Law and Legal Reasoning – Study Notes
Sources and Nature of American Law
Law is a body of enforceable rules governing relationships among individuals and between individuals and society. It determines what counts as a legally acceptable behavior and provides remedies when rights are violated. In business, many different laws can affect a single decision (e.g., a Facebook-related decision).
What businessmen or accountants should know: enough about the law to know when to seek advice.
Constitutional Law
Constitutions set forth fundamental rights of people in the United States or in a state.
They describe and empower government branches (legislative, executive, judicial).
They prescribe limitations on government power.
Statutory Law
Statutes and ordinances enacted by Congress, state legislatures, and local governing bodies.
Courts interpret statutes to determine what lawmakers meant and how to apply the law to facts.
A given statute may be based on a uniform law.
Uniform laws are created by expert panels and scholars and can be adopted by state legislatures.
The largest uniform act is the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), adopted broadly in the states except Louisiana.
Louisiana retains much of the Napoleonic code from its historical ties to France.
The Uniform Laws are overseen by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform Laws.
The UCC affects sales, leases, and negotiable instruments (e.g., checks, promissory notes).
In advanced business law courses, you study the UCC’s effect on these areas.
The Model Business Corporation Act is another uniform act used as a template for state corporation laws.
Administrative Law
Administrative law consists of rules, orders, and decisions of administrative agencies.
Federal administrative agencies fall into two categories:
Executive agencies: within cabinet departments; officers serve at the president’s pleasure who can appoint and remove them.
Independent agencies: created by Congress; officers serve fixed terms and can only be removed for cause, not at the president’s whim.
State agencies often parallel federal agencies in areas of regulation.
Administrative law also includes agency rules and procedures that implement statutes.
Case Law and the Common Law Tradition
Common law consists of rules announced in court decisions and interpretations of constitutional provisions, statutes, and regulations.
The common law tradition is judge-made law that evolves through decisions.
Independent federal regulatory agencies (not part of the cabinet) include agencies like the EEOC and OSHA.
The common law system can also interpret and enforce relationships not covered by statutes, administrative rules, or regulations.
Common Law vs. Statutes and Administrative Rules; Subsumption by Statutes
Much of common law today has been subsumed under statutes and regulations written by Congress and state legislatures and by administrative agencies.
Court decisions interpret and apply those rules.
There are still areas governed by common law (e.g., parts of contract law not governed by the UCC).
The American law tradition is summarized by the Restatements of the Law (American Law Institute): they do not have the force of law but are important secondary sources judges rely on.
Judges apply law to cases, and their decisions reflect their judicial philosophies.
Judicial Philosophies (Major Schools)
Natural law: universal moral/ethical principles inherent in human nature; law should reflect these principles.
Post-World War II, Nuremberg trials used natural law concepts to condemn crimes against humanity; defendants argued they were following German law, but natural law deemed the acts criminal.
Martin Luther King Jr. invoked natural law in opposing segregation.
Legal positivism: law is the written law of a society at a given time; morality is separate from law.
Nazis at Nuremberg could argue they acted under German positive law; morality is not the same as the legal rule.
Historical school: emphasizes earlier legal principles and writings; values from the past guide current law.
Legal realism: judges’ decisions are influenced by personal beliefs and case-specific circumstances; laws serve social justice and are tools to promote it.
These philosophies influence how judges interpret precedents and apply the law; liberal judges may emphasize natural law or realism, conservative judges may emphasize positivism or historical sources.
Classifications of Law (Brief Summary)
Substantive law vs. procedural law
Substantive law defines, describes, regulates, and creates legal rights and duties.
Procedural law provides rules for enforcing those rights.
Federal vs. state; private vs. public distinctions
Civil law vs. criminal law
Civil law: regulates relationships between persons (and between persons and governments) and the relief available when rights are violated.
Criminal law: regulates relationships between individuals and society; prescribes punishments for specified acts.
International law as a distinct category (not elaborated in detail here).
How to Find and Understand the Sources of Law (Statutory and Beyond)
Federal statutory law:
After passage, statutes are reported in uncodified form and then become part of larger codifications.
Uncodified statutes: reported in the Statutes at Large.
State uncodified statutes: reported as session laws.
Codified statutes: organized by subject in the United States Code (U.S.C.); e.g., is the Internal Revenue Code.
State statutory law: codified in the state code.
Administrative law:
Federal rules and regulations appear in the Federal Register as they are promulgated and then compiled in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), organized by subject matter.
State administrative law is reported in each state's administrative code (varies by state; Florida has an administrative code similar to the CFR).
Court decisions (case law): sources of law decided by courts.
Court Reporters and Case Terminology
State court decisions:
Highest court decisions and often intermediate appellate courts are published in official reporters.
Regional reporters (West Publishing’s National Reporter System) compile decisions from multiple states or regions.
Federal court law:
United States Supreme Court opinions are published in the official reporter, the United States Reports.
Unofficial reporters include the Supreme Court Reporter and the Lawyer’s Edition (often abbreviated as L. Ed. or L. Ed. 2d).
Appellate decisions are in the Federal Reporter (with series such as F., F.2d, F.3d).
District court opinions appear in the Federal Supplement (F. Supp., F. Supp. 2d).
Bankruptcy decisions appear in the Bankruptcy Reporter (BR).
Civil and criminal procedure decisions can appear in the Federal Rules Decisions (FRD) reports.
Common abbreviations and reporters you will encounter:
US Reports (official Supreme Court reporter)
Supreme Court Reporter (S. Ct. Reporter, unofficial)
Lawyer’s Edition (L. Ed., L. Ed. 2d)
Federal Reporter (F., F.2d, F.3d)
Federal Supplement (F. Supp., F. Supp. 2d)
BR (Bankruptcy Reports)
FRD (Federal Rules Decisions)
Party terminology in court actions:
Plaintiff or petitioner: the party who filed the action in the lower court.
Defendant or respondent: the party against whom the action is brought.
Appellant: the party seeking review in an appellate court.
Appellee: the party opposing the appeal.
Judgment: the court’s disposition or decision in favor of one party.
Opinion: the court’s reasoning behind the judgment.
Forms of opinions:
Unanimous: all judges agree.
Per curiam (per Curiam): a unanimous opinion without naming a specific author.
Majority: opinion joined by the majority of judges.
Plurality: opinion by the largest group, but not a majority.
The FIRAC Method for Legal Reasoning
FIRAC stands for: Facts, Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion.
In exams, you’ll be given facts and asked to apply the law:
Facts: determine the relevant facts.
Issue: identify the legal question.
Rule: state the governing law (statutes, precedents, constitutional provisions).
Application: apply the rule to the facts.
Conclusion: reach a conclusion based on the analysis.
The FIRAC approach helps ensure a structured, logical answer and is commonly required in course problems.
Note: Sometimes there may be no single right answer; judges determine the most appropriate outcome.
The Bottom Line on Precedent and Stare Decisis
Stare decisis: doctrine requiring courts to follow established precedent within a jurisdiction.
Binding authority: sources of law a court must follow (e.g., constitutions, statutes, treaties, regulations, or controlling prior decisions within the jurisdiction).
Persuasive authority: primary or secondary sources that a court may consider but is not obliged to follow (e.g., decisions from other jurisdictions, scholarly writings, or non-controlling authorities).
Precedent can last a long time. Example from the textbook discussion:
A 1973 Supreme Court decision relied on a precedent from 1875, illustrating long-lasting controlling authority (the Spiderman case is a textbook example mentioned).
Supreme Court precedents remain controlling until overridden by a subsequent Supreme Court decision, a constitutional amendment, or congressional legislation.
The doctrine of stare decisis contributes to predictable, quick, and fair resolution of cases and stability in the application of law.
The Supreme Court may depart from precedent when decisions are wrongly decided, contrary to public policy, or outdated due to changes in technology, society, or business practices (Brown v. Board of Education, , overruled Plessy v. Ferguson).
When there is no clear precedent, a judge may look to prior case law, underlying principles and policies behind statutory enactments, broader societal values, and data from other disciplines (e.g., sociology) to interpret the law.
The Concept of Legal Reasoning and the Sources of Law
Legal reasoning is the process judges use to decide which law applies and to apply it to the facts.
In today’s world, most common law has been subsumed in statutes and rules written by Congress, state legislatures, and administrative agencies; court decisions interpret those rules.
A few areas are still governed by common law (judge-made law), notably some contract principles not fully covered by the UCC; these will be studied later in the course.
The Restatements of the Law summarize common-law principles, but they are not binding law; they are important secondary sources.
Judges’ decisions reflect their judicial philosophies, and decisions often show elements of more than one philosophy.
Legal reasoning tests in courses frequently employ FIRAC to organize and present analysis
Notable Historical Examples and Illustrations
Nuremberg Trials (post-WWII): natural law used to condemn crimes against humanity; defendants claimed they were acting under German law.
Martin Luther King Jr.: used natural law concepts to oppose segregation.
Brown v. Board of Education (1954): overruled the long-standing Plessy v. Ferguson decision establishing “separate but equal.”
Quick Connections and Real-World Relevance
Understanding the sources of law helps business professionals know where to look for rules that govern transactions, contracts, and regulatory compliance.
The distinction between binding and persuasive authorities helps determine how to argue a point in court and how to evaluate legal arguments from other jurisdictions or sources.
Knowledge of FIRAC improves exam performance by providing a clear, test-ready method for applying law to facts.
Recognizing different judicial philosophies can illuminate why a particular decision aligns with or diverges from prior cases or broader policy goals.
Practical and Ethical Implications
The use of equity vs. law (remedies like specific performance, injunctions) reflects judgments about fairness and practicality in enforcing rights.
Equity maxims (e.g., "Whoever seeks equity must do equity" and "Clean hands") emphasize ethical conduct when seeking court relief.
The possibility of departing from precedent raises questions about stability vs. adaptability in law—how to balance predictability with evolving social norms and technologies.
The influence of multiple sources (statutes, regulations, case law, restatements) requires practitioners to harmonize rules across different domains to avoid conflicts and ensure compliance.
Key Formulas and Notation to Remember
FIRAC:
Codified statute example:
Federal administrative process: Federal Register → Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)
Court reporters shorthand (examples): US Reports, Supreme Court Reporter, Lawyer’s Edition, Federal Reporter (F., F.2d, F.3d), Federal Supplement (F. Supp., F. Supp. 2d), BR, FRD
Important years mentioned: , , ,