ENG Notes 09/08 Comprehensive Guide to Writing Argumentative Claims and Policy Statements

Just saying this a problem to worry about write statics in section 1 introduce the problem youre not ARUGING, your saying this is an issue you have to talk about



Feedback and Assignment Expectations

  • Grade Center Monitoring: Detailed and long-form feedback on assignments is recorded directly within the Grade Center. Regular review of these detailed comments is essential for tracking progress and adjusting future writing.

  • Writing Engagement: Cultivating enthusiasm and active engagement in the writing process significantly improves overall argument structure and output.

  • Cultural References and Associations: Common references like Julius Caesar frequently elicit immediate associations with figures or items such as Cesar Chavez, Caesar salad, or pop culture media (such as Planet of the Apes).

Topic Selection and Persuasive Writing Guidelines

  • Requirements for Argumentative Topics: Any topic chosen for an assignment must inherently lend itself to a persuasive argument rather than a simple statement of personal opinion or unresolvable debate.

  • Topics to Avoid (Existence vs. Non-Existence):

    • Examples of non-viable or overly difficult topics include supernatural or unproven claims such as "Alien 66" or "Ghost 66".

    • Arguing whether something fundamentally exists or does not exist presents a distinct "proof factor" obstacle.

    • Establishing a viable middle ground is nearly impossible when locked into binary absolute claims ("this exists" versus "this does not exist"). Without empirical evidence readily available, meeting assignment constraints becomes excessively difficult.

  • Selecting a Viable Social Issue:

    • Students are advised to pivot toward recognized social issues.

    • Prominent Social Issues: Issues such as modern systemic loneliness or food insecurity provide rich, evidentiary context for analytical writing.

    • Definition Baseline: Establishing clear definitions for core terms at the outset of an argument ensures clear comprehension for the audience and sets a structured foundation for the thesis.

Categorization of Thesis Statements and Argumentative Claims

  • Definition of a Claim: A claim functions as the fundamental thesis statement of an essay, serving as the explicit assertion being advanced and defended.

  • Three Primary Types of Claims:

    • 1. Claim of Fact:

    • Definition: Asserts whether a specific phenomenon, entity, or condition exists or does not exist.

    • Guidance: Students should avoid claims of fact due to the rigid burden of proof and the difficulty of building a nuanced argument within standard assignment parameters.

    • 2. Claim of Value:

    • Definition: Evaluates whether something is the best, worst, good, bad, moral, or immoral within a specific category.

    • Guidance: Avoid this claim type unless highly experienced. Subjective evaluations—such as arguing that a specific sports player or team is the absolute best—are significantly harder to prove logically and persuasively than students anticipate.

    • 3. Claim of Policy:

    • Definition: Asserts that a specific action should or should not be taken by a government entity, social agency, institution, or society at large.

    • Utility: The claim of policy is the easiest and most practical type of thesis to construct, yet it is frequently avoided by students.

    • Examples:

      • State Assistance: Asserting that the State of Ohio should establish a comprehensive hunger assistance program.

      • Institutional Programs: Asserting that educational institutions or local organizations should implement targeted food distribution programs for students in need.

    • Strategic Advantage: Claims of policy allow writers to thoroughly analyze both sides of an issue, address practical implementation barriers (e.g., funding, logistical challenges), and build compelling counterarguments.

Group Activity and Application: Homelessness Policy Claims

  • Practical Exercise: Students are tasked with selecting homelessness as a core social issue and drafting actionable policy claims to submit for approval.

  • Group Discussion and Dialogue:

    • Core Concept Review: A policy argument explicitly asserts that a specific, concrete action should or should not be undertaken by an authority or organization.

    • Targeted Proposals:

    • Establishing dedicated healthcare funds and institutional healthcare provisions tailored specifically for individuals experiencing homelessness.

    • Allocating structured funding for basic essential needs, including clean clothing and hygienic supplies.

    • Underlying Rationale: Providing basic health care, financial assistance, and clean clothing directly removes structural obstacles to employment. Equipping individuals with basic essentials fosters the necessary confidence to undertake job interviews, facilitating long-term economic integration.