Lecture 4 - Primate Evolution

K/T impact

  • cataclysmic event ~65 mya

    • separated Mesozoic and Cenozoic eras

    • caused mass extinction of terrestrial dinosaurs

    • survivors: reptiles, amphibians, birds, mammals

    • age of angiosperms and mammals

      • angiosperms → herbivores → carnivores

  • primates appeared 60-90mya

  • first protoprimates were similar to shrews in appearance and size

    • not a lot of fossil evidence, but some from N. America suggests arboreal adaptation

  • climate and climate change were important in which animals adapted and went extinct


fossil primates

  • found in every continent except Australia and Antarctica (mostly in tropics)

  • climate changes limited extent of habitats

  • highly successful and adaptive order

  • current range is not as far up north and south (e.g. no longer in N. Amer, N. Africa, Europe, southern tip of S. Amer), because climate has changed


primate fossil traits

  • forward-facing eyes

  • postorbital bar/closure

  • large cranial vault

  • reduced snout

  • versatile dentition

  • divergent big toes and thumbs

  • grasping hands and feet

  • nails on fingers and toes

  • 3 main hypotheses for rise of primate and selection of features

    • arboreal hypothesis: unique primate traits rose as adaptation to living in trees

      • selective pressures led to early primate traits

    • visual predation hypothesis: unique primate traits rose as adaptation to preying on insects and small mammals

      • visual acuity and fine motor skills led to primates

    • angiosperm radiation hypothesis: certain primates (e.g. visual acuity) occurred in response to availability of fruit and flowers following the spread of angiosperms

      • primates co-evolved with fruiting, flowering plants; symbiotic adaptations

    • likely that it is a combination of all three hypotheses


the cenozoic era

  • paleocene: ~65-54mya

    • had plesiadapiforms: first primate-like insectivores

    • increased global warming, spread tropical conditions and forests

      • great for primates and other mammals

  • eocene: 54-34mya

    • had first euprimates (true primates)

    • worldwide warming trend (evergreen tropical forests), then cooling

    • plesiadapiforms went extinct

    • new forms adapted and radiated

  • oligocene: 34-23mya

    • first monkeys

  • miocene: 23-5mya

    • first apes

  • pliocene: 5-1.8mya

    • first hominins

  • pleistocene: 1.8mya-12kya

  • holocene: 12kya-now


paleocene proprimates

  • plesiadapiforms: early primate-like mammals; proprimates

  • lived

  • lack full primate characteristics

    • no postorbital bar

    • rodent-like dentition and diastema

    • very small brain

    • claws, not nails (most)

    • lack opposability or flexible joints

  • e.g. Purgatorius: believed to be the close to last common ancestor of plesiadapiforms and primates


Eocene euprimates

  • 200+ known spp, 55-34mya

  • traits:

    • postorbital bar

    • convergent eye orbits

    • long digits, opposability

    • nails !!

      • big distinction btwn them and plesiadapiforms

    • 2.1.4.3 dental formula (extra premolar)

    • non-specialized teeth

      • can eat lots of different kinds of foods

    • larger brain:body size

    • 2-15lb

      • ~housecat size

    • possibly sexually dimorphic, males slightly larger

  • adapids: larger, likely ancestral to modern lemurs and lorises

    • diurnal, folivorous, frugivorous, insectivorous

    • from N. Amer, Europe, Asia, Africa

    • lemur-like

      • but no toothcomb (most) or other modern strepsirrhine traits

    • complete post-orbital bar

    • larger, rounder braincase

    • nails

    • binocular vision

    • possible missing link

    • Ida: a Darwinius masillae

      • most famous adapiform

      • ~47mya in Germany

      • 95% complete

      • ~2’ long

      • juvenile female

      • opposability, grasping

      • nails, no grooming claw

      • no dental comb

      • possible transitional form/missing link leading to strepsirrhines

  • omomyids: smaller, likely ancestor to modern tarsiers and possibly haplorhines

    • small, nocturnal, probably frugivorous

    • Asia, Europe, N. Africa

    • very large eyes, majority of their face

    • tarsier-like

    • complete postorbital bar

    • shape of teeth: heavily insectivorous, likely many fruits as well


Archicebus achilles

  • oldest fossil haplorhine found so far

  • eocene

  • genus of small primate found in China

  • mosaic of haplorrhine and strepsirrhine features

  • small bodied (1oz)

  • supports hypothesis that primates originated in Asia, not Africa


Eosimias

  • genus of fossil primates

  • dates to eocene

  • lots of haplorrhine features

  • “dawn monkey” in latin → early monkey or monkey-like primate

  • calceneus similar to haplorhines than to strepsirrhines

    • supports origin in Asia

  • oldest are smallest, found in China


eocene haplorhines

  • Beretia fayumensis

    • early haplorrhine

    • eocene

    • Fayum depression, Eypt

    • shows some features that may suggest Asian origin, contradicts African origin of eocene haplorhines

      • African descendant from Asia?

        • possibly migrated to Africa through a land corridor


eocene primates

  • parapithecids

    • eocene-oligocene, ~33mya

    • small bodied (2-3oz)

    • 2.1.3.3 like NW monkeys (platyrrhines)

    • folivores, likely

  • propliopithecids

    • eocene-oligocene, ~30mya

    • bigger (up to 6 kg)

    • 2.1.2.3 like OW monkeys (catarrhine, like ours)

    • frugivores

    • sexually dimorphic


global cooling

  • eocene-oligocene transition to global cooling

    • grande coupure: the big cut (36mya)

    • forested areas turned to grasslands

    • primates became limited in habitat

      • many primates went extinct


catarrhine and platyrrhine origins

  • molecular data sugest divergence 30-40mya

  • eocene-oligocene

    • catarrhine primates in Africa and Arabia

    • 2.1.2.3 dental formula

    • signals that platyrrhines and catarrhines already diverged

  • oligocene

    • platyrrhine primates in South America

    • 2.1.3.3 (extra premolar)

    • did they come from Africa, Asia, or North America?

    • African origin is more parsimonious


oligocene primates

  • Aegyptopithecus

    • catarrhine ancestor

    • 33-35 mya

    • Fayum, Egypt

    • arboreal quadruped

    • ~15lb

    • 2.1.2.3

    • post-orbital closure

    • sagittal crest

    • sexual dimorphism

    • believed that closest living behavioral analog is howler monkey

  • Branisella

    • ancestor to platyrrhines?

    • most fossil platyrrhines don’t resemble living platyrrhines

    • Bolivia, late oligocene (~26mya)

    • second oldest South American primate fossil discovered

    • either a stem platyrrhine not related to any living form, or very primitive callitrichid or tamarin

    • 2.1.3.3


platyrrhine origins

  • how did platyrrhine primates get to the new world? It was an island

    • molecular data suggest divergence btwn catarrhine (OW) and platyrrhine (NW) monkeys 30-40mya

  • hypothesis 1: ancestors migrated south from North America → evolved into platyrrhine spp of oligocene

    • doesn’t make sense, there were none in N. America, it was too cold and they had gone extinct

  • hypothesis 2: after originating in Africa, ancestors migrated across Atlantic Ocean to South America

    • natural rafts of accumulated vegetation across Atlantic

    • shallow areas of ocean, dotted with islands

    • today: reports of large floating islands with trees up to 30 ft.

      • iguanas got to Fiji this way

      • how Madagascar was colonized by animals

        • carnivores, lemurs, rodents, etc

    • aka the rafting hypothesis

    • most reasonable

  • hypothesis 3: African ancestors migrated from South Africa, across Antarctica, eventually reaching South America

    • don’t think it would’ve happened, Antarctice is too cold

  • hypothesis 4: platyrrhines and catarrhines had independent origins, evolved independently


global cooling continued

  • miocene continued to cool the climate

    • tropical forests replaced with drier grasslands

    • ice caps grow in Antarctica

      • ocean levels dropped

    • fossil apes appear


miocene

  • first apes and diversification of OW monkeys

  • early miocene

    • diverse number of apes

    • fewer monkeys

  • mid/late miocene

    • few apes

    • diverse number of monkeys

    • like now

  • by end of miocene, most apes are extinct


miocene monkeys

  • cercopithecoid catarrhines appear in early miocene

    • mix of ancestral and derived traits

    • bilophodont molars

    • earliest: Victoriapithecus and Prohylobates

      • Victoriapithecus:

        • late miocene primates from Africa

        • ancestral to OW monkeys

        • a basal cercopithecoid

        • skeletons show early adaptation to ground and tree living

        • Kenya

        • ~6-11 lb

        • very small brain

        • ~25mya

        • likely ancestral to modern macaques

  • middle miocene cercopithecoids almost disappear


late miocene monkeys

  • ~14mya, cercoopithecids have diverged → cercopithecines and colobine monkeys

    • African and Asian colobines diverged by ~10mya

  • cercopithecines (cheek-pouch monkeys) likely have African origin

    • Macaca libyca, 5-6mya, Fayum

    • Theropithecus, 4-1mya, Africa

    • Papio, 3.7mya

  • colobines (leaf-eating monkeys), today mainly in Asia, few in Africa

    • Mesopithecus, 8-9mya, Europe and Asia


miocene apes

  • first true apes during the miocene

  • African forms (23-14mya)

    • western Kenya

    • Proconsul, Morotopithecus

      • Proconsul: best known genus of early miocene ape

        • Kenya, Uganda, east Africa

        • ape-like dental formula, monkey-like skeleton

        • chimp-sized

        • no tail

        • opposable thumb

        • frugivorous

        • basal ape catarrhine?

        • suggested to live in forests and arid grasslands

        • likely more monkey-like in motion, pronograde

  • European forms (16-11mya)

    • France, Spain, Greece, Italy, Germany, Hungary

    • Dryopithecus, Ouranopithecus

      • Dryopithecus

        • mid-miocene

        • Hungary, France, Spain

        • many derived ape traits

        • chimp-sized

        • dentition similar to gorillas: Y5 molars, low round cusps, large canines and diastema, thin enamel

          • possibly ate soft leaves, fruit

        • brain size similar to chimp

        • limbs resemble brachiators, mobile shoulder joints

          • likely orthograde, characteristic of living apes

  • Asian forms (16-7mya)

    • India, Pakistan

    • Sivapithecus

      • mid to late miocene (~10-7mya)

      • India, Pakistan, Nepal, Turkey, China

      • largest Miocene ape

      • radiation of the fossil Asian apes

      • thick enameled teeth, robust jaw bones

    • Gigantopithecus

      • late miocene/plio-pleistocene (9-5mya)

      • bamboo forests of Asia

      • largest primate ~600+ lb

        • size limited it to terrestrial habitat

      • thick enameled teeth, large robust jaw

        • possible bamboo specialist

      • no postcranial bones

  • traits:

    • monkey-like body

    • smaller hands

    • restricted hip joint

    • more flexible spine

    • Y5 molars (in common)

    • equal limb length: movement on all fours

      • likely arboreal quadrupeds

    • limited wrist mobility

    • arboreal quadruped

  • modern great ape traits

    • highly mobile shoulder

    • fully extendable elbow

    • Y5 molars

    • high wrist mobility

    • brachiator anatomy

  • Afropithecus

    • Kenya, east Africa

    • cranially similar to Aegyptopithecus

    • body similar to Proconsul

    • ape-like dentition with thick enamel, possibly to eat nuts, seeds, barks


what about the apes?

  • European apes were extinct by 9mya

    • may have migrated south to Africa and east to Asia

  • by end of miocene, apes were almost extinct

    • very few spp survived

  • few fossil orangutans, practically no fossil African apes

  • chimp-human divergence by 8-10mya

  • first bipedal hominin ~6-7mya with Sahelanthropus

    • recently been disputed


early primate ecology

  • early miocene

    • Africa isolated from Eurasia

    • warm climate

    • ~5mya, Tethys Sea evaporated → land bridge btwn Africa and Eurasia

    • major adaptive radiations during middle miocene

      • Sivapithecus, Gigantopithecus, Dryapithecus, Oreopithecus

    • first cercopithecines, colobines: continue into Pliocene and Pleistocene

  • middle/late miocene

    • cooling trend

    • wooded, less forested environments

    • good for monkeys (cercopithecids), not good for apes (hominoids)

      • monkeys had smaller size, greater dietary breadth

    • OW monkeys radiate out → many monkeys, few apes


primate origins summary

  • paleocene (65-54mya)

    • early primate-like mammals, 60+mya

    • small-bodied, arboreal

  • eocene (54-34mya)

    • diversity of lemur-like forms across N. America and Eurasia

    • by late eocene, small primates with lemur-like and anthropoid features developed

      • early primates!

    • oligocene (34-23mya)

      • diversity of anthropoid primates

      • first fossil primates in S. America during late oligocene

  • miocene (23-5mya)

    • proliferation of apes over much of the OW

    • hominoid ancestors of large apes and humans appeared by 16mya, were widespread as recently as 8mya