P

Obedience 

Obedience occurs when we follow the commands of someone with authority, or the rules or laws of our society. 

Compliance involves changing one’s behaviour in response to a request to do so; it does not necessarily involve an authority figure.

Blind obedience occurs when people follow orders or instructions without question, and is often described as unquestioning compliance with authority


Milgram experiment 

  • Conducted by Stanley Milgram in the early 1960s to investigate obedience to authority.

  • Participants believed they were administering electric shocks to a learner for incorrect answers (shocks were fake).

  • Shocks ranged from mild to severe, with the highest level at 450 volts.

  • 65% of participants obeyed the experimenter and delivered the maximum shock despite the apparent distress of the learner.

  • Participants showed signs of tension and distress (nervous laughter, sweating, groaning).

  • The experiment demonstrated that ordinary people are likely to obey authority figures even against their moral beliefs.

  • Milgram introduced the concept of “destructive obedience,” where people follow harmful orders when obeying authority.


Explained by Agency Theory: people shift from an autonomous state (self-directed) to an agentic state (following authority’s orders).

  • Variables such as proximity to the learner and authority figure affected obedience levels.

  • The study raised ethical concerns due to the stress caused to participants, but it remains a landmark in understanding obedience.

  • Milgram’s findings challenge the idea that only certain types of people obey authority; obedience is a normal human behaviour under pressure.



Social Proximity 

Refers to the closeness between two or more people.

  • In Milgram’s experiment, social proximity was operationalised as the physical distance between the teacher and learner, including whether or not the teacher was physically present in the same room as the learner.  

  • When the teacher (participant) was in the same room with the learner (person being shocked), the number of fully obedient teachers dropped from 65% to 40%.

  • When the teacher was required to force the learner’s hand down into contact, the number of fully obedient teachers dropped to 30%.

  • When the teacher was out of the room and issued orders by telephone, the number of fully obedient teachers dropped to about 20%.




Group Pressure 

An individual is also more likely to be obedient when there is little or no group support for resisting the authority figure. 

An individual is more likely to be obedient where there is group support for the authority figure.

  • In Milgram’s study, participants were faced with the dilemma of whether to obey an authority figure or consider the health and safety of another human being. 

  • Individuals will often rationalise, or justify, their behaviour by offering the excuse that they cannot be held responsible for their actions because they are acting under instructions.

  • We are often confronted with situations where we have to decide whether to do what others are expecting or demanding from us or take a stand against their expectations or demands. 

  • Without obedience to the laws of our democratic society, groups could not function, and social life in the way we are accustomed to it would be extremely difficult, if not impossible.


Ethical issues in Milgram’s experiments

A common criticism of studies of obedience, such as those conducted by Milgram, is that they are unethical.

According to current ethical standards for human research, a participant’s full and informed consent must be obtained before the start of an experiment, the participant’s health and well-being must be safeguarded, and the participant must be informed about their rights and permitted to withdraw whenever they choose to do so.

  • Milgram did not actually obtain informed consent from his participants.

  • Milgram used deception; participants were intentionally misinformed about what the experiment actually involved.

  • There were also other deceptions after the participants had agreed to take part in the experiment. 





    Status and Power in Groups 

    • A group is comprised of 2 or more people who interact over a period of time, have an influence on each other, and share a common goal.

    • A person is said to have power if they can influence the behaviour or thoughts of another person.

    • A person’s status is their position within the group.

    • A role is the behaviour adopted by an individual or assigned to them that influences the way in which they function or act in different situations in life. A role comes with expectations of how to behave in various situations. 


    Type of Power 

    Source of Power 

    Example 

    Reward

    Ability to give positive consequences or remove negative consequences in response to specific behaviour.

    An employer has the power to give a pay rise or promotion; a teacher can reward students with grades, praise and privileges (and dismiss a student early from detention).

    Coercive 

    Ability to give negative consequences or remove positive consequences in response to specific behaviour.

    An employer can dismiss an employee; a teacher can give detention, or not allow a student to attend a school excursion or function.

    Legitimate 

    An individual’s status or position in a group, institution or society in general gives them the right (authority) to exercise power over those with a lower status or with less authority.

    A group leader, manager, captain of a team, classroom teacher, or police officer. 

    Referent 

    Individuals identify with or want to be like or liked by this person.

    A celebrity you want to be like or a friend who you want to be liked by. 

    Expert 

    Having special knowledge and skills that are desirable or needed. 

    A classroom teacher perceived as knowledgeable in their subject, a supervisor of a workplace trainee or new employee. 

    Informational 

    Having resources or information that are useful and are not available elsewhere. 

    Someone who knows exactly what needs to be done to meet an important team goal within a strict deadline; someone who has had a specific experience that someone else wants to know about. 



    SPE: Participant and Methods 

    Ethical concerns 

    The Stanford prison experiment provides valuable insights into the effects of status and power on individual behaviour. The experiment also raises important ethical issues and has been criticised by many psychologists on ethical grounds. 



    BBCP Study 



    Details about the BBC Prison Study 

    Aim

    To investigate how groups behave when power and status are unequal, and whether people always conform to assigned roles of dominance or submission 

    Sample

    15 male - 9 prisoners and 6 guards

    Method

    Prison was a purpose-designed environment filmed by the BBC. Researchers did not take part as authority figures. Strict ethical and safety checks by an independent committee. 

    The study was stopped 1 day early.

    Guards are given resources to maintain order, but instructions not to use aggression.
    Prisoners had fewer privileges but could communicate and organise collectively. 

    Ethics

    Approved by an independent ethics committee; participants were monitored, debriefed, and supported. They would withdraw freely at any time. The study was broadcast, but psychological welfare took priority. 

    Results 

    Guards didn't identify with their roles and didn't unify as a group. Prisoners shared a common group identity and gained power over the guards. 


    What did we learn about identity and roles?

    • Just because you are assigned a role does not mean you will identify with it. 

    • You need to identify (agree) with it (a buy-in). 


    What are the consequences of taking a common group identity?

    • When a common group identity forms, it will take over or consume the group that doesn't have a group identity. 

    • A shared identity can lead to solidarity, empowerment, and collective action. 

    • A common group (prisoners) can oppose threats (guards).

    What happens if groups fail? What happens in relation to tyranny?

    • When a group fails, there remains a power vacuum, and there is always another group to fill the vacuum. 

    • There is always another group or person to fill the power vacuum. 

    • Tyranny is more likely to happen when groups lose a shared purpose. 


    What do we learn about the ethical context of behaviour? 

    • You cannot test a lot of these things anymore without violating ethical concerns. 

    • If you are following all of the ethical concerns, are you really doing the experiment properly? 

      • Is it worth it to potentially hard your participants for the results that you could get?

    • Can alter behaviour in experimental settings. 


Deindiviualisation 

A group can sometimes have a negative influence on the thoughts, feelings and behaviour of its members. 


Deindividuation is the loss of individuality, or the sense of anonymity, that can occur in a group situation. 

  • In a group, some people shed their inhibitions and conform to the mob mentality 



Two factors about deindividuation 

  • Anonymity in a group

    • No identity 

  • Shift in attention 



Abu Ghraib Prison 

Prisoners from the Iraq war were being held by American soldiers, and photos got leaked of American soldiers emmaberising/dehumanising and torturing their prisoners. The acts that were committed were inhumane and cruel (most were convicted and went to jail). 

  • Predjucdiec 

  • Discrimination

  • Group dynamics

  • Power 

  • Deindividualisation