Controlling Microbial Growth

Controlling Microbial Growth

Lecture Outline

  • Functional Methods

  • Microbiocidal vs. Microbiostatic

  • Considerations When Selecting Method

  • Quantifying Microbial Killing

  • How to Kill Microbes

  • Pasteurization (to be included)

Methods to Stop Microbial Growth

  • Objective: Eliminate unwanted microbes.

  • Outside the body:

    • Use non-specific, harsh physical means.

    • Apply sterilization, disinfection, and antiseptic techniques for medical equipment and surfaces.

  • Inside the body:

    • Utilize more specific antibiotics.

    • Treatments can be categorized as:

    • Microbiocidal: Killing of microbes.

    • Microbiostatic: Stopping reproduction of microbes.

Functional Categories of Methods

  1. Sterilization:

    • Definition: Destruction of all living cells and viruses.

    • Methods:

      • High heat/flame.

      • High temperatures and pressure (e.g., autoclave).

  2. Disinfection:

    • Definition: Destruction of most microbes, excluding endospores.

    • Characteristics:

      • Not used on living tissues—too harsh.

    • Methods:

      • UV light, boiling, and various chemicals, including ethanol.

  3. Antisepsis (including degerming):

    • Definition: Destruction of many microbes.

    • Characteristics:

      • Can be used on living tissues.

    • Almost always chemical agents, where substances can act as either disinfectants or antiseptics depending on concentration and application surface.

Factors to Consider in Antimicrobial Strategies

  • Microbial Characteristics: Identify the target microbe.

  • Population Size & Exposure Time:

    • Number of microbes present.

    • Duration of exposure needed to effectively kill the microbe.

  • Type of Environment & Treatment:

    • Context and method of application: Where and how the killing is to be done.

Mechanism of Microbial Treatments

  • Effective treatments must damage a key cell structure:

    • Cell Wall

    • Plasma Membrane

    • Proteins (including enzymes!)

    • Nucleic Acids (both DNA and RNA)

  • Some organisms possess protective structures that increase their resistance to damage.

Resistance of Microorganisms to Chemical Biocides

  • Most Resistant:

    • Prions

    • Endospores of bacteria

    • Mycobacteria

    • Cysts of protozoa

    • Vegetative protozoa

    • Gram-negative bacteria

    • Fungi (including most fungal spores)

    • Viruses without envelopes

    • Gram-positive bacteria

    • Viruses with lipid envelopes

  • Least Resistant

Quantifying Microbial Killing

  • Importance of treatment duration for control agents.

  • Kill Curves based on experimental data are crucial for understanding killing times.

  • D-value:

    • Definition: Decimal reduction time, the time required to kill 90% of a specific microbe with a specified treatment.

    • Can be conceptualized as the “death rate,” contrasting with the generation time.

Logarithmic Killing

  • Log killing represents exponential death rather than growth.

  • Example Scenario:

    • 90% of cells die in 5 minutes (D-value = 5 minutes).

    • Survival Percentages after various times:

    • 10% remain after 5 minutes.

    • 1% after 10 minutes.

    • 0.1% after 15 minutes.

    • 0.01% after 20 minutes.

Effect of Population Size on Killing Rate

  • Larger starting populations result in longer times required to kill all microbes.

  • The rate of killing remains constant; however, it takes longer to kill all individuals in larger populations.

  • This principle applies to both heat and chemical treatments.

Calculation of Cell Death

  • Formula to calculate based on D-values:

    • $Nf = Ni \times 0.1^n$

    • $N_f$: Final number of microbes

    • $N_i$: Initial number of microbes

    • $n$: Number of D-values

    • $n = \frac{(Total Treatment Time)}{(D-value)}$

  • Example Calculation:

    • Starting with 1,000,000 (10^6) bacteria and treating with 70% ethanol (kills 90% every 30 seconds, D-value = 30 seconds)

    • $N_f = 10^6 \times 0.1^{\frac{120}{30}}$

    • $N_f = 10^6 \times 10^{-4} = 100$ cells remaining after 2 minutes.

Time Required to Kill Remaining Cells

  • Calculate total time for all cells to die:

    • $Nf = Ni \times 0.1^n$

    • Starting with 100 after 2 minutes.

    • Follow-up calculations show remaining cells reduce as follows:

    • After 30 seconds, 10 cells left.

    • After another 30 seconds, 1 cell left.

    • After another 30 seconds, < 1 cell left, indicating all are dead; thus, require 1 extra minute to ensure all cells are eliminated.

How to Kill Microbes - Chemical Agents

  • Common agents include:

    • Chlorine (as bleach, Cl2 gas, or chloramines)

    • Oxidizing Agents (e.g., Cidex)

    • Surfactants in Detergents (e.g., CaviCide)

    • Alcohols

    • Hydrogen Peroxide

    • Bisphenols (e.g., Triclosan)

    • Iodophors/Iodine

  • Most compounds function as disinfectants; some may act as antiseptics depending on concentration and application.

How to Kill Microbes - Physical Agents: Heat

  • Heat is cost-effective, widely available, and effective for microbial control.

  • Moist Heat:

    • Pasteurization or Boiling (disinfection)

    • Autoclaving (sterilization)

  • Dry Heat:

    • Bake in an oven or incinerate in a flame (sterilization).

How to Kill Microbes - Physical Agents: Irradiation

  • Non-ionizing Radiation (disinfection):

    • Lower energy, e.g., ultraviolet light can eventually sterilize with high intensity over time.

    • Mechanism: Damages DNA.

  • Ionizing Radiation (sterilization):

    • High energy, e.g., X-rays and Gamma rays are frequently used for plastics in the medical field that would not withstand high temperatures.

    • Mechanism: Causes breaks in DNA and alters reactive oxygen species levels.

Mechanical Physical Methods

  • Filtering:

    • Effective for liquids or gases that cannot be heated.

    • Example: Air filtration before entering a surgical room.

Microbiostatic Methods

  • Definition: Prevent microbial multiplication without killing them.

  • Effective primarily when the initial microbial load is low.

  • Common Applications:

    • Reducing temperatures to inhibit microbial reproduction (e.g., refrigeration/freezing).

    • Dehydration techniques or creating hypertonic environments using salt or sugar (e.g., preservation in pickles or honey).

Controlling Microbes in or on a Body

  • Antibiotics:

    • Designed to target bacteria.

    • Varied options with generally few side effects, as bacterial cells differ substantially from human cells.

    • Specificity: Each antibiotic usually acts against several bacteria.

    • Can be either microbiocidal or microbiostatic.

    • Often derived from fungi or bacteria.

    • Bacteria can develop resistance through natural selection.

    • Emerging consideration of viruses to treat bacterial diseases.

Antibiotic Modes of Action

  1. Inhibition of Cell Wall Synthesis:

    • Examples:

      • Penicillins

      • Cephalosporins

      • Bacitracin

      • Vancomycin

  2. Inhibition of Protein Synthesis:

    • Examples:

      • Chloramphenicol

      • Erythromycin

      • Tetracyclines

      • Streptomycin

  3. Inhibition of Nucleic Acid Replication and Transcription:

    • Examples:

      • Quinolones

      • Rifampin

  4. Injury to Plasma Membrane:

    • Example:

      • Polymyxin B

  5. Inhibition of Essential Metabolite Synthesis:

    • Examples:

      • Sulfanilamide

      • Trimethoprim

  • Mechanism: Each antibiotic targets structures that differ between bacteria and human cells.

Summary

  • Goal of Microbial Control:

    • Slow or stop the progression and spread of disease, food spoilage, and other microbial growth issues.

  • Agents can either be microbiocidal or microbiostatic.

  • Control methods depend on the microbe type and growth location.

  • Disinfecting or antiseptic properties may vary based on concentration.

  • All methods should aim at key bacterial structures.

  • Resistance development can occur through natural selection and mutation.

  • Kill curves and D-values provide quantifiable data for microbial death rates, and different microbial species display varied D-values for the same agents.