protein content, etc.
- Dual mandate of quarantine services
- Prevent entry of hazardous organisms
- Facilitate entry of valuable genetic resources “in a healthy state”
- Operational expectations for quarantine officials
- Provide safeguards and fast processing once material arrives at the station
- Never circumvent quarantine even if it delays or rejects material
Risk-Reduction Principles & Quarantine Procedures
- Plant vs. animal quarantine share objectives but differ in biology, production systems, trade logistics → require distinct procedures
- Regulated plant materials may include seed, straw, cereal hulls, timber, fruit, vegetables, cut flowers, fibres, gums, spices
- Regulated animal materials may include live animals, semen, embryos, meats (fresh/frozen/canned), milk products, hides, biological reagents (proteins, hormones, sera)
Entry Pathways for Pests & Pathogens
- Natural
- Winds, storms, jet streams
- Air/convection currents
- Ocean currents, surface drainage
- Natural seed dispersal, migratory insects (locusts) & other animals
- Vectors: insects, nematodes, mites, birds, higher animals
- Artificial
- Cargo (agricultural & non-agricultural)
- Mail, baggage, common carriers (ships, trucks, aircraft)
- Dunnage, crates, packing materials
- Smuggling
- Farm practices (irrigation water, used machinery)
Detection Techniques
- Core goal: detect any pest/pathogen on introduced material with zero tolerance
- Two broad classes of tests
- Generalized (broad-spectrum)
- Specialized (organism-specific)
Generalized Tests
- Visual inspection of dry seed (naked eye & low-power microscope)
- Examination under UV/NUV light → fluorescence of infected seed coats
- Seed-wash microscopy → rusts, smuts, downy mildews, etc.
- Incubation methods (moist blotter or agar) for ≈1 week under alternating light/dark
- Seedling-symptom test & grow-out test → show symptoms from fungi, bacteria, viruses
- Grow-out is primary screen for viruses; must be paired with indexing on indicator plants & serology because some viruses remain symptomless
Specialized Tests
- Insects
- X-ray radiography: detects hidden infestations
- Seed transparency test: reveals internal feeders; allows extraction & identification
- Nematodes
- Soak soil/plant debris; extract with nematological sieves or tissue paper
- Fungi, bacteria, viruses
- Serology (e.g., ELISA) → sensitive, rapid identification
- Phage-plaque technique → distinguishes bacterial strains
- Indicator plants → differentiate fungal/bacterial races & virus strains
- Modified incubation media
- Deep-freezing blotter & 2,4\text{-D} blotter for Phoma lingam (black-leg)
- Potato-dextrose-oxgall agar for Septoria nodorum in wheat
- PCNB agar selectively recovers Fusarium spp. in cereals
- Lab methods generally adequate for insects, mites, nematodes, most fungi, certain bacteria
Eradicative (Salvage) Treatments Before Release
- Quarantine tolerance = 0 → no residual inoculum permitted
- Available interventions
- Fumigation
- Heat (hot water/hot air) treatment
- Chemical treatments (seed dips, disinfectants, systemic pesticides)
- Tissue culture (meristem/embryo culture)
Fumigation Details
- Atmosphere or reduced-pressure fumigation effective for insects & mites
- Common fumigants: methyl bromide, HCN, phosphine, EDCT (ethylene dichloride + carbon tetrachloride)
Heat Treatment Guidelines (Hot Water)
- Nematodes
- Flower bulbs: 44\,^{\circ}C for 240 min
- Chrysanthemum: 48\,^{\circ}C for 25 min
- Potato tubers: 45\,^{\circ}C for 5 min
- Insects & mites
- Narcissus bulbs: 44\,^{\circ}C for 180 min
- Strawberry runners: 46\,^{\circ}C for 10 min
- Viruses
- Grapevine: 45\,^{\circ}C for 120–180 min
- Sugarcane setts: 50\,^{\circ}C for 120 min
- Potato tubers: 50\,^{\circ}C for 17 min
- Fungi
- Celery seed: 50\,^{\circ}C for 25 min
- Wheat seed: 52–54\,^{\circ}C for 10 min
Chemical Treatments
- Choice of chemical & dosage depends on target organism
- Seed treatments at origin complicate inspection (toxic, hinder detection)
Tissue Culture Advantages
- Minimises consignment size → meristem tips, excised buds, embryos
- Aseptic culture inherently exposes/avoids insects, mites, nematodes, most fungi
- Enables large-scale exchange of genetic stocks with minimal risk
Pest Risk Analysis (PRA) Considerations
- Availability of trained personnel & diagnostic capacity
- Detection technique effectiveness
- Feasible treatments at entry
- Detailed knowledge of pest life cycle, races/strains
- Modes of transmission & factors aiding establishment/spread
- Existing safeguards: manpower, chemicals, equipment, containment & eradication plans
- Adequacy of survey & surveillance programmes post-entry
International & Regional Cooperation Mechanisms
- Consortium of plant quarantine stations → harmonise protocols, data sharing
- Central seed-health testing laboratories → reference diagnostics
- Third-country intermediate quarantine → stepwise screening in climates unfavourable to pest establishment
- Biogeographical regions → region-specific pest lists & cooperative control
General Considerations for National Policy
- Continuous inflow of valuable germplasm is essential for sustainable agricultural growth
- Simultaneous protection against exotic pests, pathogens, weeds is equally critical
- Effective quarantine must be science-based & driven solely by pest-introduction risk
Lecture Summary
- Plant pests/pathogens cause heavy losses in field & storage
- Quarantine regulations (e.g., Malaysia & other nations) govern movement of plants/products to prevent entry of harmful exotics
- Quarantine only effective against pests without natural long-distance transport
- Complementary role of national services & coordinated cooperation enables safe germplasm flow
References & Additional Resources
- Malaysian Quarantine & Inspection Services (MAQIS): http://www.maqis.gov.my/
- Muthaiyan, M. C. (2009) Principles and Practices of Plant Quarantine.
- Paroda, R. S. & Arora, R. K. (1991) Conservation and Management: Concepts and Approaches.
- Videos
- “Imported Agriculture Products” — https://youtu.be/PEzf7XodY8g
- Bureau of Plant Industry – National Plant Quarantine Services Division — https://youtu.be/VZDYJGfCQVw
- “Phytosanitary and Food Safety Certification of Pineapple” — https://youtu.be/WB7GGBEWyTc