Commercial Property

Homework and Class Schedule

  • Homework on case study regarding insurance policies due next Monday.

  • Test originally planned for next class has been pushed back to the following Monday.

  • Next week's focus will be on life insurance. If the class pace requires, adjustments may be made to ensure coverage is complete.

Commercial Property Insurance Overview

  • There are similarities between commercial property policies and homeowners' policies, particularly in property coverage.

  • Key areas that require attention in commercial policies include water damage and concurrent causation, both of which were lightly covered in homeowners' discussions.

Water Damage Coverage

  • Insurers are very particular about water damage coverage and have specific exclusions.

    • Coverage includes damage from broken pipes and rain, dependent on the policy.

    • Flood damage is excluded unless there are unusual circumstances.

  • Various specifics concerning water damage coverage need to be considered:

    • Rainwater damage is covered only if wind causes an opening for water to enter.

    • Interior rain damage from poor window maintenance (e.g., bad caulking, rust, or decay) is not covered in the broad form, but may be in the special form.

  • Contrasts between broad form and special loss causes:

    • Broad Form Losses: Covers rain, snow, sand, or dust damage to the interior only if wind or hail caused the original damage.

      • Exclusions apply to situations where damage is due to wear and tear or maintenance issues.

    • Special Form Losses: Open perils coverage except for specifically excluded items.

      • Covers interior damage regardless of initial wind damage, but the burden of proof remains on the insurer to prove exclusions apply.

  • Coverage exclusions to note:

    • Flood, surface water, waves, tides, mudslides, water backflow from sewer drains, and water below ground are excluded from both broad and special causes of loss forms.

Concurrent Causation

  • Concurrent causation becomes critical in understanding insurance claims:

    • When two separate events cause damage—one covered and one excluded—often the outcome is that the insurer denies the claim citing the exclusion.

    • Reference was made to Hurricane Katrina, where concurrent causation complexity arose due to both flooding and structural integrity issues with levees.

      • If an event's nature (flood or wind) can be proven, then it will determine if the losses are covered or excluded under anti-concurrent causation clauses.

Practical Implications of Insurance Types

  • When presenting insurance options to clients, brokers must articulate the differences between basic, broad, and special coverage:

    • Basic coverage offers minimal protection.

    • Broad coverage includes additional specified perils (named perils), while special coverage typically includes all risks unless specifically excluded.

    • Theft and improved water damage coverage are significant differences when choosing between broad and special forms.

  • Understanding the behavior and risk adjustments utilized by insurers through telematics.

    • Insurers monitor driving behaviors to adjust risk calculations and rates.

    • The principle of behavioral modification suggests that monitored individuals tend to perform better under surveillance.

Claims Process and Provisions

  • When an insured property faces loss, the following steps are required:

    • Immediate reporting to the insurer and providing necessary cooperation for examinations and proof of loss.

    • Adherence to co-insurance clauses to ensure complete coverage during a claim.

      • Example: If coverage is below required values at loss time, indemnity is proportioned based on actual versus insurance value.

  • Business income interruption coverage is crucial for companies experiencing operational changes due to property loss.

    • This covers business income lost during the rebuilding phase, recognizing potential partial versus total loss scenarios depending upon business models (e.g., online versus brick-and-mortar).

    • Businesses like restaurants heavily rely on this insurance to recover lost income during reconstruction.

Additional Insurance Types

  • Specific coverage variations discussed include:

    • Inland marine forms apply to valuable items not located on the insured's premises, like contractor tools.

    • Specific questions around film production insurance relating to liability and coverage in the event of on-set accidents.

    • Special handling of stolen items and subsequent returns by law enforcement.

Key Takeaways

  • Telematics' role in personal auto insurance demonstrates the evolving landscape of risk assessment and management in the insurance sector.

  • Concurrent causation and its implications highlight ongoing challenges in property insurance and need for clear contract language and defined coverage expectations.

  • Understanding the nature of coverage options helps brokers deliver better risk management for their clients, aiding in tailored insurance offerings that suit specific business needs.