FAR Study Notes — Inventory Accounting (Area II.C)
What Counts as Inventory (and When You “Own” It)
What inventory is
Inventory is an asset held for sale in the ordinary course of business (merchandise), in the process of production for sale (work in process), or to be consumed in producing goods/services for sale (raw materials and certain supplies). Conceptually, inventory is a “waiting room” for costs: costs sit in inventory until you sell the related goods, at which point those costs become cost of goods sold (COGS).
This matters because inventory is usually one of the largest current assets for product companies, and small mistakes in inventory measurement often cause big swings in:
- Gross profit and net income (through COGS)
- Current ratio/working capital (through current assets)
- Trend analysis and loan covenants
The key FAR idea: ownership is about title and shipping terms
You record goods as inventory when you own them at the balance sheet date—not necessarily when you physically possess them. FAR commonly tests “in transit” and “on consignment” situations because they’re easy places to make cut-off errors.
Goods in transit (FOB terms)
- FOB shipping point: title transfers when the seller ships the goods. Buyer includes goods in inventory while in transit.
- FOB destination: title transfers when the goods arrive. Seller keeps goods in inventory while in transit.
A practical way to think about this: “FOB point of departure” means the buyer owns it once it leaves; “FOB destination” means the buyer owns it once it arrives.
Consigned goods
Consignment means the owner (consignor) ships goods to another party (consignee) to sell on the owner’s behalf. The consignee does not own the goods.
- Consignor: keeps consigned goods in inventory.
- Consignee: does not record inventory; may record a liability if it has collected cash owed to the consignor.
A common misconception is to treat the consignee like a buyer. In consignment, the consignee is more like an agent earning a commission.
Cutoff: the “end-of-year shipping room” problem
Cutoff is making sure purchases and sales are recorded in the correct period. Inventory cutoff errors are especially damaging because they often affect both the income statement (sales/COGS) and the balance sheet (inventory/AP).
Typical cutoff checks:
- Last shipments before year-end (sales cutoff)
- Last receiving reports before year-end (purchases cutoff)
- Shipping terms for goods in transit
- Existence of consignment arrangements
Example: who includes goods in inventory?
Company A shipped goods to Company B on December 28 under FOB shipping point; goods arrive January 3.
- Company B (buyer) owns goods on December 31, so includes them in ending inventory.
- Company A (seller) should not include them in inventory if properly recorded as a sale.
If the term were FOB destination, the opposite inventory ownership applies on December 31.
Exam Focus
- Typical question patterns:
- Determine whether goods in transit belong in buyer or seller inventory based on FOB terms.
- Identify who records inventory in consignment (consignor vs consignee).
- Correct misstatements from cutoff errors near year-end.
- Common mistakes:
- Treating “in transit” as automatically excluded from inventory (ownership can transfer before receipt).
- Recording consigned goods as consignee inventory.
- Ignoring shipping terms when adjusting purchases/sales cutoff.
Measuring Inventory at Cost: What Gets Capitalized vs Expensed
The core measurement rule
Under U.S. GAAP, inventory is generally recorded at cost when acquired/produced. “Cost” is not just the vendor’s invoice price—it includes costs necessary to bring inventory to its present location and condition.
This matters because the boundary between “inventory cost” and “period expense” determines when the cost hits the income statement. Capitalizing a cost delays expense recognition until sale.
Costs typically included in inventory for a merchandiser
For a company that buys finished goods for resale, inventory cost generally includes:
- Purchase price (net of certain discounts—see below)
- Freight-in (shipping to bring goods to you)
- Import duties and nonrefundable taxes
- Other directly attributable costs to ready goods for sale
Costs typically excluded (expensed as incurred):
- Freight-out (shipping to customers)
- Selling expenses (marketing, commissions)
- General and administrative costs
- Abnormal waste/spoilage (discussed below)
Purchase discounts: gross vs net method
Suppliers often offer terms like (2% discount if paid within 10 days; otherwise due in 30).
Two acceptable approaches:
- Gross method: record the purchase at full invoice price; recognize discount only if taken.
- Net method: record the purchase net of the discount; if discount is not taken, record the lost discount as an expense (often treated as interest/financing-type cost).
FAR questions may test your ability to compute inventory cost under either method.
Manufacturer’s inventory: product costs vs period costs
For a manufacturer, inventory includes product costs:
- Direct materials
- Direct labor
- Manufacturing overhead (both variable and fixed, allocated)
Costs like selling and administrative are period costs and are expensed as incurred.
Abnormal spoilage and idle capacity
A subtle but testable point: abnormal amounts of spoilage, scrap, or rework are generally expensed as incurred rather than included in inventory. The logic is that inventory should reflect normal, expected costs to produce goods—abnormal inefficiencies shouldn’t be deferred.
Interest and inventories
Under U.S. GAAP, interest is capitalized for certain qualifying assets during construction/production. Inventory that is routinely manufactured in large quantities on a repetitive basis is generally not treated as a qualifying asset for interest capitalization. (In other words: don’t reflexively capitalize interest into ordinary inventory.)
Example: computing inventory cost for a merchandiser
You purchase goods with an invoice price of , terms , and you pay freight-in. You pay within 10 days.
Inventory cost under gross method:
- Start with invoice:
- Discount taken:
- Net purchase cost:
- Add freight-in:
- Inventory cost:
Exam Focus
- Typical question patterns:
- Identify which costs belong in inventory vs period expense (freight-in vs freight-out; abnormal spoilage).
- Compute inventory cost including discounts and transportation.
- Manufacturer questions separating product vs period costs.
- Common mistakes:
- Including selling/shipping-to-customer costs in inventory.
- Forgetting to treat abnormal spoilage as expense.
- Misapplying discount terms (e.g., discount on freight-in, which typically is not discounted by vendor terms).
Inventory Systems and Cost Flow Assumptions (FIFO, LIFO, Average)
Inventory system: periodic vs perpetual
Your inventory system determines when you update inventory and COGS.
- Perpetual system: Inventory and COGS are updated continuously with each purchase and sale.
- Periodic system: Inventory is updated at period-end by physical count; COGS is computed at period-end.
This matters because the same cost flow assumption (FIFO, LIFO, average) can produce different computations under periodic vs perpetual systems—especially with fluctuating prices.
The fundamental relationship: BI + Purchases − EI = COGS
For a merchandiser under a periodic system:
Where net purchases typically include purchases minus returns/allowances and minus discounts, plus freight-in.
Cost flow assumptions: what they are (and what they are not)
A cost flow assumption is an accounting method for which costs are assigned to:
- Units sold (COGS), and
- Units still on hand (ending inventory)
Important: cost flow is not necessarily the same as physical flow. A company can sell oldest units first physically but still use LIFO for accounting.
FIFO (First-In, First-Out)
FIFO assumes the oldest costs are sold first; the newest costs remain in ending inventory.
Why it matters:
- In rising prices, FIFO tends to show lower COGS and higher ending inventory and higher income.
- Ending inventory on the balance sheet is closer to current replacement costs (because it consists of newer costs).
LIFO (Last-In, First-Out)
LIFO assumes the newest costs are sold first; the oldest costs remain in ending inventory.
Why it matters:
- In rising prices, LIFO tends to show higher COGS, lower ending inventory, and lower income—often resulting in tax benefits (tax is outside FAR computations sometimes, but the income effect is heavily tested).
- Ending inventory may become very old (layers from years ago), making the balance sheet less “current.”
A key FAR concept is LIFO liquidation: if inventory quantities drop, older (cheaper) layers can flow into COGS, artificially increasing income.
Weighted-average cost
Weighted-average smooths price changes by averaging costs.
- Under a periodic system, you compute one average for the whole period.
- Under a perpetual system, you often use a moving average (recomputed after each purchase).
Specific identification
Specific identification assigns actual specific costs to specific units (common for unique, high-value items like cars, jewelry, real estate lots).
Why it matters: it most closely matches actual economics but can be used to manage earnings if managers selectively choose which specific items are “sold.”
Worked example: FIFO vs LIFO vs weighted-average (periodic)
Assume:
- Beginning inventory: units @
- Purchases: units @
- Units sold: units
Total units available: . Ending units: .
FIFO:
- COGS:
- Ending inventory:
LIFO:
- COGS:
- Ending inventory:
Weighted-average (periodic):
- Average cost per unit:
- COGS:
- Ending inventory:
This illustrates the classic ordering in rising prices: and the reverse for ending inventory.
LIFO reserve (bridge between LIFO and FIFO)
Many companies using LIFO disclose a LIFO reserve, which is the difference between inventory reported under FIFO (or current cost) and inventory reported under LIFO.
A useful relationship:
And the change in the reserve affects COGS:
Be careful with the direction: if the reserve increases, it usually means FIFO inventory is pulling further ahead of LIFO inventory (typical in rising prices), and FIFO COGS becomes lower than LIFO COGS.
Exam Focus
- Typical question patterns:
- Compute ending inventory and COGS under FIFO/LIFO/average (periodic or perpetual).
- Use LIFO reserve to convert LIFO inventory to FIFO inventory, or to convert COGS.
- Identify income effects of rising/falling prices and of LIFO liquidation.
- Common mistakes:
- Mixing periodic and perpetual computations (especially for LIFO and average).
- Getting the sign wrong when using .
- Treating cost flow as physical flow (and overthinking it).
Subsequent Measurement: Lower of Cost and Net Realizable Value (and “Market” for LIFO/Retail)
Why inventory gets written down
Even if you measured inventory correctly at cost, circumstances can change:
- Damage or obsolescence
- Declining selling prices
- Increased costs to complete or sell
Accounting responds with conservatism: you generally should not carry inventory above amounts you expect to realize from selling it.
The main U.S. GAAP model: Lower of Cost and Net Realizable Value
For most inventory, U.S. GAAP uses lower of cost and net realizable value (LCNRV).
Net realizable value (NRV) is essentially expected selling price minus costs to complete, dispose, and transport.
Conceptually:
- If NRV drops below cost, you write inventory down and recognize a loss (often in COGS or a separate line depending on policy and materiality).
- If NRV later recovers, U.S. GAAP generally does not allow reversing the write-down for inventory.
The special case: lower of cost or market (LCM)
For LIFO and the retail inventory method, U.S. GAAP still uses the older lower of cost or market (LCM) rule.
Here, market is based on replacement cost, but with constraints:
- Ceiling:
- Floor:
So market is replacement cost limited to a range between the floor and ceiling.
Students often memorize this incorrectly. A clean way to apply it:
- Compute replacement cost.
- Compute ceiling (NRV) and floor (NRV minus normal profit).
- Constrain replacement cost into that range to get “market.”
- Compare cost vs market and take the lower.
Example: applying LCM with ceiling/floor
A product has:
- Historical cost:
- Replacement cost:
- NRV (ceiling):
- Normal profit margin: so floor
Replacement cost is between floor and ceiling , so market .
Lower of cost or market . Inventory is written down to .
Presentation and terminology pitfalls
- A write-down reduces inventory and increases expense (often COGS).
- Do not confuse NRV rules for inventory with fair value rules for financial instruments.
- Under IFRS, inventory write-down reversals can be allowed in some circumstances; U.S. GAAP generally does not allow reversal. FAR sometimes tests differences at a high level, but computations in FAR are typically U.S. GAAP unless stated otherwise.
Exam Focus
- Typical question patterns:
- Compute NRV and apply LCNRV for a set of inventory items.
- Apply LCM for LIFO/retail items using replacement cost with ceiling/floor.
- Determine the financial statement impact of an inventory write-down.
- Common mistakes:
- Using selling price instead of NRV (forgetting costs to complete/sell).
- Forgetting that LIFO/retail use “market” rules rather than LCNRV.
- Reversing a write-down under U.S. GAAP.
Estimating Inventory: Gross Profit Method and Retail Inventory Method
Why estimation methods exist
Sometimes you can’t do a full physical count quickly (fire, theft investigation, interim reporting). Estimation methods provide a reasonable approximation of ending inventory—useful for internal reporting and some external reporting circumstances.
These methods matter on FAR because they test whether you understand the logic of the inventory equation and the relationship between sales, gross profit, and cost.
Gross profit method (GPM)
The gross profit method estimates ending inventory by assuming gross profit behaves predictably as a percentage of sales.
Mechanism:
- Estimate COGS using expected gross profit rate.
- Compute ending inventory as goods available minus estimated COGS.
If gross profit rate is given as a percent of sales, then:
Then:
Worked example (GPM)
Beginning inventory , purchases , sales . Gross profit rate is of sales.
Goods available:
Estimated gross profit:
Estimated COGS:
Estimated ending inventory:
Common error: using gross profit percent of cost when the problem gives percent of sales (or vice versa). Always read how the rate is defined.
Retail inventory method (RIM)
The retail inventory method estimates ending inventory by converting ending inventory at retail prices back to cost using a cost-to-retail ratio.
This method is common in retail businesses with many items (department stores) where tracking cost per item is difficult but retail prices are readily available.
Mechanism (high level):
- Build goods available at cost and at retail.
- Compute cost-to-retail percentage.
- Compute ending inventory at retail: goods available at retail minus sales at retail.
- Convert ending inventory at retail to cost using the ratio.
A basic cost-to-retail ratio is:
Then:
In more advanced problems, you may need to consider markdowns/markups depending on whether the problem specifies the “conventional” retail method (which can interact with lower-of-cost-or-market concepts). On FAR, focus on following the exact instructions about including/excluding markdowns in the retail denominator.
Worked example (RIM)
Beginning inventory: cost , retail .
Purchases: cost , retail .
Sales at retail: .
Goods available:
Cost-to-retail percent:
Ending inventory at retail:
Ending inventory at cost:
Exam Focus
- Typical question patterns:
- Gross profit method: compute estimated ending inventory given sales and gross margin.
- Retail method: compute cost-to-retail ratio and ending inventory at cost.
- Identify when estimation methods are appropriate (interim reporting, casualty loss situations).
- Common mistakes:
- Mixing “gross margin % of sales” with “markup % of cost.”
- Forgetting to compute goods available at both cost and retail in RIM.
- Using sales at cost instead of sales at retail in RIM.
Advanced LIFO Topics and Purchase Commitments
LIFO layers and liquidation
Under LIFO, ending inventory is composed of “layers” from different purchase periods. In rising prices, newer layers have higher costs, so COGS is higher and income is lower.
LIFO liquidation happens when you sell more units than you purchase/produce, causing older (often cheaper) layers to be included in COGS. The effect is:
- COGS decreases (because old costs are lower)
- Gross profit and income increase
This income increase is not necessarily “good news”—it may just be an accounting effect from drawing down inventory.
Dollar-value LIFO (conceptual overview)
Dollar-value LIFO is a LIFO method that tracks layers in dollars rather than units, grouping similar items into pools. It helps companies avoid tracking layers item-by-item and reduces the chance that product mix changes accidentally trigger liquidation.
High-level steps:
- Convert ending inventory at current-year prices to base-year prices using a price index.
- Determine whether a new layer has been added in base-year dollars.
- If added, price that new layer at current-year cost.
On FAR, you may see computations that provide an index and ask you to compute base-year amounts and layer increases.
Purchase commitments
A purchase commitment is a contract to buy inventory in the future at a fixed price.
If market prices fall below the committed price and the loss is probable and estimable, U.S. GAAP generally requires recognizing a loss in the current period (before you even take delivery), often by recording a liability for the unfavorable commitment.
Why? Because the contract has become onerous: you’re locked into paying more than the market.
If prices later recover before purchase, the recognized loss may be reduced, but the accounting depends on the specific facts and whether the loss remains probable.
Example: purchase commitment loss
You commit to buy inventory for . Before year-end, the market price for the same goods falls to . The loss is probable.
Recognize a loss of:
Typically recorded as a loss and a liability (or allowance) for the commitment.
Exam Focus
- Typical question patterns:
- Identify and quantify income effects of LIFO liquidation.
- Dollar-value LIFO questions using a provided index to compute layers.
- Compute and record losses on unfavorable purchase commitments.
- Common mistakes:
- Treating LIFO liquidation as an “error” rather than an outcome when quantities decline.
- Ignoring the need for a price index step in dollar-value LIFO.
- Waiting to recognize a purchase commitment loss until inventory is received.
Inventory Errors: How Misstatements Flow Through the Financial Statements
Why inventory errors are powerful
Inventory affects both the balance sheet and the income statement, and it affects the income statement through COGS, which is a plug in many systems. That means a single mistake can distort profit without any “obvious” incorrect expense line item.
The two most common error types
- Ending inventory misstatement
- Beginning inventory misstatement (usually the prior year’s ending inventory error)
Because beginning inventory in Year 2 equals ending inventory in Year 1, many inventory errors are “self-correcting” over two years—but that does not mean they are harmless. They shift income between periods.
Effects of misstated ending inventory (periodic system intuition)
Using:
- If ending inventory is overstated, then COGS is understated, and income is overstated.
- If ending inventory is understated, then COGS is overstated, and income is understated.
Balance sheet effects at year-end:
- Inventory misstated in the same direction.
- Retained earnings overstated/understated through the income effect.
Two-period reversal (why it “self-corrects”)
If Year 1 ending inventory is overstated, then Year 2 beginning inventory is also overstated. In Year 2, that overstatement increases COGS (because BI is higher), pushing Year 2 income down. Over two years combined, total income can end up correct, but each year is wrong.
Example: ending inventory overstated
Assume Year 1 ending inventory is overstated by .
- Year 1: COGS understated , income overstated .
- Year 2 (beginning inventory overstated): COGS overstated , income understated .
Exam Focus
- Typical question patterns:
- Determine the direction and amount of net income misstatement from inventory over/understatements.
- Multi-year questions asking for Year 1 vs Year 2 income effects.
- Cutoff-driven errors that simultaneously misstate inventory and accounts payable.
- Common mistakes:
- Getting the sign backward (remember EI is subtracted in COGS).
- Forgetting that an EI error becomes next period’s BI error.
- Fixating only on the income statement and missing balance sheet effects.