Economics 1B Study Notes: The Foreign Sector

Prescribed Scope and Learning Unit Alignment

  • Course Code & Module: Economics 1B (PMAC5112 / PMAC5112w / PMAC5112p)
  • Learning Unit: Learning Unit 4: The Foreign Sector
  • Lecturer / Author: Rajh Naidoo, Varsity College - Westville
  • Prescribed Textbook Reference: Mohr P & Associates, 2026, Economics for South African Students, 7th ed. Pretoria: Van Schaik Publishers (Chapter 16, pp. 397–423 / pp. 304–307).
  • Compulsory Textbook Components:
    • Box 16-2 and Box 16-3
    • Figures 16.2 to 16.4
    • Tables 16-1 and 16-2
  • Module Learning Outcomes:
    • LO1: Explain why countries trade.
    • LO2: Explain how absolute advantage and comparative advantage determine how trade will take place.
    • LO3: Describe measures to control the volume of imports.
    • LO4: Discuss exchange rate determination between the US dollar and the Rand.
    • LO5: Explain, with the aid of diagrams, the impact of changes in demand and supply of dollars on the exchange rate.
    • LO6: Briefly explain the three policy options for floating exchange rate regimes.
    • LO7: Explain the significance of changes in the terms of trade.

Rationale for International Trade

  • Globalisation:

    • Definition: The process through which the world's economies become increasingly integrated, characterized by expanding international trade, emerging capital markets in developing economies, growing international tourism, and rapid technological advancements linking all regions of the globe.
    • South Africa as an Open Economy: Integrates into the global economic network across multiple channels, including Trade, Capital, Transport, Technology, Tourism, and Sport.
  • Case Study — Sipho and the Avocado Export Trade:

    • Context: Sipho owns a small farming operation in Limpopo, growing avocados sold both locally and internationally. Upon receiving a large order from a client in Europe, Sipho questioned his agricultural advisor why European clients would purchase avocados from South Africa when Spain also produces avocados.
    • Explanation of Comparative Advantage: Sipho's advisor explained that although Spain can grow avocados, Sipho grows them more efficiently and at a lower opportunity cost. That lower opportunity cost constitutes Sipho's comparative advantage.
    • Core Insight: International trade is not merely determined by what a country can produce, but by what it produces best relative to others, and what others produce better or cheaper. Global trade is not a zero-sum competition, but a system of mutual benefit where all participating nations gain by specializing according to their relative strengths.
  • Core Trade Concepts:

    • Absolute Advantage: The ability of a nation to produce a greater volume of a good or service using the same quantity of resources than another nation.
    • Comparative Advantage: The ability of a nation to produce a good or service at a lower opportunity cost than another nation.
    • Opportunity Cost: The cost of producing an additional unit of one good measured in terms of the foregone production of another good.
  • Numerical Example 1 — Absolute Advantage and Specialisation:

    • Production Output Table (given equal resource allocation):
    • Japan: 8 0008\,000 Computers, 16 00016\,000 Bags of Maize.
    • South Africa: 4 0004\,000 Computers, 24 00024\,000 Bags of Maize.
    • Absolute Advantage Assessment:
    • Japan holds an absolute advantage in the production of computers (8 000>4 0008\,000 > 4\,000).
    • South Africa holds an absolute advantage in the production of maize (24 000>16 00024\,000 > 16\,000).
    • Opportunity Cost Evaluation:
    • Japan's opportunity cost of producing 11 computer: 16 0008 000=2\frac{16\,000}{8\,000} = 2\text{ bags of maize}.
    • South Africa's opportunity cost of producing 11 computer: 24 0004 000=6\frac{24\,000}{4\,000} = 6\text{ bags of maize}.
    • South Africa's opportunity cost of producing computers is significantly higher than Japan's (6>26 > 2).
    • Trade Recommendation & Specialisation:
    • Japan should specialize in producing computers.
    • South Africa should specialize in producing maize.
    • Both nations trade to achieve mutual consumption gains.
    • Assumed Terms of Trade: 11\text{ computer} = 33\text{ bags of maize}.
  • Numerical Example 2 — Comparative Advantage under Absolute Advantage in Both Goods:

    • Production Output Table:
    • Japan: 7 5007\,500 DVD Players, 1 5001\,500\text{ Litres of Wine}.
    • South Africa: 2 0002\,000 DVD Players, 1 0001\,000\text{ Litres of Wine}.
    • Absolute Advantage Assessment:
    • Japan holds an absolute advantage in both goods (7 500>2 0007\,500 > 2\,000 DVD players and 1 500>1 0001\,500 > 1\,000\text{ litres of wine}).
    • Opportunity Cost Evaluation (Focusing on Wine Production):
    • Japan's opportunity cost of producing 11\text{ litre of wine}: 7 5001 500=5\frac{7\,500}{1\,500} = 5\text{ DVD players}.
    • South Africa's opportunity cost of producing 11\text{ litre of wine}: 2 0001 000=2\frac{2\,000}{1\,000} = 2\text{ DVD players}.
    • Comparative Advantage Determination:
    • The opportunity cost of producing wine for Japan is greater than for South Africa (5>25 > 2).
    • Therefore, South Africa holds a comparative advantage in the production of wine.
    • Japan holds a comparative advantage in the production of DVD players (opportunity cost of 11 DVD player in Japan is 1 5007 500=0.2\frac{1\,500}{7\,500} = 0.2\text{ litres of wine}, whereas in South Africa it is 1 0002 000=0.5\frac{1\,000}{2\,000} = 0.5\text{ litres of wine}).
    • Trade Recommendation & Specialisation:
    • Japan should produce DVD players, and South Africa should produce wine, followed by trade.
    • Assumed Terms of Trade: 11\text{ litre of wine} = 22\text{ DVD players}.
  • Sources of Comparative Advantage:

    • Differences in Technology.
    • Differences in Resource Endowments (labor force, natural resources, land, and capital).
    • Differences in Tastes or Demand preferences.
  • Equal Advantage:

    • Occurs when the opportunity cost of producing both goods is identical between two countries.
    • In a situation of equal advantage, no comparative advantage exists, eliminating any economic basis or gain from trading.

Trade Policy and Protectionist Measures

  • Case Study — Lerato and the Clothing Conundrum:

    • Context: Lerato operates a boutique clothing brand in Johannesburg utilizing locally made, sustainably sourced garments. She faces financial distress as cheaper clothing imports from Asia flood the domestic market, rendering her unable to match their low prices despite offering superior quality.
    • Trade Policy Explanation: Lerato's situation illustrates how foreign trade policy shapes domestic competition. When foreign imports undermine domestic production, governments step in with protective policies (tariffs or quotas) to balance economic growth with local industry preservation.
  • Rationale for Trade Policy and Intervention:

    • Economic Welfare Principle: Unrestricted specialisation and trade increase total worldwide output of goods and services, resulting in a overall welfare improvement.
    • Protectionist Reality: Despite welfare benefits, all national governments employ trade policy measures to shield domestic firms, preserve local jobs, and defend infant industries from aggressive foreign competition.
  • Import Tariffs:

    • Definition: Customs duties or taxes imposed by a government directly on goods imported into a country.
    • Objective: Raise the domestic price of imported products to reduce foreign price competitiveness and safeguard domestic manufacturers.
    • Illustrative Mechanism:
    • Towel produced domestically in Country A: Costs $12\$12.
    • Towel produced in Country B: Costs $10\$10.
    • Government of Country A levies a 20%20\% tariff ($2\$2) on towels imported from Country B.
    • Selling price of Country B towel in Country A: $10+$2=$12\$10 + \$2 = \$12, eliminating Country B's price advantage.

  Tariff impact on imported towel price

  • Other Protectionist Instruments:
    • Import Quotas: Quantitative restrictions establishing a physical limit on the maximum volume of a product permitted into a country during a specified time period.
    • Subsidies: Direct financial payments, tax relief, or low-interest loans provided by governments to domestic producers to lower output costs and enhance price competitiveness.
    • Other Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs): Onerous administrative regulations, safety standards, environmental compliance requirements, and custom delays engineered to limit foreign goods.
    • Exchange Controls: Regulatory limits imposed by a central bank or government on the volume of foreign currency domestic residents can purchase, effectively restricting import capability.
    • Exchange Rate Policy: Government intervention designed to deliberately devalue local currency to make domestic exports cheaper abroad and foreign imports prohibitively expensive.

Foreign Exchange Markets and Exchange Rate Determination

  • Fundamentals of Foreign Exchange (Forex):

    • International trade requires payments to be settled in foreign currencies (forex) such as Euros (EUR\text{EUR}), US Dollars (USD\text{USD}), or Japanese Yen (JPY\text{JPY}).
    • Importers must pay foreign suppliers in the currency of the exporting nation (e.g., a South African importer purchasing from Italy must pay in Euros, not Rands).
    • Exporters receive foreign currency, which must be converted back into domestic currency on international foreign exchange markets.
    • Economic Link: South African exports generate a supply of foreign exchange; South African imports generate a demand for foreign exchange. Supply and demand of forex are mediated by the South African Reserve Bank (SARB).
  • Exchange Rate Quotation Methods:

    • Direct Method: Expresses the amount of local currency required to purchase one single unit of foreign currency. This is the standard quotation format used globally.
    • Example: R12.00=$1.00R12.00 = \$1.00
    • Indirect Method: Expresses the amount of foreign currency required to purchase one single unit of local currency. It is the mathematical inverse of the direct method.
    • Example: R1.00=$0.08R1.00 = \$0.08 (calculated as 112.00\frac{1}{12.00}).
  • Contributors to the Demand for Foreign Exchange (US Dollars):

    • South African importers purchasing foreign goods and services payable in US dollars.
    • South African residents acquiring dollar-denominated assets (e.g., purchasing shares of American corporations).
    • American investors liquidating South African assets (shares, bonds) and converting Rand proceeds back into US dollars.
    • South African tourists travelling abroad purchasing dollars or dollar-denominated travellers' cheques.
    • Currency speculators anticipating a depreciation in the value of the Rand relative to the US dollar.
  • Contributors to the Supply of Foreign Exchange (US Dollars):

    • South African exporters selling goods and services abroad and receiving USD payments.
    • Foreign (US) investors purchasing South African assets using US dollars.
    • South African investors selling dollar-denominated foreign assets and converting proceeds back into Rands.
    • Foreign tourists visiting South Africa exchanging dollars or dollar-denominated travellers' cheques for Rands.
    • Currency speculators anticipating an appreciation in the value of the Rand relative to the US dollar.
  • Equilibrium Exchange Rate Determination:

    • Determined at the intersection of the demand curve (DD) and supply curve (SS) for dollars in the foreign exchange market.

  Foreign Exchange Market Equilibrium

  • Market Adjustment Mechanisms:

    • At an exchange rate below equilibrium (e.g., $1=R8.00\$1 = R8.00 when equilibrium is $1=R18.00\$1 = R18.00): Excess demand for dollars arises, placing upward pressure on the exchange rate until equilibrium is re-established.

    • At an exchange rate above equilibrium (e.g., $1=R24.00\$1 = R24.00 when equilibrium is $1=R18.00\$1 = R18.00): Excess supply of dollars arises, placing downward pressure on the exchange rate until equilibrium is re-established.

    • Currency Depreciation and Appreciation:

  • Rand Depreciation (Dollar Appreciation):

    • Definition: The Rand weakens relative to the Dollar, requiring more Rands to buy one Dollar.
    • Historical Illustration:
      • June 2010 (R7.00=$1.00R7.00 = \$1.00): Exchanging R20 000R20\,000 yielded $2 857.14\$2\,857.14
      • June 2017 (R12.87=$1.00R12.87 = \$1.00): Exchanging R20 000R20\,000 yielded $1 554.00\$1\,554.00
    • Consequences of Rand Depreciation:
      • Foreign imports become more expensive for domestic buyers.
      • Overseas travel becomes more costly for domestic residents.
      • Investing in foreign assets requires higher Rand outlays.
      • Exports become cheaper and more competitive for foreign buyers (encouraging export growth).
      • Foreign tourism into South Africa becomes cheaper and increases.
      • Domestic assets become more attractive and affordable for foreign investors.
  • Rand Appreciation (Dollar Depreciation):

    • Definition: The Rand strengthens relative to the Dollar, requiring fewer Rands to buy one Dollar.

    • Historical Illustration:

      • June 2016 (R15.25=$1.00R15.25 = \$1.00): A $199.00\$199.00 US online watch cost R3 034.75R3\,034.75
      • June 2017 (R12.87=$1.00R12.87 = \$1.00): A $199.00\$199.00 US online watch cost R2 561.13R2\,561.13
    • Consequences of Rand Appreciation:

      • Foreign imports become cheaper for domestic consumers.
      • Outbound foreign travel becomes more affordable.
      • Export competitiveness falls as South African products become more expensive for foreign buyers.
    • Market Shifts in Demand and Supply Curves for Foreign Exchange:

  • Shift 1: Decrease in Supply of Dollars

    • Causes: Restrictive monetary/fiscal policies in the US, falling international prices for South African mineral exports (e.g., gold price collapse), or capital outflow.
    • Impact: Supply curve shifts left (S→S1S \rightarrow S_1). The Rand depreciates, and the Dollar appreciates (e.g., exchange rate increases from R18R18 to R21R21 or R8R8 to R12R12).

    Decrease in the supply of dollars

  • Shift 2: Increase in Supply of Dollars
    • Causes: Major influx of foreign tourists (e.g., US citizens visiting South Africa during the FIFA World Cup 2010) or a boom in global commodity/mineral prices.
    • Impact: Supply curve shifts right (S→S1S \rightarrow S_1). The Rand appreciates, and the Dollar depreciates (e.g., exchange rate decreases from R8R8 to R4R4).

    Increase in the supply of dollars

  • Shift 3: Decrease in Demand for Dollars
    • Causes: Domestic economic recession leading to a slump in South African demand for imported US goods.
    • Impact: Demand curve shifts left (D→D2D \rightarrow D_2). The Rand appreciates, and the Dollar depreciates (e.g., exchange rate falls from R8R8 to R4R4).

    Decrease in the demand for dollars

  • Shift 4: Increase in Demand for Dollars
    • Causes: Increased purchase of capital goods from the US by domestic firms or a surge in South African tourists visiting the US.
    • Impact: Demand curve shifts right (D→D1D \rightarrow D_1). The Rand depreciates, and the Dollar appreciates (e.g., exchange rate rises from R8R8 to R12R12).

    Increase in the demand for dollars

  • Summary Tables of Foreign Exchange Movements:
    • Table 16-1: Market Changes and Exchange Rate Movements
    • Demand for dollars increases (D shifts right): Rand Depreciates | Dollar Appreciates
    • Supply of dollars increases (S shifts right): Rand Appreciates | Dollar Depreciates
    • Supply of dollars decreases (S shifts left): Rand Depreciates | Dollar Appreciates
    • Demand for dollars falls (D shifts left): Rand Appreciates | Dollar Depreciates
    • Table 16-2: Macroeconomic Impact on South Africa
    • Rand depreciates against dollar: Export prices (in dollars) decrease | Import prices (in rand) increase | Current account balance improves | Domestic prices (inflation) rise
    • Rand appreciates against dollar: Export prices (in dollars) increase | Import prices (in rand) decrease | Current account balance worsens | Domestic prices (inflation) fall

Floating Exchange Rate Policies and Speculation

  • Policy Options for Floating Exchange Rate Regimes:

    • Free Floating (Independently Floating): Market forces of supply and demand freely determine the exchange rate without central bank intervention. South Africa officially operates an independently floating exchange rate policy.
    • Managed Floating (Intervention): The central bank intervenes in foreign exchange markets by buying or selling foreign currency reserves to smooth out excessive market volatility.
    • Interest Rate Policy: The central bank adjusts domestic interest rates. Raising interest rates attracts foreign portfolio capital (seeking higher yields), increasing demand for Rands and counteracting currency depreciation.
  • Speculation and Expectations in Foreign Exchange Markets (Box 16-3):

    • Market sentiment and expectations play a critical role in exchange rate determination.
    • Anticipated Rand Depreciation Scenario:
    • If market participants expect the Rand to depreciate (or the Dollar to appreciate), importers, tourists, and speculators immediately purchase dollars to avoid higher future costs or to turn a profit.
    • Immediate demand for dollars increases, shifting the demand curve right (D→D1D \rightarrow D_1).
    • Simultaneously, dollar holders delay selling dollars in anticipation of higher prices, shifting the supply curve left (S→S1S \rightarrow S_1).
    • Outcome: The self-fulfilling expectation causes an immediate sharp depreciation of the Rand (e.g., exchange rate jumps from R18R18 to R22R22).

  Speculative shifts in foreign exchange market

Terms of Trade

  • Case Study — Nandi and the Price of Coffee:

    • Context: Nandi operates a local coffee roastery in Durban, importing coffee beans from Ethiopia and selling premium blends online. When the price of imported Ethiopian beans rose while her export income remained unchanged, Nandi realized her terms of trade had deteriorated.
    • Core Significance: Changes in the terms of trade directly alter national purchasing power and economic well-being. When import prices rise or export prices fall, a country must export a greater physical volume of goods (consuming more scarce domestic resources) to afford the same level of imports.
  • Definition and Calculation:

    • Definition: The ratio between a country's export price index and its import price index.
    • Mathematical Formula:

Terms of Trade=Export Price IndexImport Price Index×100\text{Terms of Trade} = \frac{\text{Export Price Index}}{\text{Import Price Index}} \times 100

  • Macroeconomic Implications:
    • Favourable Terms of Trade (Improving TOT): Occurs when export prices rise relative to import prices. The nation earns more per export unit, enabling it to buy more imports for the same export volume, increasing national wealth.
    • Unfavourable Terms of Trade (Deteriorating TOT): Occurs when import prices rise relative to export prices, or export prices fall (e.g., a drop in South Africa's primary export commodity prices, such as gold). The country becomes poorer as it must generate more exports to finance the baseline level of imports.

Practice Questions and Worked Solutions

  • Multiple Choice Questions 1.1 to 1.3 (France vs Spain Trade Model):

    • Table of Data:

    • France: 2020\text{ Cars}, 120120\text{ Wine Barrels} (Ratio 1:61 : 6).

    • Spain: 1515\text{ Cars}, 3030\text{ Wine Barrels} (Ratio 1:21 : 2).

    • Opportunity Cost Workings:

    • If producing Cars only (Opportunity cost of 11 car in terms of wine barrels):

      • France: 12020=6\frac{120}{20} = 6\text{ wine barrels} (Ratio 1:61 : 6).
      • Spain: 3015=2\frac{30}{15} = 2\text{ wine barrels} (Ratio 1:21 : 2).
    • If producing Wine only (Opportunity cost of 11 wine barrel in terms of cars):

      • France: 20120=16≈0.16\frac{20}{120} = \frac{1}{6} \approx 0.16\text{ cars} (Ratio 1:0.161 : 0.16).
      • Spain: 1530=12=0.50\frac{15}{30} = \frac{1}{2} = 0.50\text{ cars} (Ratio 1:0.501 : 0.50).
    • Question 1.1: In Spain, the opportunity cost of producing one car is:

    • Options: a. 1/15 of a wine barrel; b. 1/2 of a wine barrel; c. 2 wine barrels; d. 15 wine barrels.

    • Answer: c. 2 wine barrels

    • Question 1.2: France has an absolute advantage in ―――――― and Spain has an absolute advantage in ――――――.

    • Options: a. Both goods, neither good; b. Cars, wine barrels; c. Wine barrels, cars; d. Neither good, both goods.

    • Answer: a. Both goods, neither good (France produces 20>1520 > 15 cars and 120>30120 > 30 wine barrels).

    • Question 1.3: France and Spain could both benefit from trade if France produces ―――――― and Spain produces ――――――.

    • Options: a. Cars, wine barrels; b. Wine barrels, cars; c. Both goods, neither good; d. Neither good, both goods.

    • Answer: b. Wine barrels, cars (France has comparative advantage in wine barrels [0.16<0.500.16 < 0.50]; Spain has comparative advantage in cars [2<62 < 6]).

  • Multiple Choice Questions 1.4 to 1.6 (Trade Policy Workbook):

    • Question 1.4 Answer: C
    • Question 1.5 Answer: B
    • Question 1.6 Answer: C
  • Multiple Choice Questions 1.7 to 1.11 (Exchange Rates Workbook):

    • Question 1.7 Answer: D
    • Question 1.8 Answer: A
    • Question 1.9 Answer: D
    • Question 1.10 Answer: A
    • Question 1.11 Answer: A