L4 Notes

Introduction

  • The session starts by welcoming the students and ensuring that they have had enough time to log in before commencing.

  • A reminder that this is the final synchronous session of the class aside from upcoming assignments.

Module Overview

  • Discussion of Module Eight:
      - Two components to complete:
        - Discussion board participation.
        - Major semester assignment worth 50 points: Applied Legal Research.
      - The template for the major assignment is crucial as it contains all necessary questions.

Module Six Exercises

  • Focus on exercises involving:
      - Locating opinions and identifying cases from statutes.
      - Identifying cases from secondary sources.

  • Discussion about administrative agencies and resources available.
      - Emphasis on a review of the research strategy.

Westlaw and Lexis Exercises

  • Importance of using Westlaw and Lexis for legal research:
      - Example case citation process shown:
        - Searching for the case with citation 350 F. 445 results in a display with: history, citing references, and legislative flags (e.g. yellow flag indicates cases in dispute).
      - Citing with references shows relationships between cases.
      - Importance of head notes, which summarize the key law of each section of a case.

Lexis Example

  • Demonstrating.Statistical citation from Lexis for a specific case 2001 US DISC FLEXIS 60211:
      - Access to AI-generated summaries and the ability to Shepherdize to check the case's legal status.

Google Scholar

  • Discussion on using Google Scholar for case law:
      - Limitations noted, as it does not provide editorial information about the legal status of cases.

Identifying Cases from Statutes

  • Scenario: Protecting business interests via non-compete agreements.
      - Texas law allows enforceability of non-compete agreements, provided they are reasonable in terms of time, geography, and scope.

  • Definition of enforceability based on the statute and relevant cases:
      - Example cited: Vasquez v. Vasquez, where nationwide geographic coverage was deemed reasonable due to the nature of business.

Lexis Research Assignment Example

  • Scenario involving employee arbitration policies:
      - Lexis used to find cases involving inadequate notice of arbitration agreements, specifically Doe v. Columbia North Hills.

  • Analysis of case signals in Lexis showing treatment by subsequent courts.

Secondary Sources Research

  • Scenario: Trademark issues with logo usage:
      - Texas courts’ approach to trademarks involves likelihood of confusion due to similar marks.

  • Reference to factors considered by courts in the Seventh Circuit, with examples from relevant cases.

Administrative Agencies

  • Overview of administrative agencies and their functions:
      - Quasi-Legislative: Powers to create regulations.
      - Quasi-Judicial: Powers to adjudicate disputes.

  • Agencies are established by enabling statutes that define their authority and mission.

  • Examples of enabling statutes discussed:
      - 6 USC 111 - Establishment of the Department of Homeland Security.
      - 42 USC 3532 - Establishment of the Department of Housing and Urban Development.

Key Federal Statutes Impacting Agencies

  • Administrative Procedures Act: Grants public participation in rule-making processes.

  • Freedom of Information Act: Access to agency materials.

  • Sunshine Act: Requirements for open meetings by agencies.

  • Federal Register Act: Outlines regulation publication before codification.

Federal Register and Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)

  • Explanation of the purpose of the Federal Register and CFR:
      - Federal Register publishes daily updates and notices from agencies.
      - CFR organizes finalized regulations by topic.

  • Distinction that titles in the CFR and the U.S. Code are not parallel.

Conducting Administrative Research

  • Techniques for using the CFR:
      - Browsing vs. searching: Browsing may lead to incomplete research results, while searching provides targeted access.

  • Use of the CFR index for efficient research guidance.
      - Example search for discrimination regulations explained.

Free Resources for Regulations

  • Introduction to govinfo.gov: A public resource for accessing legal materials including CFR and legislative documents, albeit less frequently updated than paid legal research tools.

  • Electronic CFR (eCFR): Updated frequently and offers direct access similar to Westlaw and Lexis.

  • Federal Register online: Focused on rule-making processes and public notices.

  • Resources where you can submit comments on proposed rules: regulations.gov.

Final Research Strategy Discussion

  • Reminder of overarching research strategies:
      - Iterative nature: Research continues until no new information is found.
      - TARP framework for research (Things, Actions, People, Places).

  • Importance of reliability, authority, and suitability of sources.

Conclusion

  • Recap of the semester and class closure.

  • Open floor for final questions, with emphasis on the importance of communication post-class.