Notes on Defence, Foreign Affairs and Public Opinion in Australia

Defence, Foreign Affairs and Public Opinion

Overview of Bipartisanship in Australia

  • For most of the 20th century, except during the World Wars, defence and foreign affairs saw minimal political contestation in Australia.
  • This allowed for a long-standing bipartisanship in Australian politics, leading to low public interest and limited knowledge about strategic options among citizens.
  • Noteworthy exceptions include the Vietnam War, where political divisions emerged over support for the U.S.
  • Engagement in foreign policy issues notably increased after key events like the September 11 attacks and the Bali bombings in 2002.

Changes in Public Engagement (Post-2001)

  • The changing strategic environment has heightened public awareness of defence and foreign policy issues.
  • Australia’s military involvement in the Iraq War led to divisions among major parties and increased public scrutiny of defence policy.
  • Globalisation has intertwined economic considerations with defence and foreign policy, further awakening public interest.

Development of Public Opinion Polling

  • Prior to the late 1980s, issues related to defence and foreign affairs were rarely polled, hindering longitudinal analysis of public opinion.
  • Introduction of the Australian Election Study (AES) in 1987 and the Lowy Institute survey in 2005 provided valuable data on public attitudes.
  • Systematic study of Australian public opinion on defence and foreign affairs can now be conducted.

Examining Opinion-Policy Relationships

  • Traditional views in political science suggest public opinions are often ill-informed and unpredictable, as argued by foreign policy realists.
  • In contrast, liberal perspectives see public opinion as essential for accountability and can influence foreign policy outcomes.
  • Recent analyses have moved toward pluralist models where public opinion is seen as logical and coherent, influenced by elite cues.

Evolution of Foreign Policy in Australia

  • The bipartisan nature of foreign policy has occasionally stifled democratic debate, as major parties avoid contentious troop deployments.
  • The end of colonial ties has allowed Australia to pursue a more independent foreign policy in recent decades, highlighted by multiple free trade agreements with various countries.
  • There are shifts in demographic composition, with nearly half of Australians being overseas-born or having immigrant parents, impacting foreign policy attitudes.

Key Themes in Australian Foreign Policy

  • The discussion around defence, foreign policy, and public opinion revolves around:
    • Australia's engagement with Asia,
    • The ANZUS alliance,
    • Australia's role as an international actor.
  • Changes in demographic make-up influence public sentiment towards Asia, showing some key trends and generational shifts.

Role of Public Opinion in Defence

  • Various studies have indicated a connection between public opinion and perceived threats, affecting attitudes toward military alliances and interventions.
  • Despite bipartisan support for ANZUS, public skepticism about military interventions (like Iraq) has led to significant political debate.
  • The general tendency shows that while public opinion remains supportive of alliances, it is less forgiving of overseas military deployments not backed by strong political rationale.

Conclusion

  • The findings illustrate that public opinion in Australia regarding defence and foreign policy has become more engaged and complex.
  • Public sentiment is increasingly critical of unchallenged governmental decisions in foreign affairs, signalling a demand for more public debate in shaping policies that affect Australia’s national interests.