STEN 1000 — Introduction to Business
Strategy notes
Bad strategy doesn't always look bad. In 2000, staying focused on Blockbuster's successful stores was a defensible decision.
Challenges of strategy: decisions made with incomplete information; successful businesses reluctant to disrupt themselves; short-term success can hide long-term threats; limited resources — choosing one direction means not choosing another.
Strategy requires making choices: Where will we compete? How will we win? What will we NOT do? What needs to change when the world changes?
A strategy is more than a list of things a company would like to accomplish.
Limitations of 2x2 matrix approaches: overly simplified; elements may be difficult to define or measure.
BCG Growth-Share Matrix: Market growth rate x Relative market share → Star (high/high), Cash Cow (low MGR, high RMS), Question Mark (high MGR, low RMS), Dog (low/low).
Mining industry strategy discussion
Focus: developing a natural-resources/mining venture — identify a concrete industry problem, choose where to play, explain value creation and capture.
Opportunities discussed: uranium, exploration, development, financing, royalty-stream models; questions on deposits, viable mines, competition, risk, funding.
Move beyond a broad idea toward an actionable concept: define problem + solution, industry segment and market position, industry dynamics and competitive space, how value is created and captured.
Value creation = story/pathway of producing greater value for customers. Value capture = accelerating growth and retaining value (resale, recycling, retention, pricing power, differentiation/brand/ecosystem effects).
ESG described as a ranking/assessment system used by investors and auditors on environmental/governance responses.
Boards of directors: outside day-to-day operations, represent shareholders, oversee management; topics included ownership, equity, debt capacity, fiduciary duties, transparency, director liability/insurance.
Assessment: written project material, verbal defense, iterative feedback; 5% project.
Lesson 5
Organizational alignment: concentric layers — internal structures/processes; market-facing stories/value propositions; strategies; external environment. Durable advantage comes from alignment of internal configuration, market positioning, and value capture.
Leadership: align short-, medium-, long-term goals; communicate shared vision; manage capital; meaningful work, belonging, competence, trust.
Responses to environmental change: ignoring rules → compliance → peripheral initiatives → deep integration.
ESG/CSR/trust: trust reduces uncertainty, financing costs, oversight costs; trust breaks via cheating, concealment, broken commitments, shortcuts.
Markets spectrum: free markets to strong government intervention. Competitive market conditions: transparent prices, responsive supply/demand, low entry/exit barriers, undifferentiated products.
GDP = value of goods/services produced in a jurisdiction over a period; limited as well-being measure. Fiscal vs monetary policy. K-shaped economy. CPI as constructed index.
STEN 1000 — Midterm Review / Strategy Lecture Notes
Class: Monday, October 19, 2026
Source: Cohen's lecture transcript. This was mostly a midterm review lecture — he walked chapters 1–8 back together into one strategy story. ASR was very rough in places; uncertain bits are flagged, not invented.
Midterm admin — read this first
Midterm covers Chapters 1–8. (Already on your calendar: Wednesday, November 4, worth 20%.)
Question levels (his breakdown):
Level 1 questions ≈ 30% of the exam — knowledge/recall of the concepts.
Level 2 questions — a chunk of the rest — understanding/application to a scenario.
Level 3 questions — the remainder — analysis: piecing concepts together and creating an answer, not just reciting one.
The spread is deliberate: he wants the exam to separate high-performing from lower-performing students, so expect the Level 2/3 questions to do that work. No trickery — his words. Everything is relevant, Chapter 1 only a little less weighted than the rest.
Expect application questions — he name-checked topics like the economy and fiscal policy as the kind of thing an application question can be built on.
Same instructions/accommodation setup as last time.
Study translation: memorizing definitions gets you the ~30%. The rest of the marks are in "here's a firm/market — which concept is this, and what should it do?" Practice by applying, not re-reading.
The whole course so far, in one chain
This is how he re-built it in class — learn it as a chain, not 8 separate chapters:
Purpose → look outside → look inside → match them → choose how to compete → set goals/KPIs → act, learn, adjust
1. Start with purpose
First question of strategy: identifying purpose — what is the intent, why are we doing what we're doing?
The planning questions a firm has to answer: What are our resources and capabilities? What are our products/markets? What is the purpose of the organization? What is our source of advantage? (Accountability and performance management come later — mostly through your projects so far.)
2. Look outside (external analysis)
Macro/contextual environment — PESTLE-type scan: Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal, Environmental forces the firm operates inside. Use it to diagnose risk and spot opportunity.
Competitive/industry environment: what the immediate market/industry looks like.
ESG mandates got a brief mention as part of this external picture.
Output of looking outside = Opportunities and Threats.
3. Look inside (internal analysis)
Inventory your resources and capabilities (including human resources) — they form the base you compete from.
Output of looking inside = Strengths and Weaknesses.
SWOT is just the box you put 2 + 3 into. He was clear SWOT is one framework, not the point — the point is: figure out what you're good at, then find the intersection between that and a real market opportunity, under conditions where you can actually profit, while avoiding the threats.
4. VRIN — is the advantage real and lasting?
Resources/capabilities are a strong basis for advantage only if they are:
Valuable — they actually create value customers want
Rare — competitors don't all have them
Inimitable — can't be copied/mimicked
Non-substitutable — there's no different resource that does the same job
If all four hold → you have the foundation for a sustainable competitive advantage. Intangible resources count here — he gave brand story/reputation as the example after the midterm material.
If they don't hold (easy to imitate, substitutable, not rare) → your advantage is short-lived: a first-mover/head-start advantage only. You get a limited window, not a moat.
5. Formulation: vision, mission, and the cascade
Start formulation with vision and mission — and not as fluffy posters. A good mission statement is short and direct (he said aim for something like 7–8 words of real content): this is what we do, this is why we're here, this is what matters to us. It points you in a direction; it does not give you the pathway.
Then it cascades down:
Purpose / vision / mission
Corporate strategy — where (and in what) will we compete?
Goals and objectives — the mission turned into actionable targets
Business-level plans — how we get there
Operational reality — how it actually runs
Reality check he added: it doesn't only flow top-down. A lot of strategy emerges bottom-up — you try things, some work, happy accidents/experiments turn into opportunities you then plan around. Emergent strategy is real strategy.
6. Goals and performance
Goals should be specific and turned into objectives that stack down the organization, with KPIs / performance indicators attached so you can tell if you're actually hitting them. (This is the goal-setting material that comes in right around the midterm boundary.)
The EV / infrastructure story (his long example)
~12 years ago, driving an EV through the middle of nowhere in Wyoming: charging infrastructure barely existed → range anxiety was the real product problem, not the car.
Since then: charging networks grew a lot, battery capacity grew, and home batteries now double as household storage (charge the car / store power / sell or use it).
Now the AI build-out is creating the opposite bottleneck: not enough electricity for demand.
Lesson: whether a strategy works depends on external technology/infrastructure readiness. Tesla flirted with solar roofing and backed off — not because the idea was bad, but because the technology/manufacturing wasn't ready. Some ideas get abandoned by the conditions, not by the concept.
Exam use: this is a PESTLE (especially Technological) + timing example.
The music example — THE concept of this lecture
Same song, same $450 ticket, two completely different things being bought:
Performance A — the orchestra / Sound of Music performance
You've heard this recording 100 times. You pay $450 to hear it live and you want it exactly the same. If the band comes in early, if she riffs a "la la la" in the middle — you're mad. You go back the next day for the matinee, pay another $450, and again you want the identical performance.
Behind it: huge structure. Orchestra sections (strings, winds, percussion), 1st chair / 2nd chair / 3rd chair, a conductor, everyone listening and coordinating to produce precision.
What you're buying: precision, reliability, consistency — excellence through stability.
Performance B — John Coltrane, resurrected, tiny club in Paris
Also $450, also world-class musicians, also expensive instruments, no less mastery.
But there is no identical script — small groups coordinating with each other, improvising, interplay. If night two were note-for-note identical to night one, you'd be disappointed.
What you're buying: variation, creativity, responsiveness — excellence through flexibility.
The point (write this down): both use roughly the same resources — professional players, comparable instruments, the same song — and produce radically different value. Resources alone don't explain value; how the organization is set up to use them does.
That gives you the two strategic poles:
Stability pole: stable, predictable, reliable performance. Win by doing it efficiently (low-cost provider) or by being the premium, perfectly reliable product. Either way: no surprises.
Flexibility pole: constant adjustment, customer responsiveness, innovation, evolving with the opportunity. A very different, very hard kind of company to run.
Trying to be world-class at both poles at once is the core difficulty — the general recommendation from class is to focus and be really, really good at the thing you choose.
Ambidexterity note: some firms try to get both by structurally separating the innovation unit from the day-to-day production organization on purpose, letting new ideas develop in isolation, then flowing the winners into normal production (he gave a Ford-style example and an animation-studio example — names were garbled in the audio, the structure is the testable idea).
Market structures — recap, then match your advantage to them
Market types he reviewed:
Pure (perfect) competition — undifferentiated/commodity goods, many sellers.
Monopolistic competition — many sellers with differentiated products; firms can hold a temporary monopoly on their niche through brand reputation, new technology, patents — but it expires.
Oligopoly — a handful of firms dominate an industry (regulated or not, e.g. energy/gas-type industries).
Monopoly — one seller, either through control of a key resource or as a government-regulated monopoly.
Matching (the Level 2/3 move): after external + internal analysis, you bundle what you're good at into a platform for advantage that fits the market you're in:
Pure competition → you're a price taker (market sets the price). Your only lever is efficiency: do the same thing as competitors, at lower cost.
Regulated monopoly → price/product fights aren't the game; your position/license is the advantage.
Monopolistic competition → compete on differentiation: brand, reputation, trust — why would a customer pick you?
Volatile, fast-changing market → privileges flexibility/customer responsiveness.
Market that privileges quality, reliability, access → privileges stability/operational excellence.
The three fit questions to run on any firm (including your AquaSky project):
Is there a market for what we're good at?
Is there space/opportunity for us to compete on that basis?
Is the advantage sustainable or transient? (Run VRIN. Not rare/imitable → first-mover window only.)
Path dependence — why the choice sticks
Decisions about how to compete now create commitments that shape your future options.
If you build the whole company around efficiency and the market pivots to innovation/customization, switching is expensive, slow, and costly — bigger organizations feel this even more than small ones.
So strategy runs as a loop, not a one-time plan: plans → actions → learning from what happens → back into the plans. He closed by noting this same loop applies beyond for-profit firms — nonprofits and social organizations too.
One-page chain to memorize
Purpose → PESTLE/industry (O & T) + resources/capabilities (S & W) → SWOT intersection → VRIN test (sustainable vs. first-mover only) → vision/mission (short, real) → corporate strategy (where to compete) → goals + KPIs → compete from the stability pole or the flexibility pole → match that to your market structure → remember path dependence: today's choice prices tomorrow's pivot.
STEN 1000 — Stage 2 (AI Portfolio) Briefing + Chapter 7: Business Models
Class: Wednesday, October 22, 2026 (transcript; ASR was very rough — uncertain bits flagged, not invented). Professor: Chris Fredette.
PART 1 — Stage 2 admin: what the AI Development Portfolio actually has to show
Stage 2 ("Practice") broadly = an interim development report + AI development portfolio. Its purpose: a container that holds the team accountable and shows progress over time — instead of everything being thrown together at the last minute.
The AI piece — the questions your portfolio has to answer:
Which tools are you using, and how are they integrated into your work? (Different teams use AI differently — data aggregator, blocking/system tool, customer communication, forecasting, etc. He doesn't need to see prompts, but he needs to understand the integration.)
What is the AI actually doing in your system? E.g., for data-driven ventures: public data exists → you build a model → the AI draws inferences. Is it automated (does the AI know when to activate and draw inferences on its own)? Does it recursively improve its inferences from past experience/results?
Which AI is fundamental to the system — i.e., what is your core value-creation mechanism? (In AquaSky's case, the inference/recommendation engine IS the product — that's where the money comes from.)
What happens if that AI fails / is unavailable / costs too much? You need a plan B — an understanding of what the current system does without it.
Take screenshots as you build/create things — evidence for the portfolio.
Ownership, liability, and terms of service (lecture discussion — likely portfolio material)
If you build with a company's tools/platform, what do you own vs. what do they own? Check the tool's terms of service for your specific case.
Platform liability analogy: social media platforms aren't liable for user content (US Section 230 [transcript said "203" — the law is 230]); like a newspaper isn't liable for an ad someone places. Ownership, though, is set by each platform's terms of service.
Data privacy differs by tier/tool: e.g., Microsoft Copilot's professional/enterprise tier commits to keeping organizational data private within that structure and not learning from your use (which is why the university can use it with student data). Free/consumer tiers of tools like Gemini or Claude, and OpenAI's tools, each have different standards in their terms of service. The regulatory environment has not clarified ownership — if you create something novel and commercializable with AI, who owns the IP is a genuinely open question.
Takeaway for the portfolio: name your tools, name their tier/terms, and state your ownership/privacy position.
Peer evaluation starts at Stage 2
Peer evaluation forms begin with Stage 2; a final round comes at Stage 3. You receive aggregate scores, not individualized ones.
His advice on group problems (this is the time of semester groups start to crack): talk to your group first; if 3+ members share a concern, have that conversation together, thoughtfully; don't suffer in silence, but don't just dump it on the prof either. If you escalate, a good supervisor asks what steps you already took (dates, what was said, what changed). He WILL intervene on big issues after you've taken some action yourselves.
Design intent: the project deliberately tests two things at once — the performance piece (the deliverable) and the social performance (managing relationships). The tension between "do it all yourself and resent everyone" vs. "do none of it" is the lesson: get both together. Groups are deliberately large; expect roughly half the work to be wrangling engagement.
Class ended early for group work time.
PART 2 — Chapter 7: Business models, structure, culture, systems
Alignment (the chapter's spine)
Start from the environment: what market structure do you exist in (competitive, monopolistic competition, monopoly)? That tells you where you can/can't compete. Then map your source of competitive advantage onto it: compete on efficiency, on differentiation (innovation or customer responsiveness), or on quality/reliability/predictability (e.g., monopoly contexts demand high reliability). The business model must match the advantage and the market — misalignment = outcomes fall apart.
The three internal components (the business model)
Organizational structure — how jobs/people are organized: boxes = jobs (each with boundaries: what the job is/isn't), lines = authority/reporting relationships, hierarchy = number of layers between frontline workers and senior executives (more layers = more separation; GM was cited at ~11 layers).
Value creation happens at the frontier/frontline — where employees meet customers — not in the layers above.
Tall/hierarchical structures suit predictable, reliable, measurable outcomes. Flat structures (few layers, team-based, lots of autonomy) suit creativity, variability, innovation, and novel customer responses.
Organizational culture — the norms, patterns, values, and routines in social interactions between people in the organization. Sources: the ethics of the organization (espoused vs. realized), and especially the founders' belief systems, which permeate the firm for a long time (legacy firms like Loblaws/Lawtons under the Weston family talk and act like legacy firms, not startups). Culture is also shaped by the decisions leaders make (hiring, spending, what gets rewarded/punished).
Culture predisposes behaviour: an innovation culture (no answers are wrong, errors are useful, mistakes are learning, safe space, focus on effectiveness) vs. an efficiency culture (everyone goes home safe, zero errors, days-since-last-injury boards, supervisors circulating to keep you on the machine — no room to experiment).
Managerial systems — the technological, resource-based, and control systems that configure how resources are allocated and work gets done.
Business model — definition (know this)
The internal configuration of structure + culture + managerial systems that organizes your assets, technologies, resources, people, and skills to create replicable value creation.
Inside/outside picture: inside the organization = the business model (key partners, suppliers, key activities, value chain — how you collect resources, transform them, and send them out as your product/service portfolio). Outside = the revenue model (what you make, who wants it, your value proposition, how you're positioned — lowest cost? relationships? trust? community? — and how you capture value/money back).
The link between them is the value proposition: the story you tell shapes the revenue model; the business model has to actually deliver it. Loop: value proposition → value creation (inside) → value capture (outside, revenue returns).
Diagnosing a business model — five logics (textbook framework; first term was garbled in the audio — the five as heard):
[Uncertain — sounded like "a thousand logic"; likely the business-idea/concept logic]
Market logic — are we comprehensive enough? Are we matching what we do to customer needs, tastes, demand, demographics — now and over time?
Value creation logic — do we have the required resources/capabilities? Are they rare, valuable, sustainable, non-substitutable? Do our capabilities match our strategy?
Business logic — are the mechanics in place to convert demand/excitement into actual revenue? (Plenty of good ideas have no market mechanism.)
Risk logic — what is the possibility of success, and what is our exposure if the environment shifts? Safe space or increasingly perilous?
Use the diagnostics to decide which parts of the business to invest in/advance, maintain, or remove.
PART 3 — Case: Southwest Airlines (activity system → advantage → erosion)
Model copied from Ryanair [as stated in class]; WestJet was "Southwest North" — same low-cost model in Canada. Porter = the smaller regional alternative with higher service.
The early activity system: no-frills (carry your own bags, minimal food/service/customer care) in exchange for very low fares; lean ground operations (pilots/crews cleaned cabins instead of separate cleaning staff); team-based crews instead of hierarchy; standardized on a single aircraft type (737) — one training/logistics system, interchangeable planes and crews; point-to-point routes from underserved/secondary airports (Dallas Love Field, Houston Hobby, Burbank...) that would subsidize the carrier for the traffic.
Where was the advantage? Not unique assets (same 737s as everyone), not unique technology (same booking systems), not unique competencies (a qualified pilot is a qualified pilot). It was efficiency/cost: they entered with none of the legacy cost structure — no unionized legacy roles/infrastructure that every incumbent (20–30 years of built-up costs) carried. Competitors literally could not match the cost base. Extras reinforced it: standby/rush seating instead of assigned seats, no cargo in the belly, etc.
Erosion over time: as Southwest grew, it added partnerships/alliances, more route types, more complexity → cost structure crept up → the cost advantage thinned. Evidence: share price (a long-run reflection of expected earnings/returns) flattened; earnings-per-share growth stalled after the big 2013–2018 growth period. Lesson: competitive advantage is temporary — the activity system that created it has to be defended/renewed as the environment changes.
Today: still keeps elements (limited passenger service — though more is now sold for a fee; point-to-point roots; somewhat reliable when tech works) but ticket prices are no longer the lowest (ultra-low-cost carriers undercut them), and they're now investing in tech/reliability.
Next class (Monday): finish Ch. 7 examples, then Chapter 8.
Flagged, unverified: background student chatter mentioned other courses' final exams (sport industry "on the 17th," health & wellness "the 22nd," CAW gym venue) — too garbled to record as fact; check official schedules before relying on any of it.
STEN 1000 — Midterm logistics + business models continued (Ch. 7)
Midterm exam logistics (new — not in the Oct 19 review notes)
60 questions, 60 minutes. Mark answers right on the exam sheet — no scantrons.
Bring student ID (card preferred; driver's licence or another photo ID if not).
Sign-in/sign-out sheet at the front; invigilators roaming. Electronics and bags go to the
front of the room.If asked to move seats during the exam, it is a precaution, not an accusation.
SAS accommodations: materials will be waiting at SAS with the same instruction set.
Question levels as described in this recording: Level 1 foundational/recognition (e.g., define
fiscal policy); Level 2 application (~30% per this recording — e.g., how governments use fiscal
policy to change growth); Level 3 mastery/analysis (~20% per this recording — e.g., effect of a
growth policy on domestic interest rates).Note: this split differs from the Oct 19 review sheet (which had Level 1 at ~30%).
Treat the level split as unconfirmed; the 60-question / 60-minute format is new here.Prof: no trickery, no micro-details (e.g., won't ask for a specific 2017 investment figure).
Concepts and why they matter are what is tested.Prof's study advice (his own method, not a requirement): read the book, highlight, take notes
from the highlights; handwriting helps his memory.
Business models continued (Ch. 7)
A business model is the aggregate sum of all processes, plans, strategies and decisions
organized to express a value proposition and capture value. Internal half (what the company
does for itself) vs market-facing half (what targets customers).Five external themes framing the landscape: climate change; pollution and health; energy
crunch / lack of sustainable capital; resource depletion (if the world lived like North
America, we'd need ~5 planets); capital costs and rising interest rates (neocloud example:
CoreWeave, Nebius rent out data-centre space and are vulnerable when rates rise; widening
credit spreads signal distress).Southwest (alignment example): competitive advantage from customer responsiveness + efficiency
together — flexible labour contracts, 15-minute turnarounds, high aircraft utilization,
standardized fleet (one aircraft type = same seats, parts, maintenance, crew training).Razor-blade model: give away the handle cheap, take the margin on blades. Roku: cheap hardware
into the home, margin on the platform/subscriptions. Risk: users stop subscribing, or content
rights go exclusive elsewhere (Disney, Netflix originals). 2021 was Roku's best year; 2022
share fell as competitors multiplied.Netflix-type models rest on two assumptions: cheap, fast internet throughput and low cost.
If bandwidth is throttled or gets expensive, the model breaks. The same two factors sit behind
Blockbuster's failure.Spotify freemium/community model: free tier with ads + premium subscriptions + user data
repackaged. Only ~20% of users pay (Pareto), but a large enough community makes that 20%
profitable. Same logic as freemium games: GTA Online microtransactions, World of Warcraft
subscriptions, mobile games.Amazon ecosystem: a mutually sustaining system (marketplace, AWS, logistics, devices). Data
from all transactions identifies trends, including Amazon-branded versions of trending
products. Heavy physical investment in distribution and last-mile delivery. Took 10–12 years
to build momentum; profits wobbled when interest rates rose post-COVID.Apple ecosystem: iPod (2001) → iPhone (2007) → iPad → iOS ecosystem. The App Store works as a
gateway/landlord: Apple takes a slice of every transaction and upgrade. Switching costs
(family coordination, calendar, device integration) lock users in. BlackBerry contrast:
dominant business device, dismissed the iPhone (no keyboard, touchscreen), share collapsed
after 2008; survives in security/network niches.Stage 2 projects due Monday (Nov 2) — consistent with the known deadline.