Chapter 15: Persuasive Speaking
Edward Murrow & Persuasive Speaking
Quote: "To be persuasive, we must be believable. To be believable, we must be credible. To be credible, we must be truthful."
Edward Murrow:
Founding father of broadcast journalism and mass communication.
Born in the early 1900s, significant figure in radio broadcasting, later television.
Known for opposing McCarthyism, challenging Senator John McCarthy's accusations against individuals in the US (calling them communists).
Served as a watchdog of government actions.
Importance of credibility in persuasive speaking:
Speak on issues you believe in, supported by reason, logic, character, and emotions.
Focus of the lecture: Understanding persuasion and making persuasive appeals.
Understanding Persuasion
Definition:
Persuasion is the process of influencing others.
Goal is to motivate the audience to do, think, or believe something new or change existing beliefs.
Final speech component: Make an argument and appeals to your audience.
Aim to influence your audience.
Components of Persuasion
Building blocks of persuasive process:
Creating appeals
Constructing arguments
Appeals:
Request made to influence individuals or groups.
Example scenario: Requesting leniency from a professor due to a doctor's appointment.
Arguments:
Utilize reason and logic; constructing a claim based on evidence to support it.
Both appeals and arguments need to be incorporated in the final speech.
Important distinction:
All arguments are appeals, but not all appeals are arguments.
Ethics of Persuasion
Importance of ethics in persuasion:
Ethical considerations define the speaker's character and affect persuasive strategies.
Key ethical guidelines:
Be honest:
Avoid shading the truth. Acknowledge statistics that don’t fully support your argument.
Honesty fosters trust and respect.
Empower your audience:
Persuasion should inspire rather than coerce.
Coercion is defined by threats and deceptions, contrasting with effective persuasive techniques.
Psychological Considerations in Persuasion
Recap on the psychology of persuasion and audience disposition:
Use both reasoning and emotional appeals.
Recognize the importance of inspiring emotions in the audience.
Think about what emotions to invoke:
Low emotions (shame, sadness) to high emotions (joy, hope).
Aristotle’s rhetorical triangle (ethos, pathos, logos):
Ethos: Character and credibility of the speaker.
Pathos: Emotional appeal.
Logos: Logical reasoning, support through evidence (statistics, expert testimony).
Importance of combining logic and emotion in persuasion:
Excessive reliance on emotional appeal can be ineffective or manipulative.
The Role of Ethos in Persuasion
Definition of ethos: The audience's perception of the speaker’s wisdom and character.
Ways to build ethos:
Presenting yourself well.
Being organized, experienced, and sincere.
Establishing goodwill towards the audience.
Your demeanor and self-concept will impact audience perception.
Audience Needs
Connect persuasive message to human needs using Maslow's hierarchy:
Understand the audience's level of needs (physiological, safety, love/belonging, self-esteem, self-actualization).
Example: Experiences shared about grandmother's understanding of children's needs.
Importance of meeting basic needs before addressing higher-level needs.
Consider audience demographics and psychological states when designing speeches.
Emotional Appeals: Justification & Ethics
Importance of justified emotional appeals:
Consider if it inspires trust or loyalty.
Support emotional appeals with reasoning to counter distrust.
Various types of emotional appeals to caution against:
Fear appeals:
Example: Tooth whiteners or security systems that exploit fear.
Propaganda:
Stay clear of highly unethical approaches that manipulate audience emotions.
False advertising:
Avoid making unfounded claims.
Summary & Closing Thoughts
Recap of important concepts: Understanding persuasion, ethos, logos, pathos.
Ethical consideration is essential in persuasive speaking.
Strategy: "Don't raise your voice; improve your argument."