WEEK 3 PDF moore anatomy of a heroin problem

Editorial Board

Members:

  • Stuart H. Altman

  • Charles J. Hitch

  • Rudolph G. Penner

  • Worth Bateman

  • Matthew Holden, Jr.

  • Lyman W. Porter

  • Edward B. Berman

  • Herschel E. Kanter

  • A. Alan Post

  • John E. Brandl

  • Allen V. Kneese

  • Alice M. Rivlin

  • William A. Carlson

  • Robert A. Levine

  • Henry S. Rowen

  • William A. Cox

  • Frank S. Levy

  • Thomas C. Schelling

  • Otto A. Davis

  • Wilfred Lewis, Jr.

  • Gilbert Y. Steiner

  • Alvin W. Drake

  • Al M. Loeb

  • Donald E. Stokes

Policy Analysis Details

Title of the Volume: Policy AnalysisPublished: Quarterly by the University of California PressVolume: Two, Number Four, Fall 1976

Articles Overview

  1. Technical Success, Political Failure: The Incentive Pay Plan for California Job Agents

    • Authors: David Greenberg, Al Lipson, Bernard Rostker

    • Summary: This article examines the design and implementation of a performance-based incentive pay plan aimed at enhancing the productivity of California job agents, weighing its technical successes against political backlash and operational hurdles encountered during execution.

  2. Environmental Policy Conflicts: The Case of the German Federal Republic

    • Author: Arnold J. Meltsner

    • Summary: An analysis of the environmental policy struggles within West Germany, detailing the tension between economic interests and environmental protection, and how these conflicts shape legislative outcomes and public perceptions.

  3. Choice among Policy Instruments for Pollution Control

    • Author: Giandomenico Majone

    • Summary: This article discusses various policy instruments available for pollution control, analyzing their effectiveness and the trade-offs involved in choosing one instrument over another in the context of diminishing resources and increasing environmental concerns.

  4. Can We Learn from Experience? The Case of SSI

    • Author: Beryl A. Radin

    • Summary: This piece investigates the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program, evaluating how past missteps in policy design can inform future reforms and enhance the social safety net for vulnerable populations.

  5. The CAA Transition Task Force: How Bureaucracy Responded to a Change in Presidential Policy

    • Author: Richard W. White, Jr.

    • Summary: A critical overview of the response from the bureaucracy following a shift in presidential policy regarding the Clean Air Act (CAA), addressing adaptability, challenges, and the role of policy entrepreneurship in effectively implementing changes.

  6. Comment: An Outsider's View of the Task Force's Success

    • Author: Melvin B. Mogulof

    • Summary: A commentary providing an outsider's perspective on the achievements and shortcomings of the CAA Transition Task Force, exploring the implications these have for future policy implementations and bureaucratic responsiveness.

  7. Anatomy of the Heroin Problem: An Exercise in Problem Definition

    • Author: Mark H. Moore

    • Summary: This article elaborates on how the framing of the heroin issue affects policy responses, discussing the nuances of problem definition and its critical impact on solutions, including health interventions and law enforcement strategies.

  8. Teaching Analytical Thinking

    • Authors: Robert D. Behn and James W. Vaupel

    • Summary: A pedagogical exploration of methods for teaching analytical thinking skills crucial for effective public policy analysis, including practical examples and case studies that enhance critical reasoning capacities among students and practitioners.

Submission and Subscription Information

  • Submission: Manuscripts should be sent to Arnold J. Meltaner, POLICY ANALYSIS, Graduate School of Public Policy, University of California.

  • Subscription Rates:

    • U.S., Canada, Latin America:

      • $12.00 for one year

      • $21.60 for two years for individuals

      • $15.00 for one year and $27.00 for two years for institutions

      • $8.00 per year for students

      • $1.00 additional for subscribers elsewhere

      • Single copies $3.25.

Anatomy of the Heroin Problem Overview

Author: Mark H. MooreThesis: The definitions we apply to social problems significantly affect the policy choices we make, highlighting the importance of clarity in problem framing for effective policy development.

Considerations for Defining Problems

  • Attributes affecting utility and policy instrument effectiveness: A comprehensive evaluation of how specific attributes define the utility of various policies in addressing heroin use.

  • Policy instruments availability: Assessing the spectrum of policy responses available and their accessibility within the current administrative frameworks.

  • Causal variables influencing effectiveness: Identifying underlying variables that impact how effectively policies address the heroin epidemic.

Critical Perspectives on Heroin Policy Definitions

  • Narrow Definitions: Encouraging narrow definitions to avoid overlooking critical policy effects and ensuring comprehensive analysis.

  • Broad Definitions: Advocating for broader definitions to promote the evaluation of policy impacts across various dimensions, including public health and social equity.

  • Conflicting Objectives: Acknowledging the multifaceted objectives of heroin policies including health improvement, crime reduction, social reintegration, and cost control.

  • Historical Context: Discussing how entrenched slogans like 'law enforcement approach' versus 'medical approach' can constrain policy understanding and effectiveness.

Objectives of Government Policies on Heroin

  • Aims to improve user health, enhance autonomy, reduce crime, bolster societal morale, and lower public costs associated with heroin use.

Key Societal Factors Influencing Heroin Use

  • Consideration of various indicators such as mortality rates, economic independence, family dynamics, and overall quality of life which significantly influence heroin consumption patterns.

Policy Instrument Distinctions

  • Differentiating between policies targeting symptoms of heroin use versus those addressing root causes, and understanding the implications of both approaches in societal contexts.

Simplified Model for Strategic Objectives of Heroin Policy

  • Emphasis on core objectives: reducing the number of users and improving the overall condition of existing users through enhanced support systems.

Importance of considering numerous influences on user behavior

  • Recognizing the complexities of user behavior and lifestyle interactions, including systemic influences beyond drug consumption.

Table Overview of Heroin Problem Attributes

  • Examination of attributes such as mortality rates, health issues, economic independence, user dignity, and societal crime impacts, recognizing the intricate dynamics between these factors and user behavior.

Conclusion

  • The critical need for precise definitions in developing effective policy agendas, which encourages a holistic approach to analyzing and addressing the multifaceted problem of heroin use.