Firms in Competitive Markets: Principles of Production, Cost Curves, and Market Supply
Characteristics and Foundations of Perfectly Competitive Markets
Market Power Definition:
Market power refers to the ability of a firm to influence the market price of the good it sells.
In competitive markets, individual firms lack market power entirely.
Definition of a Competitive Market:
Also referred to as a Perfectly Competitive Market.
Defined as a market with many buyers and many sellers trading identical products, such that each buyer and seller is a price taker.
Primary Characteristics of Perfectly Competitive Markets:
Large Number of Participants: The market has many buyers and many sellers.
Homogeneous Products: The goods offered by the various sellers are largely the same (identical).
Price Takers: Because each individual buyer and seller represents a tiny fraction of the total market, they have no influence over the market price. Both buyers and sellers must accept the price determined by the market.
Free Entry and Exit: A third condition that characterizes perfectly competitive markets in the long run is that firms can freely enter or exit the market without barriers.
Revenue Measures and Behavior in Competitive Firms
Total Revenue ():
Total revenue is the total amount of money a firm receives from the sale of its output.
Calculated as market price () multiplied by the quantity of output sold ():
Average Revenue ():
Defined as total revenue divided by the quantity sold:
Average revenue indicates what a firm receives for the typical unit of output sold.
Substituting into the formula:
General Principle: For all types of firms (competitive or non-competitive), average revenue equals the market price of the good.
Marginal Revenue ():
Defined as the change in total revenue resulting from the sale of an additional unit of output:
For competitive firms specifically, selling an additional unit always adds the market price to total revenue because the price remains constant regardless of the firm's output level.
Therefore, for competitive firms, marginal revenue equals the price of the good:
Equality relationship for a competitive firm:
Schedule of Total, Average, and Marginal Revenue for a Competitive Firm:
The following schedule illustrates a competitive firm selling milk at a prevailing market price of per gallon:
Quantity: ; Price: ; Total Revenue: ; Average Revenue: ; Marginal Revenue:
Quantity: ; Price: ; Total Revenue: ; Average Revenue: ; Marginal Revenue:
Quantity: ; Price: ; Total Revenue: ; Average Revenue: ; Marginal Revenue:
Quantity: ; Price: ; Total Revenue: ; Average Revenue: ; Marginal Revenue:
Quantity: ; Price: ; Total Revenue: ; Average Revenue: ; Marginal Revenue:
Quantity: ; Price: ; Total Revenue: ; Average Revenue: ; Marginal Revenue:
Quantity: ; Price: ; Total Revenue: ; Average Revenue: ; Marginal Revenue:
Profit Maximization Principles and Numerical Analysis
Total Cost Structure in the Example:
Total cost () comprises fixed costs () and variable costs ().
In this numerical farm example, fixed costs equal (incurred even when output is zero: at , ).
Variable costs vary directly with the quantity of milk produced.
Calculation of Profit:
Profit is computed by subtracting total cost from total revenue:
The change in profit from producing one additional unit equals marginal revenue minus marginal cost:
Comprehensive Numerical Schedule of Profit Maximization:
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue (): Not applicable
Marginal Cost (): Not applicable
Change in Profit (): Not applicable
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue:
Marginal Cost:
Change in Profit:
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue:
Marginal Cost:
Change in Profit:
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue:
Marginal Cost:
Change in Profit:
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue:
Marginal Cost:
Change in Profit:
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue:
Marginal Cost:
Change in Profit:
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue:
Marginal Cost:
Change in Profit:
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue:
Marginal Cost:
Change in Profit:
Quantity ():
Total Revenue:
Total Cost:
Profit:
Marginal Revenue:
Marginal Cost:
Change in Profit:
Decision Logic Based on Marginal Thinking:
When Marginal Revenue exceeds Marginal Cost (): The firm should increase the production of milk because doing so puts more money into the firm's pockets () than it takes out (), thereby increasing overall profit.
When Marginal Revenue is less than Marginal Cost (): The firm should decrease production because reducing output saves more in costs () than it sacrifices in revenue (), thereby increasing profit (or reducing loss).
In this schedule, profit is maximized at or with a maximum profit of . Producing the gallon adds in revenue and in cost, yielding .
Marginal Cost Curve and the Competitive Supply Decision
The Three Rules for Profit Maximization:
Rule 1: If marginal revenue exceeds marginal cost (), the firm should increase its output.
Rule 2: If marginal cost exceeds marginal revenue (), the firm should decrease its output.
Rule 3: At the profit-maximizing level of output, marginal revenue equals marginal cost:
Graphical Analysis of the Firm's Supply Decision:
The cost curves diagram displays the marginal-cost curve (), the average-total-cost curve (), and the average-variable-cost curve ().
Market price () is plotted as a horizontal line because the firm is a price taker; for a competitive firm:
Analysis at Output Level :
At , marginal revenue () exceeds marginal cost ():
Raising production increases profit because additional revenue exceeds additional cost.
Analysis at Output Level :
At , marginal cost () is above marginal revenue ():
Reducing production increases profit because cost reductions exceed revenue reductions.
Profit-Maximizing Output ():
The profit-maximizing quantity is found where the horizontal line representing market price intersects the marginal-cost curve:
The Marginal-Cost Curve as the Supply Curve:
Because a competitive firm is a price taker, its marginal revenue equals the market price ().
Therefore, the firm chooses its output quantity such that:
Because the firm's marginal-cost curve determines the quantity of the good the firm is willing to supply at any given price, the marginal-cost curve is also the competitive firm's supply curve.
An increase in market price from to shifts the horizontal revenue line upward, leading to an increase in the firm's profit-maximizing quantity from to .
Short-Run Production and Shutdown Decisions
Shutdown versus Exit:
Shutdown: A short-run decision not to produce anything during a specific period because of current market conditions.
Exit: A long-run decision to leave the market completely.
Key Distinction in Cost Obligations:
A firm that shuts down temporarily still must pay its fixed costs.
A firm that exits the market pays no costs at all—neither fixed nor variable.
The Concept of Sunk Cost:
A sunk cost represents an expenditure of money or time that has already been incurred and cannot be retrieved once spent.
In the short run, fixed costs are sunk because the firm cannot avoid them even by producing zero units of output.
Sunk costs are irrelevant to the short-run decision of whether to shut down.
Mathematical Derivation of the Shutdown Condition:
A firm shuts down if the revenue it would earn from producing is less than its variable costs of production:
Dividing both sides of the inequality by total output quantity ():
Since (which represents average revenue) and (average variable cost), the condition becomes:
If a firm produces anything, it produces the quantity at which marginal cost equals the price of the good ().
However, if the market price is less than average variable cost () at that quantity, the firm loses more money by operating than by shutting down; it is better off shutting down temporarily and producing zero output ().
The Competitive Firm's Short-Run Supply Curve:
In the short run, the competitive firm's supply curve is the portion of its marginal-cost curve () that lies above its average-variable-cost curve ().
If , the firm produces along its curve where .
If , the firm shuts down temporarily and produces zero output.
Long-Run Entry and Exit Decisions
Condition for Firm Exit:
A firm exits the market in the long run if the revenue it would obtain from producing is less than its total cost of production:
Dividing both sides of the inequality by quantity ():
Because and (average total cost), the exit rule is:
A firm chooses to exit if the market price is less than the average total cost of production.
Condition for Firm Entry:
A prospective firm decides to enter the market if the revenue it would obtain exceeds its total cost of production:
Dividing both sides by quantity ():
A new firm will enter the market if the market price exceeds the average total cost of production.
The Competitive Firm's Long-Run Supply Curve:
In the long run, the competitive firm's supply curve is the portion of its marginal-cost curve () that lies above its average-total-cost curve ().
If , the firm produces on its curve where .
If , the firm exits (or does not enter) the market.
Graphical Measurement of Profit and Loss
Mathematical Formulation of Profit:
Total profit is defined as total revenue minus total cost:
Rewriting this by multiplying and dividing by output quantity ():
Substituting and :
Graphical Representation as an Area:
The firm's profit or loss is represented graphically as the area of a rectangle between the market price line and the average-total-cost curve:
Height of the Box: The difference between price and average total cost ().
Width of the Box: The profit-maximizing quantity of output produced ().
Profit and Loss Scenarios:
Positive Economic Profit:
Occurs when the market price is greater than average total cost ().
The firm produces at where .
The area of the rectangle with height and base represents positive economic profit.
Economic Loss:
Occurs when the market price is less than average total cost ().
The firm produces at the loss-minimizing quantity where .
The area of the rectangle with height and base represents the firm's total economic loss.
Operational Decision Rules for Competitive Firms
Summary Decision Matrix:
Step 1: Determine the profit-maximizing (or loss-minimizing) output quantity at which price equals marginal cost:
Step 2 (Immediate Shutdown): If , shut down immediately and remain out of business in the short run.
Step 3 (Short-Run Operation, Long-Run Exit): If , continue to operate in the short run (to cover variable costs and a portion of fixed costs), but exit the market in the long run.
Step 4 (Permanent Profitable Operation): If , stay in business in both the short run and long run, generating positive economic profits.
Market Supply Curves in the Short Run and Long Run
Short-Run Market Supply with a Fixed Number of Firms:
In the short run, the number of firms in the market is fixed because firms cannot rapidly enter or exit.
The market supply curve reflects the horizontal sum of the individual firms' supply curves (which are their marginal-cost curves above ).
Numerical Example ( Identical Firms):
Individual Firm Supply:
At a price of , an individual firm produces and supplies .
At a price of , an individual firm produces and supplies .
Market Supply:
Market output supplied is times the quantity supplied by each individual firm.
At , total market quantity supplied is:
At , total market quantity supplied is:
Long-Run Market Supply with Free Entry and Exit:
In the long run, firms can freely enter or exit the market based on profit incentives:
If , firms earn positive economic profits, encouraging new firms to enter the market.
If , firms incur economic losses, encouraging existing firms to exit the market.
The Zero Economic Profit Condition:
The entry and exit process continues until economic profit is driven to zero:
This zero-profit equilibrium requires price to equal average total cost:
Efficient Scale:
Defined as the level of production that corresponds to the lowest (minimum) average total cost.
Because a competitive firm maximizes profit where , and zero profit drives , the long-run equilibrium satisfies:
In the long-run equilibrium of a competitive market with free entry and exit, all firms operate at their efficient scale.
Horizontal Shape of the Long-Run Market Supply Curve:
Because firms enter or exit until market price equals the minimum of average total cost, the long-run market price is fixed at .
The number of firms in the market adjusts to ensure that the entire market demand is satisfied at this price.
As a result, the long-run market supply curve is perfectly elastic (a horizontal line) at the price corresponding to the minimum average total cost:
Dynamic Adjustments to Demand Shifts in Short Run and Long Run
Initial Long-Run Equilibrium (Point A):
The market starts in long-run equilibrium at the intersection of initial demand () and initial short-run supply () at Point A.
The market price is , which equals the minimum of average total cost ().
Market quantity is .
Each firm operates at its efficient scale and makes zero economic profit ().
Short-Run Impact of an Increase in Demand (Point B):
Market demand increases, shifting rightward from curve to curve .
In the short run, the number of firms cannot change. The equilibrium moves along the initial short-run supply curve from Point A to Point B.
The market price rises from to .
The total quantity sold in the market increases from to .
Because the price has risen above average total cost (), existing firms expand production along their marginal-cost curves and earn positive economic profits.
Long-Run Adjustment via Market Entry (Point C):
Over time, the presence of positive economic profits creates an incentive for new firms to enter the market.
As new firms enter, the total number of sellers increases, shifting the short-run market supply curve to the right from to .
This increase in supply exerts downward pressure on the market price.
The market reaches a new long-run equilibrium at Point C, where the new demand curve intersects the shifted supply curve .
Characteristics of the New Long-Run Equilibrium (Point C):
The market price falls back to its original level:
Total market quantity supplied increases further to (where ).
Each individual firm once again produces at its efficient scale where .
Economic profits are driven back down to zero ().
The market accommodates the higher aggregate demand solely through an increased number of active firms rather than higher individual firm output or higher prices.