Controlling Microbial Growth
Controlling Microbial Growth
Lecture Outline
Functional Methods
Microbiocidal vs. Microbiostatic
Considerations When Selecting Method
Quantifying Microbial Killing
How to Kill Microbes
Pasteurization (to be included)
Methods to Stop Microbial Growth
Objective: Eliminate unwanted microbes.
Outside the body:
Use non-specific, harsh physical means.
Apply sterilization, disinfection, and antiseptic techniques for medical equipment and surfaces.
Inside the body:
Utilize more specific antibiotics.
Treatments can be categorized as:
Microbiocidal: Killing of microbes.
Microbiostatic: Stopping reproduction of microbes.
Functional Categories of Methods
Sterilization:
Definition: Destruction of all living cells and viruses.
Methods:
High heat/flame.
High temperatures and pressure (e.g., autoclave).
Disinfection:
Definition: Destruction of most microbes, excluding endospores.
Characteristics:
Not used on living tissues—too harsh.
Methods:
UV light, boiling, and various chemicals, including ethanol.
Antisepsis (including degerming):
Definition: Destruction of many microbes.
Characteristics:
Can be used on living tissues.
Almost always chemical agents, where substances can act as either disinfectants or antiseptics depending on concentration and application surface.
Factors to Consider in Antimicrobial Strategies
Microbial Characteristics: Identify the target microbe.
Population Size & Exposure Time:
Number of microbes present.
Duration of exposure needed to effectively kill the microbe.
Type of Environment & Treatment:
Context and method of application: Where and how the killing is to be done.
Mechanism of Microbial Treatments
Effective treatments must damage a key cell structure:
Cell Wall
Plasma Membrane
Proteins (including enzymes!)
Nucleic Acids (both DNA and RNA)
Some organisms possess protective structures that increase their resistance to damage.
Resistance of Microorganisms to Chemical Biocides
Most Resistant:
Prions
Endospores of bacteria
Mycobacteria
Cysts of protozoa
Vegetative protozoa
Gram-negative bacteria
Fungi (including most fungal spores)
Viruses without envelopes
Gram-positive bacteria
Viruses with lipid envelopes
Least Resistant
Quantifying Microbial Killing
Importance of treatment duration for control agents.
Kill Curves based on experimental data are crucial for understanding killing times.
D-value:
Definition: Decimal reduction time, the time required to kill 90% of a specific microbe with a specified treatment.
Can be conceptualized as the “death rate,” contrasting with the generation time.
Logarithmic Killing
Log killing represents exponential death rather than growth.
Example Scenario:
90% of cells die in 5 minutes (D-value = 5 minutes).
Survival Percentages after various times:
10% remain after 5 minutes.
1% after 10 minutes.
0.1% after 15 minutes.
0.01% after 20 minutes.
Effect of Population Size on Killing Rate
Larger starting populations result in longer times required to kill all microbes.
The rate of killing remains constant; however, it takes longer to kill all individuals in larger populations.
This principle applies to both heat and chemical treatments.
Calculation of Cell Death
Formula to calculate based on D-values:
$Nf = Ni \times 0.1^n$
$N_f$: Final number of microbes
$N_i$: Initial number of microbes
$n$: Number of D-values
$n = \frac{(Total Treatment Time)}{(D-value)}$
Example Calculation:
Starting with 1,000,000 (10^6) bacteria and treating with 70% ethanol (kills 90% every 30 seconds, D-value = 30 seconds)
$N_f = 10^6 \times 0.1^{\frac{120}{30}}$
$N_f = 10^6 \times 10^{-4} = 100$ cells remaining after 2 minutes.
Time Required to Kill Remaining Cells
Calculate total time for all cells to die:
$Nf = Ni \times 0.1^n$
Starting with 100 after 2 minutes.
Follow-up calculations show remaining cells reduce as follows:
After 30 seconds, 10 cells left.
After another 30 seconds, 1 cell left.
After another 30 seconds, < 1 cell left, indicating all are dead; thus, require 1 extra minute to ensure all cells are eliminated.
How to Kill Microbes - Chemical Agents
Common agents include:
Chlorine (as bleach, Cl2 gas, or chloramines)
Oxidizing Agents (e.g., Cidex)
Surfactants in Detergents (e.g., CaviCide)
Alcohols
Hydrogen Peroxide
Bisphenols (e.g., Triclosan)
Iodophors/Iodine
Most compounds function as disinfectants; some may act as antiseptics depending on concentration and application.
How to Kill Microbes - Physical Agents: Heat
Heat is cost-effective, widely available, and effective for microbial control.
Moist Heat:
Pasteurization or Boiling (disinfection)
Autoclaving (sterilization)
Dry Heat:
Bake in an oven or incinerate in a flame (sterilization).
How to Kill Microbes - Physical Agents: Irradiation
Non-ionizing Radiation (disinfection):
Lower energy, e.g., ultraviolet light can eventually sterilize with high intensity over time.
Mechanism: Damages DNA.
Ionizing Radiation (sterilization):
High energy, e.g., X-rays and Gamma rays are frequently used for plastics in the medical field that would not withstand high temperatures.
Mechanism: Causes breaks in DNA and alters reactive oxygen species levels.
Mechanical Physical Methods
Filtering:
Effective for liquids or gases that cannot be heated.
Example: Air filtration before entering a surgical room.
Microbiostatic Methods
Definition: Prevent microbial multiplication without killing them.
Effective primarily when the initial microbial load is low.
Common Applications:
Reducing temperatures to inhibit microbial reproduction (e.g., refrigeration/freezing).
Dehydration techniques or creating hypertonic environments using salt or sugar (e.g., preservation in pickles or honey).
Controlling Microbes in or on a Body
Antibiotics:
Designed to target bacteria.
Varied options with generally few side effects, as bacterial cells differ substantially from human cells.
Specificity: Each antibiotic usually acts against several bacteria.
Can be either microbiocidal or microbiostatic.
Often derived from fungi or bacteria.
Bacteria can develop resistance through natural selection.
Emerging consideration of viruses to treat bacterial diseases.
Antibiotic Modes of Action
Inhibition of Cell Wall Synthesis:
Examples:
Penicillins
Cephalosporins
Bacitracin
Vancomycin
Inhibition of Protein Synthesis:
Examples:
Chloramphenicol
Erythromycin
Tetracyclines
Streptomycin
Inhibition of Nucleic Acid Replication and Transcription:
Examples:
Quinolones
Rifampin
Injury to Plasma Membrane:
Example:
Polymyxin B
Inhibition of Essential Metabolite Synthesis:
Examples:
Sulfanilamide
Trimethoprim
Mechanism: Each antibiotic targets structures that differ between bacteria and human cells.
Summary
Goal of Microbial Control:
Slow or stop the progression and spread of disease, food spoilage, and other microbial growth issues.
Agents can either be microbiocidal or microbiostatic.
Control methods depend on the microbe type and growth location.
Disinfecting or antiseptic properties may vary based on concentration.
All methods should aim at key bacterial structures.
Resistance development can occur through natural selection and mutation.
Kill curves and D-values provide quantifiable data for microbial death rates, and different microbial species display varied D-values for the same agents.