Comprehensive Study Guide: Language Origins, Design Features, Diversity, and Comparative Animal Communication

Historical and Theoretical Foundations of Language Origins

  • Timeline of Human Language Development

    • Spoken language is hypothesized to have emerged between 100,000100,000 and 50,00050,000 years ago.

    • Simple vocal patterning, including hums, whispers, and grunts, evolved in the brain alongside all vertebrates. These rudimentary vocal patterns do not constitute language; rather, they align with basic animal communication systems.

    • Written language is significantly more recent than spoken language, emerging approximately 5,0005,000 years ago.

  • Divine Origins Theories

    • Numerous global cultures and religions attribute the origin of human speech to divine creation:

    • Sarasvati: The Hindu goddess of speech, learning, and knowledge, credited with creating the Sanskrit language, which serves as an ancestor or contributor to modern languages such as Gujarati, Hindustani, Punjabi, and Marathi.

    • The Tower of Babel: A story from the biblical Book of Genesis in which a unified human population speaking a single language attempted to build a city and a clay tower reaching heaven. God disrupted their construction by confusing their speech so that they could no longer understand one another, dispersing them across the Earth.

  • Historical Language Deprivation Experiments

    • Monarchs across history conducted isolation experiments on infants to discover the "original" or natural human language:

    • Pharaoh Psammetichus (Psamtik) (c. 2,500 b.c.e.2,500\text{ b.c.e.}): Placed two newborn infants in the care of a mute shepherd with orders that no words be spoken in their presence. When one infant uttered the word bekos (Phrygian for "bread"), Psammetichus concluded that Phrygian was the original language of humanity.

    • King James IV of Scotland (15001500): Sent a mute woman to reside on Inchkeith Island in the Firth of Forth accompanied by two newborn babies. King James claimed that the children spontaneously began speaking Hebrew, concluding it was the original language.

    • Mughal Emperor Akbar the Great: Ordered twelve infants to be raised in complete silence by mute nurses. The children developed no spoken language, producing only non-linguistic sounds.

    • Experimental Conclusion: Children do not spontaneously generate an established natural language in isolation. Language acquisition requires exposure to a language spoken within the immediate environment.

  • Otto Jespersen's Speculative Theories of Language Origin

    • In his 19221922 publication Language: Its Nature, Development and Origin, Danish linguist Otto Jespersen categorized classical hypotheses regarding the acoustic origins of human speech:


Portrait of Otto Jespersen
  • The Bow-Wow Theory:

    • Proposes that language originated from human attempts to imitate sounds heard in the natural environment.

    • Rooted in onomatopoeia (derived from Greek for "name-making").

    • Examples include animal noises (meow, oink, woof, chirp), impact and action sounds (bam, crash, thud, slap), and environmental or mechanical sounds (buzz, sizzle, tick-tock, splash).

  • The Pooh-Pooh Theory:

    • Proposes that language arose from involuntary instinctive ejaculations uttered by humans to express intense emotions such as pain, surprise, or disgust.

    • Examples include ouch!, ah!, wow!, yuck!, and aww!.

    • Critique/Limitation: Most emotional exclamations are produced during sudden intake of breath (ingressive airflow), whereas natural human speech relies almost exclusively on exhalation (egressive airflow).

  • The La-La Theory (Musical Source):

    • Suggests that language developed from melodic, song-like utterances used for social charm, emotional expression, or courtship, analogous to vocalizations in birds and whales.

    • Infant development demonstrates a prolonged period where adults and infants interact via single sounds and extended melodic sound sequences, utilizing intonation as non-verbal communication.

    • Intonation patterns develop in human infants prior to other structural aspects of language, enabling newborns to recognize the unique intonation of their mother's voice.

  • The Yo-He-Ho Theory (Social Interaction Source):

    • Frames language as a cooperative physical tool designed to coordinate collective labor and group activities (e.g., heavy lifting, hauling, digging).

    • Grounded in the premise that language is fundamentally social.

    • Critique/Limitation: Fails to explain the origin of abstract vocabulary, complex syntax, or non-cooperative communication.

Evolutionary, Anatomical, and Genetic Foundations

  • Physical Adaptations and Vocal Anatomy

    • Human speech articulation relies on anatomical adaptations evolved over millions of years:

    • Bipedalism: Upright posture reorganized the chest cavity, altering respiratory control and allowing for precise breath modulation during speech production. Bipedalism also freed the hands for complex manual manipulation and gesture.

    • Teeth, Lips, and Tongue: Human teeth are upright and evenly spaced (unlike the slanting teeth of apes), facilitating labiodental sounds. Lips possess intricate muscle control, while the human tongue is shorter, thicker, and more muscular, enabling dynamic adjustments within the oral cavity.

    • Pharynx and Vocal Tract Anatomy: The evolutionary lowering of the human larynx created a expanded pharyngeal cavity above the vocal folds, acting as a resonant chamber for distinct vowel sounds.


Comparative vocal tract anatomy of modern humans vs. Neanderthals and animals
  • Key structures in the human vocal tract include:

    • Nasal cavity, soft palate (velum), hard palate, tongue, pharynx, hyoid bone, larynx (voice box), epiglottis, vocal folds, trachea, and oesophagus.

    • Tool-Making and Gestural Origins

  • Speeched vocalizations developed alongside physical gestures. Fossil evidence demonstrates human right-handedness and systematic tool-making practices dating back as far as 2,000,0002,000,000 years ago.

  • Motor skills required for precise tool manipulation overlap with neural networks responsible for gestural and spoken sign systems.

    • Brain Lateralization

  • The human brain is lateralized, divided into left and right cerebral hemispheres with specialized functions.


Brain lateralization showing anterior cortex and motor cortex connections
  • The left hemisphere hosts vital language processing regions:

    • Anterior Cortex: Heavily involved in complex vocalization and language production.

    • Motor Cortex: Controls precise muscular movements, including speech articulators and hand manipulation.

    • The physical proximity and interconnectivity of motor control areas and language centers in the left hemisphere suggest that language evolution co-evolved with fine motor control and tool usage.

    • The Genetic Source and the FOXP2 Gene

  • Innateness Hypothesis: Suggests that human language capacity is genetically encoded, enabling infants to achieve rapid language acquisition without explicit formal instruction.

  • The FOXP2 Gene: Discovered in the early 2000s2000s, the FOXP2 gene was identified as a critical factor in motor speech production and language processing.

  • Studies published in journals such as Nature documented differences in FOXP2 gene expression between humans, non-human primates (such as chimpanzees), and other vertebrates.

  • Neurobiologist Erich Jarvis conducted experiments on songbirds and genetically engineered mice with mutated FOXP2 genes:

    • Mice with FOXP2 mutations displayed altered ultrasonic vocalizations and impaired motor learning capabilities.

    • Songbirds exhibited reduced vocal learning precision when FOXP2 expression was knocked down.

  • Current consensus: While FOXP2 plays a critical role in neural connectivity related to complex motor control and vocal learning, it is not a singular "language gene." The genetic foundation of language is polygenic and complex.

Fundamental Design Features of Human Language

  • Distinguishing Communication from Language

    • Communicative Symbols: Behaviors used intentionally to convey specific informational content.

    • Examples: Saying "My name is Terry", submitting an application ("I am applying for a position at your company"), or issuing a directive ("You must complete this task by midnight").

    • Informative Symbols: Unintentional behaviors that yield information to an observer without conscious communicative intent.

    • Examples: Coughing (signals illness), shifting nervously in a seat (signals anxiety or discomfort), or speaking with a specific regional accent (signals geographic or cultural background).

  • Charles Hockett's Design Features of Language

    • Linguistic anthropologist Charles Hockett established 1616 design features outlining the properties of communication systems.

    • While several features are shared with animal communication, Hockett argued that at least 44 features (and specifically 66 major properties) distinguish human language from all non-human systems:

  • Reflexivity

    • The meta-linguistic ability to use language to analyze, describe, and critique language itself.

    • Examples: Asking "Am I using too many big terms when I'm speaking?", evaluating tone ("Do I sound too friendly?"), or observing speech cadence ("I wish he wouldn't speak so fast").

    • Non-human animals do not demonstrate the ability to reflect on or analyze their own communication systems.

  • Displacement

    • The capacity to convey information about events, objects, and concepts that are removed in time, space, or reality (referring to the past, future, hypothetical scenarios, distant locations, or imaginary realms).

    • Examples:

    • Temporal past: "When I was five, I played with sand."

    • Temporal future: "When I will be fifty, I will buy a boat."

    • Hypothetical/Counterfactual: "If I woke up on time, I would have not missed my class and passed the test."

    • Imaginary/Fictional: "In the North Pole, the elves are wrapping gifts."

    • Limitations in animals: Felines cannot communicate events removed in time or place. Honeybees exhibit a constrained form of displacement via the waggle dance, communicating the distance and direction of nectar sources, but cannot convey abstract or past/future contexts.

  • Arbitrariness

    • The absence of any natural, intrinsic, or logical connection between a linguistic signifier (spoken word/symbol) and its sign (the real-world object or concept).

    • Example: A red fruit is arbitrarily designated as apple in English, yabloko in Russian, pingguo in Mandarin, and manzana in Spanish.

    • Apparent Exceptions: Onomatopoeic words (e.g., shush, boom, bang) exhibit slight iconic mimicry, though their phonetic implementation still conforms to language-specific phonotactic rules.

  • Cultural Transmission

    • Language is acquired through social learning and environmental exposure within a culture, rather than inherited genetically.

    • Example: An infant born to Chinese parents in China but adopted at birth and raised by English speakers in the United States will natively acquire English, not Chinese.

    • In contrast, animals inherit instinctive vocal signals regardless of environment (e.g., a kitten raised in isolation or alongside apes will still produce a meow).

    • Deprived human infants raised without linguistic interaction (e.g., historical cases like Genie Wiley or Mary Noname) fail to develop natural language spontaneously.

  • Productivity (Creativity and Open-Endedness)

    • The structural capacity to construct an infinite number of novel utterances using a finite set of structural units and grammatical rules.

    • Humans continuously coin new vocabulary items (e.g., cap, aura, to google).

    • Language permits the generation of syntactically valid sentences that are semantically novel or nonsensical, as demonstrated by Noam Chomsky:

    • Grammatical and novel: "Colorless green ideas sleep furiously"

    • Grammatical and sensible: "Vibrant green birds fly swiftly"

    • Ungrammatical sequence: "We am journaling on library the"

    • Morphological Productivity: Demonstrated by child language experiments such as Jean Berko Gleason's Wug Test:


The Wug Test illustration
- When presented with a novel nonsense noun like *wug* (11 item) or *kleech* (11 item), native speakers automatically apply pluralization rules to produce *wugs* (/wʃɡz//wʃɡz/) and *kleeches* (/klitʃɩz//klitʃɩz/).
  • Duality (Double Articulation)

    • Language operates simultaneously on two structural levels:

    • Primary Level (Distinctive Sounds): Discrete phonetic elements devoid of intrinsic meaning (e.g., individual phonemes /t/, /i/, /s/, /l/).

    • Secondary Level (Meaningful Units): Combinations of phonemes forming meaningful words and morphemes.

    • Reordering a finite set of sounds yields distinct semantic meanings: combining /t/, /i/, /s/, and /l/ produces list, still, lits, its, is, silt, and slit.

    • Substituting a single phoneme alters meaning entirely (minimal pairs): sip, tip, lip, miss, mitt, mill.

    • Animals lack duality; a dog cannot recombine the acoustic elements of a woof to yield novel signals like fowo, foow, or ofow.

Comparative Analysis: Human Language vs. Animal Communication

  • Primate Vocalization and Physical Constraints

    • Early studies attempted to teach spoken human language to non-human primates, revealing profound biological limitations:

    • Gua: A chimpanzee raised alongside a human infant by Luella and Winthrop Kellogg. Gua demonstrated comprehension of approximately 100100 spoken words but was unable to produce any articulate speech sounds.

    • Viki: A chimpanzee raised in the home of Catherine and Keith Hayes. The Hayeses manually manipulated Viki's mouth to encourage vocal articulation. Over several years, Viki managed to produce heavily distorted, poorly articulated approximations of only three words: mama, papa, and cup.

    • Biological Finding: Non-human primates lack the requisite supralaryngeal vocal tract morphology, lowered larynx, and fine neural motor control needed to produce human speech sounds.

  • Gestural and Symbolic Communication Studies

    • Subsequent research shifted focus to non-vocal modalities, including American Sign Language (ASL) and artificial visual symbols:

    • Washoe: A chimpanzee trained by Beatrix and Allen Gardner to use American Sign Language (ASL).


Chimpanzee research setup with Allen and Beatrix Gardner
  - While wild chimpanzees employ roughly 6666 distinct gesture types, Washoe learned over 100100 ASL signs within 3.53.5 years.
  - Washoe combined signs to denote novel concepts and requests, such as *"Gimme tickle"*, *"More fruit"*, and *"Open food drink"* (referring to a refrigerator).
  - Observational findings indicated that Washoe's communications consisted primarily of response patterns to trainer prompts (question-answer interactions).
- **Sarah and Lana**: Chimpanzees trained to communicate using arbitrary plastic tokens or computer keyboards displaying geometric symbols (lexigrams).


Plastic shape tokens used in Sarah chimpanzee experiment
  - Demonstrated the ability to arrange tokens into ordered sequences (e.g., *"MARY GIVE CHOCOLATE SARAH"*) to receive rewards, showing basic symbol-association skills.
- **Kanzi**: A bonobo studied by Sue Savage-Rumbaugh who acquired lexigram communication spontaneously at an early age by observing training sessions conducted with his mother.
  • Synthesis of Primate Research: Non-human primates can acquire modest symbolic associations and rudiments of productivity. However, their communicative output lacks the complex recursive syntax, structural duality, and spontaneous open-ended creativity characteristic of human language acquisition.

Global Language Diversity, Typology, and Classification

  • Quantitative Scope of Global Languages

    • Linguists estimate that there are approximately 6,5006,500 mutually unintelligible human languages spoken worldwide.

    • Spoken systems constitute the vast majority of human languages.

    • Signed languages emerge naturally within Deaf communities and possess complete, independent phonological, morphological, and syntactic structures.

    • Secondary communication modalities (e.g., written scripts, whistled registers) are derived directly from primary spoken or signed languages.

  • Criteria and Metrics for Counting Languages

    • Documenting a language requires systematic field recording and linguistic analysis.

    • The standard criterion for distinguishing separate languages from dialects is mutual intelligibility: if speakers of Speech Variety A cannot understand Speech Variety B without prior study, A and B are classified as distinct languages.

    • The Swadesh List: Developed by Morris Swadesh, this lexicostatistical tool compiles 100100 to 200200 basic, non-borrowed core vocabulary concepts (e.g., star, hand, water, kill, sleep).

    • If two speech varieties share approximately 70%70\% or more cognate vocabulary on a Swadesh list, mutual intelligibility is generally inferred.

    • Sociopolitical and Identity Factors: The boundary between "language" and "dialect" is heavily influenced by political boundaries, national identity, and self-report data.

  • Documentation Status and Language Endangerment

    • A substantial proportion of the world's languages face severe endangerment or extinction due to language shift, socio-economic pressure, and globalization.

    • According to data compiled by Hammarström et al. (20152015), the world's languages display varying levels of grammatical description:


Table 3 showing status of grammatical description of world languages
  • Breakdown of Grammatical Documentation Status (6,4096,409 languages evaluated):

    • Long Grammar (≈300\approx 300 pages and beyond): 1,1341,134 languages (17.7%17.7\%

    • Grammar (≈150\approx 150 pages): 891891 languages (13.9%13.9\%

    • Grammar Sketch (≈50\approx 50 pages): 1,6021,602 languages (25.0%25.0\%

    • Phonology (Phonological description only): 711711 languages (11.1%11.1\%

    • Wordlist or Less (Short wordlist or no data): 2,0712,071 languages (32.3%32.3\%

    • Total Datapoints: 6,4096,409 languages (100%100\%

    • Undiscovered Languages and Diachronic Shift

  • Undocumented languages continue to be discovered, primarily within isolated rural communities situated in dense ecological terrain.

  • Languages undergo continuous internal diachronic change. As a general benchmark, it takes approximately 1,0001,000 years of isolated historical divergence for a language to become mutually unintelligible with its earlier ancestral form.

    • Genealogical Hierarchy and Diversity

  • Languages are classified hierarchically into Groups →\rightarrow Branches →\rightarrow Families.

  • Language Family: A group of languages descended from a single historical ancestral language (proto-language).

  • Major Language Families by Scale:

    • Indo-European: The most comprehensively documented family, comprising 580580 languages, including Dutch, English, Kurdish, Greek, French, Armenian, and Hindi.

    • Atlantic-Congo: The largest language family by member language count, encompassing 1,4301,430 languages spoken across sub-Saharan Africa.

    • Austronesian: The largest language family by geospatial extent, spanning 1,2741,274 languages distributed from Madagascar across island Southeast Asia to Hawaii.

  • Language Isolate: A language that exhibits no demonstrable genealogical relationship to any other language family, representing the sole surviving member of an isolated family.

    • Geographical Density

  • Linguistic diversity is distributed non-uniformly across the globe.

  • High linguistic density strongly correlates with rugged physical geography (e.g., mountain ranges, island archipelagos, dense tropical river basins) that historically fostered community isolation.

Structural Typology: Phonology, Morphology, and Syntax

  • Phonological Diversity

    • Languages vary in the size and composition of their consonant and vowel inventories.


World map of consonant inventories from WALS
  • Consonant inventories across global languages range from Small, Moderately Small, Average, to Moderately Large and Large.

  • Highly specialized sound types exist in select language families, such as suction-produced click consonants found in Khoisan and southern Bantu languages.

  • Phonotactics: Rules governing allowable sound sequences and syllable structures within a specific language:

    • Non-English phonotactic combinations: zroch, pvsi, jinoqb, gloze, abpieml, rseen, woller.

    • Permissible English phonotactic combinations (valid non-words): splink, draffer, glorb.

    • Morphological Diversity and Interlinear Glossing

  • Languages employ different grammatical mechanisms to express verbal aspect, tense, and nominal relations.

  • Example Comparison: Present Continuous Aspect and Case Marking:

    • English uses an auxiliary verb + progressive suffix: "I play badminton" vs. "I am playing badminton".

    • Russian lacks a distinct present progressive form, expressing aspect through lexical verb choice, but utilizes nominal case suffixes to mark grammatical function:

      • Russian construction: Ya igrayu v badminton

      • Interlinear Glossing Format:

      • Line 1 (Source Text): Ya igrayu v badminton

      • Line 2 (Morpheme Breakdown/Gloss): I play in badminton.ACCI\ \text{play}\ \text{in}\ \text{badminton.ACC}

      • Line 3 (Free Translation): 'I play / am playing badminton'

    • Syntactic Diversity and Basic Word Order

  • Structural typology categorizes languages by the default sequence of Subject (S), Verb (V), and Object (O) in simple declarative transitive clauses (e.g., "The cat saw the dog").

  • Empirical Data on Basic Word Order across Global Languages and Families (adapted from Hammarström, 20132013):


Table 7 showing counts of basic constituent orders across languages and families
  • Breakdown of Constituent Orders (7,5367,536 total languages evaluated across 424424 families):

    • SOV (Subject-Object-Verb): 2,2752,275 languages (43.3%43.3\%

    • SVO (Subject-Verb-Object): 2,1172,117 languages (40.3%40.3\%

    • VSO (Verb-Subject-Object): 503503 languages (9.5%9.5\%

    • VOS (Verb-Object-Subject): 174174 languages (3.3%3.3\%

    • NODOM (No dominant order): 124124 languages (2.3%2.3\%

    • OVS (Object-Verb-Subject): 4040 languages (0.7%0.7\%

    • OSV (Object-Subject-Verb): 1919 languages (0.3%0.3\%

    • Total Datapoints: 5,2525,252 languages (366366 families)

    • No Data: 2,2842,284 languages (5858 families)

    • Grand Total: 7,5367,536 languages (424424 families)


World map of basic word orders from WALS
  • Geographical distribution shows that SOV and SVO orders account for over 83%83\% of the world's documented languages, while object-initial orders (OVS and OSV) are extremely rare.

    • Typological Resources and Universals

  • Linguistic Typology is the branch of linguistics that analyzes, compares, and classifies languages based on structural features.

  • Key Online Typological Resources:

    • Glottolog (Version 5.0): Comprehensive bibliographic and genealogical database of the world's languages.

    • WALS Online (World Atlas of Language Structures): Database mapping phonological, grammatical, and lexical features across global languages.

Discussion Questions, Case Studies, and Course Logistics

  • Video Case Study: The FOXP2 Gene and Animal Vocalization

    • Video Reference: NOVA Wonders / PBS LearningMedia (FOXP2 Gene Linked to Language).

    • The Kearney Family Case Study: Demonstrates severe speech and language deficits (verbal dyspraxia) inherited across generations due to a specific mutation in the FOXP2 gene, highlighting the necessity of functional genetic sequences for vocal motor control.

    • Jarvis Animal Experiments:

    • Knockdown experiments in songbirds show that altering FOXP2 impairs their ability to accurately learn and copy adult tutor songs.

    • Transgenic mouse experiments demonstrate altered ultrasonic pup distress calls and disrupted motor skill execution.

    • Comparative insight: Mice vocalizations are innate rather than learned, whereas songbirds exhibit vocal learning analogous to human infant speech acquisition.

  • Discussion Questions on Language Endangerment and Preservation

    • Factors contributing to language loss: Socio-economic marginalization, colonial assimilation, globalization, migration, shift to national prestige languages, and absence of native-language schooling.

    • Factors supporting language vitality: Intergenerational transmission in the home, community language revitalization programs, official political status, digital presence, and local literary traditions.

  • Course Logistics and Assessment Schedule

    • Required Reading Assignment: Hammarström (20162016), Section 2 & 5.

    • Assessment: Quiz 1 scheduled for Tuesday (9/159/15) at the beginning of class (covering Origins of Language, Aspects of Language, and Language Diversity).