Chapter 2 - Conformity
1.Types of Conformity
Conformity: A form of social influence where individuals change their behaviour or attitudes to align with the majority.
It can involve:
Public acceptance: Going along with the majority but privately disagreeing.
Private acceptance: Genuinely accepting the majority's view.
Herbert Kellman (1958) identified 3 types:
Compliance
Internalisation
Identification
I. Compliance
Going along with the majority to gain social approval or avoid rejection, despite privately disagreeing.
Public acceptance, but not private acceptance.
Usually temporary and lasts only while majority pressure exists.
II. Internalisation
Genuinely accepting and adopting the majority's beliefs or behaviours.
Involves private acceptance.
Produces the most permanent change in behaviour/belief.
Sherif (1935)
Used the autokinetic effect (a stationary light appears to move).
Participants' estimates gradually converged towards a group estimate.
As there was no objectively correct answer, this was likely internalisation.
III. Identification
Changing behaviour to fit in with a group and be accepted as a member.
Adopt the group's beliefs and behaviours while part of the group.
Usually temporary and linked to group membership.
Quick distinction:
Compliance: “I don't agree, but I'll go along.”
Internalisation: “I genuinely believe it.”
Identification: “I'll do it to fit in.”
2. Explanation for Conformity
I. Informational Social Influence (ISI)
Deutsch & Gerrard (1955): Proposed two explanations for conformity: informational and normative social influence.
→ ISI: When we are uncertain how to behave, we look to others for information about the correct response.
More likely in ambiguous situations where there is no clear correct answer.
Leads to internalisation because we genuinely accept the majority's view.
II. Normative Social Influence (NSI)
→ Conformity occurs because of the need to be accepted, fit into a group and avoid rejection.
Peer pressure is a common example, particularly during adolescence.
Leads to compliance and identification.
Asch (1956): Found that participants sometimes gave an obviously incorrect answer because of pressure from the group.
Evaluation of ISI and NSI
Jenness (1932): Participants estimated the number of beans in a jar individually, then as a group, then individually again.
Their second estimates moved towards the group estimate, supporting ISI in an ambiguous situation.
Sherif (1935): Participants' estimates of the movement of a light converged towards the group estimate, supporting ISI.
Asch (1956): Participants sometimes gave an obviously incorrect answer when the group gave the wrong answer, supporting NSI.
Limitation: These studies were conducted in controlled laboratory conditions, so they may not reflect conformity in real-life situations.
Limitation: The theory may also overlook individual differences and other reasons for conformity.
III. Conformity to Social Roles
Social norms are expectations about how we should behave in particular situations.
Social roles involve conforming to the norms expected of that role.
This is a form of identification because conformity occurs while the individual is part of the role/group.
Zimbardo et al. (1973)
Students were assigned the roles of prisoners or guards in a simulated prison at Stanford University.
Participants quickly adopted the behaviours associated with their assigned roles.
Suggests that social roles can influence behaviour.
Reicher & Haslam (BBC Prison Study)
Found that conformity to social roles was not simply an automatic response to being given a role.
Behaviour was influenced by factors such as identification with the group.
IV. Social Impact Theory
Latané (1981) proposed that people's behaviour is influenced by the actions of others.
Source: The person/group exerting social influence.
Target: The person being influenced.
In conformity, the majority = source and the individual = target.
Three Social Forces
Strength
The perceived status, legitimacy or authority of the source.
Greater strength → greater social influence.
Immediacy
The physical or social proximity of the source to the target.
Greater immediacy → greater influence.
Number
The number of sources exerting influence.
More sources generally → greater influence, but only up to a point, after which the effect levels off.
Multiplicative effect
The three factors combine to determine social impact.
Formula: I = f(SIN)
I = impact
S = strength
I = immediacy
N = number
Social Impact Theory and Types of Conformity
Compliance: Strong, immediate and numerous majority → pressure to conform publicly.
Identification: These factors can increase desire to identify with the group.
Internalisation: A strong/immediate/numerous majority may appear more credible, encouraging genuine acceptance.
V. Evaluation of Social Impact Theory
1. Berkowitz, Bickman & Milgram (1969)
Confederates stood on a street and looked up at a building.
As the number of confederates increased, more passers-by copied them.
However, the effect levelled off after a certain point.
Supports Latané's idea that number increases social impact only up to a point.
2. Asch (1956)
Conformity increased as the majority increased.
However, after around 3–4 confederates, further increases did not significantly increase conformity.
A single dissenter giving the correct answer reduced conformity.
Supports the importance of number in social influence.
3. Reductionism
Social Impact Theory can be seen as reductionist because it reduces conformity to three factors: strength, immediacy and number.
It may overlook individual differences and the active role individuals play in social interactions.
4. Wider issues: Social control
Social Impact Theory can be used for social engineering, such as:
Choosing leaders based on their influence.
Deciding class/workplace group sizes.
Managing crowding and other social situations.
This could also be viewed as a form of social control.
3. Asch (1951) and Variation Studies
I. Asch (1951) — Original Study → Line Study
Aim: Investigate majority influence on conformity.
Participants: 50 male college students, placed in groups of 8.
Participants judged which of 3 lines matched a standard line.
7 confederates deliberately gave the same incorrect answer.
Across 12 critical trials:
32% of responses conformed to the incorrect majority.
68% were correct.
Individual differences existed:
Some participants conformed frequently.
Others remained independent.
Conclusion: Conformity is influenced by majority pressure, but individual differences also matter.
Variations
Social support
When there was another participant giving the correct answer, conformity fell to 5.5%.
When there were two naïve participants, conformity fell to 10.4%.
Having a partner provided social support, making it easier to resist majority pressure.
Losing a supporting partner increased conformity.
Size of majority
Majority of 1: little/no influence.
Majority of 2: conformity = 12.8%.
Majority of 3: greatest conformity.
Larger majorities did not significantly increase conformity further.
Therefore, the effect of majority size levels off after about 3 people.
II. Asch (1952) — Variation Studies → social support
Participants were male college students in groups of 7–9.
Majority initially gave correct answers, then gave an incorrect answer.
A dissenter sometimes challenged the majority.
About 33.2% of responses conformed to the incorrect majority.
Control group giving answers privately: only 7.4% errors.
Shows that conformity was largely due to social pressure, rather than genuinely believing the majority was correct.
Other variations
Very obviously wrong majority: conformity fell slightly to 27.2%.
One-person majority: majority influence was completely abolished.
One consistent dissenter: conformity fell to 13%.
A single minority member had little influence over a majority of 16 naïve participants.
III. Asch (1956) — Variation Studies → majority size
123 college students in groups of 7–9.
Tested whether people would conform when the majority's answer was obviously incorrect.
Control group answered privately; experimental group answered publicly.
Control group: only 3 incorrect judgements.
Experimental group: around one-third of responses were incorrect.
With an extreme incorrect judgement, 4/5 modelled the majority and 1/5 gave a compromise answer.
When the task involved judging whether coloured discs were brighter or darker, 39% of responses were incorrect.
When participants answered privately, conformity fell to 12.5%.
Supports normative social influence because public pressure increased conformity.
Overall conclusions
Majority influence can produce conformity.
Unanimity, majority size and social support affect conformity.
Individual differences also influence whether people conform.
IV. Evaluation of Asch's Studies
Ecological validity
The research used a laboratory setting and a trivial line-judgement task.
This may not represent conformity in real-life situations, where decisions may have greater consequences.
Ethics
Participants were deceived about the true purpose of the study and the confederates.
They experienced stress when publicly disagreeing with the group.
However, deception was necessary to prevent participants from knowing the true aim.
Familiarity of group members
Asch mainly used strangers/acquaintances, whereas conformity often occurs in close groups such as families and friendship groups.
Mori & Arai (2010) found that males who knew the confederates were less influenced by incorrect responses.
This suggests conformity may differ when group members know each other.
Cultural and historical differences
Asch studied American male university students in the 1950s.
Studies using different cultures, genders and time periods have produced different conformity rates.
Therefore, conformity may be influenced by culture and historical period.
Reliability
The study was highly standardised and controlled.
Everyone completed the same line-judgement tasks.
Conformity was measured objectively using error rates.
This makes the research easier to replicate and test for reliability.
Internal validity
The controlled procedure means the effect of majority influence could be isolated from other variables.
Therefore, the study has high internal validity.