Stalin's Rise to Power

The Power Vacuum and Power Struggle

Timeline of Lenin’s Last Years

  • 1922

    • April → Stalin is made General Secretary of the Party

    • May → Lenin is incapacitated by a stroke + the Triumvirate is formed

    • December → Lenin suffers a second stroke + the USSR is formed

  • 1923

    • March → Lenin is close to death after a third stroke

  • 1924

    • January → Lenin dies

    • May → Lenin’s Testament is suppressed at the Party Congress

Ideology and the Nature of Leadership

  • Marxist ideology suggested that power should be shared in a collective leadership

    • however, while ideology pointed in one direction, Lenin’s legacy, issues of practicality and individual ambitions pointed in another

    • Lenin’s state → decisions were supposedly made by collectively voting in the Central Committee, however Lenin had dominated governance

  • Lenin’s Actions

    • introduced the 1921 ‘ban on factions’

      • became dangerous to express disagreement with anything proposed by influential Party members

    • centralised control by the Party had replaced any notion of ‘power to the soviets’

      • both the 1921 ‘ban on factions’ and the Kronstadt rebellion

        • Sailors at Kronstadt, who had been strong supporters of the Bolsheviks in 1917, demanded "Soviets without Bolsheviks."

        • Lenin and Trotsky crushed the rebellion using the Red Army, killing or imprisoning thousands.

        • This demonstrated that the Bolsheviks would not allow independent soviet power if it threatened Party control

    • Leninist government had created a huge state bureaucracy, carrying out orders from superiors

      • In 1922 , Stalin became General Secretary.

        • The Secretariat managed Party appointments and records.

        • Through the nomenklatura system, officials were appointed from above and owed their positions to the Party leadership.

        • This created a bureaucracy loyal to senior leaders rather than to local soviets or workers.

Lenin’s Testament

  • December, 1922 → Lenin dictated his 600-word Testament, in which he proposed changes to the membership of the Party’s Central Committee, to double it from 50-100 members

  • What He Said About The Members

    • Lenin criticised almost everyone but was especially critical of Stalin, advising for his dismissal and removal of power

      • partly because he had been rude to Lenin’s wife, Nadezhda Krupskaya

      • partly because Stalin had used brute force to suppress Georgian independence, going directly against Lenin’s orders

    • Lenin did not endorse anyone as his successor → this may suggest he wanted the party to return to collective leadership

  • document was entrusted to Krupskaya to be read at the Twelfth Party Congress

    • Krupskaya, however, kept it a secret in the hopes that her husband would recover

      • did not produce it until after his death, when she then asked for it to be read at the Thirteenth Party Congress

  • however the document was kept a secret, as the triumvirate did not want it to be released

    • it was more critical of the triumvirate than it was of Trotsky

    • thus, only a few of the non-damning parts were read to other Party officials

Divisions and Contenders for Power

  • Playing Field

    • Trotsky initially seemed the most likely person to succeed Lenin

      • he had played key roles in the Bolshevik seizure of power and the Reds’ victory in the Civil War

    • 1922-1923 → the triumvirate was formed to block Trotsky’s rise to power

      • they dominated the Central Committee

    • 1924-25 → Stalin was becoming more dominant, so Zinoviev and Kamenev joined Trotsky in the Left Opposition

    • Bukharin was on the right of the Bolshevik party, often supported by Rykov and Tomsky

      • joined Stalin against the Left Opposition

      • Stalin resented his popularity

  • Stalin

    • Character

      • reasonable yet rude

      • patient

      • jealous

      • hard-working

      • violent

    • Strengths

      • role as General Secretary

        • meant he could appoint supporters to key roles in the Party

        • By the mid-1920s, he had appointed thousands of Party officials to key posts

      • opponents underestimated him as he was good at concealing his real thoughts and ambitions

        • e.g. he positioned himself as a central, almost mediative figure

      • placed himself close to Lenin and claimed to know Lenin’s wishes

        • e.g. delivered a prominent speech at the funeral, portraying himself as the guardian of Lenin's legacy

        • blocked Trotsky from going to the funeral

      • as he did not appear to be a threat to other contenders, Zinoviev and Kamenev allied with him to isolate Trotsky

    • Weaknesses

      • not very prominent in the October Revolution or the Civil War

        • At Tsaritsyn (1918), Stalin ignored Trotsky's orders, appointed his own commanders, and authorised harsh measures without approval from Moscow → proved he was solitary and didn’t follow orders

      • colleagues saw him as ill-educated, rude and crude

        • Lenin had criticised his violent methods e.g. Georgian independence

      • seen a boring

        • called a ‘grey blur’ by Sukhanov

        • focused on bureaucracy and administration

      • although Lenin’s Testament had been blocked, senior Bolsheviks knew Stalin had fallen from Lenin’s favour

  • Trotsky and the Left

    • Trotsky

      • Character

        • energetic

        • organised

        • ruthless

        • arrogant

      • Strengths

        • recognised as a hero of the October revolution

          • led the MRC and organised the seizure of power

        • recognised as a hero of the Civil War

          • got the Red Army from 300,000 men to 3 million

          • inspired them

        • inspirational speaker and intellectual

          • he wrote many important books on communist theory

        • known for formidable political skills and organisational ability

      • Weaknesses

        • arrogant and dismissive of people who were not as intellectual as him

          • badly underrated Stalin

          • He did not form an alliance with Zinoviev and Kamenev when they were first opposing Stalin.

          • By the time Trotsky joined the United Opposition (1926), Stalin had already defeated him politically and controlled much of the Party apparatus

        • indecisive and inconsistent

          • allying himself with Zinoviev and Kamenev after opposing them

        • many Bolsheviks feared Trotsky, as they worried he would use his Red Army influence to seize power

          • he was seen as a potential dictator

        • did not seriously try to build a base of followers in the Party

          • he even attacked the Party bureaucracy in 1924, when he needed its help

    • Zinoviev

      • Character

        • intelligent

        • imposing

        • vain

        • inconsistent

        • compromiser

      • Strengths

        • he was an ‘Old Bolshevik’

          • Lenin had once called him his ‘closest and most trusted assistant’

        • he had a strong power base in Leningrad, where he ran the local Party

        • he was one of the Party’s best speechmakers, with a commanding presence

      • Weaknesses

        • opposed Lenin in October, 1917

          • he argued against the timing of the uprising and briefly leaving the Party

        • he was vain and prone to unpredictable mood swings

        • underestimated Stalin

          • he was too late in switching support from Stalin to Trotsky, instead thinking he could use Stalin to quash Trotsky

    • Kamenev

      • Character

        • thoughtful

        • loyal

        • inconsistent

        • compromiser

      • Strengths

        • he was an ‘Old Bolshevik’ who had helped form Party policy and was close to Lenin

        • he had a strong power base in Moscow

          • he ran the local Party there

        • he was an effective team player, good at reaching compromises between different people

      • Weaknesses

        • he oppose Lenin in October, 1917 alongside Zinoviev

          • he argued against the timing of the uprising and briefly left the Party

        • was viewed as Zinoviev’s side-kick

          • was seen as lacking the ambition to be a sole leader

        • underestimated his opponents, specifically Stalin

  • Bukharin and the Right

    • Bukharin

      • Character

        • brilliant

        • very popular

        • eager to please

        • naive

      • Strengths

        • was popular in the Party

          • close to both Lenin and Trotsky

          • was a close associate of Stalin

        • widely regarded as the best theoretician in the Party

        • was an expert on economics and agriculture

          • these were key issues for the Bolshevik government

      • Weaknesses

        • he was so cooperative and wanted to avoid Party in-fighting

          • therefore he had no power base

        • his popularity in the Party made him a target for Stalin

        • he underestimated Stalin

          • he left it too late to make an alliance with Zinoviev and Kamenev

    • Rykov

      • Character

        • loyal

        • moderate

        • wanted to find common ground

      • Strengths

        • widely respected in the Party as an ‘Old Bolshevik’

        • he was a good administrator

          • he had helped implement war communism and the NEP

        • he was supported by the Sovnarkom

          • he was chosen as Deputy Chairman in 1923 and Chairman in 1924

      • Weaknesses

        • his policy of heavy taxation on vodka was very unpopular

        • opposed Lenin over the timing of the revolution

        • lacked a power base

          • too much of a conciliatory moderate and was overshadowed by Bukharin

    • Tomsky

      • Character

        • plain speaker

        • moderate political views

      • Strengths

        • widely respected in the Party as an ‘Old Bolshevik’, with working-class origins

        • had a strong base of support from being General Secretary of the Red International of the Trade Unions

        • the natural ally of moderates such as Rykov and Bukharin

      • Weaknesses

        • hated Trotsky so much that he could not see the threat from Stalin

          • underestimated him

        • his power base in the trade unions made him a target for Stalin’s resentment

        • his support for the NEP was used against him by Stalin when the grain crisis of 1927 hit


Ideological Debates and Issues in the Leadership Struggle

NEP and Industrialisation

  • The Left

    • was led by Trotsky, Zinoviev and Kamenev

    • they wanted to abandon the NEP in favour of state-controlled, rapid industrialisation funded by ‘squeezing’ the peasants

  • Stalin

    • Stalin’s attitude was inconsistent, constantly changing sides

    • during struggle against Trotsky

      • opposed the Left, thus supporting the NEP

    • then he shifted to a policy of relacing the NEP with rapid industrialisation and the collectivisation of agriculture

  • The Right

    • led by Bukharin, Rykov and Tomsky

    • believed the NEP should continue, with the peasants becoming richer and the state using taxes on the peasants to fund gradual industrialisation

‘Permanent Revolution’ or ‘Socialism in One Country’

  • Marxist Theory

    • all theories of Marxism-Leninism had assumed it was impossible for revolution to survive in a single country because the capitalist nations would work together to end the revolution

      • therefore it was essential for the Bolshevik revolution in Russia to trigger a chain reaction of other revolutions

    • Marxist theory was contradicted by real-world events

      • revolutions in Germany and Hungary were crushed

      • defeat in the Russo-Polish War in 1920 blocked the revolution from extending to the West

  • Permanent Revolution

    • Trotsky and the Left took this position

    • believed the USSR could not survive on its own without support from other socialist countries, so revolution had to be enforced in Europe

    • Lenin had also made the argument

      • Stalin had written about it

  • Socialism in One Country

    • 1924 → adopted by Stalin

      • believed that the USSR could build socialism on its own

    • Stalin referenced an old article by Lenin that said one country could show the rest of the world the benefits of socialism, and workers would then rush to support that country and rise up in revolutions in their own countries

    • Stalin used his argument to criticise Trotsky

      • Trotsky had contradicted Lenin

      • Trotsky had dismissed the USSR’s potential

Timeline

  • January, 1924 → Lenin’s funeral

    • Stalin used his powers as General Secretary to make the most of Trotsky’s absence

    • he took charge of arranging the funeral and styled himself as Lenin’s disciple

  • May, 1924 → Lenin’s Testament is blocked from being read at the 13th Party Congress

    • Triumvirate criticised by Lenin in the Testament so blocked the reading of it

    • Trotsky did not insist on the reading going ahead → could have helped him if it had been

  • May, 1924 → Trotsky’s criticism of the Party bureaucracy are rejected at the Party Congress

    • As General Secretary, Stalin’s control over the appointments to the Central Committee meant the Congress was filled with his supporters

    • Trotsky was voted down

  • October, 1924 → Trotsky criticises Kamenev and Zinoviev for not backing Lenin in 1917

    • Stalin stayed out of the fight on the LEft

    • criticism weakened his rivals whilst he appeared moderate

    • brought in more supporters to the Central Committee

  • December, 1925 → 14th Party Congress, Kamenev and Zinoviev criticise Stalin for his move to the Right and support for the NEP

    • Stalin’s support meant that every vote at the Congress went against Kamenev and Zinoviev

    • Stalin’s ‘Socialism in One Country’ policy became very popular

    • Stalin and Bukharin formed the Duumvirate and largely ran the country in 1926-27

  • 1926 → Kamenev, Zinoviev and Trotsky form the United Opposition

    • they tried to organise demonstrations against Stalin, meaning he could accuse them of factionalism

  • November, 1927 → Kamenev, Zinoviev and Trotsky are expelled from the Party

    • at the 15th Party Congress, Stalin’s supporters confirmed the expulsion of Kamenev, Zinoviev and Trotsky, along with a hundred more ‘oppositionists’

  • Early 1928 → Grain Crisis

    • food shortages begun in late 1927 and it was hard for the regime to get enough grain from the peasants

    • criticism of the NEP began to increase in the Party, leading Stalin to split from Bukharin and use harsh requisitioning methods for getting grain from peasants in western Siberia

  • April, 1928 → Bukharin criticises the ‘excesses’ of officials following Stalin’s methods

    • Bukharin expected some support for his criticism but he received none

    • now he was politically isolated and vulnerable to Stalin’s attacks

  • November, 1929 → Bukharin, Rykov and Tomsky are expelled from the Politburo

    • Stalin’s supporters were bolstered by opponents of the NEP from the Left of the Party

    • agreed to remove Bukharin from the Politburo

Outcome for other Contenders

  • Kamenev and Zinoviev criticised their past actions after their expulsion from the Party

    • they were allowed to rejoin in 1928

    • they lost their high positions and places in the Politburo

  • Trotsky refused to criticise his past actions and was exiled

    • first to Kazakhstan and then deported in 1929

    • he was then murdered in 1940 in Mexico on Stalin’s orders

  • Bukharin, Rykov and Tomsky were initially allowed to stay in the Party after admitting their ‘mistakes’

  • Bukharin, Kamenev, Zinoviev and Rykov were executed after the show trials in the late 1930s

    • Tomsky committed suicide before the same thing could happen to him

Economic Developments

Key Chronology

  • 1927

    • October → start of the grain procurement crisis

    • November → Trotsky, Kamenev and Zinoviev and expelled from the Party

    • December → End of the NEP announced at the Fifteenth Party Congress

  • 1928

    • January → Stalin demands ‘extraordinary measures’ to deal with the grain crisis

    • October → Launch of the first Five Year Plan

  • 1929

    • April → Five Year Plan confirmed by the Central Committee

    • November → Bukharin expelled from the Politburo

    • December → Stalin’s declaration of ‘war against the kulaks’

The ‘Great Turn’

  • What was the ‘Great Turn’

    • a radical change in economic policy

      • rejected the NEP and committed to rapid industrialisation under state control, alongside the collectivisation of agriculture

    • began in 1925 when the Fourteenth Party Congress committed to industrialisation

      • the Fifteenth Party Congress in 1927 announced the end of the NEP

  • Reasons for the ‘Great Turn’

    • slow pace of industrialisation under the NEP

      • NEP was failing to produce the growth that many leading communists had expected

      • due to the WAR SCARE they also wanted to increase the USSR’s military strength and develop self-sufficiency

      • more efficiency was needed, and there was serious weakness in industrial management

    • grain procurement crisis

      • the amount of grain purchased by the government in the winter of 1927-28 was 25% down from the previous year’s total

      • peasants were blamed for hoarding grain in the hopes of obtaining better prices

    • ideological concerns

      • NEP was not considered true communism, and so many Party loyalists wanted a return to the true philosophy of communism

        • thus they needed to develop industry and not have the state be dependent on the peasants for grain

      • state had lost control on the countryside, which needed to be regained, and so they launched a ‘war on grain’ to get back on the right ideological path

    • Stalin’s changing attitudes

      • he had supported the NEP, when he needed to in order to advance politically, however he was now ready to be more radical

        • could be to do with the economic circumstances or because he wanted to push through his own political agenda

      • with the abolition of the NEP, Stalinism was able to be imposed

The Launch of the First Five Year Plan

  • Aims

    • catch up with the industrial strength of the capitalist countries

      • Stalin claimed that the USSR was 50-100 years behind

    • prepare the USSR for war with capitalist countries

    • achieve ‘Socialism in One Country’

      • the USSR’s achievements could fly the flag for communism, showing what the socialist state could do

    • assert Stalin’s authority and dominance over the Party

    • it was NOT intended to improve living standards

  • Features

    • central planning

      • GOSPLAN → state planning committee, set targets for different industrial sectors

      • command economy → brough a top-down, centralised approach to managing the economy

    • rapid industrial growth

      • over industrial production was planned to increase by 300%

      • heavy industry (coal, iron, steel, oil and machinery) was prioritised

      • light industry was give a lower priority, but was expected to increase by 100%

    • investment in infrastructure

      • plan called for a huge increase in the supply of electrical power in order to transform the economy and society

      • significant investment in infrastructure, especially the railway network

    • new industrial centres

      • thousands of new industrial centres were planned

        • Magnitogorsk → built from nothing to a settlement on 175,000 people by 1932, with a huge steel production facility at its centre

    • propaganda and discipline

      • propaganda campaigns were the driving force for achieving the first Five Year Plan

      • boards were erected outside every factory showing worker output levels and Plan targets

      • the threat of harsh punishments motivated managers and workers to find way to hit these targets

    • ideology

      • ideology was that socialism could achieve what would seem impossible to bourgeois capitalists

      • Stalin said in 1931 ‘there are no fortresses the Bolsheviks cannot capture’

    • use of foreign experts

      • industrial experts were brought in to build the new complexes and to train Soviet workers

        • Magnitogorsk → planned by an America company (Arthur McKee & Co) who also trained Soviet engineers in how to build it

  • Reactions

    • positive:

      • Party members were pleased to see a commitment to radical social change and an end to the compromises of the NEP

      • propaganda worked → urban workers hoped for better employment prospects and higher living standards

      • poor and ‘middle’ peasants hoped they would benefit from further land reform and the introduction of more modern methods

    • negative:

      • Stalin authorised higher wages for skilled workers, causing some to worry about the creation of class differences within the proletariat

      • harsh imposition of collectivisation and switch to investment from agriculture to industry → people feared it would result in less food being produced

      • many of those managing industrial production were already critical of the adverse impact of central planning

        • regarded it as a high-risk gamble

Grain Procurement Crisis

  • poor harvests had reduced the supply of grain, yet the state had set a low grain price

    • shortage of manufactured goods, so there was little for the peasants to buy

    • as such there was little incentive for the peasants to sell their grain

  • 1928 → harvest in the Urals and western Siberia had generally been good, but grain procurement was down 1/3 on the previous year

    • convinced Stalin that kulaks were responsible for hoarding grain

  • Stalin closed the free markets and pressured local officials and police

    • wanted to seize the grain by force, a method known as the brutal ‘Urals-Siberian method’

Collectivisation

  • Features

    • already some collective farms, due to 1917 Decree of Land

      • not very popular → only 5% of farms were collective in 1929

    • different models

      • sovkhozy → state farms, owned and run by the state

      • kolkhozy → collective farms, run by a voluntary cooperative of farmers pooling their resources and labour

    • TARGET for collectivised farms → 15% of the USSR’s farms

      • expected to lead to a 50% increase in agricultural production

    • was ‘voluntary’ → yet Central Committee sent 25,000 industrial workers into the countryside to promote it

      • they forced peasants to collectivise and worked to remove kulaks

  • Reasons for Accelerations

    • revolution had broken up the old landlord estates and agriculture was now small scale, using traditional methods → couldn’t produce enough food for a workforce

      • collective farms → combined hundreds of peasant families and their land

      • tractors → enable the land to be worked efficiently for large scale production

      • farming specialists to introduce new, modern methods

    • private trading under the NEP had made some peasants richer → kulaks believed to be hoarding grain to drive up prices

      • collectivisation joined by dekulakisation → to be eliminated as a class

    • grain procurement crisis proved that private peasant farming was not reliable enough

      • collective farms to be set production targets and paid a fixed price

      • private trade to be banned, ensuring the state could plan production reliably and increase grain supplies without paying higher prices to farmers

    • ideology → private farming was not socialist

      • collective farms would bring peasants together to work cooperatively, for the good of everyone in the USSR

  • Bukharin and Collectivisation

    • Bukharin opposed the Urals-Siberian method and accelerated collectivisation

      • criticised these methods as they risked peasants stopping the supply of food

      • this had previously led to food shortages, rationing and protest

    • HOWEVER → drive for accelerated collectivisation became more popular during 1929

      • local Party officials were enthusiastic

    • thus Bukharin’s political position was weakened

      • was OUTVOTED on agricultural policy in the Politburo in April, 1928

    • Stalin attacked Bukharin directly in November, 1928

      • accused him of ‘Right deviation’

      • was removed from the party in November, 1929


Government, Propaganda and Foreign Relations

Style of Government

  • Bureaucratic Centralism

    • central control of the economy matched by central control of the government

    • Party leadership controlled the appointment of key bureaucratic positions, down to a local level

  • Divide and Rule

    • Stalin brought people into favour but if they became too powerful, he would encourage their rivals to bring them down

    • e.g. Yezhov and Kirov

  • Fear

    • role of the secret police became more pervasive under Lenin

      • renamed the OGPU in 1926

    • fear permeated the imposition of Stalin’s policies

      • collectivisation was forced through by the extensive use of the OGPU

  • Loyal Supporters

    • Stalin’s ability as General Secretary to influence the appointment of Party officials was key to his control over the government

    • the Politburo was filled with Stalin’s loyal supporters

      • they made decisions that the Central Committee approved without question

  • Continuing Lenin’s Legacy

    • Stalin positioned himself as Lenin’s heir and the chief interpreter of Lenin’s wishes

      • this allowed him to respond to any challenge by showing how Lenin’s word supported him

Propaganda and the Beginning of the Stalinist Cult

  • Stalin relied heavily on propaganda to launch campaigns and boost enthusiasm for his schemes

    • e.g. launch of the First Five Year Plan (1928) and the acceleration of collectivisation (1929) were both accompanied with images of happy, productive workers

  • Stalin’s image was developed as the ‘Great Helmsman’, skilfully steering the country though all of the dangers surrounding it

    • e.g. one slogan was ‘Forward to socialism under the leadership of Great Stalin!’

  • Stalin used propaganda to position himself as Lenin’s heir

    • slogans e.g. ‘Stalin is the Lenin of today’

  • Stalin boosted the cult of Lenin to add to his own

    • Lenin’s corpse was embalmed and displayed (on Stalin’s orders, going against Krupskaya’s wishes)

    • this acted as a shrine to Lenin, who was being treated like a god → gave Stalin godlike characteristics

Stalin’s attitude to foreign powers

  • Main Aim

    • to keep the USSR safe, while concentrating on the domestic priority of building socialism in One Country

    • the USSR could not stay entirely isolated

      • Georgy Chicherin (Commissar for Foreign Affairs from 1918 to 1930) wanted to pursue the instability in China and opportunities in Germany

    • Chicherin and Litvinov were the USSR’s main representatives internationally

      • presented a moderate diplomatic image, helping to reassure foreign powers about doing business with the USSR

      • Stalin saw them as important in keeping relationships with capitalist foreign powers ‘safe’ → especially Germany

    • Comintern had initially been a low priority for Stalin during the leadership struggle, but then in 1929 he used it to launch an attack on social democratic parties in Europe

      • believed them to be diluting the appeal of communism to the working classes

  • China

  • Germany and the Treaty of Berlin

    • After the Rapallo Treaty was signed in 1922 the USSR continued to build good relations with Weimar Germany

      • Stresemann and Chicherin were committed to fostering cooperation

    • 1926 the Treaty of Berlin was signed

      • aimed at building ‘trustful cooperation between the German people and the people of the USSR’

      • article 2 stated that if one of the countries was attacked by a third country, the other would remain neutral in the conflict

      • article 3 stated that neither country would join in any economic boycott organised against either of them

    • the USSR benefited economically from the Treaty, receiving large financial credits from German banks in June, 1926

    • Stresemann died in 1929

      • this, along with the development of the world economic crisis, as well as Stalin’s aggressive foreign policy approach and Hitler’s rise to power strained relations between the two nations

Changes in the Comintern

  • Before 1929 → the comintern was a low priority for Stalin as he focused on gaining control of the Party

    • his commitment was to developing socialism in one country

    • the Comintern was associated with Trotsky and his theory of permanent revolution

  • 1922 → Stalin identified a new phase for the Comintern

    • all-out attack on anti-communist, social democratic parties in Europe (‘social fascism’)

    • Comintern would ready itself for renewed fight by:

      • ensuring all foreign communist parties purged themselves of ‘weak’ elements

      • imposing strict Party discipline on foreign communist parties

      • making sure all communist partyies followed the line on policy handed down to them by the USSR

    • Soviet control over the Comintern became tighter as Stalin appointed ‘Yes men’ to lead it

  • reasons for Stalin’s more agressive approach are unclear

    • maybe a way to attack Bukharin → he was opposed to the new focus

    • a result of his confidence in having removed Trotsky

    • connected to Stalin’s fear of challenges from power bases in other countries