CMAC-F

Foundations and Process of Public Speaking

Public speaking is an organized, face-to-face, prepared, intentional attempt to inform, entertain, or persuade a group of people (typically five or more) through words, physical delivery, and visual or audio aids. It is characterized by the speaker holding the primary focus of attention for a specific period.

Early twentieth-century public speaking scholars Edwin Du Bois Shurter and James Albert Winans described public speaking as an "enlarged conversation." As an enlarged conversation, it shares key communication elements with informal dialogue:

  • Awareness of and sensitivity toward the audience.

  • An exchange of explicit content messages (facts, information) and less explicit relationship messages (trust, respect, liking).

  • Dependence on nonverbal feedback to gauge audience comprehension.

  • Face-to-face interaction rather than mediated delivery.

Public speaking differs from everyday conversation in its higher level of purposefulness, formal organizational structure (such as clear introductions and main points), projected delivery (louder volume, greater energy), and reliance on researched evidence beyond personal experience.

Glossophobia and Speech Anxiety

Glossophobia, derived from the Greek roots for "tongue" (glossa) and "fear or dread" (phobos), refers to a severe fear of public speaking. Physical symptoms include mouth dryness, weak vocal projection, body tremors, sweating, blushing, and rapid heart rate. In clinical psychology, a phobia is defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual IV (DSM-IV) as a state of significant and persistent fear experienced when in the presence of, or anticipating, a specific object, place, or situation.

According to the 1993 Bruskin-Goldring Research Report, 45%45\% of 1,0001{,}000 surveyed subjects identified speaking before a group as their primary fear. Research from the University of Wisconsin-Stout identifies three cognitive misperceptions driving speech anxiety:

  1. All-or-Nothing Thinking: The mindset that falling short of absolute perfection constitutes total failure.

  2. Overgeneralization: Believing that a single negative outcome represents a universal pattern of failure.

  3. Fortune Telling: Anticipating a negative outcome regardless of the amount of preparation or practice.

Psychologist Carol Dweck demonstrates that skills and intelligence are not fixed traits but are malleable—open to growth through effort and practice. Accepting a growth mindset allows speakers to view obstacles as opportunities for skill development rather than proof of an inborn deficit.

Public speaking anxiety also stems from two core psychological fears:

  • Fear of Failure: Rooted in past negative speaking experiences, lack of preparation, unfamiliarity with the context, or uncertainty regarding the speaking task.

  • Fear of Rejection: Rooted in the belief that the audience will reject the speaker's ideas or personhood. Overcoming this fear requires cultivating respect and empathy for the audience.

Anxiety Management Strategies
  • Mental Preparation: Reframe focus away from self-scrutiny and toward the audience and the message. Recognize that internal anxiety levels are rarely visible to listeners; an internal anxiety level perceived by the speaker as a 1717 on a 1010-point scale is typically perceived by the audience as a 33 or 44.

  • Physical Preparation: Secure adequate sleep, consume protein-based meals rather than processed sugars prior to speaking, wear comfortable clothing and supportive footwear, and execute physical tension-release exercises (such as stretching limbs and wide yawns).

  • Contextual Preparation: Visit the speaking venue in advance, test all electronic equipment, arrive early to eliminate rush-induced stress, and interact informally with audience members prior to the presentation.

  • Speech Preparation: Avoid procrastination. Conduct active, oral, repeated practice while standing, wearing shoes, using visual aids, and timing the delivery. Practice recording sessions from the waist up to analyze body language.

  • Nonverbal Adjustment: Striking a "power pose" (expansive posture with feet apart and hands on hips or raised overhead) for two minutes prior to speaking can alter physiological states and boost confidence.

The Communication Process and Models

Human communication is defined as the sharing of meaning between two or more people. It consists of seven core elements:

  1. People: Senders (originators of messages) and receivers (listeners/decoders).

  2. Context: The environment surrounding the communication act, which includes:

    • Historical Context: Previous interactions and relationships between communicators.

    • Cultural Context: The system of learned and shared symbols, language, values, and norms distinguishing groups.

    • Social Context: The nature of the relationship (e.g., instructor-student, employer-employee).

    • Physical Context: The environmental attributes of the location (temperature, seating, lighting).

  3. Message: The verbal and nonverbal content being transmitted.

  4. Channel: the means through which a message travels from sender to receiver. Face-to-face communication is a "rich" channel (transmitting multiple verbal and nonverbal cues simultaneously), whereas text-based communication is a "lean" channel.

  5. Feedback: Direct or indirect verbal and nonverbal responses sent from the receiver back to the sender to signal understanding, agreement, or disinterest.

  6. Noise: Interruptions or interference in the communication process, categorized as:

    • Contextual Noise: Physical environment distractions.

    • Physical Noise: Physiological states of the sender or receiver (illness, fatigue).

    • Psychological Noise: Internal mental distractions, stress, or prejudice.

    • Semantic Noise: Differing interpretations of words, symbols, or jargon.

  7. Outcome: The change in audience knowledge, attitudes, or behaviors, or the alteration of the social context resulting from the message.

Communication models illustrate these dynamics. Early linear models (such as Shannon and Weaver's 1949 model) viewed communication as a one-way transmission. Modern public speaking relies on a transactional model, which emphasizes the simultaneous sending and receiving of messages and the co-creation of meaning.

Communication theorist Em Griffin contrasted communication models using three game metaphors:

  • Bowling: Linear transmission where the speaker throws a message at an audience to knock them down; the audience merely reacts.

  • Table Tennis (Ping-Pong): Interactive back-and-forth exchange where the primary objective is to win.

  • Charades / Pictionary: Transactional and collaborative process where participants work together using feedback and trial-and-error to achieve mutual understanding.

Communication is a symbolic process. A symbol is a word, icon, picture, object, or number used to represent a concept, object, or experience. Symbols carry both denotative meanings (the objective, literal dictionary definition shared by speakers of a language) and connotative meanings (the subjective, emotional, or cultural associations evoked by a word).

Classical Rhetorical Origins and the Canons of Rhetoric

Formal study of public address originated thousands of years ago. Systematized study of rhetoric developed in ancient Greece during the fifth and fourth centuries BCE under scholars such as Corax, Tisias, Plato, Isocrates, and Aristotle. Rhetorical traditions also developed independently in ancient China (Confucius, Han Fei Tzu), India (Buddha), and Egypt.

Marcus Tullius Cicero (106–43106\text{--}43 BCE), a Roman statesman and orator, codified the process of public speaking into the Five Canons of Rhetoric:

  1. Invention (inventio): Discovering and creating the arguments, topics, and evidence for a speech.

  2. Disposition (dispositio): Structuring and organizing the arguments logically.

  3. Style (elocutio): Selecting the appropriate vocabulary, clarity, and rhetorical devices.

  4. Memory (memoria): Mastering the speech content through rehearsal and mental retention.

  5. Delivery (pronuntiatio): Managing nonverbal behavior, vocal projection, pitch, rate, and physical gestures.

Personal, Educational, and Professional Value

Employer surveys consistently rank oral communication skills among the top attributes desired in job candidates (Smith, 2022). A study conducted at Dalton State College indicated that 72%72\% of 341341 graduating seniors agreed that skills learned in introductory public speaking transferred directly to success in upper-division coursework (Tucker, Kinkead, & Self, 2019).

A 2017 Strada-Gallup survey of 86,93586{,}935 U.S. adults revealed that 58%58\% identified career advancement as their primary reason for pursuing higher education, while 23%23\% cited the acquisition of knowledge. Public speaking equips individuals to participate in civil society, advocate for community policy, and articulate personal values.

Key underlying communication principles include:

  • Dual Dimensions: All human communication operates on two simultaneous levels—content (facts, data, information) and relationship (trust, respect, credibility) (Watzlawick, Beavin, & Jackson, 1967).

  • Introversion and Extraversion: Introverts comprise up to 50%50\% of the population (Buettner, 2012). While extraverts may feel comfortable before crowds, they may under-prepare; introverts often excel through thorough preparation and structured execution.

Chapter 2

Audience Analysis, Demographics, and Psychographics

Audience-centered speaking requires analyzing listeners before, during, and after a speech to adapt the content, organization, and delivery to their specific characteristics and needs.

Demographic Characteristics

Demographic analysis examines the outward, observable characteristics of an audience. When conducting demographic analysis, speakers must avoid two logical errors:

  • Stereotyping: Generalizing about a group and assuming that every individual in that group possesses a specific trait.

  • Totalizing: Reducing an individual or group to a single characteristic, making it the sum total of who they are.

Eleven core demographic variables inform audience analysis:

  1. Age: Audience age influences cultural references, historical knowledge, and life priorities. According to the National Center for Education Statistics (2019), over 37%37\% of U.S. college students are over the age of 2525.

  2. Gender: Gender roles and communication patterns are socialized. Deborah Tannen (2007) notes that women often utilize a "rapport" style (expressive, detail-oriented, collaborative, inductive), whereas men frequently favor a "report" style (informational, direct, deductive, advice-offering). Speakers must avoid gender stereotypes and use inclusive language.

  3. Race, Ethnicity, and Culture: Race is a social construct rather than a biological reality. Ethnicity refers to shared cultural heritage, national origin, or language. Audiences may be homogeneous (highly similar across demographic traits) or heterogeneous (diverse across multiple traits).

  4. Religion: Religious affiliation varies widely; Pew Research (2015) indicates that approximately 23%23\% of U.S. adults identify as religiously unaffiliated ("nones"). Speakers should avoid assuming shared religious beliefs.

  5. Group Affiliation: Membership in political parties, labor unions, civic clubs, or professional associations indicates shared values and commitments.

  6. Region: Geographic origin (Northeast, South, Midwest, West) and residence type (urban, suburban, rural) shape perspectives, local concerns, and access to resources.

  7. Occupation: An audience's professional background dictates their familiarity with specialized vocabulary and their industry-specific interests.

  8. Education: Educational attainment influences general knowledge and exposure to academic disciplines. Angela Duckworth (2016) links educational completion to grit (perseverance and passion for long-term goals).

  9. Socio-economic Level: Income level and financial stability influence audience perspectives on economic policies, purchasing power, and lifestyle choices.

  10. Sexual Orientation: Recognizing LGBTQ+ identity requires avoiding heteronormative assumptions and using inclusive terminology such as "partner" or "spouse."

  11. Family Status: Whether listeners are single, married, divorced, or parents directly affects their life priorities and financial concerns.

Speakers must also consider disability and neurodiversity, adopting respectful, person-first language.

Psychographic Characteristics

Psychographic analysis examines the internal psychological characteristics of an audience, comprising four distinct constructs:

  1. Beliefs: Statements that individuals hold to be true (Bem, 1970). Beliefs are derived from personal experience and trusted sources. The difficulty of changing a belief depends on four factors:

    • Stability: How long the belief has been held.

    • Centrality: How deeply the belief is tied to the individual's identity.

    • Saliency: How frequently the individual thinks about the belief.

    • Strength: The amount of experiential or intellectual evidence supporting the belief.

  2. Attitudes: Stable positive or negative evaluative responses to a person, object, idea, or policy (Myers, 2012). Attitudes drive behavior and are formed through experiences, peer groups, and underlying beliefs.

  3. Values: Core goals and ideals that people consider desirable and important (e.g., freedom, equality, security, achievement). Values motivate behavior and provide the criteria by which actions are judged.

  4. Needs: Important physical or psychological deficiencies that motivate human behavior. Abraham Maslow (1943) conceptualized human motivation as a five-tiered hierarchy:


Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs
  • Physiological Needs: Air, food, water, sleep, homeostasis, excretion.

  • Safety Needs: Physical security, employment, resources, health, property.

  • Love / Belongingness Needs: Friendship, family, intimacy, social connection.

  • Esteem Needs: Self-esteem, confidence, achievement, respect of others, respect by others.

  • Self-Actualization Needs: Morality, creativity, spontaneity, problem-solving, altruism.

Maslow's model posits that lower-level physiological and safety needs must be substantially satisfied before individuals are motivated by higher-level esteem and self-actualization needs. Speakers must address both "real" needs (vital survival deficiencies) and "felt" needs (strong perceived wants).

Contextual Factors

Contextual audience analysis involves assessing the physical and situational constraints of the speech event:

  • Time Allocation: Strictly adhering to assigned time limits demonstrates respect for the audience and preparation.

  • Time of Day: Audience alertness varies throughout the day (e.g., early morning vs. mid-afternoon).

  • Reason for Gathering: Understanding whether audience attendance is voluntary or mandatory influences the speaker's approach to gaining attention.

  • Physical Space: Room size, seating arrangement, temperature, lighting, and audiovisual infrastructure.

  • Audience Size: Larger audiences require greater vocal projection, larger physical gestures, and more formal visual aids.

  • Audience Expectations: The formal norms and expectations associated with the specific event or venue.

Listening Mechanics, Barriers, and Improvement Strategies

Listening is an active, intentional psychological process of receiving, attending to, understanding, evaluating, and responding to a message. It is distinct from hearing, which is a passive, physiological process of sound waves striking the eardrum and sending electrochemical impulses to the brain.

Types of Listening

  1. Comprehensive Listening: Focuses on understanding, processing, and retaining information from a message.

  2. Empathetic Listening: Focuses on understanding the feelings, motivations, and emotional states of another person to provide support.

  3. Appreciative Listening: Focuses on enjoying and appreciating an aesthetic performance, music, or literature.

  4. Critical Listening: Focuses on analyzing, evaluating, and judging the validity, logic, and evidence of a message.

Barriers to Effective Listening

  • Processing Speed Differential: The human brain can process spoken information at approximately 200200     words per minute (wpm), whereas the average oral speaking rate is 100–120 wpm100\text{--}120\,\text{wpm} (Foulke, 1968; Barnard, 2018). This lag time allows the mind to wander.

  • Attention Capacity and Cognitive Overload: Constant electronic distractions and environmental noise reduce sustained focus.

  • Confirmation Bias: The tendency to search for, interpret, favor, and recall information in a way that confirms pre-existing beliefs (Nickerson, 1998).

  • Prejudgment: Dismissing a speaker or topic prior to hearing the full argument based on superficial traits, delivery style, or initial disagreement.

  • Physical and Mental Distractions: Fatigue, hunger, ambient room noise, or co-listener disruptions.

Strategies for Improving Listening and Retention

Speakers assist listener comprehension through planned redundancy—the intentional repetition and restatement of structural elements (preview, transitions, internal summaries, and conclusion reviews) throughout the speech.

Listeners can improve comprehension through:

  • Active Note-Taking: Taking longhand notes using pen and paper results in superior conceptual processing and retention compared to typing notes on a laptop (Mueller & Oppenheimer, 2014).

  • Mindful Focus: Eliminating electronic devices and sitting near the front of the room to minimize visual distractions.

  • Formulating Questions: Engaging the mind during natural pauses by formulating critical questions regarding the speaker's evidence and claims.


Chapter 3

Communication Ethics, Credibility, and Plagiarism

Ethics is the branch of philosophy involving determinations of what is right, moral, and good. Ethical public speaking requires respecting audience members, presenting truthful information, citing sources accurately, and encouraging informed decision-making.

Legal, Cultural, and Philosophical Foundations

  • First Amendment: Guarantees freedom of speech and expression. Constitutional scholar Thomas Emerson (1970) argued that freedom of expression is essential to individual self-fulfillment and democratic self-governance. John Milton's Areopagitica (1644) established the concept of the "free marketplace of ideas."

  • Legal Exceptions: Speech is restricted in cases of defamation (false statements of fact damaging character or reputation - U.S. Dept. of State, 2013), true threats against public officials, or speech directly inciting imminent lawless action.

  • Philosophical Frameworks:

    • Plato vs. Aristotle: Plato criticized rhetoric for making false arguments appear superior; Aristotle responded in Rhetoric by framing public address as a practical art governed by logic and ethics.

    • Quintilian: Defined the ethical orator as "the good man speaking well."

    • Utilitarianism (John Stuart Mill & Jeremy Bentham): Ethical actions are those that produce the greatest good for the greatest number of people.

    • Pragmatism (Charles Sanders Peirce): Actions are evaluated by their practical outcomes.

    • Categorical Imperative (Immanuel Kant): Act only according to maxims that you would will to become universal laws.

    • Existentialism (Jean-Paul Sartre): Individuals are freely responsible for their choices and the ethical consequences of those choices.

    • Discourse Ethics (Jürgen Habermas): Emphasizes equal opportunity for participation and uncoerced consensus in communication.

Speaker Credibility (Ethos)

Aristotle defined ethos as the speaker's character, wisdom, and goodwill. Modern communication scholars view credibility as an audience attitude comprising four dimensions:

  1. Similarity: Perceived common ground, values, and experiences shared between speaker and audience.

  2. Character: Perceived honesty, integrity, and moral uprightness.

  3. Competence: Perceived expertise, knowledge, and skill regarding the topic.

  4. Goodwill: Perceived intent to act in the best interest of the audience.

Credibility shifts across three stages (McCroskey, 2006):

  • Initial Credibility: The perception of the speaker's credibility before the speech begins.

  • Derived Credibility: The credibility generated throughout the delivery of the speech based on evidence, reasoning, and nonverbal behavior.

  • Terminal Credibility: The final credibility rating assigned to the speaker at the conclusion of the presentation.

Plagiarism and Source Attribution

Plagiarism is the act of using another person's words, ideas, or intellectual property without proper attribution. WriteCheck / Plagiarism.org identifies six primary forms of plagiarism:

  1. Submitting another person's work as your own.

  2. Copying words or ideas without giving credit.

  3. Failing to place exact quoted language within quotation marks.

  4. Providing incorrect source citation details.

  5. Patchwriting (changing words while retaining the original sentence structure without attribution).

  6. Over-relying on source material such that it constitutes the majority of the work, regardless of attribution.

Three Levels of Plagiarism
  • Stealing: Wholesale theft of an entire paper, outline, or speech from an online mill, classmate, or outside source. Includes self-plagiarism (submitting work previously submitted in another class without permission).

  • Sneaking: Patchwriting or cutting and pasting snippets from multiple online sources into a composite text while omitting citations.

  • Borrowing: Failing to properly paraphrase or summarize borrowed ideas, or failing to provide proper oral attribution for data and concepts.

Oral Source Attribution

Unlike written papers utilizing parenthetical citations, oral speech citations must be integrated seamlessly prior to the presented information. Effective oral citations include:

  1. Name of the author / expert.

  2. Credentials or authority of the source.

  3. Title of the publication or sponsoring organization.

  4. Date of publication.

Example: "According to Dr. Samuel Jones, Head of Cardiology at Vanderbilt University, in a 2017 article published in the Journal of the American Medical Association…"

Common knowledge (facts widely known and verified across multiple sources, such as freezing temperatures of water) does not require citation, whereas unique facts, specific statistics, and proprietary research must be cited.

Venues of Public Discourse

  • Debate: Formal competitive structure utilizing propositions. Academic debate features equal, timed speeches (e.g., First Affirmative Constructive [8 min], First Negative Constructive [8 min], Rebuttals [4 min]) to evaluate arguments based on evidence and logic.

  • Town Hall Meetings: Public gatherings where elected or organizational leaders interact directly with constituents to answer questions and gather feedback.

  • Public Forums: Designated spaces where free speech is protected (Perry Education Association v. Perry Local Educators' Association, 1983 classified forums into traditional, designated, and nonpublic).

  • Panels and Symposia: Panels involve an informal moderated discussion among experts before an audience; symposia feature a series of formal, distinct presentations by experts on subtopics of a central theme.

Speech Development: Topic, Purpose, and Central Idea

Formulating the Specific Purpose Statement

Speech preparation begins by narrowing a general purpose (to inform, to persuade, to entertain/inspire) into a specific purpose. The specific purpose statement is a single, clear, infinitive phrase stating precisely what the speech intends to accomplish.

[Specific Communication Word] + [Target Audience] + [Content Goal]

Example: "To inform my classmates of the three primary causes of the 2014 Ebola outbreak in West Africa."

A specific purpose statement must be:

  • A single, grammatically correct infinitive phrase (never a question).

  • Focused on one single idea (avoiding the conjunction "and" to combine two subjects).

  • Consistent with the general purpose (informative statements must not use persuasive language).

  • Specific and manageable within the assigned time limits.

  • Relevant to the audience's interests and needs (WIIFMWIIFM).

Formulating the Central Idea Statement

The central idea statement (also termed the thesis statement) is a single, complete declarative sentence that summarizes the core argument, topic, and main points of the speech. It is delivered orally near the end of the introduction.

Example: "When elderly individuals lose their animal companions, they experience significant psychological, emotional, and physical effects."

Unlike an essay thesis, a speech central idea statement can use personal pronouns (II, wewe, youyou) and preview the main structural divisions of the speech.

Specific Purpose Statement

Central Idea Statement

Infinitive Phrase ("To inform my audience…")

Complete Declarative Sentence

Written for speaker/instructor planning

Spoken aloud to the audience in the introduction

Unspoken during the speech

Explicitly stated near the end of the intro

Single, un-compounded focus

Summarizes the core thesis and main points

Researching Speeches and Source Evaluation

Primary vs. Secondary Sources

  • Primary Sources: Firsthand, original evidence or raw data produced by direct participants or researchers (e.g., empirical study results, historical documents, letters, interviews, census data).

  • Secondary Sources: Works that analyze, interpret, summarize, or evaluate primary sources (e.g., textbook chapters, magazine articles, review essays).


Primary vs Secondary Sources by Discipline

Library and Database Search Strategies

Library catalogs (such as GIL-Find) and subscription databases (such as GALILEO, Academic Search Complete, and Opposing Viewpoints Resource Center) provide access to peer-reviewed academic journals, periodicals, and e-books.


Database Advanced Search Interface

Search optimization techniques include:

  • Exact Phrase Search: Placing phrases in quotation marks ("attention deficit disorder") to ensure words are searched in exact sequence.

  • Boolean Operators:

    • AND: Narrows results by requiring both terms.

    • OR: Broadens results by accepting either term.

    • NOT: Excludes specific unwanted terms.

  • Truncation: Using an asterisk (medica*) to search all words stemming from a root (medical, medication, medicare).

Evaluating Online Information: SIFT Framework

To evaluate web-based sources, Mike Caulfield recommends the SIFT framework:

  1. Stop: Pause before trusting or sharing information.

  2. Investigate the Source: Determine the authority and expertise of the author or publishing entity.

  3. Find Better Coverage: Look for consensus or coverage across established, trusted fact-checking platforms (FactCheck.org, PolitiFact, Snopes).

  4. Trace Claims to the Original Context: Go "upstream" to locate the original primary research paper or document to verify if it was accurately represented.

Note on Wikipedia: Wikipedia is a general reference source suitable for initial background orientation, but it is not a acceptable peer-reviewed source for college-level speech citations. Use the references cited at the bottom of Wikipedia pages to locate primary and secondary sources.

Conducting Primary Research

  • Surveys: Gathering quantitative data from a target group. Surveys should utilize objective, non-biased, closed-ended questions (multiple-choice, Likert scales, yes/no) rather than open-ended questions.

  • Interviews: Conducting qualitative interviews with subject matter experts. Interviewers should research the topic beforehand, prepare open-ended questions, arrive on time, respect time limits, and send a formal thank-you note afterward.

Speech Organization, Outlining, and Connective Statements

Principles of Organization

Short-term memory capacity is limited. George Miller (1956) identified the magical number $$7 egin{matrix} egin{small