Culture Notes: Material vs Symbolic; Diversity, Subcultures, and Ethnocentrism
Definition of Culture
Culture is defined as everything that is human made. This is an imperfect, widely-used definition; there has never been a perfect definition of culture. The speaker notes a critique: this definition might even seem to include people since people are human-made in a broad sense, but typically the body itself isn’t treated as culture. The core idea is that culture encompasses the products and systems humans create in lived experience.
The aim is to analyze culture by breaking it into two broad forms: material culture and symbolic culture.
Material culture: all the physical, tangible objects and spaces created by humans (the stuff in our environment).
Symbolic culture: beliefs, values, norms, institutions, language, and shared meanings—things that aren’t tangible but structure and give meaning to social life. Symbolic culture can include the meaning of geographic spaces and how we interpret places.
Material Culture
Defined as the “stuff” that humans create and use. Examples include:
The desks, chairs, whiteboard, and overall space in the classroom (the room itself as part of material culture).
Everyday eating utensils: forks, spoons, knives, and chopsticks depending on culture.
Food-related practices and utensils (e.g., chopsticks in many Asian cultures; using hands for eating in some cultures).
Items around the home and their maintenance (e.g., a yard/lawn, fence, paint on the fence, a dog that knocks boards down, and the effort to maintain decorative spaces).
Cross-cultural material differences:
In American/Western culture: use of forks, spoons, and knives to eat.
In many Asian cultures: use of chopsticks.
Some cultures use hands to eat rather than utensils.
Visual examples of material culture differences across regions:
United States: typical home features like a yard and a lawn, a garage, a fence, and a four-post layout of home spaces.
Japan: smaller plots of land, minimal or no yards, dense urban living, and spaces like a futon drying area.
China (urban living): apartments that combine living spaces with access to city amenities; smaller average living spaces (e.g., about 750 ext{ ft}^2 in some middle-class urban apartments) versus the American norm (~2{,}600 ext{ ft}^2 for a typical middle-class house).
Clothing, jewelry, food, and technology are all components of material culture.
Symbolic Culture
Symbolic culture includes the shared interpretations of beliefs, values, norms, and institutions that guide behavior.
The speaker frames “American culture” or “Chinese culture” through symbolic aspects like language, religion, and social norms.
Religion and belief systems illustrate symbolic culture:
The United States is religiously diverse, with a large proportion of people identifying as Christian. The speaker cites approximately 70\% of the population identifying as Christian in the U.S., illustrating how religion shapes cultural norms and social expectations.
Some people identify as atheists or spiritual but not religious; religion is a cultural variable that can be debated in terms of how it shapes culture.
Language as a symbolic component:
Language is human-made and transmitted across generations; in the U.S., English is the dominant language learned in schools, though the country is multilingual.
Data examples used in class:
In the United States, about 21\% of the population speaks a language other than English at home.
Regional examples of Spanish-language prevalence: Moreno, Texas has a very high Spanish-speaking population (≈95\%), Los Angeles, California has about 45\% Spanish speakers, and many areas have significant multilingual populations.
The United States is multilingual and diverse, but English is the primary language for communication in most contexts.
Language education differences: In the U.S., English is the main instructional language; other languages are offered (e.g., Spanish, French) but not as intensively taught as in some other countries that emphasize multilingual education.
Major Values Discussed as Culture
Values are a core part of symbolic culture and are often invoked in political and election contexts (e.g., talking about "American values").
Some common values discussed:
Individualism: the belief that individuals should work hard, lift themselves up, and be responsible for their own success; personal autonomy and self-reliance.
Freedom: pride in liberty and political rights (e.g., democracy, personal freedoms).
Equality: the notion that all people should be treated as equals under the law (referenced to the declaration of equality: "All men are created equal").
The speaker notes that while these values are proclaimed, there are ongoing tensions and gaps between ideals and practice (e.g., equality and equity issues, voter participation, and social inequalities).
Political participation discussion:
A large portion of eligible voters do not vote, including a significant share of young people.
The classroom is described as a teaching environment, not a democratic setting where students vote on what content is taught; demonstrates how many real-world systems operate more like dictatorships than democracies in day-to-day control, even when democratic values are professed.
The speech highlights ongoing debates about how closely these values are realized in practice and acknowledges that there are disagreements about what values should be prioritized (e.g., the balance between individual liberty and collective equity).
Cultural Diversity Within the United States
The U.S. is culturally diverse with multiple subcultures and ethnic communities that maintain distinct practices:
Food cultures as examples of diversity: a traditional dish (like a potato-based flatbread or other culturally specific foods) representing the unique culinary traditions brought by different groups; the speaker uses multiple food examples to illustrate cultural variety within society.
The rural–urban divide: distinct cultural patterns between urban and rural areas (values, dating customs, pace of life, political leanings).
Urban-rural differences:
Urban areas tend to lean toward Democratic political orientations; rural areas toward more conservative (often red) alignments.
Differences in dating culture and social networks; rural dating may be less dependent on dating apps due to smaller population and more intimate knowledge of potential partners.
Pace of life can differ (e.g., faster in some cities, slower in others).
Everyday life and social norms: local driving behaviors (e.g., a stop sign in Fayette and the tendency to push social expectations) illustrate how everyday practices reflect cultural norms.
Subcultures: smaller cultural groups within the larger culture that diverge in meaningful ways from the dominant culture. Examples include:
Ethnic neighborhoods (e.g., Chinatowns in large cities like Houston) where language, foods, and cultural practices are concentrated and distinct from the broader society.
Wealth-based subcultures (e.g., polo as a sport associated with a wealthier segment, with distinct games and social practices).
The existence of multiple subcultures is viewed as evidence of cultural diversity and freedom of cultural expression within the United States.
Subcultures and Countercultures
Subculture: a group within a larger culture that has distinct beliefs, values, or practices but remains part of the larger society (e.g., Chinatown communities, ethnic enclaves, or wealth-based subcultures like polo).
Counterculture: a subculture that actively opposes the norms and values of the dominant culture and seeks to change society by challenging the status quo.
Examples mentioned: Hippies (historical) and Extinction Rebellion (a more contemporary, global counterculture) which uses civil disobedience to protest environmental degradation and push for immediate action.
Tactics of counterculture: disruption of everyday life to draw attention (e.g., blocking major events like the Tour de France) to bring attention to their causes.
Ethnocentrism and Xenophobia
Ethnocentrism: the tendency to evaluate other cultures by the standards and values of one's own culture, often judging them as inferior or wrong.
The speaker notes this tendency in everyday reactions to culturally different practices (e.g., women's clothing or head coverings).
Xenophobia: an intensified or irrational dislike or fear of people from other countries; a more extreme form of ethnocentrism.
Historical and contemporary manifestations include resistance to immigration and fear of immigrants changing national culture.
The speaker notes that xenophobia and ethnocentrism persist in modern societies and can influence policy debates around immigration and cultural integration.
Real-World Relevance and Implications
The interplay between material and symbolic culture affects everyday life, policy, and social cohesion:
Housing and urban planning reflect cultural values around space, privacy, and community (e.g., yards and garages in the U.S. vs. compact urban living in Japan and China).
Language policy and education shape social integration and access to opportunities; multilingualism has real social and economic implications.
Food and cuisine illustrate how immigrant communities contribute to national culture and how food becomes a site of identity and inclusion/exclusion.
Debates over values influence political discourse, voting behavior, and policy decisions in areas like democracy, equality, and freedom.
Ethical and philosophical implications include balancing individual rights with collective equity, and managing cultural diversity without eroding core national identities.
Practical implications include how schools prepare students for a multicultural society, how communities negotiate differences, and how policies address ethnocentrism and xenophobia.
Connections to Foundational Principles and Real-World Examples
The material vs. symbolic culture distinction aligns with foundational sociological frameworks that separate tangible artifacts from the meanings and norms that accompany them.
Language, religion, and values illustrate symbolic culture in action and show how groups reproduce culture through socialization (e.g., how a majority religious identification emerges in a given country).
The urban–rural divide and subcultures demonstrate the diversity of cultural experiences within a single country and highlight how demographic and spatial factors shape cultural expression.
Countercultures and movements (e.g., Extinction Rebellion) illustrate how groups challenge dominant cultural norms to advance alternative visions for society.
Ethnocentrism and xenophobia underscore the ethical concerns of evaluating others through one’s own cultural lens and the real-world impact on immigrant communities and policy.
Quick Reference: Key Figures and Examples Mentioned
U.S. Christian identification: ext{Approximately }70 ext{ extperthousand} or $$70\