Fluency Disorders
Normal Fluency and Disfluency
- Fluency:
- Speech is effortless in nature.
- Easy, rapid, rhythmical, even-flowing.
- Disfluency:
- Marked by word or phrase repetitions, interjections, pauses, and revisions.
- Normal speakers produce disfluencies some of the time.
Fluency Disorders
- Stuttering:
- Unusual, tense disfluencies that interfere with communication.
- Most common form of fluency impairment.
- Acquired/neurogenic stuttering:
- Adulthood, brain damage, or emotional trauma.
- Cluttering:
- Rapid bursts of dysrhythmic, unintelligible speech.
What is Stuttering?
- Unusually high frequency or durations of repetitions, prolongations, and/or blocks (tense moments when voicing/air flow interrupted).
- Excessive mental and physical effort to resume talking.
- Lose train of thought, focus on stuttering.
- Negative perceptions of communication abilities.
- Low self-esteem.
- Internalize negative reactions of others.
Primary Stuttering Behaviors (Core Behaviors)
- Part-word repetitions:
- Syllables (with or without schwa vowel).
- Interjections (“uh”/ “um”).
- Phonemes (“baseb,b,b,ball”).
- Prolongations:
- vvvvvvvvvvvan
- Blocks:
- Silent prolongations.
- Get “stuck”.
Secondary Stuttering Behaviors
- Counterproductive behaviors as people try to avoid primary stuttering behaviors.
- Looking away.
- Open jaw.
- Purse lips.
- Eye blinks.
- Facial grimaces.
- Change words.
- Limb movements.
- Become more automatic.
- Are more distracting than primary behaviors.
How Often Does Stuttering Occur?
- Ratio of male stutters: female stutters is 3:1.
- Prevalence: 1%.
- Incidence: 5%.
Individual Variability
- Typical duration ~ 3 sec, can be longer.
- Peaks and valleys of fluency --> frustration.
- Pressure to be fluent --> greater dysfluencies.
- May be fluent when:
- Singing.
- Using pretend voices.
- Talking to babies or animals.
Differences Between Stutterers and Nonstutterers
- Self-concept.
- Language abilities.
- Motor systems
- Voice Onset Time
- Neurological differences:
- More activation in right hemisphere speech and language areas.
- More activation in the cerebellum.
- Less activation in left hemisphere speech and language areas.
Myths About Stuttering
- Stuttering is a nervous reaction.
- General anxiety levels, relaxation therapies not effective.
- Increase anxiety may increase stuttering, not underlying cause.
- Overly Sensitive Parents.
- Speech style and rate of speech.
- Parental anxieties, overprotectiveness.
- Overly critical?
How to interact with a person who stutters
- Maintain reasonable eye contact.
- Do not finish his or her words or sentences.
- Do not interrupt.
- Pay attention to what the person is saying, not how he or she is saying it.
- Pause at least 1 second prior to responding.
- Do not allow common stereotypes to override your opinion of the person who stutters.
Current Thinking About Etiology
- Dynamic Relationships Between
- Inherited traits:
- Temperament, cognitive abilities, language abilities, attention, perception, speech motor control.
- External conditions:
- Parental Expectations, relationships with others, child-rearing practices, educational experiences.
- Inherited traits:
Development of Stuttering
- Usually gradual - Sometimes develops suddenly.
- Genetic predisposition - 15% first-degree relatives.
- Balance between demands and capacities.
- Neurological development
- Language development
- Emotional constancy
Indicators of Early Stuttering in Children
- An average of 3 or more sound repetitions, prolongations, or blocks per 100 words.
- An average of 3 or more stuttering-like disfluencies (i.e., single-syllable-word repetitions, syllable repetitions, sound repetitions, prolongations, or blocks) per 100 words.
- Seventy-two percent or more stuttering-like disfluencies per total disfluencies.
- Twenty-five percent or more of the total disfluencies are prolongations or blocks.
- Instances in which repetitions, prolongations, or blocks occur in adjacent sounds or syllables within a word.
- Increases in the rate and irregularity of repetitions.
- Signs of excess tension or struggle during moments of disfluency.
- Secondary behaviors such as eye blinks, facial tics, or interjections immediately before or during disfluencies.
- Feelings of frustration about disfluencies.
Chronic Stuttering
- Chronic stuttering – continues from childhood into adolescence/adulthood.
- Contributing factors:
- Negative feelings and attitudes (self-conscious, out of control).
- Avoidance (phonemes, situations).
- Difficulties with speech motor control (unusual breathing patterns).
- Difficulties with language formulation (phonology/semantics/syntax).
Assessment
- Interviews and Case History
- Speech Samples
- Language Development
- Consistency
- Adaptation
- Feeling and Attitudes
- Trial Therapy
Measures
- Non-stuttering disfluencies (phrase repetitions, revisions) vs stuttering disfluencies
- Frequency of Stuttering
- 500 Total Words, 76 words were stuttered on. %
- Percentage of each disfluency type
- 76 words were stuttered on, 21 words contained sound prolongations. % prolongations
Treatment - Stuttering Modification
- Van Riper, 1973
- MIDVAS
- Motivation
- Identification
- Desensitization
- Variation
- Approximation
- Cancellations
- Pull-outs
- Preparatory Sets
- Stabilization
Treatment - Fluency Shaping
- Change the way people talk – aim for stutter-free speech
- Control rate, onset, transitions, phrasing
- Airflow therapy
- Gradual Increase in Length and Complexity of Utterances (GILCU)
- Aim to integrate Stuttering Modification and Fluency Shaping
Stuttering Modification Versus Fluency Shaping
- Stuttering Modification
- Client is taught to stutter less and more easily.
- Speech is more natural.
- Considerable focus on attitudes and negative reactions to speaking situations.
- Fluency Shaping
- Client is taught to have stutter-free speech.
- Loss of speech naturalness.
- Little to no attention given to attitudes, negative reactions, and so on.
Key Terms and Concepts
- Fluency vs disfluency
- Stuttering vs cluttering
- Repetitions, prolongations, and blocks
- Primary and secondary stuttering behaviors
- Prevalence and recovery rate
- Myths about stuttering
- Etiology and development of stuttering
- Assessment and measures
- Stuttering Modification vs fluency shaping