Global. Consumption & Exploitation part 2

Overview of the Pamphlet on Slavery

  • Discussion focuses on a primary source text about slavery from the late 1700s.

  • Originally produced in Philadelphia, likely by a Quaker community.

  • Significant anti-slavery activism during this period, especially among Pennsylvania Quakers.

  • The text circulated specifically in the Rhode Island colony.

Historical Context of Rhode Island

  • Rhode Island during this time was still a part of the British Empire and not yet an independent state.

  • Slavery was legal in Rhode Island, as in all colonies of British America.

  • Rhode Island's economy was heavily invested in the slave trade due to a large merchant shipping fleet.

  • Notable slave trading families, including the Brown family, were influential, with connections to establishments like Brown University.

Content of the Pamphlet

  • Aimed at slaveholders and financiers of the slave trade in Rhode Island.

  • The author critiques the societal treatment of enslaved individuals, contending:

    • The contempt for enslaved people leads white children to view black individuals as comparable to domestic animals.

    • This systemic thinking fosters long-term prejudice, embedding the notion that African descendants are lesser beings in society.

Critique of Prejudice and Justice

  • The pamphlet argues that societal prejudice against black individuals is entrenched:

    • "…creatures have always looked upon so vastly below themselves can stand on the same footing…"

    • The text emphasizes the moral obligation of society to treat everyone equally under the concept of a universal father.

    • Conveys that profound prejudices not only affect public perception but hinder the acceptance of justice.

Socioeconomic Landscape of Slavery in Rhode Island

  • Mid-18th century, Rhode Island had the highest proportion of enslaved persons to white persons among northern colonies.

  • State’s economy relied heavily on maritime slave trade operations.

  • Laws governing slavery in Rhode Island were among the most brutal.

Gradual Emancipation Following Independence

  • Post-independence (after 1784), Rhode Island began a gradual emancipation process, unlike states that pursued immediate abolition.

  • Even decades later, individuals remained enslaved.

  • The pamphlet continues to influence anti-slavery discourse for years beyond its publication.

Philosophical Arguments Against Slavery

  • The author presents a critical view on the moral credibility of slave ownership:

    • Ownership of slaves implicates individuals in the original sin of slavery even if not directly involved in the capture.

    • "…impossible for anyone of their own seeking and choice to be concerned in slave keeping or partake of the profits without incurring a degree of the original guilt."

    • All descendants of enslaved individuals are inextricably linked to the historical injustices of slavery.

Inheritance of Slave Status

  • The text raises ethical questions concerning enslavement based on lineage:

    • The pamphlet argues against the notion that children of enslaved people should inherit the status of slavery.

    • Compares this to societal norms, which do not punish children for parents' crimes.

    • Cites specific historical examples, including children born of Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings, highlighting moral inconsistencies in maintaining the status quo.

Anti-slavery Stance and Legacy

  • The pamphlet serves as a religiously-based treatise challenging the immorality of slavery.

  • It critiques the notion of inheriting slave status, bolstering arguments against slavery's permanence in societal structure.

  • Anticipates the evolving national discourse and conflict surrounding slavery over the next several decades, culminating in the U.S. Civil War.

Role of Consumption in the Slave Trade

  • Connects to previous discussions about global consumption, particularly the sugar trade, to illustrate the interconnectedness of economic activities and their impact on slavery.

  • Asserts that anyone benefiting economically from slavery, whether directly or indirectly, shares responsibility for the injustices perpetrated.

  • "There are no innocent bystanders in this world."

Conclusions on Abolition Movements

  • The text captures the divisiveness within early America regarding slavery, setting the stage for future debates and conflicts.

  • Describes events, including riots and violence related to slavery discussions, indicating deep societal rifts within what would become the United States.