Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Theory Revision: Moving Culture From the Macro Into the Micro - Notes

Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Theory

Abstract

  • Bronfenbrenner's bioecological theory is widely known in human development.

  • The notion of culture within the macrosystem is problematic as it is considered separate from everyday practices and microsystems.

  • Reconceptualization of Bronfenbrenner's model by placing culture as part of proximal development processes.

  • Culture defines and organizes microsystems, becoming part of central human development processes.

  • Culture is an evolving system of daily practices in social communities and their interpretation through language.

  • Diversity is integral to a child’s microsystems, leading to culturally defined developmental processes and outcomes.

Keywords

  • Cultural microsystems

  • Human development

  • Bronfenbrenner’s theory

Introduction

  • Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological theory is a well-known theoretical framework.

  • Despite its contributions, research within the framework has resulted in conceptual confusion and inadequate testing (Tudge et al., 2009).

  • The notion of culture is particularly problematic.

  • Major theoretical views challenge the bioecological theory’s stance on culture, suggesting culture is a product of human activity (Markus & Kitayama, 2009).

  • Culture is within everyday action and part of communities of practice through language.

  • Culture is also found in cognitive processes like intelligence and memory.

  • Bronfenbrenner’s model barely formally introduces culture, disguising it in the distal environment.

  • The theory raises questions about treating individual and cultural processes as separate entities (Rogoff, 2003).

  • Individual and larger contexts are conceived as existing separately in a hierarchical fashion.

  • This article unites Rogoff, Weisner, and Vygotsky’s sociocultural perspective to reconceptualize culture as part of proximal developmental processes.

  • A revision to the model is proposed where culture operationalizes microsystems, becoming part of the central processes of human development.

  • The diversity of human experience is emphasized in this new model.

  • The article will provide a historical overview of the role of culture in Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological theory.

  • It will present theoretical arguments from the Rogoff, Weisner, and Vygotsky perspectives.

  • Finally, it will present a revision to the model and empirical cross-cultural data.

Historical Overview of the Role of Culture in Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Paradigm

  • Two major periods in the development of Urie Bronfenbrenner’s theory: the 1970s and the 1990s.

  • First publication was in 1958, Bronfenbrenner was concerned with the state of research in developmental psychology.

  • Bronfenbrenner criticized the emphasis on experimental rigor instead of theory development.

  • Bronfenbrenner stated that developmental psychology is the science of strange behavior of children in strange situations with strange adults for brief periods of time (Bronfenbrenner, 1977, p. 513).

  • Bronfenbrenner developed ecological theory in the 1970s, influenced by Kurt Lewin’s approach to group dynamics.

  • Bronfenbrenner defined ecological theory as the study of human development in context or enduring environments (Bronfenbrenner, 1974).

  • The child’s ecology was the enduring environments in which the child lived, consisting of two concentric layers: the upper and the supportive and surrounding layers.

Upper Layer
  • The upper layer or the immediate settings (home, school, street, playground, etc.) had three dimensions: a physical, people & their roles, and activities & their social meanings.

Supportive Layer
  • The supportive layer was an adjacent one to the immediate encompassing system that determined what can or cannot occur in the immediate context (Bronfenbrenner, 1974).

  • It included the physical and geographical settings as well as institutional contexts (social systems).

  • The possibility of second-order effects interfering with the immediate context existed.

  • The second-order effect was defined as the effect of a third C in A and B (Bronfenbrenner, 1974).

  • Culture is implied in the form of social systems that are part of the supportive layer.

  • The supporting and surrounding layer limits and shapes what can and does occur within the immediate setting.

1977 Expansion
  • Bronfenbrenner’s further development of the theory in 1977 expanded the layer model into a more complex series of systems interdependent on each other.

  • The ecological environment became a nested arrangement of structures, each contained within the next.

  • The structures now were referred to as the microsystem, the mesosystem, the exosystem, and the macrosystem.

  • Culture is not defined on its own, but it is said to contain the macrosystems, as well as to be an ideological structure of the mesosystem (Bronfenbrenner, 1977).

  • Concepts associated with culture are part of various macrosystems, such as laws, rules, information, and ideology.

  • Another concept introduced is the blueprint, which is mentioned as part of the macrosystem.

  • The concept of blueprint is not further explained but could be assumed to be associated with how culture gets reproduced from one setting to another.

  • Culture for Bronfenbrenner is homogenizing rather than diversifying the human experience.

1990s Revision
  • The 1990s brought another set of important revisions in Bronfenbrenner’s theory, named the general ecological model or bioecological paradigm (Bronfenbrenner & Ceci, 1994).

  • The developments were summarized in two propositions.

  • He also introduced the process-person-context notion.

  • Along with highlighting proximal processes, revisions were made to some of the systems and a new one was added.

  • The one added was the chronosystem that alludes to changes or consistencies over time of the characteristics of the person and the environment (Bronfenbrenner, 1999).

  • In regard to investigating the impact of time as a proxy for the historical period on the proximal processes, studies would have to be longitudinal (Tudge et al., 2009).

  • Another important revision made was in the description of the microsystem.

  • It was said that it comprised patterns of activities in the immediate setting, but now some of the activities were described as involving interactions with symbolic features, that is, interactions with persons, objects, and symbols (Bronfenbrenner, 1995b).

  • He also states that “for reciprocal interaction to occur, the objects and symbols in the immediate environment must be of a kind that invites attention, exploration, manipulation, elaboration, and imagination” (Bronfenbrenner, 1999, p. 6).

  • Although there is further development of the role of social and interactional features of the microsystems, as well as objects and symbols, there is no tie to the notion of culture in these developments or with these concepts.

  • Culture does not appear in everyday practices or activities, since culture is somewhat theoretically divorced from its products (objects and symbols).

  • From its inceptions and throughout its revisions, Bronfenbrenner’s model lacks clarity of precision around the construct of culture.

  • Since the theory’s development, a proper in-depth definition of culture and an acknowledgment of its important role in human development have been lacking.

  • Culture has been situated in the macrosystem and said to play a role because of the interdependence of the systems.

  • But how these transactions operate and how culture is operationalized and measured remain invisible in these models.

  • No conceptual definition of culture has been elaborated.

  • Without a proper conceptual definition, research and interpretation in human development and culture are negatively affected.

  • The following sections will introduce Vygotskian and neo-Vygotskian approaches to the role of culture in development to challenge Bronfenbrenner’s approach, conceptually as well as methodologically.

  • The conceptual framework follows Mistry et al.’s (2016) conceptualization of culture as “generalizable ideologies and practices shared by groups, as well as, the meaning-making processes through which individuals interpret their environmental contexts by drawing on the shared ideologies available to them as members of groups” (p. 4).

  • Culture is both the process and the content of daily activity and is thus inseparable from all contexts where developmental processes and outcomes take place, especially in the microsystems.

Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory

  • Culture is a major concept in Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory.

  • Sociocultural theory is based on how culture mediates human experience and transforms human activity.

  • One of its fundamental premises is that the external use of culturally defined tools and signs is later internalized in higher psychological functions.

  • From this framework, culture is not a separate entity operating from a higher outside macro system, but culture is the system in which every human daily activity is realized and eventually internalized.

  • Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory originated following the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution in Russia.

  • Concepts such as tools, labor, and culture and history were drawn from within Marxist influence and reconceptualized to explain learning, development, and higher psychological functions.

  • Cultural forms of behavior arise during infancy: in particular in the use of tools and the development of human speech: “This alone places infancy at the center of the prehistory of cultural development” (Vygotsky, 1930–1934/1978, p. 34).

  • Development is, from the beginning, a culturally mediated process because the use of tools and human speech are culturally defined and acquired behaviors.

  • The acquisition of cultural forms of behavior implies also that interpsychological functions between members of a cultural group become intrapsychological.

  • This is expressed by the "general law of cultural development":

Everyfunctioninthechild’sculturaldevelopmentappearstwice:first,onthesociallevel,andlater,ontheindividuallevel;first,betweenpeople(interpsychological),andtheninsidethechild(intrapsychological).Thisappliesequallytovoluntaryattention,tologicalmemory,andtotheformationofconcepts.Allthehigherfunctionsoriginateasactualrelationsbetweenhumanindividuals.(Vygotsky,1930–1934/1978,p.48)Every function in the child’s cultural development appears twice: first, on the social level, and later, on the individual level; first, between people (interpsychological), and then inside the child (intrapsychological). This applies equally to voluntary attention, to logical memory, and to the formation of concepts. All the higher functions originate as actual relations between human individuals. (Vygotsky, 1930–1934/1978, p. 48)

  • Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory places culture in everyday activity because every form of human activity is a cultural form of behavior, developed and enacted in a defined cultural context and later internalized by the individual.

  • Vygotsky’s account of culture suggests “human mental functioning, even when carried out by an individual acting in isolation, is inherently social, or socio cultural, in that it incorporates socially evolved and socially organized tools” (Wertsch & Tulviste, 1992, p. 551).

  • It is also a notion closely related to semiotic mediation, understanding language as a system of signs inherent to developmental processes and outcomes (Wertsch & Tulviste, 1992).

  • Although Bronfenbrenner was influenced earlier by Vygotsky with the concept of reciprocal activity occurring in microsystems, as well as proximal processes (Wong, 2001), he did not consider Vygotsky’s more abstract formulations (Bronfenbrenner, 1995a).

  • Vygotsky’s perspective contrasts with Bronfenbrenner’s notion of culture as part of a remote macrosystem, whose involvement in human activity and settings is by means of interdependence between concentric circles.

  • The concept of interdependence comes from the discipline of dynamics in physics and was used by Kurt Lewin to explain the behavior of social forces in a field (Lewin, 1939).

  • Interdependence implies “dynamic properties,” “types of reactions,” and “types of influences” (Lewin, 1939).

  • In Bronfenbrenner’s theory, culture is an external influence because it belongs in the macrosystem.

  • Culture is a separate entity from the immediate settings.

  • The nature of interaction is seen in the patterns of the activities performed, which are said to be influenced by it.

  • Therein lies the fundamental conceptual difference between Bronfenbrenner and Vygotsky.

  • Bronfenbrenner’s use of the concept of interdependence simplifies the role of culture in development by situating culture as an external influence, whereas Vygotsky’s cultural mediation places it at the center of the microsystem because culture provides the means, activities, and meanings of every human activity within a particular social origin.

  • It is important to distinguish between Lewin’s influence on Bronfenbrenner and his influence on Vygotksy.

  • As Wong (2001) observes:

Lewin was highly valued by Vygotsky. . . . In “Tool and Symbol in Children’s Development,” Vygotsky (1930) adhered to the Lewinian distinction between phenotypic (description of external manifestation) and genotypic (explanation of origin or essence) viewpoints and declared his inclination to determine causal-dynamic relations in psychological analyses. But the Lewinian concept of “ life space” or “ total situation” did not fertilize the soil of the cultural-historical approach. (p. 367)

Lewin’s concepts adhere more to a geographical and physical analogy, while Vygotsky’s cultural mediation is a dialectic internalization of what once were external cultural signs and tools.The dialectic internalization implies that higher psychological functions are neither external or internal because the dialectics require a radical transformation that blurs any line across them.The external becomes an extension of internal psychological functions.Aside from fundamental limitations in the notion of culture in Bronfenbrenner’s theory, methodological questions have arisen too.If culture enters developmental research as an external factor from another system, its analysis is reduced to describing the interaction with other systems.As argued from Vygotsky’s perspective, culture is part of the articulation of the microsystems in the research process, because developmental changes imply “mastery of devices and means of cultural behavior and thinking” (Luria, 1930, cited by Wertsch & Tulviste, 1992).Through daily activities and practices, culture becomes the unit of analysis.Vygotsky’s perspective has influenced a lot of theorists.Contributions from this perspective contrast with Bronfenbrenner’s theory and situate the importance of considering culture and context as inseparable (Mistry et al., 2016).

Thomas Weisner: Ecocultural Theory

  • Thomas Weisner has contributed conceptual and empirical work from the perspective of the ecocultural theory in the topic of culture and developmental research.

  • From this theoretical perspective, the cultural community provides children with developmental pathways inside an ecocultural context (Weisner, 2002).

  • Developmental pathways are internalized (or crystallized) in everyday routines (bedtime, video games, homework, cooking dinner, etc.).

  • Culture is the routines we engage in.

  • According to Weisner, García Coll, and Chatman-Nelson (2010, p. 84), “developmental pathways refers to the different kinds of activities, organized by families and local communities, in which the child could or will engage during development.”

  • Although Bronfenbrenner’s perspective takes into consideration the importance of routines and activities on the microsystem, there is no clear reference to these actions as culturally defined or mediated.

  • Similar to Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory, the ecocultural perspective understands culture as not separated from the person and its interactions with the microsystem, but developing as habits in a cultural community.

  • Cultural pathways consists of activities we “step into” and move through life (Weisner, 2002).

  • According to Weisner, there are multiple behavioral and mental processes involved in the developmental attainment of culture (Weisner, 2015).

  • Some of them can be in conflict with cultural values and producing intrapsychic and cultural conflict (Weisner, 2009).

  • The mentality of an individual’s culture includes shared and idiosyncratic beliefs, practices, and experiences that can be at conflict and could lead to contradictory actions (Tonyan, Mamikonian-Zarpas, & Chien, 2013).

  • This phenomenon cannot be located in any of the systems of Bronfenbrenner’s theory, since it is the individual child or parent internalization or not of cultural scripts.

  • The individual becomes an actor in its own development and not a total passive recipient of culture.

  • Weisner’s theory recognizes the importance of the ecological and cultural environment where the process of development is taking place, headlining the relationship between individual processes and sociocontextual conditions that have an effect on the processes and outcomes (McWayne, Limlingan, Melzi, & Schick, 2016).

  • Because these processes are contextual, one has to determine where the person is developing, and what are the resources, practices, beliefs, goals, institutions, and so on in that cultural community.

  • Knowing the “developmental niche” the person is experiencing (Super & Harkness, 2002).

  • This concept makes sense with the model of cultural microsystems because it identifies the practices, narratives, and institutions, among others, in a cultural community that contribute to developmental processes and outcomes.

Barbara Rogoff: Transformation of Participation Perspective

  • Barbara Rogoff describes development as transformation of participation in sociocultural activities (Rogoff, 2003).

  • Her conceptualization of cultural processes in human development originates from Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory.

  • Rogoff places culture within “community routines” that provide guidelines “of engagement to cultural participation to build on in daily activities” (p. 2).

  • Cultural processes are not part of a hierarchical system that interacts indirectly with the individual.

  • Culture permeates all aspects of life (routines, habits, language) and therefore developmental outcomes and processes.

  • Culture mediates development and learning since the child begins the process of socialization (Correa-Chávez & Rogoff, 2005).

  • Learning processes are related to cultural practices that dictate the type of engagement the child will partake in the community.

  • Children are assigned to specific settings (day care, soccer practice) by their caregivers or other agents of socialization.

  • “These settings have important consequences on the development of habits of interpersonal behavior, consequences that may not be recognized by the socializers who make the assignments” (Whiting, 1980, p. 111).

  • Cultures differ in how they make these assignments and how these settings are organized in profound ways.

  • The intent community participation approach emphasizes the inclusion and engagement of children in productive community activities (Rogoff, Correa-Chávez, & Silva, 2009).

  • Children learn from listening and actively observing adults engaged in production activities.

  • This tradition attempts to carry out objectives by shared communicative efforts between children and adults.

  • The assembly line approach separates children from adult community activities and situates them in particular settings designed exclusively for them, such as schools and day care settings, which in turn structure communication differently (Correa-Chávez & Rogoff, 2005).

  • Communication is mainly dyadic since information is transmitted from experts to children without shared productive efforts and communication and even learning mostly relies on words.

  • This exemplifies the importance of culturally defined institutions, traditions, and practices in establishing the settings and the everyday practices in which members of a community will participate, the microsystems in Bronfenbrenner’s model.

Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Model Revision: Moving Culture From the Macro Into the Micro

  • From the theoretical perspectives of Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory, Thomas Weisner’s ecocultural theory, and Rogoff’s transformation of participation perspective, culture plays a central role in everyday actions and provides the immediate context for human development.

  • Culture is an ever-changing system composed of the practices of social communities and the interpretation of those practices through language.

  • Language is not only a medium for communication; through language, practices are defined in content and form facilitating action that is not completely limited by those definitions because of context.

  • Through language and practices, culture provides the tools and signs that are part of the historical legacy of those communities, these are integral parts of the child’s microsystems.

  • In the revision to the bioecological model, the critique comes from an ontological dimension and from a practical dimension.

  • Human development takes place within a cultural system.

  • Culture constitutes the context and reality of the developing person and that makes culture a paradigm.

  • From a practical dimension, individuals participate in cultural practices shaped by context specificity and interact with communities and social institutions that are both proximal and distal.

  • Communities and social institutions are also interpretative systems that have the power to change and be changed in those interactions.

  • Culture is embedded in all institutions that have the power to homogenize the daily routines within that context through political policies, laws, and regulations.

  • Individuals interact in different contexts and internalize certain cultural values and practices, making each experience unique from a particular time in life development.

  • The individual adds diversity to the setting it interacts in.

  • A child’s cultural system is within an ever historical transforming sphere (chronos), which moves and contains the other systems in the bioecological model, but does not relate to them as an outside layer.

  • The model proposes cultural microsystems, which include family, peers, school, neighborhoods, day care centers, and so on, shaped and structured by the social relationships and activities that operate within certain cultural definitions.

  • Cultural microsystems not only organize the relationships between what Bronfenbrenner considered mesosystems, but the larger institutions outside the immediate settings or Bronfenbrenner’s exosystem.

  • There is no need to differentiate mesosystems and macrosystems from cultural microsystems or the exosystem, because cultural practices already contain those relationships.

  • These systems flow from one another and interact with one another, not bounded and distinctly, but fluidly.

  • Within the child’s cultural systems, socialization is done through community routines that provide guidelines “of engagement in daily activities” or in cultural pathways.

  • Socialization is done in everyday activities within human relationships that culturally define age-appropriate daily activities, routines, and pathways.

  • Other communities, settings, and social institutions, which are located in layers outside of the microsystem in Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological paradigm, are also constantly being transformed by the cultural system in a reciprocal way.

  • They are not bounded separate entities, but flow into one another.

  • Bronfenbrenner’s exosystem and macrosystem contain the outside settings in which the child does not directly participate, but they still are also originated by culture.

  • Culture is what binds together the various institutions, through the creation of communities of practice that the child participates in or is a part of.

  • In regard to the biological dimension, biology is in a subordinated position to the social and the cultural-historical.

"Biology and culture are not alternative influences but inseparable aspects of a system within which individuals develop" (Rogoff, 1990, p. 28).

Scientific research has proven that its influence can transcend generations, promoting vulnerability and predispositions as mentioned by Conrad Wassington’s term of “epigenetics.”Presently, “the majority of environmental factors such as nutrition or toxicants such as endocrine disruptors do not promote genetic mutations or alterations in DNA sequence. However, these factors do have the capacity to alter the epigenome expression” (Skinner, Manikkam, & Guerrero-Bosagna, 2010, p. 214).The environment in which the individual resides might change over time.The human capacity for adaptation, both cultural and biological, will be tested when being presented with new challenges in a series of diverse conditions.The particular response to the exposure to toxins, hazards, changes of diet and stressors, caretaking changes, increasing school demands, and so on will be a function of an adaptive system that has evolved biologically and culturally up to now.Diagrams serve as visual tools that facilitate the understanding of theoretical ideas (Rogoff, 2003).The ways in which ideas are represented may restrain or limit our understanding.Bronfenbrenner portrayed the systems that compose the ecological paradigm in a diagram made out of concentric circles.This layout of nested circles is questionable since it “separates person and culture into stand-alone entities, with culture influencing the person” (Rogoff, 2003, p. 49), contrasting with perspective that proposes individual development not separated from its social and cultural-historical context (Rogoff, 2003).The separation of the systems carries an implicit meaning about the hierarchical relationships between them, implying that the outer circles influence the inner ones, and the latter are dependent on the systems in which they are embedded.The above is not consistent with understanding of the transformative and “mutually defining processes” between individuals and cultural practices (Rogoff, 2003, p. 49).Instead of concentric circles, a spiral is depicted moved by the chronos dimension in which culture exists within different settings, distal or proximal in relation to the individual.It seeks to represent settings as cultural practices (cultural pathways) that relate to the individual in mutually defining processes, emphasizing the transactional nature of human development.Cultural microsystems are justified theoretically by the notions of cultural mediation in Vygotsky’s theory, and the notions of cultural routines and cultural pathways by the theories of Rogoff and Weisner.Many cross-cultural studies have validated a variety of cultural systems by paying attention to social activities, relationships, and negotiations being done in everyday activities and how they affect and shape human development.

Empirical Studies That Support the Cultural Microsystems Paradigm Shift

  • Presents examples of research that supports the revision of Bronfenbrenner’s model within a cultural framework of daily practices.

  • Takes into account culture in every phase of the research process, but especially in the conceptualization and theoretical framework that defines and operationalizes the research problem.

  • Quantitative research focuses on measuring daily practices with instruments that are culturally sensitive in both theory and adaptation.

  • Qualitative research focuses on describing and understanding daily practices within a unique cultural framework.

Culture as Part of Family Systems’ Daily Practices
  • Ren and Hu (2014) conducted a multiple-case study to analyze maternal interaction strategies in four Chinese families in Singapore and explored factors that influence choice of interaction strategies and some of the social, cultural, and contextual factors that shape it.

  • Among the differences found were that teaching mothers had more control over the interaction than non-teaching mothers and immigrant mothers tended to solicit more active participation (Ren & Hu, 2014).

  • This study highlights differences in contextual and sociocultural factors that influence mother-child interactions that could contribute to different developmental processes.

  • García Coll and colleagues (García Coll et al., 2002; García Coll & Marks, 2009), have found that parental involvement in children’s education varies widely among immigrant groups.

  • Consistent with the model in the sense that the communities and individuals can diversify the experience and interactions in a specific context.

  • Research based on Weisner’s ecocultural theory has also proven the shaping of culture in everyday routines (Newland et al., 2013; Plowan, Stevenson, Stephen, & McPake, 2011).

  • McWayne et al. (2016) explore the “niche profiles” of families engagement practices in a group of low-income Spanish- and English-speaking Latino families of preschool children.

  • There is heterogeneity in the pattern of family engagement practices among the families and demographic factors were good predictors of the pattern on the language group and have a relationship with children’s social and language skills.

  • Highlights the importance of studying cultural practices in daily activities to comprehend heterogeneity within an ethnic group.

  • The study of routines facilitates the recognition of factors that contribute to development.

Culture as Part of Schools and Other Learning Environments
  • Rogoff et al. (2007) suggest that “investigating the organization of children’s participation in routine activities offers a way to address the dynamic nature of repertoires of cultural practices” (p. 490).

  • Mejía-Arauz, Rogoff, Dexter, and Najafi (2007) conducted a study to explore peer interaction in three groups of children.

  • Results indicated that triads of children who had indigenous heritage and whose Mexican families had immigrated to the United States communicated more often as a group, while the triads of children from European heritage more frequently engaged dyadically or individually.

  • Triads of children from Mexican heritage with maternal extensive schooling exhibited both patterns of communication or resembled the European heritage children.

  • Schooling and community participation do not operate separately in a mechanistic fashion, but rather “participation in institutions is an important aspect of a constellation of related cultural practices that contribute to children’s repertoires of social organization” (p. 1003).

  • Cultural processes in different settings mediate children’s approach to peer interactions and suggests that culture is within everyday activity and routine practices.

  • The significant role that routine organizers play in creating the settings that members of a community attend and the routine activities in which they partake (Rogoff et al., 2007).

  • Institutionalized rules lay out the foundations that structure human relations and communication, which occur in culturally defined settings.

  • Tsethlikai and Rogoff (2013) conducted a study to examine how cultural practices impact learning in two groups of American Indian children.

  • Results indicated that children who were more engaged in cultural activities in their community could recall the story with more precision.

  • Highlights the transactional nature of development and how it is influenced by the cultural contexts in which participation takes place.

  • Tonyan (2015) showed that family child care providers’ descriptions of “culturally organized ideals of care, or cultural models, held by adults can impact the kind of activities that children experience in their daily lives” (p. 312).

Culture as Part of Day Care Settings
  • Tonyan et al. (2013) used an ecocultural model to develop a group-based approach to understand the relationship between beliefs and practice on child care providers from an archival analysis using the Observational Ratings of the Caregiving Environment.

  • The group-based approach managed to identify meaningful groups of providers with shared beliefs, experiences, and working conditions, and the characteristics of those groups differed in observed behavior.

  • Rogoff’s (2003) approach, beliefs and practices are only part of what keep peoples and communities together.

  • McWayne et al. (2016) used the ecocultural perspective to investigate the distinct patterns of engagement among 650 Spanish and English self-identified Latinos primary caregivers of Head Start children with low income and 38 teachers and to examine the relation between the patterns, family demographic factors, and children’s language and social skills.

  • Findings suggested that providers of care who reported low engagement had less education than those who reported average engagement.

  • Parents of both language groups who reported high levels of engagement with children engaged in a high level of supplemental practice.

  • There were distinctions across the dimension of high-profile care provider between the Spanish- and English-speaking subsamples.

  • Ecocultural theory reminds that the cultural niches in which children and families live give indications of what communities, families, and children have in common and value by their cultural heritage, and their particular cultural constructions.

Conclusions

  • The importance of this revision lies in the fact that Bronfenbrenner’s model guides not only research but also some important ways of thinking and serving communities.

  • Bronfenbrenner originally stated the importance of bridging social policy and developmental research (Bronfenbrenner, 1974).

  • The model has been incorporated by major institutions worldwide (World Health Organization, UNICEF) as one of the theoretical backgrounds for social programs and research.

  • Current revisions of the model have been applied to new interpretations of social policies as dynamic developmental systems where the bioecological model’s key concepts are used to inform different aspects of it (Foster & Kalil, 2005).

  • The revision incorporates Foster and Kalil’s (2005) dimensions, but emphasizes that culture needs to take an important role in public policy as the major informant of processes, contexts, persons, and time.

  • Any social policy and social program should incorporate the analysis of how cultures operate in everyday activity.

  • The successful implementation of new public policies might be a function of how they are relevant, incorporated, and supported by the cultural microsystems.

  • The original conceptualization of how culture operates in Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological model is problematic because it is situated in a macrosystem, as if operating externally from everyday activities, actions, and routines in the microsystems.

  • A revision of the model from Vygotskian and neo-Vygotskian approaches led to create a new framework that situates culture as a critical part of the microsystems as well as all other systems that the microsystems are part of.

  • The bioecological paradigm should be revised with a conceptualization of culture operating as part of the microsystems.

  • Evidence to support the revision includes theoretical definitions of culture as well as empirical studies where culture is observed as part of daily routines and practices in families, peer settings, and child care and school settings.


Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Theory

Abstract
  • Bronfenbrenner's bioecological theory is a prominent framework in understanding human development across various contexts.

  • The conventional understanding of culture within the macrosystem presents a conceptual challenge, as it is often treated as separate from the everyday practices and direct interactions within microsystems.

  • A refined perspective involves reconceptualizing Bronfenbrenner's model to integrate culture as a fundamental aspect of proximal development processes.

  • Culture plays a crucial role in defining and organizing microsystems, thereby becoming an integral component of central human development processes.

  • Culture is viewed as a dynamic and evolving system encompassing the daily practices within social communities, along with their interpretation through language.

  • Diversity is acknowledged as a significant element within a child’s microsystems, leading to culturally defined developmental processes and outcomes.

Keywords
  • Cultural microsystems

  • Human development

  • Bronfenbrenner’s theory

  • Proximal Development

  • Sociocultural Context

Introduction
  • Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological theory is a widely recognized and influential theoretical framework in the field of human development.

  • Despite its significant contributions, research conducted within this framework has encountered conceptual ambiguities and challenges in empirical testing (Tudge et al., 2009).

  • The conceptualization of culture within the bioecological theory has been identified as particularly problematic.

  • Several major theoretical perspectives challenge the bioecological theory’s position on culture, proposing that culture is a dynamic product of human activity (Markus & Kitayama, 2009).

  • According to these perspectives, culture is embedded within everyday actions and is integral to communities of practice through the medium of language.

  • Culture also manifests in cognitive processes such as intelligence and memory, influencing how individuals perceive and interact with their environment.

  • Bronfenbrenner’s model, in its original formulation, introduces culture somewhat peripherally, often situating it within the distal environment.

  • The theory raises important questions regarding the treatment of individual and cultural processes as distinct and separate entities (Rogoff, 2003).

  • The model tends to present individual and broader contextual factors as existing independently within a hierarchical structure.

  • This article aims to integrate Rogoff, Weisner, and Vygotsky’s sociocultural perspectives to reformulate culture as an intrinsic part of proximal developmental processes.

  • It proposes a revised model wherein culture operationalizes microsystems, thereby becoming a central element in the processes of human development.

  • The revised model places emphasis on the diversity inherent in human experience, recognizing the multifaceted influences that shape individual development.

  • The article will provide a comprehensive historical overview of the role of culture within Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological theory.

  • It will present theoretical arguments derived from the perspectives of Rogoff, Weisner, and Vygotsky, offering a critical analysis of the existing framework.

  • Ultimately, it will propose a revised model supported by empirical cross-cultural data, illustrating the significance of culture in shaping human development.

Historical Overview of the Role of Culture in Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Paradigm
  • The development of Urie Bronfenbrenner’s theory can be delineated into two primary periods: the 1970s and the 1990s, each representing significant advancements in his conceptualization of ecological systems.

  • Bronfenbrenner’s initial publication dates back to 1958, reflecting his early concerns regarding the state of research in developmental psychology.

  • Bronfenbrenner critiqued the field’s predominant emphasis on experimental rigor, often at the expense of robust theory development, advocating for a more balanced approach to understanding human development.

  • Bronfenbrenner famously stated that developmental psychology risks becoming “the science of the strange behavior of children in strange situations with strange adults for brief periods of time” (Bronfenbrenner, 1977, p. 513), underscoring the importance of ecological validity in research.

  • During the 1970s, Bronfenbrenner formulated his ecological theory, drawing inspiration from Kurt Lewin’s work on group dynamics to conceptualize the interconnectedness of environmental influences on human development.

  • Bronfenbrenner defined ecological theory as the study of human development within the context of enduring environments, emphasizing the reciprocal relationship between individuals and their surroundings (Bronfenbrenner, 1974).

  • The child’s ecology encompassed the sustained environments in which the child lived, comprising two concentric layers: the upper layer, representing immediate settings, and the supportive layer, providing contextual support and surrounding influences.

Upper Layer
  • The upper layer, consisting of immediate settings such as the home, school, street, and playground, was characterized by three fundamental dimensions: physical attributes, the individuals present and their respective roles, and the activities undertaken along with their associated social meanings.

Supportive Layer
  • The supportive layer served as an adjacent contextual system that influenced the immediate setting, determining the possibilities and constraints within the child’s immediate context (Bronfenbrenner, 1974).

  • It encompassed both physical and geographical elements, as well as institutional contexts, representing broader social systems that indirectly impacted the child’s immediate environment.

  • The potential for second-order effects, characterized as the influence of a third element C on the relationship between elements A and B, could interfere with the immediate context, adding complexity to the ecological system (Bronfenbrenner, 1974).

  • Culture was implicitly integrated within the form of social systems comprising the supportive layer, shaping the norms, values, and expectations within the child’s environment.

  • The supporting and surrounding layer served to both constrain and shape the possibilities within the immediate setting, guiding developmental trajectories and outcomes.

1977 Expansion
  • Bronfenbrenner’s subsequent development of the theory in 1977 involved expanding the layer model into a more intricate arrangement of interdependent systems, each nested within the next.

  • The ecological environment was reconceptualized as a nested system of structures, comprising the microsystem, mesosystem, exosystem, and macrosystem, representing varying levels of influence on human development.

  • While culture was not explicitly defined, it was posited to permeate the macrosystem and to inform the ideological structure of the mesosystem (Bronfenbrenner, 1977), thereby exerting indirect influence on individual development.

  • Concepts associated with culture were embedded within various macrosystems, encompassing laws, rules, information, and ideology, representing the broader societal contexts shaping individual experience.

  • The concept of a “blueprint” was introduced as part of the macrosystem, although its precise elucidation remained limited, potentially alluding to the mechanisms through which culture is reproduced across settings.

  • Bronfenbrenner’s conceptualization of culture tended to emphasize its homogenizing influence rather than acknowledging its role in diversifying human experience, thereby overlooking the heterogeneity within cultural contexts.

1990s Revision
  • The 1990s marked another phase of significant revisions in Bronfenbrenner’s theory, resulting in the formulation of the general ecological model, later termed the bioecological paradigm (Bronfenbrenner & Ceci, 1994).

  • These developments were encapsulated in two primary propositions, highlighting the importance of proximal processes and the interplay between person, context, and time in shaping developmental outcomes.

  • In addition to emphasizing proximal processes, revisions were made to refine the conceptualization of certain systems and to introduce the chronosystem, acknowledging the impact of temporal changes on individual development.

  • The chronosystem accounted for changes or consistencies over time in the characteristics of both the person and the environment (Bronfenbrenner, 1999), recognizing the dynamic nature of developmental processes.

  • Longitudinal studies were deemed necessary to investigate the impact of time as a proxy for historical periods on proximal processes, allowing for the examination of long-term developmental trajectories (Tudge et al., 2009).

  • Another notable revision involved refining the description of the microsystem, now defined as encompassing patterns of activities within the immediate setting, including interactions with symbolic features such as persons, objects, and symbols (Bronfenbrenner, 1995b).

  • Bronfenbrenner emphasized that for reciprocal interaction to occur, the objects and symbols within the immediate environment must possess qualities that invite attention, exploration, manipulation, elaboration, and imagination (Bronfenbrenner, 1999, p. 6).

  • Despite further development of the role of social and interactional features within microsystems, as well as the inclusion of objects and symbols, there remained a lack of integration with the broader concept of culture, reflecting a degree of theoretical separation between culture and its manifestations.

  • Culture was not explicitly linked to everyday practices or activities, suggesting a theoretical disconnect between culture and its tangible products such as objects and symbols, leading to a conceptual gap within the model.

  • From its inception and throughout its subsequent revisions, Bronfenbrenner’s model lacked clarity and precision in its conceptualization of culture, failing to provide an in-depth definition and acknowledgment of its pivotal role in human development.

  • Culture was primarily situated within the macrosystem, exerting influence through the interdependence of various systems, yet the mechanisms through which these transactions operated and culture was operationalized remained ill-defined.

  • The absence of a comprehensive conceptual definition of culture has posed challenges in research and interpretation within the domains of human development and culture, hindering a nuanced understanding of their interplay.

  • The subsequent sections will introduce Vygotskian and neo-Vygotskian approaches to the role of culture in development to challenge Bronfenbrenner’s approach, conceptually as well as methodologically, offering alternative perspectives on the integration of culture within developmental frameworks.

  • The conceptual framework aligns with Mistry et al.’s (2016) conceptualization of culture as encompassing “generalizable ideologies and practices shared by groups, as well as, the meaning-making processes through which individuals interpret their environmental contexts by drawing on the shared ideologies available to them as members of groups” (p. 4).

  • Culture is posited as both the process and the content of daily activity and is thus inseparable from all contexts where developmental processes and outcomes take place, particularly within the microsystems, emphasizing its pervasive influence on human development.

Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory
  • Culture constitutes a foundational concept within Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory, shaping the contours of human experience and development.

  • Sociocultural theory posits that culture mediates human experience and transforms human activity through the internalization of culturally defined tools and signs, leading to the development of higher psychological functions.

  • A fundamental premise of this theory is that culture is not an external entity operating from a remote macrosystem but rather serves as the very system within which every human daily activity is enacted and subsequently internalized, shaping individual cognition and behavior.

  • Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory emerged in the aftermath of the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution in Russia, drawing upon concepts such as tools, labor, and culture and history from within Marxist thought and reconceptualizing them to explain learning, development, and higher psychological functions.

  • Cultural forms of behavior emerge during infancy, particularly in the use of tools and the development of human speech, underscoring the critical role of early experiences in shaping cultural development: “This alone places infancy at the center of the prehistory of cultural development” (Vygotsky, 1930–1934/1978, p. 34).

  • Development is viewed as a culturally mediated process from its inception, as the use of tools and human speech are culturally defined and acquired behaviors, shaping the individual’s interaction with the world.

  • The acquisition of cultural forms of behavior implies that interpsychological functions between members of a cultural group become intrapsychological, signifying the internalization of social interactions and cultural norms, expressed by the "general law of cultural development":

Everyfunctioninthechild’sculturaldevelopmentappearstwice:first,onthesociallevel,andlater,ontheindividuallevel;first,betweenpeople(interpsychological),andtheninsidethechild(intrapsychological).Thisappliesequallytovoluntaryattention,tologicalmemory,andtotheformationofconcepts.Allthehigherfunctionsoriginateasactualrelationsbetweenhumanindividuals.(Vygotsky,1930–1934/1978,p.48)Every function in the child’s cultural development appears twice: first, on the social level, and later, on the individual level; first, between people (interpsychological), and then inside the child (intrapsychological). This applies equally to voluntary attention, to logical memory, and to the formation of concepts. All the higher functions originate as actual relations between human individuals. (Vygotsky, 1930–1934/1978, p. 48)

  • Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory situates culture within everyday activity, positing that every form of human activity is a cultural form of behavior, developed and enacted within a defined cultural context and subsequently internalized by the individual, shaping their cognition and behavior.

  • Vygotsky’s account of culture suggests that “human mental functioning, even when carried out by an individual acting in isolation, is inherently social, or socio cultural, in that it incorporates socially evolved and socially organized tools” (Wertsch & Tulviste, 1992, p. 551), underscoring the social origins of individual cognition.

  • This notion is closely related to semiotic mediation, understanding language as a system of signs inherent to developmental processes and outcomes (Wertsch & Tulviste, 1992), highlighting the role of language in shaping thought and communication.

  • Although Bronfenbrenner was earlier influenced by Vygotsky with the concept of reciprocal activity occurring in microsystems, as well as proximal processes (Wong, 2001), he did not fully embrace Vygotsky’s more abstract formulations (Bronfenbrenner, 1995a), leading to a divergence in their theoretical perspectives.

  • Vygotsky’s perspective contrasts with Bronfenbrenner’s notion of culture as part of a remote macrosystem, whose involvement in human activity and settings is mediated by interdependence between concentric circles, thereby underemphasizing the direct influence of culture on individual development.

  • The concept of interdependence originates from the discipline of dynamics in physics and was utilized by Kurt Lewin to elucidate the behavior of social forces within a field (Lewin, 1939), emphasizing the interconnectedness of elements within a system.

  • Interdependence implies “dynamic properties,” “types of reactions,” and “types of influences” (Lewin, 1939), suggesting a complex interplay of factors within the ecological environment.

  • In Bronfenbrenner’s theory, culture is viewed as an external influence owing to its placement within the macrosystem, treating it as a separate entity from the immediate settings in which individuals develop.

  • The nature of interaction is seen in the patterns of activities performed, which are said to be influenced by culture, highlighting the indirect impact of culture on behavior.

  • Therein lies the fundamental conceptual difference between Bronfenbrenner and Vygotsky: Bronfenbrenner’s utilization of the concept of interdependence simplifies the role of culture in development by situating it as an external influence, whereas Vygotsky’s cultural mediation places it at the center of the microsystem, providing the means, activities, and meanings of every human activity within a particular social origin.

  • It is important to distinguish between Lewin’s influence on Bronfenbrenner and his influence on Vygotksy, as Wong (2001) observes:

Lewin was highly valued by Vygotsky. . . . In “Tool and Symbol in Children’s Development,” Vygotsky (1930) adhered to the Lewinian distinction between phenotypic (description of external manifestation) and genotypic (explanation of origin or essence) viewpoints and declared his inclination to determine causal-dynamic relations in psychological analyses. But the Lewinian concept of “ life space” or “ total situation” did not fertilize the soil of the cultural-historical approach. (p. 367)

Lewin’s concepts adhere more to a geographical and physical analogy, whereas Vygotsky’s cultural mediation entails a dialectic internalization of what once were external cultural signs and tools, underscoring the transformative nature of cultural influence.The dialectic internalization implies that higher psychological functions are neither external nor internal because the dialectics require a radical transformation that blurs any line across them, suggesting a dynamic interplay between external and internal processes.The external becomes an extension of internal psychological functions, blurring the boundaries between individual and cultural influences, highlighting the interconnectedness of human experience.Aside from fundamental limitations in the notion of culture in Bronfenbrenner’s theory, methodological questions have arisen too, particularly regarding the treatment of culture as an external factor in developmental research.If culture enters developmental research as an external factor from another system, its analysis is reduced to describing the interaction with other systems, thereby neglecting its intrinsic role in shaping human behavior.As argued from Vygotsky’s perspective, culture is part of the articulation of the microsystems in the research process, as developmental changes imply “mastery of devices and means of cultural behavior and thinking” (Luria, 1930, cited by Wertsch & Tulviste, 1992), emphasizing the active role of individuals in shaping their own development.Through daily activities and practices, culture becomes the unit of analysis, providing a lens through which to examine human behavior and development, underscoring the importance of contextualized research.Vygotsky’s perspective has exerted considerable influence on subsequent theorists, shaping contemporary understandings of culture and development.Contributions from this perspective contrast with Bronfenbrenner’s theory and situate the importance of considering culture and context as inseparable (Mistry et al., 2016), emphasizing the need to integrate cultural and contextual factors in developmental research.

Thomas Weisner: Ecocultural Theory
  • Thomas Weisner has contributed conceptual and empirical work from the perspective of the ecocultural theory in the topic of culture and developmental research, providing valuable insights into the interplay between culture and development.

  • From this theoretical perspective, the cultural community provides children with developmental pathways inside an ecocultural context (Weisner, 2002), shaping their developmental trajectories and outcomes.

  • Developmental pathways are internalized (or crystallized) in everyday routines (bedtime, video games, homework, cooking dinner, etc.), underscoring the role of daily experiences in shaping development.

  • Culture is embedded within the routines in which individuals engage, influencing their behavior and shaping their understanding of the world, highlighting the importance of studying everyday activities.

  • According to Weisner, García Coll, and Chatman-Nelson (2010, p. 84), “developmental pathways refers to the different kinds of activities, organized by families and local communities, in which the child could or will engage during development,” emphasizing the role of social contexts in shaping developmental trajectories.

  • Although Bronfenbrenner’s perspective takes into consideration the importance of routines and activities on the microsystem, there is no clear reference to these actions as culturally defined or mediated, limiting the integration of culture within his theoretical framework.

  • Similar to Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory, the ecocultural perspective understands culture as not separated from the person and its interactions with the microsystem, but developing as habits in a cultural community, emphasizing the embeddedness of culture within social contexts.

  • Cultural pathways consist of activities we “step into” and move through life (Weisner, 2002), shaping our experiences and influencing our development, underscoring the dynamic interplay between individuals and their cultural environments.

  • According to Weisner, there are multiple behavioral and mental processes involved in the developmental attainment of culture (Weisner, 2015), highlighting the complexity of cultural acquisition.

  • Some of these processes can be in conflict with cultural values and producing intrapsychic and cultural conflict (Weisner, 2009), leading to tensions between individual desires and cultural expectations.

  • The mentality of an individual’s culture includes shared and idiosyncratic beliefs, practices, and experiences that can be at conflict and could lead to contradictory actions (Tonyan, Mamikonian-Zarpas, & Chien, 2013), underscoring the diversity within cultural contexts.

  • This phenomenon cannot be located in any of the systems of Bronfenbrenner’s theory, since it is the individual child or parent internalization or not of cultural scripts, highlighting the limitations of Bronfenbrenner’s model in capturing individual agency.

  • The individual becomes an actor in its own development and not a total passive recipient of culture, suggesting a more dynamic and reciprocal relationship between individuals and their cultural environments.

  • Weisner’s theory recognizes the importance of the ecological and cultural environment where the process of development is taking place, headlining the relationship between individual processes and sociocontextual conditions that have an effect on the processes and outcomes (McWayne, Limlingan, Melzi, & Schick, 2016), emphasizing the need to consider both individual and contextual factors in developmental research.

  • Because these processes are contextual, one has to determine where the person is developing, and what are the resources, practices, beliefs, goals, institutions, and so on in that cultural community, underscoring the importance of conducting research within specific cultural contexts.

  • Knowing the “developmental niche” the person is experiencing (Super & Harkness, 2002), provides valuable insights into the cultural context shaping individual development.

  • This concept aligns with the model of cultural microsystems by identifying the practices, narratives, and institutions within a cultural community that contribute to developmental processes and outcomes, offering a more nuanced understanding of cultural influences.

Barbara Rogoff: Transformation of Participation Perspective
  • Barbara Rogoff describes development as transformation of participation in sociocultural activities (Rogoff, 2003), underscoring the active role of individuals in shaping their own development through participation in cultural practices.

  • Her conceptualization of cultural processes in human development originates from Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory, building upon Vygotsky’s foundational work to further refine our understanding of cultural influences on development.

  • Rogoff places culture within “community routines” that provide guidelines “of engagement to cultural participation to build on in daily activities” (p. 2), emphasizing the role of everyday practices in shaping cultural understanding and development.

  • Cultural processes are not part of a hierarchical system that interacts indirectly with the individual, but rather permeate all aspects of life, shaping routines, habits, language, and ultimately developmental outcomes and processes.

  • Culture mediates development and learning since the child begins the process of socialization (Correa-Chávez & Rogoff, 2005), influencing the acquisition of knowledge, skills, and cultural norms from an early age.

  • Learning processes are related to cultural practices that dictate the type of engagement the child will partake in the community, shaping the child’s opportunities for learning and development within their cultural context.

  • Children are assigned to specific settings (day care, soccer practice) by their caregivers or other agents of socialization, influencing their exposure to different cultural practices and social interactions.

  • “These settings have important consequences on the development of habits of interpersonal behavior, consequences that may not be recognized by the socializers who make the assignments” (Whiting, 1980, p. 111), highlighting the unintended effects of socialization practices on children’s development.

  • Cultures differ in how they make these assignments and how these settings are organized in profound ways, reflecting the diversity of cultural practices and their impact on individual development.

  • The intent community participation approach emphasizes the inclusion and engagement of children in productive community activities (Rogoff, Correa-Chávez, & Silva, 2009), fostering a sense of belonging and promoting learning through active participation.

  • Children learn from listening and actively observing adults engaged in production activities, acquiring knowledge and skills through observation and imitation, underscoring the importance of modeling in cultural learning.

  • This tradition attempts to carry out objectives by shared communicative efforts between children and adults, fostering collaboration and shared understanding within the community.

  • The assembly line approach separates children from adult community activities and situates them in particular settings designed exclusively for them, such as schools and day care settings, which in turn structure communication differently (Correa-Chávez & Rogoff, 2005), potentially limiting opportunities for cultural learning and social interaction.

  • Communication is mainly dyadic since information is transmitted from experts to children without shared productive efforts and communication and even learning mostly relies on words, emphasizing the role of formal instruction in this approach.

  • This exemplifies the importance of culturally defined institutions, traditions, and practices in establishing the settings and the everyday practices in which members of a community will participate, the microsystems in Bronfenbrenner’s model, underscoring the influence of culture on shaping social contexts.

Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Model Revision: Moving Culture From the Macro Into the Micro
  • From the theoretical perspectives of Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory, Thomas Weisner’s ecocultural theory, and Rogoff’s transformation of participation perspective, culture plays a central role in everyday actions and provides the immediate context for human development, underscoring the need to integrate culture more fully into developmental models.

  • Culture is an ever-changing system composed of the practices of social communities and the interpretation of those practices through language, reflecting the dynamic and evolving nature of cultural influences.

  • Language is not only a medium for communication; through language, practices are defined in content and form facilitating action that is not completely limited by those definitions because of context, highlighting the role of language in shaping cultural understanding and social interactions.

  • Through language and practices, culture provides the tools and signs that are part of the historical legacy of those communities; these are integral parts of the child’s microsystems, shaping their cognitive and social development.

  • In the revision to the bioecological model, the critique comes from an ontological dimension and from a practical dimension, underscoring the need to address both theoretical and practical limitations in the existing framework.

  • Human development takes place within a cultural system, and culture constitutes the context and reality of the developing person, making culture a paradigm that shapes individual experiences and developmental trajectories.

  • From a practical dimension, individuals participate in cultural practices shaped by context specificity and interact with communities and social institutions that are both proximal and distal, underscoring the interconnectedness of individuals and their larger social environments.

  • Communities and social institutions are also interpretative systems that can change and be changed in those interactions, highlighting the reciprocal nature of cultural influences and the potential for individual agency in shaping cultural norms.

  • Culture is embedded in all institutions that have the power to homogenize the daily routines within that context through political policies, laws, and regulations, underscoring the role of institutions in shaping cultural practices and reinforcing social norms.

  • Individuals interact in different contexts and internalize certain cultural values and practices, making each experience unique from a particular time in life development, acknowledging the diversity of individual experiences within cultural contexts.

  • The individual adds diversity to the setting it interacts in, highlighting the role of individual agency in shaping cultural practices and contributing to cultural change.

  • A child’s cultural system is within an ever historical transforming sphere (chronos), which moves and contains the other systems in the bioecological model, but does not relate to them as an outside layer, underscoring the dynamic and interconnected nature of cultural influences on development.

  • The model proposes cultural microsystems, which include family, peers, school, neighborhoods, day care centers, and so on, shaped and structured by the social relationships and activities that operate within certain cultural definitions, emphasizing the role of social contexts in shaping individual development.

  • Cultural microsystems not only organize the relationships between what Bronfenbrenner considered mesosystems but also the larger institutions outside the immediate settings or Bronfenbrenner’s exosystem, underscoring the interconnectedness of different levels of social influence.

  • There is no need to differentiate mesosystems and macrosystems from cultural microsystems or the exosystem, because cultural practices already contain those relationships, simplifying the model by integrating cultural influences across different levels of social organization.

  • These systems flow from one another and interact with one another, not bounded and distinctly, but fluidly, emphasizing the dynamic and interconnected nature of cultural influences on individual development.

  • Within the child’s cultural systems, socialization is done through community routines that provide guidelines “of engagement in daily activities” or in cultural pathways, shaping the child’s understanding of cultural norms and expectations.

  • Socialization is done in everyday activities within human relationships that culturally define age-appropriate daily activities, routines, and pathways, highlighting the role of social interactions in shaping cultural understanding and development.

  • Other communities, settings, and social institutions, which are located in layers outside of the microsystem in Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological paradigm, are also constantly being transformed by the cultural system in a reciprocal way, underscoring the dynamic interplay between individuals and their larger social environments.

  • They are not bounded separate entities but flow into one another, emphasizing the interconnectedness of different levels of social influence within the cultural system.

  • Bronfenbrenner’s exosystem and macrosystem contain the outside settings in which the child does not directly participate, but they are still also originated by culture, influencing the child’s development indirectly through their impact on the microsystem.

  • Culture is what binds together the various institutions through the creation of communities of practice that the child participates in or is a part of, fostering a sense of belonging and promoting cultural understanding within these communities.

  • In regard to the biological dimension, biology is in a subordinated position to the social and the cultural-historical, acknowledging the influence of social and cultural factors on biological processes.

"Biology and culture are not alternative influences but inseparable aspects of a system within which individuals develop" (Rogoff, 1990, p. 28).

  • Scientific research has proven that its influence can transcend generations, promoting vulnerability and predispositions as mentioned by Conrad Wassington’s term of “epigenetics,” underscoring the intergenerational transmission of cultural influences.

  • Presently, “the majority of environmental factors such as nutrition or toxicants such as endocrine disruptors do not promote genetic mutations or alterations in DNA sequence. However, these factors do have the capacity to alter the epigenome expression” (Skinner, Manikkam, & Guerrero-Bosagna, 2010, p. 214), highlighting the role of environmental factors in shaping gene expression.

  • The environment in which the individual resides might change over time, requiring adaptation and resilience in the face of new challenges.

  • The human capacity for adaptation, both cultural and biological, will be tested when being presented with new challenges in a series of diverse conditions, underscoring the importance of adaptability in navigating changing environments.

  • The particular response to the exposure to toxins, hazards, changes of diet and stressors, caretaking changes, increasing school demands, and so on will be a function of an adaptive system that has evolved biologically and culturally up to now, highlighting the interplay of biological and cultural factors in shaping individual responses to environmental stressors.

  • Diagrams serve as visual tools that facilitate the understanding of theoretical ideas (Rogoff, 2003), providing a means of representing complex concepts in a more accessible format.

  • The ways in which ideas are represented may restrain or limit our understanding; therefore, it is important to critically evaluate the assumptions underlying visual representations.

  • Bronfenbrenner portrayed the systems that compose the ecological paradigm in a diagram made out of concentric circles, visually representing the nested nature of environmental influences on development.

  • This layout of nested circles is questionable since it “separates person and culture into stand-alone entities, with culture influencing the person" (Rogoff, 2003, p. 49), contrasting with a perspective that proposes individual development should not be separated from its social and cultural-historical context (Rogoff, 2003), which questions the assumption of unidirectional influence.

  • The separation of the systems carries an implicit meaning about the hierarchical relationships between them, implying that the outer circles influence the inner ones, and the latter are dependent on the systems in which they are embedded, reinforcing the notion of hierarchical influence within the model.

  • The above is inconsistent with understanding of the transformative and “mutually defining processes” between individuals and cultural practices (Rogoff, 2003, p. 49), which challenges the assumption of unidirectional influence and emphasizes the reciprocal nature of individual and cultural influences.

  • Instead of concentric circles, a spiral is depicted moved by the chronos dimension in which culture exists within different settings, distal or proximal in relation to the individual, offering an alternative visual representation that emphasizes the dynamic and interconnected nature of cultural influences.

  • It seeks to represent settings as cultural practices (cultural pathways) that relate to the individual in mutually defining processes, emphasizing the transactional nature of human development and the reciprocal influences between individuals and their cultural environments.

  • Cultural microsystems are justified theoretically by the notions of cultural mediation in Vygotsky’s theory and the notions of cultural routines and cultural pathways by the theories of Rogoff and Weisner, providing a theoretical foundation for understanding the role of cultural influences within microsystems.

  • Many cross-cultural studies have validated a variety of cultural systems by paying attention to social activities, relationships, and negotiations being done in everyday activities and how they affect and shape human development, underscoring the importance of conducting research within specific cultural contexts to understand the diversity of human experiences.

Empirical Studies That Support the Cultural Microsystems Paradigm Shift
  • Here are examples of research that supports the revision of Bronfenbrenner’s model within a cultural framework of daily practices, providing empirical evidence for the importance of integrating culture into developmental research.

  • These studies take into account culture in every phase of the research process, but especially in the conceptualization and theoretical framework that defines and operationalizes the research problem, emphasizing the need for culturally sensitive research methodologies.

  • Quantitative research focuses on measuring daily practices with instruments that are culturally sensitive in both theory and adaptation, ensuring that research tools are appropriate for the cultural contexts in which they are used.

  • Qualitative research focuses on describing and understanding daily practices within a unique cultural framework, providing rich insights into the lived experiences of individuals within specific cultural contexts.

Culture as Part of Family Systems’ Daily Practices
  • Ren and Hu (2014) conducted a multiple-case study to analyze maternal interaction strategies in four Chinese families in Singapore and explored factors that influence choice of interaction strategies and some of the social, cultural, and contextual factors that shape it, highlighting the role of culture in shaping family dynamics.

  • Among the differences found were that teaching mothers had more control over the interaction than non-teaching mothers and immigrant mothers tended to solicit more active participation (Ren & Hu, 2014), underscoring the diversity of parenting styles within cultural contexts.

  • This study highlights differences in contextual and sociocultural factors that influence mother-child interactions that could contribute to different developmental processes, emphasizing the need to consider cultural influences in understanding child development.

  • García Coll and colleagues (García Coll et al., 2002; García Coll & Marks, 2009), have found that parental involvement in children’s education varies widely among immigrant groups, reflecting the diversity of cultural values and practices related to education.

  • Consistently with the model, the communities and individuals can diversify the experience and interactions in a specific context, underscoring the importance of individual agency and contextual factors in shaping experiences and interactions.

  • Research based on Weisner’s ecocultural theory has also proven the shaping of culture in everyday routines (Newland et al., 2013; Plowan, Stevenson, Stephen, & McPake, 2011), reinforcing the notion that culture is embedded within daily practices.

  • McWayne et al. (2016) explore the “niche profiles” of families' engagement practices in a group of low-income Spanish- and English-speaking Latino families of preschool children, offering insights into the diversity of family engagement practices within this population.

  • There is heterogeneity in the pattern of family engagement practices among the families, and demographic factors were good predictors of the pattern on the language group and have a relationship with children’s social and language skills, underscoring the complexity of family engagement and its relationship with child development.

  • Highlighting the importance of studying cultural practices in daily activities to comprehend heterogeneity within an ethnic group, reinforcing the need for culturally sensitive research methodologies.

  • The study of routines facilitates the recognition of factors that contribute to development, highlighting the importance of studying everyday practices in understanding individual development.

Culture as Part of Schools and Other Learning Environments
  • Rogoff et al. (2007) suggest that “investigating the organization of children’s participation in routine activities offers a way to address the dynamic nature of repertoires of cultural practices” (p. 490), emphasizing the role of routine activities in shaping cultural understanding and development.

  • Mejía-Arauz, Rogoff, Dexter, and Najafi (2007) conducted a study to explore peer interaction in three groups of children, examining cultural influences on social interactions within peer groups.

  • Results indicated that triads of children who had indigenous heritage and whose Mexican families had immigrated to the United States communicated more often as a group while the triads of children from European heritage more frequently engaged dyadically or individually, reflecting the influence of cultural values on communication patterns.

  • Triads of children from Mexican heritage with maternal extensive schooling exhibited both patterns of communication or resembled the European heritage children, underscoring the impact of education in shaping communication styles.

  • Schooling and community participation do not operate separately in a mechanistic fashion, but rather “participation in institutions is an important aspect of a constellation of related cultural practices that contribute to children’s repertoires of social organization” (p. 1003), emphasizing the interconnectedness of different levels of social influence.

  • Cultural processes in different settings mediate children’s approach to peer interactions and suggests that culture is within everyday activity and routine practices, reinforcing the notion that culture is embedded within daily practices.

  • The significant role that routine organizers play in creating the settings that members of a community attend and the routine activities in which they partake (Rogoff et al., 2007), shaping opportunities for cultural learning and social interaction.

  • Institutionalized rules lay out the foundations that structure human relations and communication, which occur in culturally defined settings, underscoring the role of institutions in shaping social interactions and communication patterns.

  • Tsethlikai