Understanding Interdisciplinary Studies in the Real World
Foundations and Overview of Interdisciplinary Studies
Publishing and Text Context:
- SAGE Publishing was founded in by Sara Miller McCune to support the dissemination of usable knowledge and educate a global community.
- SAGE publishes over journals and more than new books each year across a wide range of subject areas.
- SAGE's expanding library portfolio includes archives, data, case studies, and video content.
- SAGE remains majority-owned by its founder and will transition post-lifetime to a charitable trust to secure long-term organizational independence.
- Introduction to Interdisciplinary Studies (Third Edition) is authored by Allen F. Repko (University of Texas at Arlington, Retired), Rick Szostak (University of Alberta, Canada), and Michelle Phillips Buchberger (Miami University of Ohio).
- Dedicated to spouses, children, and grandchildren.
- Text Epigraph: "The greatest force in the world is an idea whose time has come."
Part I Architecture: Understanding Interdisciplinary Studies:
- Focuses on interdisciplinary studies (IDS) as a diverse, dynamic, and growing field spanning core chapters.
- Explains the drivers behind the field's steady advance and offers an integrated definition of the concept.
- Examines intellectual capacities, values, traits, and skills fostered by interdisciplinary learning.
- Traces the rise of modern disciplines and the parallel emergence of interdisciplinary studies.
- Identifies defining elements of disciplines, characterizing them as epistemic, social, and organizational communities.
- Analyzes the concept of disciplinary perspective and examines the underlying "DNA" of IDS in terms of assumptions, theories, epistemology, and perspectives.
Core Objectives, Outcomes, and Guiding Questions
Overall Objectives of Interdisciplinary Learning:
- Spark interest in interdisciplinary studies and illustrate its real-world significance.
- Provide a practical, time-tested framework to address the inherent complexity of real-world and workplace problems.
- Demonstrate why interdisciplinarity is basic to modern education, research, professional practice, and innovation.
- Connect interdisciplinary skill acquisition directly to long-term career development.
Specific Learning Outcomes:
- Demonstrate an understanding of why interdisciplinary studies is basic to education, problem solving, professional practice, and innovation.
- Describe the primary drivers of interdisciplinary studies today.
- Identify and describe new and emerging interdisciplinary fields of study and their broader significance.
- Explain why systems thinking and contextual thinking are increasingly recognized as vital cognitive capacities.
- Explain why a modern knowledge society requires both disciplinary specialization and interdisciplinary breadth.
- Detail the specific academic benefits of pursuing an interdisciplinary studies degree.
- Explain the direct relevance of interdisciplinary studies to career development and adaptability.
Core Guiding Questions:
- Why is interdisciplinarity increasingly recognized as important across academic and professional domains?
- What is the value of an interdisciplinary education, particularly regarding personal educational goals?
- What is the precise relationship between specialized disciplines and interdisciplinarity?
- What kinds of complex questions do interdisciplinary scholars actively engage?
The Driving Forces of Interdisciplinary Studies
Purpose of Higher Education and Century Skill Demands:
- Education enables individuals to make a meaningful contribution to society across multiple domains: educating children, becoming responsible workers/citizens, protecting the environment, combating poverty, reducing crime and violence, creating art, discovering disease cures, developing technologies, starting businesses, improving public policy, and promoting peace, justice, and security.
- Navigating century complexities requires specific high-level skills: making connections across domains, understanding diverse perspectives, solving complex problems, leading teams, engaging in strategic thinking, communicating effectively, applying analytical thinking, and working collaboratively.
The Six Key Drivers:
- . The complexity of nature, society, and ourselves.
- . The complexity of the globalized workplace.
- . The need for systems thinking and contextual thinking.
- . The changing nature of university research.
- . The public world and its pressing needs.
- . A knowledge society's dual need for disciplinarity and interdisciplinarity.
Drivers 1 & 2: Complexity of Nature, Society, and the Globalized Workplace
Driver 1: The Complexity of Nature, Society, and Ourselves:
- Nature, human society, and individual psychology are complex systems.
- A subject or problem is classified as complex when its multiple constituent parts require study by different disciplines.
- Disciplines in isolation fail to study the critical interactions among these parts.
- Case Study: Illegal Immigration:
- Immigrant's home country: Analyzed by history, sociology, and cultural anthropology.
- Geographic proximity to destination country: Analyzed by Earth science.
- Legal and immigration policies of destination country: Analyzed by political science.
- Economic opportunity: Analyzed by economics.
- Isolated disciplinary study fails to explain the root causes or full effects; an interdisciplinary approach treats illegal immigration as a complex system of interacting parts, critically analyzes disciplinary insights, builds common ground, and produces a comprehensive understanding or holistic solution.
- Research Example: Electronic Medical Records (EMRs):
- Research by Razmak and Bélanger () investigated why EMRs were adopted more slowly in North America than in Europe.
- Identified interacting variables across disciplines: psychological resistance among medical staff, managerial challenges, complex political decision-making, financial constraints, and software application flaws.
- Concluded that only interdisciplinary research can resolve such complex problems in business and healthcare management.
Driver 2: The Complexity of the Globalized Workplace:
- Effective workplace communication requires sensitivity to diverse cultures in a world with a human population reaching , straining finite resources.
- The global economy has undergone radical structural change (That Used to Be Us by Thomas Friedman and Michael Mandelbaum, ).
- Fundamental Workplace Restructuring (Box 1.1):
- The merger of globalization and the IT revolution at the turn of the century altered every job, industry, service, and hierarchical institution.
- Raised required skill levels to obtain and retain employment while intensifying global competition for jobs.
- Made politics transparent, interconnected the world, made authoritarian structures vulnerable, and empowered individuals and small groups.
- Educational systems historically produced specialists trained in a single academic area; Michelle Phillips Buchberger (quoted by Tejaswi, ) notes that IDS provides a cognitive process where individuals or groups integrate insights from all relevant disciplines to gain a holistic understanding of complex problems.
- Profile of the Modern Knowledge Worker:
- Must understand, use, and integrate knowledge, technology, and methods.
- Must collaborate with people from diverse cultural and disciplinary backgrounds.
- Must work with intangible information to generate tangible products, requiring cross-domain teamwork.
- Example: Apple iPhone App Design: Demands integration of software coding, art, mathematics, gaming design, English grammar, marketing, legal frameworks, database management, finance, and interpersonal communication.
- Integrative Skills in Management (Box 1.2):
- Jan Rivkin (, Harvard Business School Strategy Unit) emphasizes that integrative skills allow managers to spot innovative strategies, understand cross-departmental implications, and build out ideas across an organization's value chain.
- Example: Information system updates in retail directly affect store location decisions, store manager autonomy, pricing policy, and vendor relations.
Driver 3: Systems Thinking, Contextual Thinking, and Academic Structure
Systems Thinking Defined and Applied:
- Systems thinking is the ability to break a problem down into its constituent parts to reveal internal and external influences, determine how parts relate to each other and the whole, and identify which disciplines address specific components.
- Critical for assessing daily systems (environment, economy, transportation) and formulating effective public policy.
- Macroeconomic System Example: U.S. Federal Reserve Rate Cuts:
- Lowering the prime interest rate reduces loan costs (car loans), stimulating sales and automotive manufacturing, leading to potential hiring increases.
- Concurrently, lower rates reduce bank interest paid on savings, diminishing fixed interest income relied upon by retirees.
- Produces international political impacts: Foreign creditors (e.g., China) holding U.S. national debt may reduce further debt purchases due to lower yields.
- Determining the ideal central bank interest rate requires input from political science (government policy, international relations), economics (consumer behavior), philosophy (ethics, logic), and history (historical patterns).
Contextual Thinking and Liberal Education:
- Contextual thinking is the ability to view a subject from a broad perspective by placing it in the fabric of time, culture, or personal experience.
- Characterized by wholeness, relationships between parts, and the premise that knowledge evolves over time (King & Kitchener, ).
- The Silo Perspective (Figure 1.1): Specialized discipline majors risk developing a narrow view of reality, seeing the university and world solely through a single major's lens.
- Integrative Perspective (Figure 1.2): Connects specific elements to the whole system using multiple disciplinary lenses.
- Liberal Education Role: Fosters systems and contextual thinking, cultivating "integrative arts" (Schneider, ) to teach students how to learn, integrate conflicting viewpoints, apply theory to practice, and solve problems collaboratively (Huber, Hutchings, & Gale, ).
The Structure and Nature of the Academy (Box 1.3):
- Modern universities are organized around autonomous, discipline-based departments controlling hiring and curriculum.
- Universities lack an overarching master strategy for knowledge synthesis; university leadership typically lacks a map of cross-departmental theories, methods, and subjects.
- General education programs often require courses across disciplines without teaching connection-making, inadvertently reinforcing narrow disciplinary focus or leaving students frustrated by expert disagreements.
- Interdisciplinary education transforms frustration into engagement by demonstrating that expert disagreement stems from differing disciplinary assumptions and providing tools to evaluate and integrate conflicting insights.
Driver 4: Changing Nature of University Research and Interdisciplinary Borderlands
Advocacy from Scientific Leadership:
- Rita Colwell (, former Director of the National Science Foundation / NSF): Interdisciplinary connections are fundamental because scientific excitement is most intense at interdisciplinary interfaces.
- Mark C. Taylor (Columbia University; Baskin, ): Interdisciplinary research is both scientifically and economically essential; hyper-specialized graduates face employment hurdles due to unsustainable departmental hierarchies.
- Myron P. Gutmann (, NSF Official & University of Michigan Professor): Promoted interdisciplinary research across campuses to secure competitive federal grants, citing breakthroughs in atomic-scale health applications and extreme weather analysis combining physical and social variables.
Interdisciplinary Social and Health Science Initiatives:
- NSF Social, Behavioral, and Economic Sciences Directorate (Box 1.4): Houses crosscutting programs combining economists, political scientists, sociologists, psychologists, linguists, neuroscientists, and anthropologists to address coastal flood responses, aging populations, and military behavioral insights.
- National Institutes of Health Interdisciplinary Research Program (Box 1.5): Aims to dissolve departmental boundaries, promote inter-institutional cooperation, train scientists in team science, and bridge biological sciences with behavioral and social sciences.
National Landscape of Interdisciplinary Majors (Table 1.1):
- Social Science Research Council (SSRC, ) survey of academic institutions (analyzed by Klein, ) identified top interdisciplinary majors:
- Environmental studies and science: of institutions
- Women's and gender studies: of institutions
- Neuroscience and psychobiology: of institutions
- American studies: of institutions
- Biochemistry and molecular biology: of institutions
- Asian and East Asian studies: of institutions
- International relations: of institutions
- African American and Africana studies: of institutions
- Latin American studies: of institutions
- Intercultural studies: of institutions
- Analysis: Over half focus on global/area studies; three utilize a biology-plus framework; popular majors align with advocacy/activism fields. Two-thirds of institutions surveyed intended to expand interdisciplinary offerings over years due to research demands.
- Interdisciplinary Borderlands: Significant scientific advances occur at the boundaries where established disciplines overlap (Cooke & Hilton, ).
Drivers 5 & 6: Public Needs, Transdisciplinarity, and Knowledge Society Balance
Driver 5: The Public World and Its Pressing Needs:
- Modern society relies on science and technology for food, water, energy, transport, and jobs, but technical solutions frequently generate secondary problems (National Academy of Sciences, , Box 1.6):
- Greenhouse gas emissions Global warming.
- Synthetic fertilizer applications Water pollution.
- Nuclear energy production Radioactive waste management.
- Automobile transport Traffic fatalities, urban sprawl, air pollution.
- Public interest policy challenges—such as animal/plant genetic modification, higher education affordability as a civic right, populist political movements, and income inequality—require multi-disciplinary evaluation.
- Interdisciplinary analysis evaluates policy alternatives dispassionately, synthesizing constructive components without demonizing opposing viewpoints.
Transdisciplinarity and Community Engagement:
- Stakeholder: A person or entity outside academia holding an interest or material stake in a societal issue.
- Transdisciplinarity: Research initiatives that explicitly integrate non-academic stakeholders alongside university researchers.
- Community Development (Butterfield & Korazim-Korosy, ): Addresses local issues (homelessness, gang violence, affordable housing, green space, public transit, local arts) through dual integration: integrating across academic disciplines and integrating academic expertise with community stakeholders.
- Integrative Studies Programs (Hughes, Munoz, & Tanner, , Box 1.7): Bridge classroom coursework with student residence life, volunteer initiatives, and community service learning.
Driver 6: A Knowledge Society Needs Both Disciplinarity and Interdisciplinarity:
- Disciplinarity and interdisciplinarity are complementary, not mutually exclusive (Frodeman & Mitcham, ).
- Specialized disciplines provide shared terminology, methods, and theories for efficient communication, but ignore non-conforming perspectives. Interdisciplinarity integrates these specialized insights.
- Knowledge Society: An economy where knowledge creation and application serve as the primary engine for economic growth and social empowerment.
- Knowledge Production vs. Utilization Disconnect (Box 1.9):
- Sheer information volume overwhelms individual and institutional decision-making; public leaders call for more research to delay policy decisions.
- Specialized disciplines crowd out awareness of ultimate ends or societal goals.
- Disciplinary vertical depth (specialization) lacks superior epistemological justification over horizontal breadth (understanding the overall landscape of human affairs; e.g., evaluating a PhD versus an individual holding three master's degrees).
Intellectual Capacities, Successful Intelligence, and Ethical Analysis
Components of Successful Intelligence (Robert J. Sternberg, ):
- Successful intelligence requires maintaining a balance across three distinct thinking modes:
- . Creative Intelligence: Formulates original ideas and connects concepts. Fosters cognitive tools including observing, imaging, abstracting, pattern recognition, pattern formation, analogizing, empathizing, modeling, transforming, and integrating.
- . Analytical Intelligence: Deconstructs problems into components, solves structural problems, and evaluates idea quality.
- . Practical Intelligence: Applies ideas effectively in business, policy, or daily life.
Integrative Thinking and the Interdisciplinary Mind:
- Integrative Thinking: The cognitive ability to synthesize information from diverse sources to create a comprehensive understanding or new meaning.
- Howard Gardner () Five Minds for the Future: Identifies the synthesizing/interdisciplinary mind as essential for modern society.
- Cross-Functional Team Dynamics (Box 1.8): Medical teams (surgeons, anesthesiologists, radiologists, nurses, therapists, social workers) and corporate teams (inventors, designers, marketers, sales, management) cross disciplinary silos to generate breakthroughs.
- Career Adaptability: Andrew Ross () states that fixed lifetime employment patterns no longer exist, requiring graduates to possess flexible cognitive skills across changing careers.
Ethical Analysis in Interdisciplinary Inquiry:
- Interdisciplinary analysis applies to descriptive questions (how the world functions) and normative/ethical questions (how the world ought to function and how people should act).
- Addressing century public policy amid cultural diversity requires establishing consensus on normative goals as well as descriptive mechanics.
Academic Benefits and Personal Identity Integration
Four Practical Reasons for Interdisciplinary Recognition:
- . Equips scholars to formulate and answer complex questions transcending individual disciplines.
- . Places complex issues in broad contexts that challenge existing societal values (e.g., balancing environmental sustainability with individual liberties).
- . Provides an explicit methodology to integrate specialized disciplinary insights into a coherent understanding.
- . Empowers students across five operational domains:
- a. Dealing with complex societal/civic problems through empathy and ethical awareness.
- b. Translating academic knowledge to new contexts, problems, and environments.
- c. Analyzing complex issues without being intimidated by specialized disciplinary experts.
- d. Locating and evaluating information reliability in an era of data overload.
- e. Constructing a holistic understanding of personal identity.
Empirical Assessment Data:
- University of North Dakota Assessment (Carmichael & LaPierre, ): Demonstrates that interdisciplinary learning communities significantly enhance student academic achievement, engagement, skill attainment, and degree completion rates.
- Self-Directed Learning (Van der Lecq, ): Shows that interdisciplinary students become self-directed learners who actively seek breadth and evaluate multiple perspectives.
Personal Identity Integration (Box 1.10):
- Norfolk State University Introduction to Interdisciplinarity course utilizes intersectionality research (Crenshaw, ) in video projects.
- Personal identity intersects across race, class, gender, sexuality, family, government, economy, education, religion, and technology.
- Interdisciplinary methods help students integrate conflicting identity aspects into a cohesive self-understanding.
Career Development, Employer-Desired Skills, and Graduate Outcomes
Comparison of Top Employer-Rated Skills (Figure 1.3):
- Century Survey (): Oral Communications, Teamwork, Ethics/Social Responsibility, Professionalism, Reading Comprehension, Strong Work Ethic.
- NACE Survey (): Communications, Analytical Skills, Teamwork, Technical Skills.
- AMA Survey (): Communications, Collaboration/Teamwork, Critical Thinking/Problem Solving, Creativity/Innovation.
Three Highlighted Interdisciplinary Career Skills:
- . Communication:
- Ability to communicate across disciplinary boundaries by identifying shared underlying concepts, theories, and methods despite varying specialized jargon.
- Ability to communicate productively with colleagues and clients holding conflicting viewpoints.
- . Creative Problem Solving:
- Combining disparate perspectives and unrelated ideas to construct novel and useful solutions (Szostak, ).
- . Analytical Thinking:
- Evaluating idea quality and blending analytical rigor with intuitive creativity (Sternberg, ); vital for competitive technology companies like Apple, Google, and Facebook.
Empirical Graduate Survey Data (West Virginia University, ):
- Survey of interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary program graduates yielded employed respondents ( employment rate).
- Career Sector Breakdown:
- in customer-facing business sectors (sales, real estate).
- in core corporate operations (human resources).
- in education.
- in health care.
- in government service.
- in other specialized careers.
- Overall degree satisfaction reached and showed consistency across all employment sectors.
Threaded Practical Example: Interdisciplinary Analysis of Basic Income
Concept Definition:
- Basic income: A guaranteed minimum income provided unconditionally to every adult citizen in a society.
Ideological Perspectives:
- Political Left: Viewed as an direct policy tool to eradicate poverty.
- Political Right: Viewed as a streamlined replacement for overlapping social welfare bureaucracies that restores employment incentives.
- Skeptics: Question economic feasibility and social desirability.
Multi-Disciplinary Dimensions of Basic Income Analysis:
- Political Science: Examines administrative implementation and the political feasibility of consolidating multi-level government welfare programs into a single model.
- Economics: Calculates total fiscal output, required income distribution levels, and tax/program offset savings.
- Psychology and Sociology: Evaluates behavioral impacts on recipient work motivation, stress reduction, and household stability.
- Health Sciences: Measures prospective health outcome improvements resulting from baseline economic security.
- Social Work: Incorporates frontline field observation regarding recipient interactions and daily resource allocation.
- Ethical Analysis: Addresses normative questions regarding societal obligations to impoverished members, expectations of labor participation, and fair distribution benchmarks.
Critical Thinking and Practical Applications
Critical Thinking Prompts:
- . Assess how globalization alters personal educational priorities and post-graduation preparation.
- . Evaluate why systems thinking, contextualization, perspective taking, integrative thinking, and ethical analysis are mandatory for complex problem solving.
- . Explain why cross-disciplinary connection-making drives scientific advance.
- . Analyze how humanities insights inform scientific policy issues such as genetic modification or special education funding.
- . Detail the mechanisms through which interdisciplinary study develops creative intelligence.
- . Identify generative technologies that resulted from integrating knowledge across distinct domains.
- . Explain why major research agencies (e.g., NSF) prioritize interdisciplinary methodologies in institutional grant allocations.
- . Evaluate how interdisciplinary perspectives improve public policy debates.
Practical Applications & Exercises:
- . Analyze academic strategies for navigating a career path defined by multiple job and career transitions.
- . Map external non-academic systems (e.g., transit, ecology) affecting daily routines.
- . Self-assess individual competencies across Sternberg's creative, analytical, and practical intelligence dimensions.
- . Identify critical interdisciplinary skills required for a target profession and frame these capabilities for job interviews.
- . Diagnose an unresolved workplace problem and outline an interdisciplinary resolution framework.
- . Predict changes in top interdisciplinary academic majors over a -year horizon based on current societal trends.
- . Map constituent elements of personal identity and identify challenges in achieving internal integration.