Chapter 15: Persuasive Speaking

Edward Murrow & Persuasive Speaking

  • Quote: "To be persuasive, we must be believable. To be believable, we must be credible. To be credible, we must be truthful."

  • Edward Murrow:

    • Founding father of broadcast journalism and mass communication.

    • Born in the early 1900s, significant figure in radio broadcasting, later television.

    • Known for opposing McCarthyism, challenging Senator John McCarthy's accusations against individuals in the US (calling them communists).

    • Served as a watchdog of government actions.

  • Importance of credibility in persuasive speaking:

    • Speak on issues you believe in, supported by reason, logic, character, and emotions.

    • Focus of the lecture: Understanding persuasion and making persuasive appeals.

Understanding Persuasion

  • Definition:

    • Persuasion is the process of influencing others.

    • Goal is to motivate the audience to do, think, or believe something new or change existing beliefs.

  • Final speech component: Make an argument and appeals to your audience.

    • Aim to influence your audience.

Components of Persuasion

  • Building blocks of persuasive process:

    1. Creating appeals

    2. Constructing arguments

  • Appeals:

    • Request made to influence individuals or groups.

    • Example scenario: Requesting leniency from a professor due to a doctor's appointment.

  • Arguments:

    • Utilize reason and logic; constructing a claim based on evidence to support it.

    • Both appeals and arguments need to be incorporated in the final speech.

    • Important distinction:

    • All arguments are appeals, but not all appeals are arguments.

Ethics of Persuasion

  • Importance of ethics in persuasion:

    • Ethical considerations define the speaker's character and affect persuasive strategies.

  • Key ethical guidelines:

    1. Be honest:

    • Avoid shading the truth. Acknowledge statistics that don’t fully support your argument.

    • Honesty fosters trust and respect.

    1. Empower your audience:

    • Persuasion should inspire rather than coerce.

    • Coercion is defined by threats and deceptions, contrasting with effective persuasive techniques.

Psychological Considerations in Persuasion

  • Recap on the psychology of persuasion and audience disposition:

    • Use both reasoning and emotional appeals.

    • Recognize the importance of inspiring emotions in the audience.

    • Think about what emotions to invoke:

    • Low emotions (shame, sadness) to high emotions (joy, hope).

  • Aristotle’s rhetorical triangle (ethos, pathos, logos):

    • Ethos: Character and credibility of the speaker.

    • Pathos: Emotional appeal.

    • Logos: Logical reasoning, support through evidence (statistics, expert testimony).

  • Importance of combining logic and emotion in persuasion:

    • Excessive reliance on emotional appeal can be ineffective or manipulative.

The Role of Ethos in Persuasion

  • Definition of ethos: The audience's perception of the speaker’s wisdom and character.

  • Ways to build ethos:

    • Presenting yourself well.

    • Being organized, experienced, and sincere.

    • Establishing goodwill towards the audience.

    • Your demeanor and self-concept will impact audience perception.

Audience Needs

  • Connect persuasive message to human needs using Maslow's hierarchy:

    • Understand the audience's level of needs (physiological, safety, love/belonging, self-esteem, self-actualization).

    • Example: Experiences shared about grandmother's understanding of children's needs.

    • Importance of meeting basic needs before addressing higher-level needs.

  • Consider audience demographics and psychological states when designing speeches.

Emotional Appeals: Justification & Ethics

  • Importance of justified emotional appeals:

    • Consider if it inspires trust or loyalty.

    • Support emotional appeals with reasoning to counter distrust.

  • Various types of emotional appeals to caution against:

    1. Fear appeals:

    • Example: Tooth whiteners or security systems that exploit fear.

    1. Propaganda:

    • Stay clear of highly unethical approaches that manipulate audience emotions.

    1. False advertising:

    • Avoid making unfounded claims.

Summary & Closing Thoughts

  • Recap of important concepts: Understanding persuasion, ethos, logos, pathos.

  • Ethical consideration is essential in persuasive speaking.

  • Strategy: "Don't raise your voice; improve your argument."