Chapter 2 - Conformity

1.Types of Conformity

Conformity: A form of social influence where individuals change their behaviour or attitudes to align with the majority.

  • It can involve:

    • Public acceptance: Going along with the majority but privately disagreeing.

    • Private acceptance: Genuinely accepting the majority's view.

  • Herbert Kellman (1958) identified 3 types:

    • Compliance

    • Internalisation

    • Identification


I. Compliance

  • Going along with the majority to gain social approval or avoid rejection, despite privately disagreeing.

  • Public acceptance, but not private acceptance.

  • Usually temporary and lasts only while majority pressure exists.


II. Internalisation

  • Genuinely accepting and adopting the majority's beliefs or behaviours.

  • Involves private acceptance.

  • Produces the most permanent change in behaviour/belief.

Sherif (1935)

  • Used the autokinetic effect (a stationary light appears to move).

  • Participants' estimates gradually converged towards a group estimate.

  • As there was no objectively correct answer, this was likely internalisation.


III. Identification

  • Changing behaviour to fit in with a group and be accepted as a member.

  • Adopt the group's beliefs and behaviours while part of the group.

  • Usually temporary and linked to group membership.


Quick distinction:

  • Compliance: “I don't agree, but I'll go along.”

  • Internalisation: “I genuinely believe it.”

  • Identification: “I'll do it to fit in.”














2. Explanation for Conformity

I. Informational Social Influence (ISI)

Deutsch & Gerrard (1955): Proposed two explanations for conformity: informational and normative social influence.

→ ISI: When we are uncertain how to behave, we look to others for information about the correct response.

  • More likely in ambiguous situations where there is no clear correct answer.

  • Leads to internalisation because we genuinely accept the majority's view.



II. Normative Social Influence (NSI)

→ Conformity occurs because of the need to be accepted, fit into a group and avoid rejection.

  • Peer pressure is a common example, particularly during adolescence.

  • Leads to compliance and identification.

  • Asch (1956): Found that participants sometimes gave an obviously incorrect answer because of pressure from the group.


Evaluation of ISI and NSI

  • Jenness (1932): Participants estimated the number of beans in a jar individually, then as a group, then individually again.

    • Their second estimates moved towards the group estimate, supporting ISI in an ambiguous situation.

  • Sherif (1935): Participants' estimates of the movement of a light converged towards the group estimate, supporting ISI.

  • Asch (1956): Participants sometimes gave an obviously incorrect answer when the group gave the wrong answer, supporting NSI.

  • Limitation: These studies were conducted in controlled laboratory conditions, so they may not reflect conformity in real-life situations.

  • Limitation: The theory may also overlook individual differences and other reasons for conformity.



III. Conformity to Social Roles

  • Social norms are expectations about how we should behave in particular situations.

  • Social roles involve conforming to the norms expected of that role.

  • This is a form of identification because conformity occurs while the individual is part of the role/group.


Zimbardo et al. (1973)

  • Students were assigned the roles of prisoners or guards in a simulated prison at Stanford University.

  • Participants quickly adopted the behaviours associated with their assigned roles.

  • Suggests that social roles can influence behaviour.


Reicher & Haslam (BBC Prison Study)

  • Found that conformity to social roles was not simply an automatic response to being given a role.

    • Behaviour was influenced by factors such as identification with the group.



IV. Social Impact Theory

Latané (1981) proposed that people's behaviour is influenced by the actions of others.

  • Source: The person/group exerting social influence.

  • Target: The person being influenced.

  • In conformity, the majority = source and the individual = target.


Three Social Forces

  1. Strength

    • The perceived status, legitimacy or authority of the source.

    • Greater strength → greater social influence.

  2. Immediacy

    • The physical or social proximity of the source to the target.

    • Greater immediacy → greater influence.

  3. Number

    • The number of sources exerting influence.

    • More sources generally → greater influence, but only up to a point, after which the effect levels off.


Multiplicative effect

  • The three factors combine to determine social impact.

  • Formula: I = f(SIN)

    • I = impact

    • S = strength

    • I = immediacy

    • N = number


Social Impact Theory and Types of Conformity

  • Compliance: Strong, immediate and numerous majority → pressure to conform publicly.

  • Identification: These factors can increase desire to identify with the group.

  • Internalisation: A strong/immediate/numerous majority may appear more credible, encouraging genuine acceptance.



V. Evaluation of Social Impact Theory

1. Berkowitz, Bickman & Milgram (1969)

  • Confederates stood on a street and looked up at a building.

  • As the number of confederates increased, more passers-by copied them.

  • However, the effect levelled off after a certain point.

  • Supports Latané's idea that number increases social impact only up to a point.


2. Asch (1956)

  • Conformity increased as the majority increased.

  • However, after around 3–4 confederates, further increases did not significantly increase conformity.

  • A single dissenter giving the correct answer reduced conformity.

  • Supports the importance of number in social influence.


3. Reductionism

  • Social Impact Theory can be seen as reductionist because it reduces conformity to three factors: strength, immediacy and number.

  • It may overlook individual differences and the active role individuals play in social interactions.


4. Wider issues: Social control

  • Social Impact Theory can be used for social engineering, such as:

    • Choosing leaders based on their influence.

    • Deciding class/workplace group sizes.

    • Managing crowding and other social situations.

  • This could also be viewed as a form of social control.











3. Asch (1951) and Variation Studies

I. Asch (1951) — Original Study → Line Study

  • Aim: Investigate majority influence on conformity.

  • Participants: 50 male college students, placed in groups of 8.

  • Participants judged which of 3 lines matched a standard line.

  • 7 confederates deliberately gave the same incorrect answer.

  • Across 12 critical trials:

    • 32% of responses conformed to the incorrect majority.

    • 68% were correct.

  • Individual differences existed:

    • Some participants conformed frequently.

    • Others remained independent.

  • Conclusion: Conformity is influenced by majority pressure, but individual differences also matter.


Variations

Social support

  • When there was another participant giving the correct answer, conformity fell to 5.5%.

  • When there were two naïve participants, conformity fell to 10.4%.

  • Having a partner provided social support, making it easier to resist majority pressure.

  • Losing a supporting partner increased conformity.

Size of majority

  • Majority of 1: little/no influence.

  • Majority of 2: conformity = 12.8%.

  • Majority of 3: greatest conformity.

  • Larger majorities did not significantly increase conformity further.

  • Therefore, the effect of majority size levels off after about 3 people.



II. Asch (1952) — Variation Studies → social support

  • Participants were male college students in groups of 7–9.

  • Majority initially gave correct answers, then gave an incorrect answer.

  • A dissenter sometimes challenged the majority.

  • About 33.2% of responses conformed to the incorrect majority.

  • Control group giving answers privately: only 7.4% errors.

  • Shows that conformity was largely due to social pressure, rather than genuinely believing the majority was correct.


Other variations

  • Very obviously wrong majority: conformity fell slightly to 27.2%.

  • One-person majority: majority influence was completely abolished.

  • One consistent dissenter: conformity fell to 13%.

  • A single minority member had little influence over a majority of 16 naïve participants.



III. Asch (1956) — Variation Studies → majority size

  • 123 college students in groups of 7–9.

  • Tested whether people would conform when the majority's answer was obviously incorrect.

  • Control group answered privately; experimental group answered publicly.

  • Control group: only 3 incorrect judgements.

  • Experimental group: around one-third of responses were incorrect.

  • With an extreme incorrect judgement, 4/5 modelled the majority and 1/5 gave a compromise answer.

  • When the task involved judging whether coloured discs were brighter or darker, 39% of responses were incorrect.

  • When participants answered privately, conformity fell to 12.5%.

  • Supports normative social influence because public pressure increased conformity.


Overall conclusions

  • Majority influence can produce conformity.

  • Unanimity, majority size and social support affect conformity.

  • Individual differences also influence whether people conform.



IV. Evaluation of Asch's Studies

Ecological validity

  • The research used a laboratory setting and a trivial line-judgement task.

  • This may not represent conformity in real-life situations, where decisions may have greater consequences.


Ethics

  • Participants were deceived about the true purpose of the study and the confederates.

  • They experienced stress when publicly disagreeing with the group.

  • However, deception was necessary to prevent participants from knowing the true aim.


Familiarity of group members

  • Asch mainly used strangers/acquaintances, whereas conformity often occurs in close groups such as families and friendship groups.

  • Mori & Arai (2010) found that males who knew the confederates were less influenced by incorrect responses.

  • This suggests conformity may differ when group members know each other.


Cultural and historical differences

  • Asch studied American male university students in the 1950s.

  • Studies using different cultures, genders and time periods have produced different conformity rates.

  • Therefore, conformity may be influenced by culture and historical period.


Reliability

  • The study was highly standardised and controlled.

  • Everyone completed the same line-judgement tasks.

  • Conformity was measured objectively using error rates.

  • This makes the research easier to replicate and test for reliability.

Internal validity

  • The controlled procedure means the effect of majority influence could be isolated from other variables.

  • Therefore, the study has high internal validity.