L4 Notes
Introduction
The session starts by welcoming the students and ensuring that they have had enough time to log in before commencing.
A reminder that this is the final synchronous session of the class aside from upcoming assignments.
Module Overview
Discussion of Module Eight:
- Two components to complete:
- Discussion board participation.
- Major semester assignment worth 50 points: Applied Legal Research.
- The template for the major assignment is crucial as it contains all necessary questions.
Module Six Exercises
Focus on exercises involving:
- Locating opinions and identifying cases from statutes.
- Identifying cases from secondary sources.Discussion about administrative agencies and resources available.
- Emphasis on a review of the research strategy.
Westlaw and Lexis Exercises
Importance of using Westlaw and Lexis for legal research:
- Example case citation process shown:
- Searching for the case with citation350 F. 445results in a display with: history, citing references, and legislative flags (e.g. yellow flag indicates cases in dispute).
- Citing with references shows relationships between cases.
- Importance of head notes, which summarize the key law of each section of a case.
Lexis Example
Demonstrating.Statistical citation from Lexis for a specific case
2001 US DISC FLEXIS 60211:
- Access to AI-generated summaries and the ability to Shepherdize to check the case's legal status.
Google Scholar
Discussion on using Google Scholar for case law:
- Limitations noted, as it does not provide editorial information about the legal status of cases.
Identifying Cases from Statutes
Scenario: Protecting business interests via non-compete agreements.
- Texas law allows enforceability of non-compete agreements, provided they are reasonable in terms of time, geography, and scope.Definition of enforceability based on the statute and relevant cases:
- Example cited: Vasquez v. Vasquez, where nationwide geographic coverage was deemed reasonable due to the nature of business.
Lexis Research Assignment Example
Scenario involving employee arbitration policies:
- Lexis used to find cases involving inadequate notice of arbitration agreements, specifically Doe v. Columbia North Hills.Analysis of case signals in Lexis showing treatment by subsequent courts.
Secondary Sources Research
Scenario: Trademark issues with logo usage:
- Texas courts’ approach to trademarks involves likelihood of confusion due to similar marks.Reference to factors considered by courts in the Seventh Circuit, with examples from relevant cases.
Administrative Agencies
Overview of administrative agencies and their functions:
- Quasi-Legislative: Powers to create regulations.
- Quasi-Judicial: Powers to adjudicate disputes.Agencies are established by enabling statutes that define their authority and mission.
Examples of enabling statutes discussed:
- 6 USC 111 - Establishment of the Department of Homeland Security.
- 42 USC 3532 - Establishment of the Department of Housing and Urban Development.
Key Federal Statutes Impacting Agencies
Administrative Procedures Act: Grants public participation in rule-making processes.
Freedom of Information Act: Access to agency materials.
Sunshine Act: Requirements for open meetings by agencies.
Federal Register Act: Outlines regulation publication before codification.
Federal Register and Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)
Explanation of the purpose of the Federal Register and CFR:
- Federal Register publishes daily updates and notices from agencies.
- CFR organizes finalized regulations by topic.Distinction that titles in the CFR and the U.S. Code are not parallel.
Conducting Administrative Research
Techniques for using the CFR:
- Browsing vs. searching: Browsing may lead to incomplete research results, while searching provides targeted access.Use of the CFR index for efficient research guidance.
- Example search for discrimination regulations explained.
Free Resources for Regulations
Introduction to govinfo.gov: A public resource for accessing legal materials including CFR and legislative documents, albeit less frequently updated than paid legal research tools.
Electronic CFR (eCFR): Updated frequently and offers direct access similar to Westlaw and Lexis.
Federal Register online: Focused on rule-making processes and public notices.
Resources where you can submit comments on proposed rules: regulations.gov.
Final Research Strategy Discussion
Reminder of overarching research strategies:
- Iterative nature: Research continues until no new information is found.
- TARP framework for research (Things, Actions, People, Places).Importance of reliability, authority, and suitability of sources.
Conclusion
Recap of the semester and class closure.
Open floor for final questions, with emphasis on the importance of communication post-class.