In-depth Notes on Community Sentences, Probation, and Intermediate Sanctions
Evidence-Based Justice
"Decide Your Time" (DYT) Program: No difference found in drug use, probation, and recidivism compared to traditional probation. DYT participants did not perform better than those under conventional supervision.
HOPE Program Evaluation by Pamela Lattimore et al.: HOPE supervision did not result in a decrease in arrests among participants compared to controls despite promises of swift and certain sanctions.
Study by Alexander Cowell et al.: Similar findings to prior studies with emphasis on methodological shortcomings suggesting the need for improved research designs in evaluating interventions.
Critical Thinking Questions
- Do you agree with the effectiveness of the Hawaii HOPE model?
- Is punishment sufficient to enable life changes for offenders?
- Does the success of HOPE seem too good to be true?
Risk Assessment in Probation
- Level of Service Inventory-Revised (LSI-R): A standardized risk assessment tool with 54 items indicating future criminal behavior, developed in Canada and used by U.S. correctional agencies. Evaluations indicate high validity but stress the need for improvement in measurement validity and consideration of community factors.
Legal Rights of Probationers
Civil Rights
- Unique Status: Probationers receive fewer constitutional protections compared to citizens.
- Key Legal Cases:
- Minnesota v. Murphy (1984): Probation relationships not confidential; information can be relayed to police.
- Griffin v. Wisconsin (1987): Warrantless searches are permissible under probation conditions to ensure compliance.
- United States v. Knights (2001): Upheld warrantless searches based on reasonable suspicion of new crimes.
Revocation Rights
- Probation Violations: Certain violations can provoke revocation leading to institutionalization.
- Formal Hearing: Defendants are entitled to hearings before revocation, with procedural due process outlined in:
- Mempa v. Rhay (1967): Right to counsel during revocation proceedings.
- Morrissey v. Brewer (1972): Requirement for probable cause determinations in revocation cases.
- Gagnon v. Scarpelli (1973): Limited right to counsel for both probationers and parolees.
- Beardon v. Georgia (1983): Cannot revoke probation solely for failure to pay fines unless the inability to pay is not the fault of the probationer.
- United States v. Granderson (1994): Clarification that revocation cannot result in longer sentences than initially prescribed.
Success Rates in Probation
Approximately 65% of probationers successfully complete their sentences. Most violations occur in the early stages (first 3 months).
A study by Joan Petersilia tracked 1,672 felons:
- Rearrest Rate: 65% rearrested; high rates for property crimes.
- Supports probation despite high failure rates as it results in lower recidivism compared to incarceration.
Factors Influencing Success and Failure
- Stability indicators such as marital status, employment, and residence length positively impact success rates.
- Substance abuse history negatively affects outcomes, with women showing a higher success rate under stable conditions.
Future of Probation
- Shift from rehabilitation towards risk assessment and control may threaten the original rehabilitative goals of probation.
Proposed Improvements
- Financial Resources: Better funding for effective programming in probation.
- Community Engagement: Initiatives like NYC's Neighborhood Opportunity Networks.
- Area Needs Assessment: Reorganizing caseloads based on where probationers live.
- Specialized Probation: Focus on specific crimes for tailored supervision.
- Privatization: Limited oversight of private probation services can undermine quality.
Swift and Sure Punishment
- Examples of community correctional practices where probationers face immediate sanctioning for violations have shown effectiveness in reducing reoffending.
Intermediate Sanctions ("Probation Plus")
- Include measures like house arrest, intensive supervision, and electronic monitoring.
- Designed to balance between probation and incarceration, providing cost-effective alternatives to manage offenders while ensuring oversight and accountability.
Advantages of Intermediate Sanctions
- Cost-Effectiveness: Generally less expensive than imprisonment; facilitate repaying debts like restitution.
- Equitable Sentencing Options: Allow differentiation of responses based on crime severity.
- Increased Control: Enhanced monitoring for higher-risk offenders without full incarceration.
- Reduced Overcrowding: Alleviates jail issues by managing nonviolent offenders in the community.
- Support for Probation Violators: Potential to correct behavioral patterns before resorting to incarceration.