mindes
Conceptual Framework of the Lawyer Image
Symbolic and Cultural Meaning of Social Positions
The symbolic meaning attributed to an identifiable social position constitutes a major structural force shaping its nature and consequences.
The legal system undergoes rapid, unexamined transformation characterized by expanding prison populations, swollen court dockets, evolving doctrinal bodies, growing professional ranks, and shifting social attitudes and institutions.
Many structural shifts originate within the internal dynamics of the legal profession. Controlling these developments requires understanding the symbolic forces shaping professional life.
Occupation as Central Identity and Living History
Occupation serves as a central organizing identity in modern society, especially within professions demarcated by specialized training, rigorous entry procedures, distinct skills, behavioral styles, and shared frames of reference.
Members of the legal bar carry a living history consisting of habits, outlooks, expectations, and cognitive patterns. This living history shapes individual and collective behavior through metaphors, person-images, concrete visual/tactile representations, and defined human types.
As expressed in professional subculture, legal work permeates personal existence; practicing the law is an inescapable state of being that defines member identity continuously.
Reciprocal Social Expectations
Symbolic metaphors of the profession are owned collectively by society as a whole.
Living history defines both lawyer behavior and lay behavior toward lawyers. The client role—lacking formal training—is derived from this shared history.
Roles, institutions, and processes maintain symbiotic relationships where lawyers and society continuously define, shape, and confirm each other through reciprocal expectation, perception, and conduct.
The Three Archetypal Images Defined
The symbolic structure of the legal profession comprises three distinct social types or archetypes: the Hero, the Trickster, and the Helper.
The Hero:
Described by adjectives: aggressive, self-confident, competitive, energetic, successful, and looked up to (along with active and intelligent).
Represents the champion or defender of worthy causes, principles, organizations, or individuals.
Takes initiative in struggles against adversaries, expecting victory through intelligent effort and self-belief.
Combines honor with toughness and non-sentimentality; fulfills a need for primary significance, sustained by vicarious community support.
The Trickster (or Shyster):
Described by adjectives: tricky, evasive, manipulative, overbearing, greedy, and cold (along with intimidating, unethical, egotistical, and condescending).
Operates through guile, cleverness, and sneakiness to advance personal financial interests and client objectives at the expense of others.
Does not fight openly or fairly; exhibits deceit, bluffing, shifting loyalties, weak ethics, and a cynical, angry stance.
Embodies socially suppressed impulses of rebellion, destruction, and naughtiness enjoyed vicariously by the public.
The Helper:
Described by adjectives: helpful, likable, cooperative, broadminded, understanding, and informal (along with accommodating and fair).
Characterized by honorable, kind, optimistic, and nonjudgmental loyalty to clients.
Sacrifices personal self-interest for clients, acting as an unselfish, friendly support system focused on fairness and conflict avoidance.
Development and Methodology of the Three-Image Theory
Background Preliminary Research (1974–1978)
Initial exploratory research began in 1974–1975 in a professional responsibility course at a Chicago law school, originally designed to improve student interviewing skills.
Students administered schedules of 30 balanced adjectives depicting human traits on a 5-point scale measuring the perceived proportion of lawyers possessing each trait:
Open-ended items inquired: "Which adjectives particularly apply to lawyers?" and "Who becomes a lawyer?"
The adjective list was refined across successive nonrandom convenience interview samples:
1975–1976 sample size:
1976–1977 sample size:
Interview locations included public transportation stations, airports, laundromats, and personal acquaintances.
Exploratory factor analyses using varimax rotation consistently yielded the same three independent factor constructs across successive years, proving that the three-image model was an empirical discovery rather than an a priori theoretical assumption.
In 1978, a sample of lawyers surveyed at a state bar meeting and through student interviews confirmed that lawyers shared the exact three-factor structure held by the lay public.
The 1980 Southwestern Community Study Design
A rigorous empirical test was conducted in 1980 in a medium-sized southwestern metropolitan area using 18 target adjectives representing the three images.
Four distinct data sets were collected using two parallel random sampling procedures:
Public Perception of Lawyers: Telephone survey conducted in February–March 1980 using random digit dialing (; response rate ). Measure: 5-point scale on proportion of lawyers having each trait.
Lawyers' Perception of Lawyers: Questionnaire survey distributed in April–June 1980 to a random sample drawn from Martindale-Hubbell and a local bar directory (; response rate out of net sample ). Measure: 5-point scale on proportion of lawyers having each trait.
Lawyers' Estimate of Public Perception: Administered within the same lawyer questionnaire. Measure: predicted lay public response on the same 5-point scale.
Lawyers' Self-Perception: Administered within the same lawyer questionnaire. Measure: self-rating accuracy scale (, , , , ).
Attitude Measurement and Survey Validation
Both public and lawyer instruments contained 20 general attitude statements scored on a 5-point agreement scale ( to ).
Four items replicated national baseline data from the American Bar Foundation study The Legal Needs of the Public (Curran, 1977):
"Lawyers don't really try to understand what their clients want": Agree ( national), Disagree ( national), Don't Know ( national).
"Most lawyers charge more for their services than they are worth": Agree ( national), Disagree ( national), Don't Know ( national).
"Most lawyers would engage in unethical or illegal activities to help a client in an important case": Agree ( national), Disagree ( national), Don't Know ( national).
"If you, yourself, were accused of a crime, you could expect to get a fair trial": Agree ( national), Disagree ( national), Don't Know ( national).
Two-tailed chi-square tests confirmed no statistically significant difference () between the local public sample and national baseline data.
An 11-item internal scale extracted from the attitude items produced a reliable pro-lawyer attitude index.
Sociological Context and Comparative Literature
General Sociological Foundations
Emile Durkheim: Defined shared social images as "collective representations" that maintain or alter social order.
Georg Simmel: Analyzed social types (e.g., the stranger, miser, spendthrift, adventurer, poor) as functional structural positions.
Max Weber: Constructed "ideal types" (e.g., the Protestant ethic character) to explain historical socio-economic developments.
Robert E. Park: Conceptualized social types as specific occupational characters and originated the concept of the "marginal man."
Ruth Benedict: Extended typology to whole cultures organized around dominant personalized principles.
Cooley and Mead: Explored internal role-taking via the looking-glass self and social interactionism.
Erving Goffman: Analyzed how favorable and unfavorable stereotypes impose identity constraints on stigmatized and non-stigmatized roles.
Occupational Sociology: Everett Hughes noted that work subcultures shape personality; David Riesman identified the "coercion of images"; Donald Super highlighted self-concept in vocational entry; Theodore Caplow demonstrated that occupational stereotypes serve as primary agents conditioning role behavior.
Historical Continuity of the Lawyer Image
Historical documentation demonstrates a constant blend of legal distinction and popular hostility across centuries:
New Testament: Luke 11:52 ("Woe unto you, lawyers!").
14th-Century England: Arthur Bryant noted that lawyers were the most hated legal enforcers.
16th-Century England: Shakespeare's King Henry VI, Part 2 ("The first thing we do, let's kill all the lawyers").
Colonial and Revolutionary America: Benjamin Franklin's writings and general anti-lawyer sentiments coexisted with high occupational prestige (Tyree & Smith).
Empirical Typologies in Legal Literature
Divorce Practitioners (Hubert J. O'Gorman, 1963):
Study of New York City divorce lawyers identified three distinct role orientations based on professional satisfactions:
Problem-oriented (): Focused on trial combat, dramatic competition, and technical legal puzzles (Hero analog).
People-oriented (): Derived satisfaction from personal relationships and helping clients in distress (Helper analog).
Money-oriented (): Focused candidly on financial gain and client fees (Trickster analog).
Supreme Court Advocates (Jonathan D. Casper, 1972):
Study of lawyers arguing Warren Court civil liberties/rights cases (1957–1966) revealed three role concepts:
Civil Libertarian: Viewed cases as vehicles for advancing general societal democratic principles (Hero analog).
Group Advocate: Committed to representing specific ideological, racial, or ethnic client groups (Helper analog).
Advocate: Focused strictly on winning individual cases using any tactical stratagem regardless of broader ramifications (Trickster analog).
Urban vs. Rural Bar Stratification:
Urban studies (Carlin, 1962, 1966; Ladinsky, 1963; Heinz & Laumann, 1978) document extreme stratification:
Elite corporate firm attorneys handling high-prestige, lucrative corporate matters reflect the Hero image.
Solo and small-firm practitioners handling lower-prestige individual/minor criminal matters reflect the Trickster/Pettifogger image.
Non-urban studies (Landon, 1981; Wells, 1964; Handler, 1967) show that rural practitioners exhibit non-specialized practice, personal client counseling, and community intimacy based on friendship and altruism, reflecting the Helper image.
Comparative Analysis of Survey Responses across Four Viewpoints
Rank Order and Means of Adjective Profiles
Adjective | Public Perception of Lawyers (Mean / Rank) | Lawyers' Perception of Lawyers (Mean / Rank) | Lawyers' Estimate of Public View (Mean / Rank) | Lawyers' Self-Perception (Mean / Rank) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Self-confident | / 1 | / 2 | / 4 | / 5 |
Competitive | / 2 | / 1 | / 2 | / 7 |
Aggressive | / 3 | / 7 | / 3 | / 9 |
Successful | / 4 | / 10 | / 1 | / 11 |
Energetic | / 5 | / 6 | / 10 | / 6 |
Helpful | / 6 | / 3 | / 14 | / 1 |
Cooperative | / 7 | / 4 | / 16 | / 3 |
Understanding | / 8 | / 8 | / 17 | / 2 |
Likable | / 9 | / 5 | / 15 | / 8 |
Manipulative | / 10 | / 13 | / 8 | / 13 |
Broadminded | / 11 | / 9 | / 13 | / 4 |
Looked up to | / 12 | / 11 | / 12 | / 12 |
Tricky | / 13 | / 17 | / 6 | / 18 |
Evasive | / 14 | / 14 | / 7 | / 14 |
Greedy | / 15 | / 15 | / 5 | / 15 |
Overbearing | / 16 | / 16 | / 9 | / 16 |
Informal | / 17 | / 12 | / 18 | / 10 |
Cold | / 18 | / 18 | / 11 | / 17 |
Key Empirical Patterns across Response Sets
The Public View: Rates lawyers highest on Hero attributes (self-confident, competitive, aggressive, successful, energetic), intermediate on Helper attributes (helpful, cooperative, understanding, likable), and lowest on Trickster attributes (tricky, evasive, greedy, overbearing, cold).
Lawyers' Perception of Lawyers: Rates the bar as significantly less aggressive ( vs. ) and successful ( vs. ) than the public does, but substantially more helpful (), cooperative (), likable (), and broadminded ().
Lawyers' Estimate of Lay View (The Perceptual Discrepancy):
Lawyers predict a drastically hostile public view that does not exist in reality.
Lawyers assume the public ranks successful as #1 () and projects severe Trickster traits into top public rankings: greedy (#5, ), tricky (#6, ), evasive (#7, ), manipulative (#8, ), and overbearing (#9, ).
Lawyers incorrectly believe the public views lawyers as severely lacking Helper traits: helpful (#14, ), cooperative (#16, ), understanding (#17, ), and likable (#15, ).
Lawyers' Self-Perception: Highly idealized self-image dominated by Helper characteristics (helpful , understanding , cooperative , broadminded ) and strongly rejecting Trickster characteristics (tricky , cold , overbearing ).
Statistical Validation via Factor Analysis (EFAP & LISREL IV)
Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFAP)
Preliminary Exploratory Factor Analysis for Categorical Data (EFAP) confirmed that three factors accounted for between (lawyers' self-description) and (lawyers' estimate of public view) of the variance across response sets.
The adjective informal failed to load sufficiently on any factor construct and was excluded from subsequent structural models.
Confirmatory Factor Analysis (LISREL IV)
Confirmatory factor analysis using LISREL IV tested the fit of the three-factor model across all four response sets simultaneously.
The overall model demonstrated exceptionally high statistical fit: Chi-square , goodness-of-fit index ( of total adjective covariance explained).
LISREL IV Factor Loadings Across Response Sets
Factor & Adjective | Public Perception of Lawyers | Lawyers' Est. of Public View | Lawyers' Perception of Lawyers | Lawyers' Perception of Self |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Trickster Dimension | ||||
Greedy | ||||
Tricky | ||||
Evasive | ||||
Overbearing | ||||
Cold | ||||
Manipulative | ||||
Hero Dimension | ||||
Self-confident | ||||
Aggressive | ||||
Successful | ||||
Competitive | ||||
Looked up to | ||||
Energetic | ||||
Helper Dimension | ||||
Helpful | ||||
Broadminded | ||||
Likable | ||||
Cooperative | ||||
Understanding |
Structural Variations in Factor Definition
Trickster Structure: Highly consistent across sets. In self-ratings, manipulative () and tricky () define the core of the self-perceived Trickster construct.
Hero Structure: The public defines the Hero strictly in terms of posture and action (self-confident , competitive ), whereas successful has a factor loading of (outcomes do not define the Hero for the lay public). For lawyers viewing other lawyers, outcomes dominate the Hero factor (successful , looked up to ).
Helper Structure: Represents a robust, highly unified construct across public perception, lawyer estimation of public, and lawyer view of the bar (), but exhibits lower conceptual unity in lawyers' self-ratings ().
Interfactor Pearson Correlations ()
Data Set | Trickster & Helper | Hero & Trickster | Hero & Helper |
|---|---|---|---|
Public's Perception of Lawyers | |||
Lawyers' Est. of Public View | (N.S.) | ||
Lawyers' Perception of Lawyers | |||
Lawyers' Perception of Self |
Analysis of Interfactor Relationships
Public views Hero as compatible with both Trickster () and Helper ().
Lawyers evaluating fellow lawyers view Helper and Hero as highly compatible (), while Hero and Trickster are strongly mutually exclusive ().
Lawyers estimating public views make a major cognitive error: they assume the public sees Hero and Helper as completely unrelated (), failing to realize that the public views Heroes as helpful.
Scale Means and Pro-Lawyer Attitude Correlations
Adjusted Image Scale Means:
Public: Trickster , Hero , Helper
Lawyers' Est. of Public: Trickster , Hero , Helper
Lawyers' View of Lawyers: Trickster , Hero , Helper
Lawyers' Self-Perception: Trickster , Hero , Helper
Across-set range: Hero exhibits the lowest variance (), proving it is the stable core identity of the profession.
Correlations with 11-Item Pro-Lawyer Attitude Index:
Public View: Trickster (); Helper (); Hero (Not Significant).
Lawyers' Est. of Public: Trickster (); Helper (); Hero (Not Significant).
Lawyers' View of Lawyers: Trickster (); Helper (); Hero ().
Lawyers' Self-Perception: Trickster (N.S.); Helper (N.S.); Hero ().
Finding: The Hero image is morally neutral for the lay public (); favorability toward lawyers depends entirely on high Helper and low Trickster ratings.
Psychological, Identity, and Professional Ethics Implications
The Perceptual Discrepancy and Group Paranoia
Lawyers operate under a severe misperception, believing the lay public holds an intensely hostile, antilawyer Trickster stereotype.
This misperception cannot be explained by survey lying or selective communication alone. It reflects group paranoia, exaggerated suspicion of outsiders, and self-rejection characteristic of minority status dynamics.
The Legal Practitioner as a "Marginal Man"
Applying Robert E. Park's concept, the lawyer acts as a marginal character participating in two distinct cultural traditions (the legal subculture and the general public) without being fully integrated into either.
Lawyers experience undiscussed normative conflicts, maintaining a professional facade that separates legal truths from general lay morality.
Intraprofessional cohesion is reinforced by external perceived hostility, prompting lawyers to seek solidarity within the bar while distancing themselves from lay judgment.
Impact on Lawyer-Client Relationships
Prentice-Hall Missouri Bar Study Comparison:
Dissatisfied clients cited lawyer attitude—"superior, bored, indifferent" (#1), rude, impatient, brusque—as their primary grievance.
Lawyers mistakenly believed clients cared only about instrumental outcomes (results, efficiency, money, honesty), completely failing to recognize client demand for interpersonal Helper qualities.
Client Control and Reality Negotiation (Hosticka, 1979):
Lawyers routinely suppress client expressions of feeling and non-legal facts, reshaping client problems into standardized legal categories.
Lawyers act based on generalized case assumptions formed prior to meeting clients, using client-control tactics to protect their professional perspective.
Role-Centered Morality and Paternalism:
Believing clients expect them to be Tricksters frees lawyers to adopt amoral, hostile, or manipulative behaviors, shifting moral responsibility onto the client or the adversary process.
Lawyers redefine potentially deceptive tactics as legitimate, professional, and protective of client interests, creating a self-fulfilling dynamic of mutual distrust.
Sociocultural, Mythic, and Systemic Foundations
The Adversary System as a Symbolic Driver
The adversary trial model serves as the primary role framework for American legal identity.
Operational conflict relies on credible threat capacity (). To make threats credible, a lawyer must appear tough, aggressive, unyielding, willing to cause harm, and unconcerned with being liked.
The adversary framework requires viewing opposing parties as hostile, justifying aggressive tactics and generating an escalatory process ().
Applying adversary assumptions to non-adversarial contexts (e.g., contract negotiation, counseling, corporate advice) leads to defensive drafting, heightened interpersonal conflict, and escalated costs.
Archetypal and Mythological Origins
The Nuclear Family Triad: The three images mirror the basic nuclear family structure: Father (Hero), Mother (Helper), and Child/Son (Trickster). Robin Fox traces this to primate social structures: dominant males, nurturing females with offspring, and peripheral rebellious young males.
Mythic Manifestations:
Hero: Universal mythic archetype of the noble warrior/champion (Joseph Campbell).
Helper: The nurturing Great Mother / White Goddess archetype (Neumann, Graves).
Trickster: Universal mythic figure of guile, theft, rebellion, and boundary-crossing, represented by Hermes, Loki, and Satan (Radin, Henderson, Brown, de Vries, Russell, Ricoeur).
Social Typologies (Orrin Klapp):
Fits Klapp's categorization of American social types into "heroes, villains, and fools."
Maps onto the "clever hero" archetype (e.g., Robin Hood, Jesse James, Will Rogers) combining trickery with noble ends.
Gender and Role Stereotyping
Hero traits overlap directly with traditional male gender stereotypes; Helper traits align with female gender stereotypes.
The Trickster displays "protest masculinity"—a sharp rejection of nurturing behavior.
Although legal demographics have shifted, the symbolic culture of the law retains strongly masculine archetypal traits.
Institutional Status of the Images
Hero: Consensual, dominant identity required for professional self-esteem, but vulnerable to deflation.
Trickster: Dominates public criticism and regulatory reform focus (e.g., ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct draft revisions aimed at curbing Trickster behavior).
Helper: Systematically devalued and marginalized within law schools and firm reward structures. Interpersonal, non-adversarial counseling skills are frequently dismissed as un-lawyerlike, despite high client demand for these traits.
Empirical Demographics and Methodology Appendices
Public Survey Demographics ()
Gender: Male, Female.
Age Distribution: 18–24 (), 25–34 (), 35–49 (), 50–64 (), 65+ ().
Race / Ethnicity: White (), Black (), American Indian (), Mexican-American (), Other ().
Education: Grammar school (), Some high school (), High school graduate (), Some college (), College graduate or higher ().
Family Income: Under $10,000 (), $10,000–$14,999 (), $15,000–$19,999 (), $20,000–$24,999 (), $25,000+ ().
Lawyer Utilization: Never used a lawyer ( / ), Used once ( / ), Used more than once ( / ).
Client Satisfaction Rating of Own Lawyer: Excellent (), Good (), Adequate (), Fair (), Poor ().
Bar Survey Demographics and Response ()
Sampling and Response Rate:
Initial sample drawn: (Local Bar Directory = , Martindale-Hubbell = ).
Excluded / Not reached: () [Dead/sick = 4, Moved = 16, Not found = 21].
Net valid sample: ().
Refusals: (); Unreturned questionnaires: ().
Total completed responses: ( response rate).
Gender and Age: Male, Female. Mean age = (range 24–81; under 30, over 60).
Race and Religion: White (), Black ( / ), Mexican-American ( / ), American Indian ( / ), Oriental ( / ). Protestant (), Catholic (), Jewish (), Other (), No preference ().
Political Orientation: Highly conservative (), Somewhat conservative (), Neither (), Somewhat liberal (), Highly liberal ().
Type of Practice: Law firm ( / ), Solo practice ( / ), Judge / Government / Corporate / Other legal ( / ), Not currently practicing ().
Law School Attended: In-state public university ( / ), Local private university ( / ), Other state/local ( / ), Major regional ( / ), 2nd/3rd rank ( / ), National-rank ( / ).
Bar Association Membership: held American Bar Association membership.