TB1+W9+Who+Becomes+Antisocial+Slides

Who Becomes Antisocial? AKA do I have to worry about the person sitting next to me? PS4005 Week 4

Check In

  • Initial interaction points to discuss participants' understanding and feelings about the topic.

Outline of Discussion Topics

  • Social and familial influences

  • Media influences

  • Types of violence

  • Risk and protective factors

  • Assessments

  • Prevention

Learning Objectives

  • Personal Characteristics Influence: Explore how individual traits affect behavior.

  • Parenting Styles Impact: Connect different parenting approaches with child development and behavior.

  • Good Lives Model: Utilize reframing techniques to understand incidents of offending behavior.

  • Prevention Programs: Develop structured programs aimed at decreasing criminal behavior in targeted groups.

Ecological Systems Theory

  • Urie Bronfenbrenner (1977): Introduced a framework that depicts the complexity of child development as influenced by various interacting environments.

  • Five Systems Overview:

    • Microsystem: Immediate environment (Parents, siblings, teachers—relationships are bi-directional).

    • Mesosystem: Interconnections between microsystems (e.g., teachers communicating with parents).

    • Exosystem: Larger social systems that indirectly affect child (e.g., the impact of media on parenting).

    • Macrosystem: Broad cultural elements (e.g., socioeconomic status, race).

    • Chronosystem: Life transitions and historical factors that affect development over time.

Parenting Styles

Types and Characteristics

  • Authoritative:

    • Combines limits and emotional support; encourages autonomy with boundaries.

  • Authoritarian:

    • Emphasizes strict discipline, may lack emotional warmth; assertive parenting.

  • Permissive:

    • Minimal rules; treats children more as friends; low control.

  • Neglectful:

    • Lack of emotional and physical support; children often fend for themselves.

Outcomes of Parenting Styles

  • Authoritative:

    • Results in better adjustments, increased self-sufficiency, and positive emotional states.

  • Authoritarian:

    • Associated with frustration, withdrawal, and distrust.

  • Permissive:

    • Linked to poor self-regulation, higher levels of depressive symptoms, and risk of criminal behavior.

  • Neglectful:

    • Leads to poor mental health, antisocial behavior, and substance abuse.

Media Influence on Behavior

  • Effects of Violent Media Consumption:

    • Questions raised about its influence on empathy, emotional responses, and aggression levels.

Types of Violence

Reactive Violence

  • Definition: Impulsive actions in response to provocation; typically driven by emotional responses.

Instrumental Violence

  • Definition: Premeditated aggressive acts used to achieve a specific outcome; emotional response is secondary.

Case Examples

  • Jeffrey: Robs a store at gunpoint (instrumental).

  • Joey: Punches peer over insults (reactive).

  • Jack Bauer: Uses extreme measures for specific information (instrumental).

Reactive vs. Instrumental Offenders

  • Reactive offenders often experience high emotional arousal and rejection.

  • Instrumental offenders may demonstrate psychopathic traits and less emotional regulation.

Risk Factors and Assessments

Identifying Risk Factors

  • Use Paul's case study to understand history and impact including PTSD and violence.

Generations of Risk Assessment

  • 1st Generation: Clinical assessments based on professional judgment; subjective.

  • 2nd Generation: Statistical methods deriving scores from past behaviors; more objective.

  • 3rd Generation: Integrates dynamic and clinical factors with structured professional judgment.

  • 4th Generation: Includes treatment readiness and dynamic assessments.

Good Lives Model

  • A strengths-based approach to offender treatment; advocates for fulfilling life goals through prosocial means.

Prevention Strategies

Types of Strategies

  • Primary Prevention: Focus on social factors to prevent the emergence of risky behaviors.

  • Secondary Prevention: Provides social and clinical support for youth exhibiting behavioral issues.

  • Tertiary Prevention: Aim focuses on treating identified individuals and addressing risk factors.

Risk Factor Domains

Youth and Adult Factors

  • Youth: Individual traits, familial relationships, school connections, peer influence, and community context.

  • Adult: Major factors include criminal history, attitudes, peers, and varying degrees of substance use and familial networks.

Protective Factors

  • Significant domains that can mitigate risk: Individual, Family, Peer, School, and Community contexts.

Conclusion

  • Risk assessments, though imperfect, remain valuable in predicting and addressing the likelihood of future criminal behavior. Emphasis should be on developing individualized treatment and prevention strategies.